The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 89 (88):31Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And if his children forsake my law, and walk not in my judgments:

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

אִם־יַֽעַזְב֣וּ בָ֭נָיו תּוֹרָתִ֑י וּ֝בְמִשְׁפָּטַ֗י לֹ֣א יֵלֵכֽוּן׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

6 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Beloved, grasp the essence of the psalm that I am about to explain, through God’s grace, as we place our hope in the Lord Jesus Christ. Take courage, for He who makes promises is faithful to fulfill them; He has done much already. Our confidence stems not from our own merits but from His grace. In my view, the term “by Himself” refers to Ethan the Israelite, from whom this psalm derives its name. It highlights that strength comes solely from the hope in God's promises; in our human frailty, we are powerless, yet His mercy grants us strength. The psalmist commences with, "I will sing of your mercies, O Lord, forever; with my mouth, I will declare your truth to all generations" (Psalms 88:1).

He states, "Let my members serve the Lord." This implies that when I speak, it is only of Your words. My mouth will proclaim Your truth: should I fail to follow You, I am no true servant; if I speak independently, I am a deceiver. Speaking Your truth differs greatly from speaking my own; one belongs to me, the other to You. Let us pay attention to the faithfulness He displays and the praises He sings.

For You have declared, "Grace shall be settled forever" (Psalm 87:2). This is the truth that I sing: this is the message my mouth strives to proclaim. Thus You proclaim, “I build not to destroy.” Some You do destroy without rebuilding, while others You do rebuild after destruction. Were it not so, Jeremiah would not have written, “Behold, I have charged you today to destroy and to build” (Jeremiah 1:10). Indeed, those who once worshipped images and stones could not be anchored in Christ without experiencing demise due to their previous errors. If not for those who were led to destruction, the scripture would not state, “He will destroy them, and not build them up.”

He interconnects mercy and faithfulness; "For You have said, Mercy shall be settled forever; Your truth shall be established in the heavens," where both mercy and truth intersect, for all of the Lord's paths are marked by mercy and truth. The manifestation of truth in the realization of promises cannot occur without the preceding mercy demonstrated in the forgiveness of transgressions. Furthermore, many promises were made in prophecies to the people of Israel, descended from Abraham's lineage, and God ensured these promises were fulfilled among them. Nevertheless, He also extended the fountain of His goodness to the Gentiles, who were placed under the guidance of angels while Israel remained His chosen people. The apostle mentions the Lord's mercy and truth to both groups, calling Christ the minister of the circumcision, confirming the promises made to the patriarchs (Romans 15:8). See how God has remained faithful; see how He has not forsaken His people, whom He has known beforehand.

Even while the apostle addresses the Jews' fall, he counters the notion that they have completely turned away from God, stating that God has not cast off His people, whom He foreknew, as exemplified in his own identity as an Israelite (Romans 11:1-2). If all of this people have become thorns, what then is said of the wheat? This is to ensure that the truth of God would be revealed in those Israelites who believed, thus connecting the wall of circumcision to the cornerstone. Yet this stone would not be the cornerstone without the wall brought in by the Gentiles: the first wall pertains specifically to truth, while the second pertains to God’s grace. The apostle emphasizes that Jesus Christ was the minister of circumcision for the truth of God, confirming the promises made to the fathers, and that the Gentiles might glorify God for His mercy (Romans 15:8-9).

It is rightly said, "Your truth you shall confirm in the heavens," for all Israelites called to be apostles became as the heavens, proclaiming the glory of God, as noted in the scripture: "The heavens declare the glory of God, and the firmament shows the work of His hands." Although they left this world before the Church spread across the earth, since their words reached the ends of the earth, we rightly conclude that "You will establish Your truth in the heavens" filled in them.

You have said, “I have made a covenant with My chosen” (Psalm 88:3). But what is this covenant but a new covenant, through which we are renewed for a new inheritance, filled with longing and love, expressed in our new song? The psalmist declares, “I have made a covenant with My elect; I have sworn to David, My servant.” How boldly does he speak who understands and whose lips serve truth! I speak without fear, for You have said. If Your word makes me fearless, how much more shall I be fearless when You have sworn! For God’s oath guarantees the fulfillment of the promise.

Humans are justly admonished against swearing (Matthew 5:34), for the habit may lead to perjury, yet God alone swears securely because He alone is infallible. Let us see what God has sworn: “I have sworn to David, My servant; I will establish your seed forever” (Psalm 87:4). But what is the seed of David but the seed of Abraham? "And to your seed," He says, "which is Christ" (Galatians 3:16).

It is conceivable that Christ, the Head of the Church and the Savior of the body (Ephesians 5:23), is the seed of Abraham and of David. But indeed, we are also the seed of Abraham, as the apostle affirms, "But if you are Christ's, then you are Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise" (Galatians 3:29). In this context, we should interpret the words, “I will establish your seed forever,” not only referring to the flesh of Christ born of the Virgin Mary but also to all who believe in Him. For we are members of this Head. This body cannot exist without the Head: if the Head is glorified forever, so are the members, thus Christ remains complete forever. “I will establish your seed forever, and I will establish your throne for generation and generation.” We assume he says “forever” because it pertains to each generation; as stated above, “With my mouth I will always show Your truth to generation and kindred.”

What is meant by generation and generation? To every generation, for the repetition emphasizes the ongoing nature rather than mere numerical recurrence. Perhaps we should conceive of two generations: one of flesh and blood, and the other in the resurrection of the dead. Christ is acknowledged both here and there, proclaimed here for belief and welcomed there for sight. “I will establish your throne from generation to generation.” Christ currently reigns within us; His throne is established within us, for if He were not seated on His throne within, He would not rule over us. Were we not under His rule, we would be cast down ourselves. Thus, He resides in us, reigning over us; He also reigns in another generation that comes from the resurrection of the dead. Christ will reign over His Saints forever. God has promised it; He has declared it; if that were insufficient, God has sworn it. Thus, since the promise is reliable—not due to our merits, but because of His mercy—none should shy away from declaring that which he cannot doubt.

Let this truth enrich our hearts, as Ethan's name suggests a strong heart; let us proclaim the truth of God—His utterance, His promises, His oath; and strengthened from all sides by these means, let us glorify God and, carrying Him within, become as Heaven.

“Lord, even the heavens will praise Your marvelous works” (Psalm 88:5). They will not praise themselves but will exalt Your marvelous deeds, O Lord. In every act of mercy extended to the lost, in justification of the unjust, what do we celebrate but the marvelous works of God? Praise Him for raising the dead and for redeeming the lost. What grace, what mercy! You might witness a man yesterday ensnared in drunkenness yet today a model of sobriety; yesterday a shackle of luxury, now a beacon of temperance; yesterday a blasphemer, today a worshipper; yesterday a slave to creation, today a servant of the Creator. Such transformations arise from despair; let them look not to their merits but become like Heaven, praising the marvelous works of Him who created them.

“Who among the clouds can compare with You, O Lord?” (Psalm 88:6). Will it be the admiration of Heaven; will it be their rain? Are preachers convinced no one among the clouds equals the Lord? Is it an extraordinary exaltation that clouds cannot match their Creator? If taken literally and not mystically, it doesn’t hold; can the stars that overshadow the clouds be compared to the Lord? Can the sun, moon, angels, and heavens match Him? Why then does it suggest an elevation of praise saying, "Who is He among the clouds?" We understand, beloved, that these clouds, akin to the heavens, are heralds of truth; the prophets, apostles, proclaimers of God's word...

If clouds serve as voices of truth, let us first discern why they are termed clouds. The same beings are called both heaven and clouds: heaven reflects the brilliance of truth, while clouds signify the obscurities of our flesh. All clouds appear dark due to mortality and transit. Concerning these obscurities, the apostle says, "Therefore judge nothing before the time, until the Lord come, who shall lighten the hidden things of darkness" (1 Corinthians 4:5). You can observe what a person expresses; however, what lies in their heart remains unseen. The outward manifestations show, while the concealed truths do not.

Who among us can penetrate the clouds? Thus, clouds serve as vessels of truth in the flesh. The Creator took on flesh Himself... We are called clouds due to our flesh, and we are messengers of truth thanks to the rain brought forth by clouds; yet our existence is birthed in one way, His in another. We too are called sons of God, yet He is the Son of God in a different sense. His cloud emerged from the Virgin, He is the Son from eternity, consubstantial with the Father. Who is the One among the clouds who could rival the Lord? And who, among the sons of God, parallels Him? Let the Lord Himself declare whether a match for Him exists.

"Who do people say I am, the Son of Man?" He asks, perhaps reflecting upon how common He has appeared among us. Tell me, for whom do people recognize Me, the Son of Man? Indeed, when they see the son of man, they recognize a cloud; but they question, "Who do people think I am?" In response, they recount various opinions: some say John the Baptist; some, Elijah; others, Jeremiah or one of the prophets. Clouds and sons of God are mixed together; as the righteous and holy, they too can be called sons, just as Jeremiah, Elijah, and John. Their role as proclaimers aids their identity as clouds.

"You have described how clouds represent Me; now also consider, ‘Who do you say that I am?’" Peter answered for all, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God” (Matthew 16:13-16). Not as those other sons of God who aren't equal to You. You came as flesh but not as clouds, which aren’t equal to You.

“God is greatly to be revered in the assembly of the righteous and revered by all who surround Him.” (Psalm 88:7). God is everywhere; thus, who is surrounding Him who is ever-present? If He had anything surrounding Him, He would appear finite. Moreover, if it is genuinely said of and about God, then His greatness is limitless; who remains around Him except that He who is omnipresent chose to be born in flesh at one place, dwell among one people, be crucified at one locale, rise from there, and ascend to Heaven? Where He performed these acts, He had Gentiles in His presence. Had He simply remained where He accomplished these deeds, He would not have been deemed great nor reverenced by all. Instead, by preaching in a manner that sent His name’s ambassadors throughout the globe, performing wonders among His emissaries, He grew in renown, instilling awe among all.

Read the full text in the app

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Those who abandon the law, disregard judges, disregard justice, and violate the commandments are met with correction, which represents God's instruction, and will find themselves lacking His compassion. This indicates that within the Church, only those anticipating punishment remain. Just as divine justice instills fear through righteousness, so too does mercy temper with gentleness.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

God declares that even if the descendants of David commit numerous wrongdoings, He will discipline them; however, He will uphold the covenant made with David unwaveringly. God will not remove His grace from David, nor will He violate His truth. In place of "I will not transgress," Simmachus translated it as "I will not transgress," while Aquila rendered it as "I will not lie."

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

If, He states, the followers of Christ—those who are reborn through the gospel and the sacrament of baptism—forsake the law, neglect my courts, dishonor my judgments, and disregard my commandments, I will address their transgressions with a rod and scourge. The distinctions between the law and judgment, as well as truth and commandment, are elaborated upon in Psalm 17, where the phrase For the age of his judgments is before me is used. The term 'defile' is chosen in place of 'destroy'; for that which is profane is non-sanctified, serving to differentiate it from the sacred or from items held in low regard. In this context, the rod and scourge represent temptations.

Read more (167 words)

The essence of this message is that I will instruct the trespassers of my law among believers through the rebellions of nations, the harshness of rulers, plagues, and similar trials; however, I will not completely forsake them. Ultimately, He refers to iniquities and unrighteousness as synonymous with the same faults. Through these statements, He warns those who commit sins that can be healed of an impending visitation of iniquity through the rod; this divine rod, as an instrument of correction, brings forth firm judgments. To those who remain unrepentant, He asks, "Why are you still wounded? You have felt all injuries and scorned all blows intended for your repentance; despair awaits you." Among the calamities that befall humanity, some are for the sake of sins, some aim to correct the morals of those who are tempted, and others serve for the brokenness of the desperate, as illustrated in the story of Pharaoh. The latter group is no longer warned with wounds or scourges, but faced with destruction.

Hesychius of Jerusalem

5th centuryChurch Father

Those who violate even the least commandment of God's law and seek to interpret its precepts according to their personal desires, rather than in alignment with the intentions of the Lawgiver, abandon God's statutes. Those who show favoritism towards the wealthy or the poor during judgment do not uphold divine justice, while the Lord desires that His judgment be impartial for all.

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

The prophet further expresses that despite the transgressions of David's lineage, God will show compassion and refrain from meting out justice in its fullest measure. To reinforce the validity of this promise, God is often depicted as speaking directly to them within the context of the covenant. This emphasis is crucial because without God's infinite mercy forgiving our sins, any of His covenants would be rendered ineffective, given our frailty and tendency to stumble. God foresaw that David's descendants would stray from the covenant due to their sins; thus, He instituted a means of restoration.

Read more (310 words)

Understanding that divine discipline is beneficial, God assures His people that He will not respond in a manner that allows sin to flourish, but rather with a corrective yet gentle approach, reflecting a loving father who does not demand the utmost retribution. He pledges to pardon not only minor transgressions but also the most serious offenses. The reason behind this is articulated with phrases such as “if they forsake My law,” “if they profane My judgments,” “if they do not walk in My ways,” and “if they do not keep My commandments.” These warnings are intended to demonstrate that God's patience and kindness towards David's heirs extend even to the gravest of sins.

This is further supported by the words of the prophet Jeremiah: “I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah; not according to the covenant I made with their forefathers; I will put My laws in their minds and write them on their hearts, and I will be merciful to their iniquities, and I will remember their sins no more” (Jeremiah 31:31ff). Nevertheless, since God does not welcome us into His family to allow us to sin without consequence, discipline is firmly established, showing His aversion to sin and His call for repentance. As Paul teaches, “But when we are judged, we are chastened by the Lord, that we may not be condemned with the world” (1 Cor. 11:32). Thus, the promise stands: “I will visit their iniquity with a rod, and their sin with stripes; yet My lovingkindness will not depart from them.” Although anger may arise from wrongdoing, God's love remains steadfast towards those He disciplines for their own good. The following declaration, “I will not violate My faithfulness,” and as rendered in Hebrew, “I will not lie regarding My faithfulness,” affirms that God's promises are unwaveringly true.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.