“‘Bearing with,’ ανεχομενοι, is the same as ‘carrying,’ βασταζοντες, one another: you carry him, and he carries you. Do not judge one another’s defects and falls with sharp severity. Rather, counting them as small things, pass them by without attention” (Blessed Theophylact).
“Bearing with” refers more to what displeases us in one another and annoys us, without relation to ourselves. “Forgiving” refers to what touches us personally, what one may complain of, what is not blameworthy merely in itself but is hurtful and offensive to us. The Apostle expressed this by the word μομφη, “complaint.”
Today he has done something for which you rightly have a complaint against him. Tomorrow you may act the same way toward him. When you meet such cases, forgive one another, χαπιζομενοι εαυτοις. Freely give one another such incidents, without beginning disputes, quarrels, and discord because of them.
To endure and bear one another is to carry a more external burden. Forgiveness has as its object what enters the heart. Therefore it reveals a merciful heart and freely gives to another what one might exact from him.
However simple all this seems in thought and word, in deed it is difficult to bear and forgive even some small matter, let alone something great. The Apostle strengthens his commandment with the strongest motive, the forgiveness that each person receives from the Lord.
Why do people not forgive? A self-centered movement enters the heart: why should I forgive him? Then forgiveness, often already prepared, is driven away. This is the main source of unforgiveness. The Apostle blocks it with a firm and heavy stone.
As soon as selfhood says within you, “Why should I forgive?” quickly bring to mind the all-forgiveness you have received from Christ the Lord, and selfhood will fall silent. How will it dare to make even the faintest sound when you consider the immeasurable offense you have committed against the boundless God?
Consider what immeasurable sacrifice satisfaction for it required. Consider how forgiveness of it was freely given to you, the most unworthy and contemptible. If you take this into feeling, and how could you not, then what will be in your soul afterward is not, “Why should I forgive this or that small matter?” Rather it will be: give me more and more that I may forgive.
The Apostle says, “as Christ forgave you.” He recalls the greater forgiveness in holy baptism. Consequently, he supposes that those to whom he writes have not sinned after baptism. To those who sin after baptism one must say: otherwise Christ God will not forgive you either.
The Savior showed in bright light, both by direct word and by parable, that the forgiveness of each person’s sins depends entirely on his forgiveness of his neighbor for what he has against him. If you do not forgive, you yourself will not be forgiven. Here is the answer to selfhood: why should I forgive? Because otherwise you yourself will not be forgiven.
But if you are not forgiven, you will suffer something with which nothing that you endure from another, and that requires your forgiveness, can be compared even by a hair.
Chrysostom says: “See how Saint Paul showed the insignificance of this, namely what must be forgiven another, by calling it a complaint. Then he adds, ‘as Christ forgave you.’ A great example! Paul always does this. He persuades by the example of Christ.
He says ‘complaint,’ by which he showed that what is endured from others is insignificant. Yet when he brought forward the example, he affirmed that even if we had serious accusations, we must forgive. The words ‘as Christ’ mean this. And not only this, but also that we must forgive from the whole heart.
Not only this, but also that we must love those who offend us. For Christ, set forth as the example, teaches all this. He also teaches that we must forgive offenses even if they are great, even if we ourselves have not first offended those who offend us.
He teaches this even if we are people of importance and those offending us are insignificant. He teaches it even if, after forgiveness, they intend to offend us again. Finally, He teaches that we must lay down our soul for them. The word ‘as’ requires this. It also shows that we must stand for those who offend us not only unto death, but, if possible, even after death.”
Therefore, “look upon the Master’s love for mankind. How many sins He has granted you remission of! Therefore imitate the Master, and let each forgive the sins committed against him by his brother” (Blessed Theodoret).
The limit of this is love and peace. Through self-renunciation, having struck selfhood down, they then go by one path toward compassion and kindness, and by the other toward meekness and longsuffering. By the first path they reach love, and by the second, the peace of God.
Comparing these with the passions, we see that love is established in place of all the passions of desire, and peace in place of all the passions of irritation. I recall that Saint Maximus the Confessor somewhere distributes in this way what takes place within us.