The Church Fathers on this verse

Hosea 10:4Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

You speak words of an unprofitable vision, and you shall make a covenant: and judgment shall spring up as bitterness in the furrows of the field.

Douay-Rheims

דִּבְּר֣וּ דְבָרִ֔ים אָל֥וֹת שָׁ֖וְא כָּרֹ֣ת בְּרִ֑ית וּפָרַ֤ח כָּרֹאשׁ֙ מִשְׁפָּ֔ט עַ֖ל תַּלְמֵ֥י שָׂדָֽי׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

In the beginning, as indicated in verse 3, the wild grass will fade away across the land, particularly affecting the calf of the house of Onova. This wild grass flourishes in fields, especially those that are untilled and left to ruin, spreading rapidly into surrounding territories. Its extensive reach makes it challenging to contain for anyone attempting to halt its relentless growth beyond the neighboring areas. Therefore, He declares that judgment, surely from God, will arise like wild grass upon the land of Selnei, particularly impacting the calf of the house of Onov. It is as if He is asserting that a destructive judgment and punishing blow will strike the idols at the temple in Bethel, resembling wild grass.

Read more (139 words)

This refers specifically to the house of Ones, as some translators interpret it to mean the calf of the house of Bethel. The Septuagint translates this differently, referring to it as ‘the house of Ones.’ I have previously provided the rationale for this, but it is worth reiterating that the Egyptians, in their myths, portrayed Apis as the offspring of the moon and the grandson of the sun, wherein the sun represented their deity, while the heifer created by Jeroboam was an imitation of the Egyptian Apis. Therefore, He states that like wild grass, which overtakes and dominates its surroundings, judgment from Me shall befall the calf of the house of Onov or Bethel, for the divine nature is always all-powerful, and nothing can withstand His will. As it is written, "Who can stop His mighty hand?" (Isaiah 14:27).

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

The agreement, referring to their commitment to worship the Samaritan idols eternally, was a source of profound expectation for them. They manifested the judgment that truth imposes on the unrighteous, akin to a detrimental weed growing unchecked in a farmer's unkempt field. Just as thorns are removed from land prepared for planting, so shall they face destruction through captivity and conflict.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

They will proclaim, “We have no king; we do not revere the Lord, so what can a king accomplish for us?” They utter the words of a hollow vision and form a pact, but the judgement will sprout like bitter grass in the fields. As the Lord dismantles the idols of Israel and demolishes their altars and statues, when their final captivity arrives, they will exclaim, “We have no king.” To counter any notion that judgement is long overdue, it is emphasized that “they will now say” at the moment they face desolation, recognizing that their last king, Hosea, has been taken from them. This king is lost to us because we did not honor the Lord, the true Sovereign; for what can a mere man do for us, even if he wears a crown?

Read more (400 words)

You may mourn your former delusions and cling to false happiness, yet this will swiftly turn to sorrow: you will forge an alliance, but not with God, rather with falsehood. Following this union, which the LXX refers to as a covenant, you will not reap a bountiful harvest of bread or even barley—fit for livestock—nor will you gather assorted vegetables or grapes that yield their juice for wine, nor will trees convert the earth’s moisture into delightful fruits, but instead, you will encounter bitterness, or the judgement of bitterness, or ἄγροστις, expressed in Latin as gramen. This grass resembles a reed, with every knee producing branches above and roots below, and in time, these very branches serve as seeds for new growth, rendering fields akin to thorns if not eradicated in their entirety. Even if a dry portion settles on cultivated ground, it will quickly fill the area with this grass, if it possesses a crannog. This we note concerning the LXX translation. However, in Hebrew, it is termed ros, indicating bitterness, specifically the bitterness of judgement, as the Lord declares in the Gospel, “For judgement I am come into this world” (John 9:39). Additionally, it is noted that these will incur greater judgement (Mark 12:40). Likewise, disciples of opposing beliefs, when their falsehoods crumble and their altars and groves are dismantled, will express regret—yet too late: “We have no kings who once governed us, who through deceit led us to disregarding the Lord.” What did it benefit us to follow them? In our hour of need, we find no assistance from them. Thus, they may seek to justify themselves, claiming that they were not at fault, but rather led astray by poor leaders. The LXX translates their words as false justifications, which the prophet renounces, stating, “Let not my heart sink into the words of deceit, neither let me be guilty of sins” (Psalm 140:4). We readily praise our vices, and succumbing to our passions, blame the frailty of the flesh or obey the stringent commands of those in authority. Hence, the words and visions of heretics will prove futile, and they will form an alliance, not with God, but with bitterness, which, when the day of judgement arrives, will flourish in the furrows of their fields, leading those who once sowed joyfully to reap in tears, those who laughed to mourn, and those who felt comfort to grieve.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

We have not received assistance from the ruler, and we ought to have placed our faith in God, who works in every way on our behalf. Instead, we have relied on a person who speaks deceitfully, constantly contriving excuses and entering into agreements with others. Yet, God declares that you will face consequences for this wrongdoing. The judgment will fade like a thorn on a tree. Just as wheatgrass flourishes in unplowed soil, untouched by footfall or cultivation, so too will the repercussions I have imposed upon you come upon you unexpectedly.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.