The Church Fathers on this verse

Romans 8:27Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And he that searcheth the hearts knoweth what the Spirit desireth: because he asketh for the saints according to God.

Douay-Rheims

ο δε ερευνων τας καρδιας οιδεν τι το φρονημα του πνευματος οτι κατα θεον εντυγχανει υπερ αγιων

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

11 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

'He who searches the hearts.' Do you see that the discussion is not about the Comforter, but about the spiritual heart? Otherwise he should have said, 'He who searches the Spirit.'

But so that you may understand that he is speaking of the spiritual man who has the gift of prayer, the Apostle adds: 'He who searches the hearts knows what is the mind of the spirit,' that is, of the spiritual man.

'Because according to God he intercedes for the saints.' He intercedes, the Apostle reasons, not because God does not know our needs, but so that we may learn to pray for what is necessary and to ask God for what is pleasing to Him.

This is what 'according to God' means. Thus this was done both for the consolation of those present and for the best instruction, since the One Who communicates gifts and bestows countless blessings was the Comforter.

'All these things,' the Apostle says, 'are worked by one and the same Spirit' (1 Cor 12:11). This also happens for our instruction and to manifest the love of the Spirit, Who descends to us to such a degree.

Therefore all listened to the one praying, because the prayer was offered according to God's will. Do you see how many lessons the Apostle gives them about God's love for them and the honor shown to them?

Indeed, what has God not done for us? For us He created the corruptible world, and for us the incorruptible. For us He willed that the prophets suffer afflictions.

For us He sent them into captivity. For us He allowed them to fall into the furnace and endure countless sufferings. For our sake He created the prophets themselves, and for us the apostles.

For us He gave up the Only-begotten. For us He punishes the devil. He seated us at His right hand. For us He endured reproaches, for it says, 'The reproaches of those who reproached You fell upon Me' (Ps 69:9).

Yet if after this we depart from Him, He does not abandon us. He calls us again and disposes others to ask for us, so that He may grant us His grace.

This happened with Moses, to whom God said, 'Leave Me, and I will destroy them' (Ex 32:10), in order to move him to intercede for the Jews. He does the same now, which is why He gives the gift of prayer.

God did this not because He Himself needs our prayer, but so that, if saved without prayers, we might not become worse. For this same reason He repeatedly says that He is reconciled to the Jews for David's sake, or for one or another person.

He does this to give reconciliation the appearance of lawfulness, although He would show Himself more loving toward mankind if He said that He ceased His anger against the Jews for His own sake and not for another's.

But He cared not so much about this as about ensuring that the very cause of reconciliation not become an occasion of negligence for those being saved.

Thus, when He said to Jeremiah, 'Do not pray for this people; for I will not hear you' (Jer 11:14), He did not wish the prophet to stop praying. God greatly desires our salvation.

Rather, He wished to frighten the Jews. The prophet, knowing this, did not stop praying. To convince you that this was said to shame the Jews, not to turn the prophet away from prayer, hear what God says: 'Do you not see what they are doing?'

When He says to the city of Jerusalem, 'Though you wash yourself with lye and use much soap, you are stained before Me' (Jer 2:22), He does not wish to cast it into despair, but to move it to repentance.

As He frightened the Ninevites and most of all disposed them to repentance by uttering an indefinite sentence against them and giving them no good hope, so He acts here.

He rouses the Jews and instills reverence for the prophet, so that by this way at least they might obey him. Since they remained in incurable sickness and were in no way instructed by the captivity of others, God first exhorts them to remain there.

When they could not endure this and began fleeing to Egypt, God allowed it, but required them not to surrender to Egyptian impiety. When they did not obey even in this, He sent the prophet to them, lest they be utterly corrupted.

Since they did not come at His call, He Himself goes after them, corrects them, restrains them from greater impiety, and constantly accompanies and follows them, like a tenderly loving father after a son who fails in everything.

For this reason God sent not only Jeremiah to Egypt, but Ezekiel to Babylon. The prophets did not resist this, because they knew how greatly the Master loved the Jews.

They even did it gladly, like a grateful servant who is filled with pity for his master's undisciplined son when he sees that the father grieves and is crushed over him.

And what did the prophets not suffer from the Jews? They were sawn in two, persecuted, reviled, subjected to countless afflictions, and after all this they came to them again.

Samuel did not cease grieving over Saul, though he had been cruelly insulted by him and endured unbearable wrongs. Yet he remembered none of them.

Jeremiah even wrote a lamentation for the Jewish people. When the Persian commander gave him complete freedom to live safely wherever he wished, he preferred to suffer evil with his people and endure hardship in a foreign land rather than remain in his homeland.

So Moses, leaving the royal palace and courtly life, hastened to share the misfortunes of the Israelites. Daniel for twenty-six days tasted no bread and afflicted himself with the strictest fast, in order to appease God toward the Jews.

The three youths, while in the furnace and in the mighty fire, offered fervent prayers for the Jews and did not lament over themselves, because they were unharmed. Since they hoped then to have special boldness, they prayed for them, saying: 'With a contrite soul and a humble spirit may we be accepted' (Dan 3:39).

For their sake Joshua tore his garments (Josh 7:6). For their sake Ezekiel shed tears and lamented when he saw them being killed. Jeremiah said: 'Leave me, that I may weep bitterly' (Isa 22:4).

Before this, not daring to intercede for the complete cessation of disasters, he asked when they would end, saying, 'How long, O Lord?' Thus the whole assembly of holy men was filled with love.

Therefore Paul also said: 'Put on, therefore, as the elect of God, holy, bowels of mercies, kindness, humility' (Col 3:12). Do you notice the full force of the words, and how the Apostle wants us always to be merciful?

He did not simply say, Be merciful, but, 'Put on,' making known that mercy, like clothing, must always be with us. Nor did he simply say, Put on mercy, but, 'bowels of mercies,' so that we might imitate the natural feeling of tender love.

But we act otherwise. If someone approaches asking for the smallest coin, we rebuke him, revile him, and call him a deceiver.

Do you not shudder, man? Are you not ashamed that for a piece of bread you call him a deceiver? Even if he is pretending, for that very reason he deserves pity, because hunger torments him so greatly that he is forced to assume such a mask.

This is proof of our cruelty. Since we do not easily give voluntarily, the poor are forced to invent countless devices to deceive our inhumanity and soften our harshness.

It would be different if he asked you for a silver or gold coin; then you would have grounds for suspicion. But if he comes to you for necessary food, why philosophize without need and examine with excessive precision, accusing him of idleness and laziness?

If this must be said, we should accuse not others but ourselves. Therefore, when you come to God asking mercy for your sins, remember these words.

You will understand that it would be more just for you yourself to hear them from God than for the beggar to hear them from you. Yet God has never spoken such words to you.

He did not say: Go away, for you are a hypocrite. You constantly go to church and hear My laws, but in the marketplace you prefer gold, your desire, friendship, and in short everything to My commandments.

Now you appear humble, but after prayer you become insolent, harsh, and inhuman. Therefore, go away and never come to Me. We deserve to hear this and even more, yet God has never reproached us with anything of the kind.

He is long-suffering, fulfills everything on His part, and gives us more than we ask. Reflecting on this, let us deliver those who ask from poverty. Even if they pretend, let us not investigate it.

We ourselves need salvation, and salvation with condescension, love for mankind, and much mercy. If strict inquiry were made into our affairs, it would be impossible ever to be saved.

All would have to undergo punishment and perish. Therefore let us not be strict judges of others, so that strict account is not demanded from us, for we are burdened with sins beyond all pardon.

Let us have greater compassion for those who sin without deserving indulgence, so that we ourselves may hope for such mercy toward us. However much we try, we will never be able to show such love for mankind as we need from the God Who loves mankind.

Is it not senseless, then, when we ourselves are in such great need, to examine the affairs of our brothers strictly and do everything against ourselves?

You do not so much show him unworthy of your benefaction as yourself unworthy of God's love for mankind. Whoever strictly exacts from his brother will be much more strictly examined by God.

Therefore let us not speak against ourselves. Whether someone approaches through carelessness or laziness, let us give. We ourselves often, indeed always, sin through negligence.

Yet God does not at once demand an account from us, but gives us time for repentance. Every day He feeds us, corrects us, teaches us, and provides everything else, so that we too may imitate Him in such mercy.

Let us put aside cruelty and cast off savagery, for by this we benefit ourselves more than others. To others we give money, bread, and clothing, but for ourselves we prepare the greatest glory, which cannot be described in words.

Clothed in incorruptible bodies, we shall be glorified and reign with Christ. How great this is we shall learn from what follows. Or rather, at present we cannot by any means receive a clear notion of it.

But to form some understanding of it from our present goods, I shall try, as far as I can, to describe what I have said. Tell me: if someone promised suddenly to make you, now old and living in poverty, young again, to bring you into flowering age, make you stronger and more beautiful than all. And give you royal authority over the whole earth for a thousand years, securing your reign with perfect peace, what would you not agree to do and endure for such a promise?

But behold, Christ promises not this, but far greater things. The difference between old age and youth is not so great as that between corruption and incorruption.

Nor is the difference between kingship and poverty so great as that between future glory and present glory. Between them is the same difference as between a dream and reality.

Yet even by this I have still explained nothing. In general, there are no words to depict the greatness of the difference between the future and the present, since because of time the whole difference is impossible for the mind to grasp.

How can one compare with the present a life that has no end? The peace of the future life differs from the peace of this life as much as peace differs from war.

Incorruption surpasses corruption as much as a pure pearl is better than a lump of dirt. Or rather, whatever anyone says will not fully depict this difference.

If I compare the beauty of future bodies to the light of a sunbeam or to the brightest lightning, I will still have said nothing worthy of that splendor.

For the sake of such things, what earthly treasures, what bodies, or rather what souls, should we not despise? If someone now brought you into the royal palace, enabled you to speak with the king before all, and even to be with him and eat at the same table, you would certainly count yourself happier than all.

Read the full text in the app

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

That man stands and prays, he says, not because our needs are unknown to God. The One who searches the hearts knows the mind of the spirit, that is, of the spiritual man. He asks on behalf of the believers who are in the Church, for they are saints, and he asks what is pleasing to God. This happens so that we may learn to ask according to God’s will, that is, for what is pleasing to God. Therefore, if the Spirit intercedes for us, do not grieve when you are wronged.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

The One who searches the hearts knows what the intention of the spirit is, because He intercedes for the saints according to the will of the Godhead. Those who spoke in tongues, he says, prayed by the spirit. The Spirit Himself knew what they knew in tongues, and He Himself spoke (1 Cor 14).

Ambrosiaster

4th centuryChurch Father

It is evident that God, for whom nothing is unspoken or hidden, knows the prayer of every spirit (see Job 37:16; Acts 15:18; 1 Jn 3:20; 3 Esd 16:62). How much more must God know what the Holy Spirit says, since He has the same essence?

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Here the Apostle calls “Spirit” not the Hypostasis of the Spirit, but the grace given to believers. Inflamed by it, we pray more zealously and enter into converse with God our Savior through unutterable groanings. The divine Apostle wrote this because he had experienced it himself. For he too asked to be delivered from temptations, not once or twice, but three times. Yet he did not receive what he asked, but heard, “My grace is sufficient for you, for My power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Cor 12:9). Having learned this, he came to love the very thing from which he had desired deliverance, and says, “Therefore I will most gladly boast rather in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may dwell in me.”

Constantius

5th centuryChurch Father

In Holy Scripture, the gifts of the Spirit are commonly called Spirit. Thus in this place also the Holy Spirit means the gifts of the Spirit, which are given and distributed among men in different ways. This accords with the Apostle’s words in the Epistle to the Corinthians: “There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit” (1 Cor 12:4).

Caesarius of Arles

6th centuryChurch Father

Thus, silently inspired by the Holy Spirit, the cry of the saints is heard in the presence of God.

Ivanov A.V.

19th centuryChurch Father

“He who searches the hearts,” that is, God, “knows what is the mind,” or thought and action, of the Spirit in a man’s heart. In other words, He knows the dispositions and movements that are stirred in man toward God. Therefore He also knows the intercession that the Holy Spirit offers to God for us. Since the Holy Spirit intercedes for Christians only in accordance with the will and by the providence of God, and only for what is saving for them, God accepts this intercession.

Michail Cheraskov

19th centuryChurch Father

Whatever heavy sorrows may visit Christians on earth, the Holy Spirit, who intercedes for them with “groanings too deep for words,” will strengthen them in their weaknesses. He will order all things for good, so that nothing will turn them from the path of virtue that leads to glory, for they have been called to it according to God’s good pleasure.

Nikanor (Kamenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

Then, going more deeply into the life and condition of Christians, the Apostle again returns to the thought of their sufferings.

He teaches that, against them, besides hope, there is another remedy: the all-effective help of the Holy Spirit and prayer.

This is especially the prayer performed by the inspiration of the Spirit and expressed in wondrous divine feelings that cannot be spoken in words, in noetic prayer.

Concerning prayer of this kind Ambrosiaster writes: “God knows the prayer of all spirits.

Still more is the prayer of the Holy Spirit known to Him, for the Spirit is of one essence with Him.

When He intercedes for us, He speaks not through the vibration of air, nor as angels or other creatures do, but as befits His Godhead.

Read more (83 words)

Thus He prays to God in us and asks only for what He knows is pleasing to God and useful for us.”

According to Chrysostom, “in the primitive Church the gift of prayer came upon one person, who alone asked for what was generally useful for the Church and taught others to pray.

The one counted worthy of that grace would stand in the assembly. With great contrition and the deepest groanings, falling before God, he asked for what was useful to all.”

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

Let us repeat again what has been said. The Spirit prays for us, and God knows this mind of the Spirit, as the One who searches the hearts.

Consequently, this mind, or this prayer, does not go to God apart from man. It is first reflected in his heart and through him ascends to God.

Again, this prayer, placed by the Spirit, is received and felt by the heart. It may not be embraced by thought or expressed fittingly by the tongue.

But this does not hinder its efficacy, for God sees what is in the heart of the one who prays in this way. He also sees what thought belongs to the Spirit who placed the prayer there.

“Because He intercedes for the saints according to God.”

Read more (327 words)

“Intercedes” means the same as “makes intercession.” “For the saints” means for believers, who both keep the faith and live according to faith by the grace of the Holy Spirit.

But what does “according to God” mean? It means in accordance with God’s plans and intentions, both for the whole Church and for each believer.

The Spirit of God, as God, knows these plans and intentions, for He has one knowledge with God the Father.

Knowing this, the Holy Spirit prays for us accordingly, or forms prayers for us and places them in our heart.

God knows them beforehand, by the unity of knowledge in the tri-hypostatic God.

Ambrosiaster writes: “God knows the prayer of all spirits, because nothing is hidden from Him.

Still more is the prayer of the Holy Spirit known to Him, for the Spirit is of one essence with Him.

When He intercedes for us, He speaks not through the vibration of air, nor as angels or other creatures do, but as befits His Godhead.

Thus He prays to God in us and asks only for what He knows is pleasing to God and useful for us.”

Perhaps “knows” here means not bare knowledge, but also gracious attention, as in the first Psalm: “The Lord knows the way of the righteous” (Ps 1:6).

Since such prayer is according to God and wholly agrees with God’s intentions, it is graciously heard and accepted, and draws a swift fulfillment.

Our own prayer does not always find God’s path. Therefore we pray, but not as we ought, and we do not see our prayers fulfilled.

He prays as he ought who prays not only for what is pleasing to God in general, but for what is pleasing to God at this time and in these circumstances.

Since we cannot say that we know this definitely, the best prayer for us is: Let Thy will be done, O Lord, upon us, as we have hoped in Thee.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 17 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  2. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. ἐραυνῶν
    eraunōn
    I search diligently
    G2045 · ἐρευνάω
  4. τὰς
    tas
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  5. καρδίας
    kardias
    the heart
    G2588 · καρδία
  6. οἶδεν
    oiden
    I know
    G1492 · εἴδω
  7. τί
    ti
    who
    G5101 · τίς
  8. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  9. φρόνημα
    phronēma
    thought
    G5427 · φρόνημα
  10. τοῦ
    tou
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  11. Πνεύματος
    pneumatos
    wind
    G4151 · πνεῦμα
  12. ὅτι
    hoti
    that
    G3754 · ὅτι
  13. κατὰ
    kata
    down from
    G2596 · κατά
  14. Θεὸν
    theon
    God
    G2316 · θεός
  15. ἐντυγχάνει
    entynchanei
    I meet
    G1793 · ἐντυγχάνω
  16. ὑπὲρ
    hyper
    in behalf of
    G5228 · ὑπέρ
  17. ἁγίων
    hagiōn
    set apart
    G40 · ἅγιος