The Church Fathers on this verse

1 Peter 3:17Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

For it is better doing well (if such be the will of God) to suffer than doing ill.

Douay-Rheims

κρειττον γαρ αγαθοποιουντας ει θελοι το θελημα του θεου πασχειν η κακοποιουντας

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

6 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

A reason is presented, not for what was said immediately before, but for what was said a little above, namely: “If you suffer for righteousness, you are blessed” (1 Pet 3:14). For it is better to endure evil for good deeds than for evil ones.

If someone wishes to connect this reason with the immediately preceding discourse, then the words “good deeds” should be understood not as beneficence toward another, but as virtue in general. The word “evil” must be understood in the same way.

He adds, “if it is the will of God,” showing by this that nothing happens to us without God’s permission. It happens either to lighten us from sins, or to reveal and glorify us, or even for the salvation of others.

Read more (87 words)

This happens in two ways. Either some righteous man suffers evil for the chastening of other sinners, according to what is said: “If the righteous man is scarcely saved, where will the sinner appear?” (1 Pet 4:18).

From this comes a twofold benefit. For the righteous sufferer there is an increase of righteousness through patience. For the sinner there is conversion, as has been said.

Or the righteous man suffers both for his own glory and for the conversion and salvation of others, as Christ also did.

Andrew the Monk

6th centuryChurch Father

Again he exhorts us not to grieve over what we suffer unjustly, saying, "if the will of God should so will" that we suffer (1 Pet. 3:17). He teaches us that afflictions come providentially, by God's permission, for our training in virtue. By this he comforts us.

Oecumenius

6th centuryChurch Father

This brings a twofold benefit. Through endurance it makes the righteous sufferer still more righteous, and it turns the sinner who sees our way of life toward our faith, as we have said.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

“For if it is the will,” and so forth: cf. 1 Pet 2:20-21. “A reason is presented, not for what was said immediately before, but for what was said a little above, namely: ‘If you suffer for righteousness, you are blessed’ (1 Pet 3:14). For it is better to suffer for good deeds than for evil ones.

If someone wishes to connect this reason with the immediately preceding discourse, then the words ‘doing good’ should be understood not as beneficence toward another, but as virtue in general. The same applies to the words ‘doing evil.’

He adds, ‘if it is the will of God,’ showing by this that nothing happens to us without God’s permission. It happens either to lighten us from sins, or to reveal and glorify us, or even for the salvation of others.

Read more (243 words)

From this comes a twofold benefit. For the righteous sufferer there is an increase of righteousness through patience. For the sinner there is conversion, as has been said.

Or the righteous man suffers both for his own glory and for the conversion and salvation of others, as Christ also did” (Theophylact).

Reviling and censuring the good Christian life is already, in itself, a suffering for the one reviled. It causes him spiritual suffering, and, as the history of the persecutions of Christians shows, it may bring external sufferings as well.

It is good for a Christian, in the same sense as in 1 Pet 2:20, if he suffers innocently for good deeds, having a good conscience, and not for evil deeds.

Suffering for evil deeds is not an ascetic struggle, but a just punishment for evil, according to the law of eternal righteousness, which always punishes evil sooner or later.

As the foundation and proof of this truth, the apostle here, as above (1 Pet 2:20 and following), cites the example of the Lord Jesus Christ, Who suffered innocently.

Here, however, this thought is unfolded from certain special aspects. In all the New Testament writings, these aspects belong exclusively to this place in the epistle.

For this reason they present some difficulty in explanation. There are no parallel and clearer passages by which certain sayings in this place, unclear at first glance, might be explained. Thus interpreters explain them in very different ways.

Michail Cheraskov

19th centuryChurch Father

But what if, after all, one must suffer according to the will of God? (1 Pet 3:17-22). "It is better to suffer for good deeds than for evil; for Christ also, that He might bring us to God, once suffered for our sins, the righteous for the unrighteous," and was even put to death in the flesh.

But then His glory begins. Having been made alive in spirit and having descended into the dark wilds of Hades, He illumined them also with the radiance of His Resurrection.

As the sovereign conqueror of death, from the belly of Hades He delivered all the victims languishing there, who awaited their deliverance and joyfully heeded His preaching.

He delivered even such victims as seemed the inalienable prey of Hades, namely, people who had perished in the waves of the flood.

Read more (921 words)

The example of the eight saved souls of Noah's family in the ark should inspire Christians also with hope and patience. They are surrounded by the abyss of the sinful world and seem to sail in an ocean of every possible trial from the sons of this age.

Corresponding to this figure, that is, to the floating ark, baptism now also saves us. Its saving power is appropriated by faith in the Resurrection of Jesus Christ.

He Himself, by the path of suffering, ascended into heaven and abides at the right hand of God. Angels, authorities, and powers have been subjected to Him, that is, also according to His humanity.

Having said that it is better to suffer for good deeds than for evil (1 Pet 3:17), the holy Apostle Peter adds: "For Christ also once suffered for our sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, that He might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit.

By this also He went and preached to the spirits in prison."

When reading these apostolic words, the first question naturally arises: what should be understood by the prison into which Christ descended with His soul while His body remained in the tomb?

By this prison the Apostle means that region little known to us, to which the souls of dead people depart and where they abide.

The people of the Old Testament called this region by the common name sheol, or the netherworld, which in Greek is called Hades. This is not Hades in our sense as a place of torment for sinners alone.

It is Hades in the general sense of the realm of the dead (Gen 37:35).

By calling this place a prison or confinement, the Apostle clearly attributes to it something restrictive for the human spirit. It hinders the free manifestation of its powers and is in general something unpleasant and undesirable.

Such was the character of this place before the coming of Christ the Savior for all people who died in general.

Of course, the degree of their righteousness, as well as the degree of their impiety, was reflected in the corresponding degrees of their confinement in sheol.

That is, the souls of the departed patriarchs and, for example, the souls of people who perished during the flood, of whom the Apostle speaks in particular, were not in one place or in the same state.

Why did the Lord descend into Hades? The holy Apostle Peter answers this by saying that Christ, having descended into the prison of the spirits, preached.

Thus the Lord descended into this prison for preaching. The content of this preaching was, of course, that the salvation of mankind had been accomplished.

It also proclaimed that this Savior is He Himself, the Son of Man, who had descended into the nether regions of the earth to the prisoners of Hades.

It proclaimed that the sole and universal means for the salvation of people from there had become moral communion with Him.

Thus "whoever has faith in Him" as the incarnate Son of God "will be saved, but he who does not have faith will be condemned" (Mk 16:16).

That this truly was the essence of Christ's preaching in Hades is indicated rather clearly by the Apostle, when he calls this preaching the Gospel, or good tidings, below in 1 Pet 4:6.

We know that the chief aim, or essence, of the Gospel proclamation is that people may believe "that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that believing they may have life in His name" (Jn 20:31).

To which spirits did Christ preach when He descended into Hades? The Apostle later replaces his expression, that Christ's preaching was to spirits, with another expression: "Christ's good tidings were preached to the dead" (1 Pet 4:6).

Therefore, according to the Apostle, only human spirits, that is, the souls of dead people, were instructed by Christ's preaching, and not spirits in general, such as fallen angelic spirits.

Because these latter spirits lack every good receptivity, preaching to them would be completely hopeless and therefore vain.

On this same basis, one may suppose that even in the realm of human spirits only a portion of them was saved by the radiant preaching of the Resurrection and led out from the strongholds of Hades.

This was the portion in which at least some small receptivity to this preaching and faith in Christ had been preserved.

All the same, it is supremely consoling that the divinely inspired Apostle Peter considerably expands the sphere of people saved by Christ's preaching.

He points to them even where it would have been difficult for us to suppose them, according to our human reasoning. He points precisely to the realm of people who perished in the waves of the flood.

These were people formerly disobedient to the divine longsuffering that awaited them, in the days of Noah, during the building of the ark (1 Pet 3:20).

That many of these people were saved is directly declared by the Apostle when he says: "For to this end the Gospel was preached even to the dead, that. Having been judged according to men in the flesh," that is, having perished and suffered in the body, "they might live according to God in the spirit" in the world beyond the grave (1 Pet 4:6).

Perhaps at the moment of their destruction they recognized their impiety, and who knows? Perhaps they died with cries to God and with repentance.

Nikanor (Kamenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

Here the apostle says that sufferings for righteousness are pleasing to God, and therefore they should be desirable for Christians. Through them Christians avoid the possibility of suffering for sins, both those already committed and those into which they might fall (cf. 1 Pet 4:1, 15), if they were not subjected to sufferings.

“Do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul,” says Jesus Christ. “Rather fear Him who can destroy both soul and body in Gehenna” (Mt 10:28).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 12 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. κρεῖττον
    kreitton
    stronger
    G2908 · κρείσσων
  2. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  3. ἀγαθοποιοῦντας
    agathopoiountas
    I do that which is good
    G15 · ἀγαθοποιέω
  4. εἰ
    ei
    if
    G1487 · εἰ
  5. θέλοι
    theloi
    I will
    G2309 · θέλω
  6. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  7. θέλημα
    thelēma
    will
    G2307 · θέλημα
  8. τοῦ
    tou
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  9. Θεοῦ
    theou
    God
    G2316 · θεός
  10. πάσχειν
    paschein
    I am acted upon
    G3958 · πάσχω
  11. ἢ
    ē
    or
    G2228 · ἤ
  12. κακοποιοῦντας
    kakopoiountas
    I do harm
    G2554 · κακοποιέω