John Chrysostom
I appoint you as a judge. Should I not feel anger due to the violation of your essence and the degradation of your statutes, declares the Lord?
In the parts of the torrent is thy portion, this is thy lot: and thou hast poured out libations to them, thou hast offered sacrifice. Shall I not be angry at these things?
בְּחַלְּקֵי־נַ֣חַל חֶלְקֵ֔ךְ הֵ֥ם הֵ֖ם גּוֹרָלֵ֑ךְ גַּם־לָהֶ֞ם שָׁפַ֥כְתְּ נֶ֙סֶךְ֙ הֶעֱלִ֣ית מִנְחָ֔ה הַ֥עַל אֵ֖לֶּה אֶנָּחֵֽם׃
3 Church Fathers comment on this verse
I appoint you as a judge. Should I not feel anger due to the violation of your essence and the degradation of your statutes, declares the Lord?
By labeling them as murderers of the Lord, he reveals that they are afflicted by a different ailment – a profound animosity toward God and a willingness to commit murder – and this affliction has not just recently emerged but has been within them since ancient times. For he says, “For ye, from ancient times have prayed to an idol under a frequent tree.” Though the teachings of Moses conveyed righteous instructions to them, declaring unequivocally, “Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and serve him only,” they nonetheless fell into such folly, or more aptly, such wild and extreme wickedness, that they became architects of idols, offering sacrifices to them, and instigating others to revere these false gods beneath the shade of trees, bestowing upon them honors meant for the Divine.
This is poignantly expressed by the Almighty through the prophet Jeremiah, who proclaimed, “Have you seen what the house of Israel has done to me? They went up into every high mountain, and under every leafy tree, and gathered them together” (Jeremiah 3:6). They occupied the heights of the mountains and the most favorable spots to establish altars and places of worship, where they made offerings and libations to unclean spirits and showed no compassion even toward their own offspring. Thus did Jechoniah sacrifice his son to the supposed gods. Concerning this, God, through one of His holy prophets, reveals the cruelty of the wicked: “devour men, for the calves are scarce” (Hosea 13:2). So you, he implies, pray to the idol beneath the tree of the frequent, while burying your children in the underbrush among the stones. What follows from this? That is your rightful portion; this is your destiny. If, he states, you have bowed down to falsehood, then such shall be your end, and your destiny will be emptiness. Alternatively, he may be indicating something else: you have slain your children in the wilderness, and for this, your fate shall mirror the same suffering and destruction that you have wrought. Why is this so? First, because you have become murderers of your own children; and second, because you have offered libations to unclean spirits and lifeless idols, bringing sacrifices to them. Therefore, he asks, shall I not be justified in my anger against these actions? Is not my wrath against you well warranted, and is there not sufficient ground for your punishment? Upon the high and exalted mountain, there is your resting place, where you have made your offerings; and behind the hedges of your doors, you have kept your memories alive. The prophetic word frequently reminds us that they laid down on the mountains to pursue dreams. It is noted that the Israelites strayed to such an extent that they inscribed images of idols on their doors and doorposts, ensuring that as they entered and exited their homes, they would constantly behold them and remember them. All of this clearly demonstrates a profound level of impiety; they referred to these various images of idols as saviors and helpers.
Your allotment lies in the streams; it is your share, and through it you have poured out drink offerings and made sacrifices. Will I not be enraged by this? It is indeed your share and lot, given that you have offered libations and prepared sacrifices through it. Will I not be furious with this? What is expressed here relates to the days of Isaiah when the mountains, valleys, and waterways were filled with the worship of false gods. The prophet Jeremiah noted that fathers and sons gather wood to kindle a fire for baking cakes for the host of heaven, while women mix fat and flour to incense the Lord (Jeremiah 7). There is no doubt that these cakes or biscuits, expertly crafted, are referenced here, known in our language as chavonae.
Moses, speaking from the prophetic spirit, declared on behalf of the Lord in the song of Deuteronomy, “They have provoked Me with foreign gods and have stirred My anger with their abominations. They have sacrificed to demons, not to God” (Deuteronomy 32:16-17). They chose to do so willingly, for it is in our power to choose between good and evil. Thus, it is also said to those who dedicate themselves to God through their virtues: “Choose for yourselves our inheritance, the goodness of Jacob that you cherish” (Psalm 46:5). Furthermore, it is proclaimed, “For the Lord’s portion is His people; Jacob is His allotted inheritance” (Deuteronomy 32:9). In the Acts of the Apostles, it is recorded that many committed themselves to the cause of Paul and Silas (Acts 17). Therefore, those who belong to the Lord, like the Levites, will share a portion with Him and echo David’s words: “The Lord is my portion” (Psalm 72:26). This can also be understood in the context of heretics, who, having abandoned the fear of God, honor the idols of their falsehoods, making sacrifices and drink offerings to them—engaging in acts that are unworthy even of mention, leading astray foolish women burdened with sins, driven by diverse desires, always seeking knowledge yet never arriving at the truth (2 Timothy 3:6). Hence, given that such iniquities and others are perpetrated by the wicked, can we not conclude that God righteously harbors anger towards them?
Passages read together with this verse.