The Church Fathers on this verse

1 Corinthians 2:16Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he may instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.

Douay-Rheims

τις γαρ εγνω νουν κυριου ος συμβιβασει αυτον ημεις δε νουν χριστου εχομεν

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

13 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

We know the nature of present things and the dignity of future things. We know what will happen to the world hereafter, what punishment sinners will suffer, and what the righteous will enjoy.

We know that present goods have no worth, and we expose their nothingness. To judge means also to expose. The things to come are eternal and unchanging.

The spiritual man knows all this. He knows what punishment the natural man will suffer in the life to come. He also knows what the believer will enjoy after departing from here.

But the natural man knows nothing of this. Therefore, to explain what has been said, the Apostle adds: "For who has known the mind of the Lord, that he may instruct Him? But we have the mind of Christ" (1 Cor 2:16).

Read more (969 words)

That is, we know what is in the mind of Christ, what He wills, and what He has revealed to us.

Since the Apostle said above that the Spirit revealed it to us, lest anyone reject the Son, he adds that Christ also revealed it.

He does not mean that we know everything Christ knows. He means that all our knowledge is not human and therefore subject to doubt, but is knowledge of the mind of Christ and is spiritual.

The mind that we have in this matter is Christ's. That is, the knowledge we have concerning the things of faith is spiritual knowledge.

Therefore, truly, no one can judge us, since the natural man cannot know divine things.

For this reason the Apostle said, "For who has known the mind of the Lord?" He affirms that our mind concerning these things is His mind.

And he did not add the words, "that he may instruct Him," without purpose. He added them in accordance with the words above: "the spiritual man is judged by no one."

If no one can know the mind of God, much less can anyone teach or correct it. This is what the words "that he may instruct Him" mean.

Do you see how variously he refutes external wisdom and shows that the spiritual man knows more and better?

The reasons already given might not have seemed very persuasive, strong, necessary, or useful to unbelievers. These reasons were: "that no flesh should glory," "God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise," and "lest the Cross of Christ be made of no effect."

Therefore he finally brings forward the chief reason. Only in this way can we see and know things that are high, mysterious, and above us.

Reason proved insufficient because by worldly wisdom we cannot comprehend what is above us. Is it not evident how useful it is to receive teaching from the Spirit?

Such teaching is both the easiest and the clearest. "But we have the mind of Christ," that is, a spiritual and divine mind, having nothing human in it.

Christ communicated to our reason not the mind of Plato or Pythagoras, but His own.

Let us be ashamed, beloved, and let us conduct a virtuous life. Christ Himself presents as a sign of great friendship the fact that He revealed the mysteries to us.

"I no longer call you servants," He says, "but I have called you friends, because I have told you all things that I heard from My Father" (Jn 15:14-15). That is, He entrusted them to you.

If trust alone is a sign of friendship, consider what love He showed by entrusting the mysteries to us. He did this not in words only, but by communicating them to us in reality.

Let us be ashamed, then. If Gehenna does not greatly terrify us, let this be more fearful to us than Gehenna: to prove ungrateful and thankless toward such a friend and benefactor.

Let us do everything not as hired slaves, but as sons and free men, out of love for the Father. Let us cease clinging to the world, so that we may put the Gentiles to shame.

Now, when I desire to contend with them, I fear that while refuting them by words and by the truth of doctrine, we may incur great ridicule because of our life.

For they, though in error and believing none of our teachings, practice philosophy. We do exactly the opposite.

Nevertheless I will speak. Perhaps, while striving to refute them, we shall also strive to prove better than they are in life itself.

Earlier I said that the Apostles would never have thought of preaching what they preached if they had not had the grace of God.

I said that they not only would not have accomplished so great a work, but would not even have undertaken it. Let us speak now about the same subject.

Let us show that it would have been impossible for them to undertake or even conceive it if Christ had not been with them.

This was not only because they, being weak, went out against the strong. Nor was it only because a few went against many, the poor against the rich, and the unlearned against the wise.

It was also because the power of prejudices was great. You know that nothing among men is stronger than long-standing custom.

Therefore, even if they had not been twelve men and had not been so despised, this would still have been difficult.

Even if another whole world had been on their side, and a number of men equal to their opponents, or even far greater, it would still have been difficult.

Custom helped their opponents, while novelty hindered the Apostles. Nothing so disturbs the soul as the introduction of something new and extraordinary, even if it is useful.

This is especially true when it concerns worship and reverence for God. I will explain later how strong this obstacle was.

But first I will say that there was another obstacle on the side of the Jews. Among the Gentiles the Apostles overthrew their gods and all their teaching.

With the Jews, however, they did not reason in the same way. They rejected much of their teaching, yet commanded them to worship God the Lawgiver.

Commanding them to honor the Lawgiver, they said, "Do not obey in everything the law given by Him." This applied to the keeping of the Sabbath, circumcision, the offering of sacrifices, and similar matters.

Thus, among the Jews, it was not only the sacrifices that were an obstacle. There was also the fact that, while commanding them to worship God, the Apostles commanded them to leave many of His laws.

Among the Gentiles, the force of custom was great.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

"For who has known the mind of the Lord, that he may judge Him?" He calls the spiritual mind the mind of the Lord. The word "judge" (symbibasei) stands in place of "correct" (diorthosetai).

Having said above, "the spiritual man is judged by no one," he now proves that he said this justly.

For who has known the mind of the Lord so as to dare to judge it, that is, to correct it?

If no one can even know the mind of the Lord, and such is the mind of the spiritual man, then still less can anyone teach or correct him.

"But we have the mind of Christ." Do not marvel, he says, that I have called the spiritual man and his mind the mind of the Lord.

We all have the mind of Christ. That is, whatever we know has been revealed to us by Christ.

Read more (47 words)

Our understanding (ton noun) of divine things is from Christ. In other words, the knowledge we have concerning the spiritual objects of faith is from Christ.

Therefore truly no one can judge us. Some, however, have called the Father the mind of Christ, and others the Spirit.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

For who has known the mind of the Lord, except the one who will be a partaker of it? Just as they say that the righteous of old, who were participants in divine worship, knew the will of God, so also we, by our participation in the sufferings of Christ, have received the mind of Christ.

Ambrosiaster

4th centuryChurch Father

We also have the mind of the Lord. Paul says this because we believers receive our portion in the divine providence.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

The Apostle has sufficiently proved that divine teaching has need of nothing. For if not only the God of all needs nothing, but His wisdom is also incomprehensible, and He has communicated this wisdom to us, then we also have no need of the teaching of the so-called wise.

Maximus the Confessor

7th centuryChurch Father

The mind of Christ, which the saints receive, according to him who said, "we have the mind of Christ" (1 Cor 2:16), does not come by depriving us of our own intellectual power.

Nor does it come as though it essentially and personally passed into our mind in place of it.

Rather, by its own quality it illumines the power of our mind and carries it toward one and the same activity with itself.

In my judgment, the one who has the mind of Christ is he who thinks of all things in His spirit, and through all things is brought to the thought of Him.

The heart is pure when it offers God its memory completely formless, without the intrusion of visions, ready to receive only His impressions.

Read more (74 words)

In just this way the saints acquire the mind of God, or, as the Apostle said, "we have the mind of Christ" (1 Cor 2:16).

This mind does not deprive us of our own intellectual faculty. It does not become an addition to our mind.

Nor is it essentially united to our mind according to hypostasis. Rather, by its own quality it illumines the faculty of our mind, encouraging it toward its own activity.

Oecumenius

6th centuryChurch Father

By the mind of Christ the Apostle means the Father. We have within ourselves, he says, the Father of Christ.

Symeon the New Theologian

10th centuryChurch Father

So it is with those who sit in the darkness of life's pleasures and in the darkness of vainglory. Seeing, they do not see Your divine glory.

Hearing, they do not at all understand Your commandments and ordinances. So it will be with me in Your light, when even seeing I shall not see the world or the things in the world.

For who, seeing You and perceiving himself illumined by Your glory and by Your divine light, has not been changed in mind, soul, and heart?

Who has not been deemed worthy, O Savior, to see differently and to hear in the same way, with sovereign freedom?

For when the mind is plunged into Your light, it is enlightened and becomes light, like Your glory. It is called Your mind.

Read more (183 words)

Whoever has been deemed worthy to become such is then also deemed worthy to have Your mind. He becomes indivisibly one with You.

How, then, will he not see and hear all things dispassionately, as You do?

Having become god by grace, how would he desire anything sensory, anything swiftly passing and corruptible, or any other vain glory?

How would one who has become higher than all this, and above every visible glory, desire it?

For how could one who has become higher than all visible things and has drawn near to God, or better, one who has himself been called god, seek glory or luxury from things cast down upon the earth?

For truly they are shame and reproach to him, abasement and dishonor.

His glory, consolation, and wealth are God the Trinity and all that is God's and divine. To Him belong all glory, honor, and dominion always, now and unto all ages. Amen.

The simple, pure light is Christ. Therefore, whoever has within himself the light of Christ shining in his mind is said to have the mind of Christ.

Gregorios Palamas

14th centuryChurch Father

For according to the divine Paul, the Holy Spirit is called the Spirit and mind of Christ (1 Cor 2:16; Rom 8:9; 2 Cor 3:17-18; Gal 4:6). On the relation of these and similar names to the hypostasis of the Holy Spirit, see Gregory the Theologian, Oration 31, 29 (PG 36, 165B).

Ignatij (Briantchaninow)

19th centuryChurch Father

"We have the mind of Christ," said the holy Apostle Paul on behalf of the whole Christian Church.

We Christians must think, reason, and speak as our incarnate God thought, understood, and spoke.

The pastors of the Church must plant, cultivate, and preserve such union with the Lord in themselves with particular care.

They bear the most sacred duty of guiding the whole Christian brotherhood toward virtue and salvation.

The trinity that is man is healed by the Trinity Who is God. By the Word, thought is healed and transferred from the realm of falsehood and self-delusion into the realm of Truth.

By the Holy Spirit, the spirit is made alive and transferred from carnal and psychic sensations into spiritual sensations.

The Father appears to the mind, and the mind becomes the mind of God. "We have the mind of Christ," says the Apostle.

Ivanov A.V.

19th centuryChurch Father

"But we have the mind of Christ," that is, the spiritual, divine mind, knowledge, and spirit that were in Christ. This is not self-exaltation, but the expression of a deep conviction. The same Spirit of God, Who rests in Christ as the Head of the Church, also lives and acts in the members of His Body, in all believers.

Nikanor (Kamenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The apostles and other preachers of Christian teaching were spiritual, but not only because they were guided by the highest principle of the soul, the spirit.

They were spiritual also because, to the degree possible for men, they knew Christ the Savior and understood His teaching.

Moreover, they had within themselves the Spirit of God, Who spoke through the prophets and acted upon the minds and hearts of the apostles.

When sending the apostles to preach, Jesus Christ said, "It is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father Who speaks in you" (Mt 10:20).

When promising to send them the Holy Spirit, Christ said, "He will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I have said to you" (Jn 14:26).

Read more (240 words)

From this it is clear that the apostles were shown both what psychic people could grasp and what belongs only to spiritual people to understand.

Therefore they could freely discuss everything. Psychic people can judge only from their narrow point of view, and therefore they can often err.

Consequently, it is better for them not to reason independently about spiritual things, but to seek those who can enlighten and instruct them in everything inaccessible to them.

Explaining the holy Apostle's words, "we have the mind of Christ," St. John Chrysostom says: "Since the Apostle said above that the Spirit revealed this to us, lest anyone reject the Son, he adds that Christ also revealed it.

He does not mean that we know everything Christ knows. Rather, he means that all our knowledge is not human and therefore subject to doubt, but is the knowledge of Christ's mind and is spiritual.

We know what is in the mind of Christ, what He wills, and what He has revealed to us.

Christ Himself presents as proof of perfect friendship the fact that He has revealed mysteries to us. 'I no longer call you servants,' He says. 'You are My friends, because I have told you all that I heard from My Father.'

That is, He entrusted it to us (Jn 15:15). Do you see how variously the Apostle refutes external wisdom and shows that the spiritual man knows more and knows better?"

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

He gives the reason why none of the natural can understand or judge the spiritual man. For what is in the spiritual man, he says, is the mind of Christ.

He has the spirit of Christ, Christ's contemplations, Christ's dispositions, Christ's powers, plans, and hopes. Everything in him is Christ's.

But none of the natural can understand the mind of Christ, the mind of the Lord, so that everything in it would be clear to him.

Since none of them can understand this, he cannot understand the spiritual man either. For the spiritual man has the same mind.

Some refer the words "that he may instruct Him" to the mind of the Lord in this way: who knows the mind of the Lord so as to understand it clearly and bring it into agreement with his own concepts? This is Theophylact's interpretation.

Read more (483 words)

Others refer them to the spiritual man in this way: who understands the mind of the Lord so as to understand and judge the spiritual man?

But in us, the spiritual, is the mind of Christ, that is, of the Lord.

The chief thought remains one and the same under either understanding of these words. The spiritual realm, with what it contains, and with its persons and realities, is inaccessible to the natural man.

He can understand nothing in it, not only as it is in itself, but also as it appears in persons who live spiritually.

Here is what Chrysostom says about this: "'We have the mind of Christ' means that we know what is in the mind of Christ, what He wills, and what He has revealed to us."

"Since the Apostle said above that the Spirit revealed it to us, lest anyone reject the Son, he adds that Christ also revealed it."

"He does not mean that we know everything Christ knows. He means that all our knowledge is not human and therefore subject to doubt, but is knowledge of the mind of Christ and is spiritual."

"The understanding we have is Christ's. That is, the knowledge we have concerning the things of faith is spiritual knowledge. Therefore no one can truly judge us, for the natural man cannot know divine things."

"For this reason the Apostle said, 'For who has known the mind of the Lord?' He affirms that our understanding of these things is His understanding."

"And he did not add the words, 'that he may instruct Him,' without purpose. He added them in accordance with the words above: 'the spiritual man is judged by no one.'"

"Do you see how variously he refutes external wisdom and shows that the spiritual man knows more and better?"

"Only in this way, by having the mind of Christ, can we see and know things that are high, mysterious, and above us. Reason proved insufficient, because by worldly wisdom we cannot comprehend what is above us."

"But we have the mind of Christ," that is, a spiritual and divine mind, having nothing human in it. Christ communicated His own knowledge to our reason.

Christ Himself presents as proof of perfect friendship the fact that He revealed the mysteries to us. He says, "No longer do I call you servants. You are My friends, because all things that I heard from My Father I have told you" (Jn 15:14-15).

That is, He entrusted them to you. If trust alone is a sign of friendship, consider what love He showed by entrusting the mysteries to us.

He did so not in words only, but by communicating them to us in reality.

Let us be ashamed, then. If Gehenna does not greatly terrify us, let this be more fearful to us than Gehenna: to prove ungrateful and thankless toward such a friend and benefactor.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 13 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Τίς
    tis
    who
    G5101 · τίς
  2. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  3. ἔγνω
    egnō
    I come to know
    G1097 · γινώσκω
  4. νοῦν
    noun
    the mind
    G3563 · νοῦς
  5. Κυρίου
    kyriou
    lord
    G2962 · κύριος
  6. ὃς
    hos
    who
    G3739 · ὅς, ἥ
  7. συμβιβάσει
    symbibasei
    I unite
    G4822 · συμβιβάζω
  8. αὐτόν
    auton
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  9. ἡμεῖς
    hēmeis
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  10. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  11. νοῦν
    noun
    the mind
    G3563 · νοῦς
  12. Χριστοῦ
    christou
    anointed
    G5547 · Χριστός
  13. ἔχομεν
    echomen
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω