The Church Fathers on this verse

1 Thessalonians 5:19Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Extinguish not the spirit.

Douay-Rheims

το πνευμα μη σβεννυτε

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

13 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

A kind of dense gloom, darkness, and mist is spread over the whole earth. Pointing to this, the Apostle said, “You were once darkness,” and again, “But you, brethren, are not in darkness, that the day should overtake you like a thief” (Eph 5:8; 1 Thess 5:4).

Since it is now night, as it were a moonless night, and we walk in the midst of this night, God has given us a bright lamp. He has kindled in our souls the grace of the Holy Spirit.

After receiving this light, some made it brighter and clearer, such as Paul, Peter, and all the saints. Others quenched it, such as the five virgins, those who suffered shipwreck in the faith, the Corinthian fornicator, and the fallen Galatians.

Read more (810 words)

Therefore Paul now says, “Do not quench the Spirit,” that is, the gift. For he is accustomed to call the gift of the Holy Spirit by this name. An impure life quenches it.

When a man pours water on the light in a lamp, or throws earth on it, or even only pours out its oil, he extinguishes the light. So it is also with the gift of grace.

If you have brought in earthly things, if you have surrendered yourself to cares over passing affairs, you have already quenched the Spirit.

Or even if you have done nothing of the kind, a temptation may come from outside and rush violently upon you, like a kind of wind.

If the flame in you was not burning strongly, or if there was not much oil for it, or if you did not close the lamp’s opening or shut the doors, then everything is lost.

What is this opening? As in a lamp, so also in us there is an opening. It is the eye and the ear. Do not allow the violent spirit of wickedness to rush through these openings, lest it extinguish the lamp.

Guard them with the fear of God. The doors are our lips. Close and bar them, so that the light may pass through them and they may repel the attack from outside.

For example, if someone has wronged you or insulted you with words, close your mouth. If you open it, you will raise a storm.

Do you not see what happens in houses? When two opposite doors stand directly across from one another and a strong wind rises, close one door, and there will be no draft. The wind will do nothing, but will lose much of its force.

So it is here. There are two doors: your mouth and the mouth of the one who insults and slanders you. If you close your mouth and do not open a free course to the air from the opposite side, you destroy all the force of the wind.

But if you open it, the wind becomes uncontrollable. Therefore let us not quench Him. Yet it often happens that this flame is extinguished without any external cause.

When oil is lacking, when we do not give alms, the Spirit is quenched. Since He Himself came to you by the mercy of God, when He does not find this fruit in you, He flies away from you.

For He does not remain in a merciless soul. What happens after the Spirit is quenched is known to those among you who have walked on a moonless night.

If it is difficult to walk at night along a road leading from one earthly place to another, how can one safely walk the path leading from earth to heaven?

Do you not know how many demons are along this distance, how many beasts, how many spirits of wickedness? But if we have that light within ourselves, they will not be able to harm us.

If we extinguish it, they will immediately seize us and at once take everything from us. Robbers also first extinguish the lamp, and only then plunder. They see in that darkness because they do the works of darkness.

But we are not accustomed to such light. Therefore let us not quench it. Every evil deed quenches this light: slander, insult, and every sin you may name.

As with fire, everything alien to it destroys it, and everything akin to it strengthens it. So also with this light. Whatever is dry, warm, and fiery strengthens the spiritual flame.

Therefore let us bring to it nothing cold and nothing wet. Such things destroy it.

There is, however, another explanation of this passage from the epistle. In those times many prophesied, some truly and others falsely. The Apostle mentions this also in the epistle to the Corinthians.

He says that for this reason God gave the discernment of spirits (1 Cor 12:10). The devil, being crafty, wished through this gift of prophecy to overthrow everything in the Church.

Because of this, both foretold the future: the demon and the Spirit. The first spoke falsely, the second truly. There was no sign available by which one could distinguish one from the other.

For both kinds of prophets taught without giving an account, like Jeremiah or Ezekiel. But in time the false prophets were exposed, and the ability to discern spirits was given.

Therefore, since many among the Thessalonians were prophesying at that time, the Apostle hints at this elsewhere. He says, “Do not be quickly shaken in mind or troubled, either by spirit, or by word, or by letter as if from us, as though the day of Christ had come” (2 Thess 2:2).

Having said, “Do not quench the Spirit,” he aptly added the following words: “Do not despise prophecies.”

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Since the present life is night, God has given us a clear lamp, the Holy Spirit. Some have made this lamp brighter, as all the saints have done. Others have extinguished it, like the five virgins who left it without oil.

The Corinthian fornicator also extinguished it, for he poured impurity into it. Therefore he said, "Do not quench the Spirit," that is, the gift.

Shut the doors, that is, the senses, so that the spirit of wickedness may not enter and extinguish the lamp. Do not bring in earthly cares, and the lamp will remain unquenched.

Or it may also be understood in this way. There were among them prophets of God and false prophets. Since it was not known who was a true prophet, they turned away from all.

Therefore the Apostle says to them: Do not quench the Spirit, that is, the gift in the true prophets, by turning away from them as from false prophets. And do not despise prophecies from the Holy Spirit.

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

The blessed Paul also exhorts us to this, since he does not wish to see the gift of grace entrusted to us grow cold. He writes: "Do not quench the Spirit." Thus we shall remain partakers of Christ if we firmly hold the pledge of the Spirit from beginning to end. For the Apostle said, "Do not quench Him." He did not mean that the Holy Spirit is handed over to the power of men and can suffer anything from them. Rather, those who show themselves evil and ungrateful in their desires quench Him. Like them, those who have grown old in their iniquities are opponents of the Holy Spirit.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

"Do not quench the Spirit," that is, do not make silent those who speak with tongues of the Spirit.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

"Do not quench the Spirit." And by what is the Spirit quenched? "Do not despise prophecies." Some say that even in the time of the Apostles the devil raised up false prophets against true prophets. Therefore, because of false prophecies, some forbade even those who prophesied and foretold the truth to prophesy. For this reason the Apostle commands them not to forbid prophetic grace, because those who do this, as it were, quench the illumination given by grace. The following words also show this. Verse 21: "Test all things; hold fast what is good."

Ammon Abba

4th centuryChurch Father

The most negligent monks have no warmth within themselves, but follow their own desires. When they meet with you, they speak about the things of this age. By such conversation they quench your warmth and deprive you of it, preventing you from attaining progress. It is written: "Do not quench the Spirit." It is quenched by vain words and distraction. When you see such monks, do them a service and flee from them, without entering into communion with them. For they are the ones who do not allow a man to make progress during this life.

Antonius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

"Do not quench the Spirit; do not despise prophecies" (1 Thess 5:19-20). Know that nothing quenches the Spirit so much as vain conversations.

Macarius the Egyptian

4th centuryChurch Father

Why is it written, "Do not quench the Spirit," when He is unquenchable and light-bearing? Because when you neglect the Spirit and do not agree with Him by your will, you become extinguished to the Spirit.

In the same way Scripture says, "Do not grieve the Holy Spirit, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption" (Eph 4:30).

You see that it lies in your will and in your free choice to honor the Holy Spirit and not to grieve Him.

And I tell you that even in perfect Christians, who are taken captive and made drunk by the good, there remains free choice. Therefore, after being tested by thousands of evils, they turn toward the good.

Question: Why do some fall after grace has visited them? How can there be night where day is?

Read more (94 words)

Answer: They fall not because grace is extinguished or grows weak. Rather, God permits malice to act in order to test your choice and your freedom, to see where they incline.

And when you again draw near to the Lord by your will, you once more call down upon yourself the visitation of grace.

For why is it written, "Do not quench the Spirit," when He is unquenchable and light-bearing? Because when you do not care for the Spirit and do not agree with Him by your will, you become extinguished to the Spirit.

Marcus the Ascetic

4th centuryChurch Father

Learn from the words of the same Apostle: "Do not quench the Spirit," and again: "Do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption" (Eph 4:30).

We have brought forward these testimonies not because we consider every man who has been baptized and received grace to be thereby unchangeable and no longer in need of repentance.

Rather, we wished to show that, from baptism, by the gift of Christ, perfect divine grace has been given to us for the fulfillment of all the commandments.

But afterward, each man who has received it mystically and does not fulfill the commandments according to the measure of his purification falls under the activity of sin. This sin is not Adam's, but belongs to the one who has sinned.

Read more (214 words)

The Holy Spirit is given at once in baptism to those who firmly believe. But we ourselves grieve and quench Him within us.

Therefore the Apostle commands: "Do not quench the Spirit" (1 Thess 5:19), and, "Do not grieve the Holy Spirit, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption" (Eph 4:30).

This does not mean that everyone baptized and receiving grace is thereby unchangeable and no longer needs repentance.

It means that, from baptism, by the gift of Christ, perfect divine grace has been given to us for the fulfillment of all the commandments.

But afterward, each man receives it mystically and does not fulfill the commandments. To the measure that he neglects them, he falls under the activity of sin.

This happens because, through negligence, having received the power to act, he does not perform the works.

If we desire to become perfect, whether quickly or slowly, we must believe Christ completely and fulfill all His commandments, having received from Him the power for this work.

As much as we, believing, fulfill the commandments of God, so much does the Holy Spirit bring forth His fruits in us.

The fruits of the Spirit, according to Saint Paul, are love, joy, peace, longsuffering, kindness, mercy, faith, meekness, and self-control (Gal 5:22).

Nilus of Sinai

5th centuryChurch Father

One must never remain in idleness or cease the study of Scripture, prayer, spiritual hymns, and light-bearing action in accord with truth. Otherwise, by becoming negligent toward ourselves and relaxed in conduct, we may lose the warmth of grace. Therefore the divine Apostle commands, crying out: "Do not quench the Spirit" (1 Thess 5:19). And in the Old Testament law, as you have often heard, it is prescribed: "The fire on the altar shall burn on it," that is, in the ruling part of the soul, "and it shall not go out" (Lev 6:12).

Ivanov A.V.

19th centuryChurch Father

"Do not quench the Spirit." Spiritual gifts are often compared with light or fire. The action of the Spirit in a man also requires special conditions of life. Fire in a lamp goes out when there is no oil, or when impure oil is poured in, or when some nonflammable substance is poured in. Light grows dim from smoke, or from being screened by dark objects. So it is with the spirit living in us. It is quenched by lack of mercy, love, and goodness. It goes out through an impure life. It grows dim through evil deeds and thoughts. The Apostle requires purity of the lamp of conscience, purity of the vessel, the body, and the oil of virtues.

Nikanor (Kamenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The grace of God, in its common manifestations and in its particular gifts, as also the prophetic gift, constitutes the highest manifestations of spiritual life in Christ. They are, as it were, the very springs of this life.

Saint John Chrysostom speaks thus about the burning of the spirit: "Night surrounds us, so to speak, moonless night, and we walk amid this night. But God has given us a clear lamp, kindling in our souls the grace of the Holy Spirit.

"Having received this light, some made it brighter and clearer, as Paul, Peter, and all the saints did. Others extinguished it, like the five virgins.

"Therefore Paul now says, 'Do not quench the Spirit,' that is, the gift. For this is how he usually names the gift of the Holy Spirit.

Read more (49 words)

"An impure life extinguishes it. Therefore let us not quench it. Every evil deed extinguishes this light: slander, insults, and everything of that kind.

"As with fire, whatever is foreign to it destroys it, while whatever is akin to it strengthens it. So it is also with this light."

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

From the height of spiritual life the Apostle now descends to its very source and spring. A man usually lives in carelessness and negligence toward divine worship and salvation. Grace, calling him to salvation, awakens the sleeping sinner.

When he heeds this call in feelings of repentance, he rises to the resolve to dedicate the rest of his life to works pleasing to God. By this he works out his salvation. This resolve is revealed in zeal.

Zeal becomes powerful when the grace of God is joined to it through the divine mysteries. From that moment the Christian begins to burn in spirit. That is, he zealously and unceasingly strives to fulfill everything conscience shows him as the will of God.

Read more (982 words)

This burning of the spirit can be supported and strengthened, but it can also be quenched. It is kindled most of all by works of love for God and neighbor, which form the essence of this spirit.

It is also kindled by fidelity to all the commandments of God, by peace of conscience, by pitiless ascetic labors of soul and body, by prayer, and by contemplation of God.

It is quenched by turning attention away from God and the works of God, by immoderate anxiety over worldly affairs, by concessions to sensual pleasures, by indulging the flesh in lust, and by attachments.

If this spirit is quenched, Christian life is quenched as well. A man again becomes what he was: negligent and careless. He begins to live as life happens, without being deeply concerned whether he falls into evil or into good.

Warning against this ruinous step, the Apostle teaches us not to quench the Spirit. That is, we must not quench this spirit of zeal by inclining toward what is contrary to it. Rather, we must kindle and nourish it with what is akin to it.

What St. Paul expresses here so briefly, he explains in Romans in three clauses: “Do not be slothful in zeal, be fervent in spirit, serve the Lord” (Rom 12:11).

“Do not merely be zealous, but unflagging. Do not merely have the Spirit, but burn with the Spirit. That is, be earnest and zealous” (Chrysostom on this passage in Romans).

To burn in spirit, therefore, means to strive with all zeal to please the Lord by unfailingly fulfilling His holy will. Servants do this toward their masters. Not to quench the Spirit means not to quench this zeal.

St. Chrysostom speaks at length about this burning of the spirit. We cite his words briefly: “A kind of dense gloom, darkness, and cloud is spread over the whole earth. Pointing to this, the Apostle said, ‘You were once darkness’ (Eph 5:8).

Night surrounds us, as it were a moonless night, and we walk in the midst of this night. But God has given us a bright lamp, kindling in our souls the grace of the Holy Spirit.

After receiving this light, some made it brighter and clearer, such as Paul, Peter, and all the saints. Others quenched it, such as the five virgins, those who suffered shipwreck in the faith, the Corinthian fornicator, and the fallen Galatians.

Therefore Paul now says, ‘Do not quench the Spirit,’ that is, the gift. For he is accustomed to call the gift of the Holy Spirit by this name. An impure life quenches it.

If someone pours water, throws earth on the light in a lamp, or simply pours out its oil, the light goes out. So also the gift of grace is extinguished.

If you have brought in earthly things, if you have surrendered yourself to cares over passing affairs, you have already quenched the Spirit. The flame is also extinguished when oil is lacking, namely, when we do not give alms.

Since He Himself came to you by the mercy of God, when He does not find this fruit in you, He flies away from you. For He does not remain in a merciless soul.

Therefore let us not quench Him. Every evil deed quenches this light: slander, insults, and everything of this kind. As with fire, everything alien to it destroys it, while everything akin to it strengthens it. So it is with this light.”

Thus the common Christian spirit of grace is revealed. For repentance and faith it descends into the soul of each person in the mystery of Baptism, or is restored in the mystery of repentance.

The fire of zeal constitutes its essence. Yet it may take different directions, according to the persons involved. In one man it is wholly directed toward self-correction in strict ascetic labors.

In another it is chiefly directed toward works of love. In another it is directed toward the good ordering of Christian society. In another it is directed toward spreading the Gospel teaching by preaching.

This was so, for example, in Apollos, who, “being fervent in spirit, spoke and taught accurately the things concerning the Lord” (Acts 18:25).

In all these directions, not quenching the Spirit means not suppressing His demands, inspirations, and impulses. Rather, one must satisfy them prudently, directing everything to the glory of God and to one’s own salvation and that of the brethren in the Lord.

Some understand by “Spirit” here the special gift of receiving sudden illuminations of the mind. This gift enters into contemplation of revealed divine truths, whether already known or new.

It also bears an irresistible desire to communicate these illuminations and inspirations of the Spirit to others in powerful and animated speech. Not quenching such a spirit means not hindering it from manifesting and acting in oneself and in others, for the good of the Church.

In that case, however, this would be the same as saying, “Do not despise prophecies.” Since the Apostle writes lessons of life in brief clauses, each contains its own distinct rule.

Therefore there is no reason to see one and the same thought in these two sayings, verses 19 and 20. Rather, we should suppose that St. Paul first spoke about preserving this common Christian spirit of grace.

This is the spirit of life in Christ Jesus. Then he also recalled the prophetic spirit, toward which people were not everywhere behaving as they should. He mentioned it almost in passing.

He had no need to say much about this particular gift, nor about the other gifts of grace. This is easier to accept because immediately after “Do not despise prophecies” follow lessons defining the proper use of the common spirit of grace.

This is the spirit of life in the Lord, in compelling oneself toward every recognized good and in resisting every recognized evil.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 4 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  2. Πνεῦμα
    pneuma
    wind
    G4151 · πνεῦμα
  3. μὴ
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  4. σβέννυτε
    sbennyte
    I extinguish
    G4570 · σβέννυμι