The Church Fathers on this verse

Ecclesiastes 2:3Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

I thought in my heart, to withdraw my flesh from wine, that I might turn my mind to wisdom, and might avoid folly, till I might see what was profitable for the children of men: and what they ought to do under the sun, all the days of their life.

Douay-Rheims

תַּ֣רְתִּי בְלִבִּ֔י לִמְשׁ֥וֹךְ בַּיַּ֖יִן אֶת־בְּשָׂרִ֑י וְלִבִּ֞י נֹהֵ֤ג בַּֽחָכְמָה֙ וְלֶאֱחֹ֣ז בְּסִכְל֔וּת עַ֣ד אֲשֶׁר־אֶרְאֶ֗ה אֵי־זֶ֨ה ט֜וֹב לִבְנֵ֤י הָאָדָם֙ אֲשֶׁ֤ר יַעֲשׂוּ֙ תַּ֣חַת הַשָּׁמַ֔יִם מִסְפַּ֖ר יְמֵ֥י חַיֵּיהֶֽם׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

7 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Gregory of Nyssa

4th centuryChurch Father

After examining these matters, Ecclesiastes reflects: I will discern if my heart will gravitate like wine to my flesh, meaning I intend to discover how spiritual concerns can take precedence over bodily impulses, ensuring harmony within our nature instead of discord, when the mind opts for one path while the flesh inclines toward another. This harmony allows our earthly reasoning to submit to the rational aspect of the soul, where the lesser desires are overwhelmed and absorbed by the more abundant, akin to those who thirst. Just as wine, when brought to the thirsty lips, does not stay confined within the cup but rather spills over into the drinker, transforming the one who imbibes deeply into a more buoyant state.

Read more (415 words)

Upon my realization of this, my journey toward understanding became certain and unimpeded. "My heart, my heart," Ecclesiastes proclaims, “guide me in wisdom,” through which I triumphed over the allure of indulgence; and this enlightenment served as my foundation for maintaining joy.

The essence of these words, in relation to my readings, expresses my deep longing to be guided, not to squander my existence on vanity, but rather to seek out the good that, once attained, leads to accurate discernment of true value and remains steadfast, not fleeting, throughout life. It instills hope for enduring goodness across all stages—beginning, middle, and end—and throughout all my days. “I shall observe,” he states, “the good deeds of mankind under the sun over the span of their lives.” While the desires of the flesh often serve as temptations for the senses in the moment, their gratification is short-lived. For no pleasure derived from the body can sustain enjoyment for long; the joy of drinking ends with satisfaction, and in eating, the fullness of the stomach diminishes the appetite. Similarly, every other desire wanes once fulfilled, and if it reemerges, it fades once more. Nothing appealing to the senses endures eternally.

Moreover, various experiences are beneficial for a child, different for a young adult, distinct for a mature individual, and yet again for the elderly, including those who gaze down toward the earth. Yet I, Ecclesiastes asserts, have pursued that goodness which holds equal merit at every stage of life—such a goodness where one is neither exhausted nor satisfied, for even when one partakes, desire persists, and pleasure grows together with longing, unfettered by the age of the seeker. The more one delights in this goodness, the more it fosters an increase in desire, igniting fresh pleasure, remaining ever beautiful for those who cherish it, unaffected by the fluctuations of time and age. Whether one turns their gaze or lifts their sight, amid prosperity or adversity, throughout night or day—in essence, it serves as a universal good, remaining unchanged for those in unfortunate circumstances.

In my view, this represents the genuine goodness that Solomon endeavored to explore: “what humans accomplish under the sun throughout their lifetimes.” It appears to me as nothing less than a work of faith, a reality universally accessible, offered to all who yearn for it, omnipotent and perpetually present in life. This is the good work that may also dwell within us, through Christ Jesus our Lord. To Him be glory forever and ever! Amen.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

I contemplated that I would indulge my flesh with wine; yet my heart guided me towards wisdom and away from folly, leading me to discern the value in the deeds of humanity during their earthly days. I aspired to dedicate my existence to pleasures, seeking to liberate my flesh from all burdens and to indulge as one would with wine. However, through reflection and the innate understanding bestowed by God, even upon sinners, I was redirected to pursue wisdom and overcome foolishness, allowing me to recognize the goodness in human endeavors. It is fitting to liken pleasures to drunkenness, as both can undermine the stronghold of the spirit. Those who can substitute this intoxication with wisdom—and as some traditions suggest, "obtain spiritual joy”—will be enabled to grasp what in this life is worth pursuing and what should be avoided.

Dionysius of Alexandria

3rd centuryChurch Father

My heart guides me in wisdom, allowing me to maintain joy as I seek what is beneficial for humanity, observed during their days under the sun. Under the influence of wisdom, I attained an understanding of the joys of laughter. However, the intention behind my actions was not to waste my life in emptiness but to uncover the true good that, once obtained, makes it clear what is truly advantageous. This good, though fleeting, sustains one's existence through life.

Gregory the Wonderworker

3rd centuryChurch Father

After reflecting on the ability of the spirit to uplift the physical body, which resembles the qualities of wine, and recognizing that self-control binds desire to itself, I made up my mind to understand the noble and truly significant purposes that were initially meant for humanity to fulfill in this life.

Olympiodorus of Alexandria

6th centuryChurch Father

It is not the elevation of intellect that is acknowledged, but the state of the heart—whether it is employed nobly or disgracefully in utilizing this blessing—that receives admiration or reproach.

Wladimir (Bogojawlenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The perspective of the wise Solomon regarding wine is evident in Ecclesiastes 2:3, where he declares, “I have thought in my heart to gratify my body with wine, and, while my heart is guided by wisdom, to hold fast to foolishness also, until I see what is good for the children of men, what they ought to do while they live under heaven." Solomon identifies what is essential for forming an unbiased understanding of what is beneficial for humanity and recognizing what is folly, a principle that remains relevant, especially for those who perceive themselves called to be leaders and educators today. This counsel is particularly significant for those who engage with the topic of alcohol.

Read more (41 words)

This is further supported by Proverbs 20:1, which states, “Wine is foolishness, and strong drink is riotous; and every one that is addicted to them is foolish.” Does this imply that Scripture is at odds with those who choose to abstain?

Ireneus (Orda)

19th centuryCommentator

The preacher reflects on the pleasures of life, questioning whether they can truly provide peace or fulfill human aspirations. Solomon, having fashioned for himself an earthly paradise filled with delight, ultimately found no tranquility there. After realizing the futility of a life focused on material possessions, he turned his attention to the pursuit of wisdom. While he acknowledged that knowledge brings insight into one’s actions, he soon discerned that such striving leads to vanity, as both the wise and the foolish meet the same end—death, obscurity, and the passing on of their gains to an heir who might squander them. This pursuit is fraught with constant anxiety and concerns.

Read more (129 words)

Despite the futility present in both sensual and material pursuits, as well as in purely intellectual endeavors, it does not follow that human existence should devolve into chaos and immorality. Instead, one should seek a balance of knowledge and enjoyment, acknowledging that all gifts come from God and are bestowed upon the righteous. The ability to relish life is contingent upon God’s will, not human effort. Since God determines good and evil based on the moral stature of individuals, the paramount principle for living is to act with righteousness while enjoying life, blending wisdom with pleasure. This principle is validated by the observation that all things possess only relative worth; nothing is intrinsically good or bad, pleasant or unpleasant; instead, these qualities depend on the context of the moment.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.