The Church Fathers on this verse

1 Timothy 4:8Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

For bodily exercise is profitable to little: but godliness is profitable to all things, having promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come.

Douay-Rheims

η γαρ σωματικη γυμνασια προς ολιγον εστιν ωφελιμος η δε ευσεβεια προς παντα ωφελιμος εστιν επαγγελιαν εχουσα ζωης της νυν και της μελλουσης

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

16 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Some suppose this is said about fasting. But this cannot be accepted, for fasting is not a bodily exercise but a spiritual one. If it were bodily exercise, it would nourish the body.

But if it exhausts, refines, and dries up the body, then it is not bodily exercise. Therefore he is not speaking about bodily exercise. We need spiritual exercise.

Exercise of the first kind brings no advantage and gives only a little benefit to the body. Exercise in piety bears fruit also in the life to come. It gives consolation both here and there.

"This is a faithful saying." That is, it is true, both here and there. See how everywhere he introduces this expression. It needs no special preparation, but is stated directly, because he addresses his speech to Timothy.

Read more (180 words)

Therefore even here we remain in good hope. Indeed, the one who is conscious of no crime and performs countless good works rejoices even in the present life.

By contrast, the wicked man bears punishment not only there, but also here. He constantly lives in fear, not daring to look at anyone boldly, trembling, growing pale, and wasting away.

Are not the covetous and thieves like this, uncertain of what they possess? Do not adulterers and murderers lead the most grievous life, looking with distrust even at the sun?

Is this life? No, it is rather a grievous death.

And why, you ask, does he mention bodily exercise here? In order, by comparison, to show the excellence of spiritual struggles.

The first, bodily exercise, is joined to great labors, yet brings neither benefit nor anything worth mentioning. The latter, spiritual struggles, bring unchangeable and abundant benefit.

In the same way he also commands women "not to adorn themselves with braided hair, or gold, or pearls, or costly clothing, but with good works, as befits women professing piety" (1 Tim 2:9-10).

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

"For bodily exercise is profitable for a little." Some suppose that fasting is meant by bodily exercise. This is not true: fasting is spiritual exercise. By bodily exercise he means that which requires great labors, yet brings little benefit, and only for a time. "But piety is profitable for all things, having the promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come." Here, he says, piety helps a man. For one who is not reproached by conscience for anything evil rejoices in spirit even here, having sure promises of future good things. There, in actual reality, he will live the true life. By comparison, the Apostle shows the superiority of piety.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Piety, that is, the true worship of the true God, is profitable in every respect. It either averts or lightens the hardships of this life, and it leads to another life and to salvation. There we shall no longer suffer any evil, but shall enjoy the highest and eternal good. I exhort you, as I exhort myself, to strive toward it more perfectly and hold to it more steadfastly.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

For the bodily exercise of those who practice it is profitable for little. As long as their body lives, it gives them help. But the works of righteousness in which souls are trained are always profitable: here, because they gain a good name; and in the age to come, because they give us the blessedness of eternal life.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

Among ordinary people, only what is profitable is called useful. But we speak of the usefulness found in losing earthly things in order to gain Christ (cf. Phil 3:8).

The gaining of Christ occurs where there is piety with contentment (1 Tim 6:6). Truly great is that gain by which we acquire piety.

For piety before God is rich not with corruptible wealth, but with eternal gifts. In them there are no dangerous temptations, but constant and eternal grace.

Usefulness may be of two kinds: one bodily, the other spiritual, as the Apostle distinguished them: bodily exercise is of little profit, but piety is profitable for all things.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Those who care for bodily well-being, says the Apostle, enjoy it only briefly. The struggles of piety make the ascetics glorious in this life, and in the future prepare them to be counted worthy of unfading crowns. By "training" in piety the Apostle meant a praiseworthy life, because life resembles a contest.

Maximus the Confessor

7th centuryChurch Father

Do not be wholly concerned for the flesh, but assign it labor according to its strength. Turn your whole mind inward. For bodily exercise is profitable for little, but piety is profitable for all things.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

"For bodily training is of little profit."

It gives health to the body, and therefore it is useful only for bodily well-being.

"But piety is profitable for all things."

The knowledge of piety is useful not only for the present life, but also for the future. The former, bodily training, sometimes, or rather often, harms the one who has it. But piety is always and everywhere useful.

"Having promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come."

It contains within itself the promise of the present and future life. For life properly consists in piety, even if one has a body worn out by hardship. Likewise, life in sins is death, even if the flesh possesses health.

Hesychius of Jerusalem

5th centuryChurch Father

Do not occupy yourself entirely with bodily training. Rather, assign to the body a struggle according to its strength, and turn your whole mind inward. For "bodily training is profitable for little, but piety is profitable for all things" (1 Tim 4:8).

John Cassian

5th centuryChurch Father

The blessed Apostle says clearly: bodily exercise is of little profit, but piety, by which love is undoubtedly meant, is profitable for all things, having promise of the present and future life.

This exercise is called of little profit. Therefore it cannot be practiced at all times, and by itself alone it cannot bestow the highest perfection on the one who labors.

For "little" may refer to both things: to the shortness of time, since bodily exercise cannot be coeternal with man, either in the present life or the future; or to the smallness of the benefit gained from bodily exercise.

For the affliction of the body is a certain beginning of progress, but it is not the perfection of love itself, which has the promise in the present and future life.

Peter of Kiev

17th centuryChurch Father

What is the sixth gift of the Holy Spirit?

Answer: Piety. Together with true faith, it is founded on diligent prayer and good works. The Apostle speaks of it in this way: "Piety is profitable for all things, having promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come" (1 Tim 4:8).

Therefore only those are rightly called pious who offer unceasing prayers to God and withdraw from every impiety and sin.

Here piety is understood not as outward piety, such as the Pharisees had, but as true piety of the heart. Otherwise the Lord would say of it also: "This people honors Me with their mouth and lips, but their heart is far from Me" (Mt 15:8).

And again: "Blind Pharisee, first cleanse the inside of the cup and dish, that the outside of them may also be clean" (Mt 23:26).

Platon (Levshin)

18th centuryChurch Father

For one who reflects on the coming of Your Imperial Majesty to this monastery, it is not difficult to find the moving cause of it.

Moved solely by piety, and kindled by fervent faith toward God and His saints, you deigned to undertake this labor.

In the hidden place of your soul, you sang that verse of David: 'How precious to me are Your friends, O God'; Ps 138:17.

We acknowledge no small condescension in this undertaking. Yet we also confess that by this condescension Your Majesty is more greatly exalted and glorified.

In this deed, as in all else, you imitate your most exalted and pious ancestors, Great Monarch.

They left posterity in doubt whether they gained immortal memory more by piety or by courage, more by courage beyond the fatherland or by wise rule within it.

Their courage in the field did not prevent them from ruling wisely and providently at home. Both together did not prevent them from performing works of piety with every reverence.

All of them sanctified this place with their sacred footsteps. I shall pass over Your Majesty's more distant predecessors, for this would require much labor.

It is enough to recall that the Great Peter, worthy to live immortally, the most precious grandfather of Your Majesty, was a special patron of this place.

The most glorious monarchs Anna and Elizabeth, Your Majesty's beloved aunts, were most zealous adorners of this monastery. From the abundant fountain of their munificence they watered the stream of Radonezh.

Emulating their piety, Your Imperial Majesty has also deigned, by your monarchical visitation, to honor this Lavra for the second time already.

For this may the Dayspring from on high visit you.

And we, listeners, having in our Monarch an example of piety, shall offer a brief discourse: how much benefit comes to every man if he diligently exercises himself in the pious work of worshiping God.

I most humbly beg you, most pious Sovereign Lady, to confirm this word by your most exalted permission.

Piety requires not only that one have true knowledge of God, but also that one render Him sincere and God-befitting honor.

One must love Him with the whole heart as a most compassionate Father, fear Him as a strict Judge who abhors vices, and place all hope in everything upon Him as a provident Caretaker.

Therefore there is no doubt that without piety it is impossible to receive the grace of God, expect His help, or hope for the Kingdom of heaven.

For 'the ungodly shall not see the glory of the Lord,' sings the Prophet; Is 26:10.

Leaving this aside, since it is very clear in itself and known to all, we shall direct our speech more to this point.

Even the affairs that pertain to this present life cannot be carried on prosperously and successfully by men without piety.

All affairs in general may be divided into public, spiritual, and civil. Let us first consider public affairs.

Public affairs are such things as plowing the land, selling, buying, hiring, working, helping, lending, and the like.

For the perfect correction of these affairs, willing zeal is needed, sincere fidelity, open honesty, labor, and diligence.

There must be no idleness, drunkenness, cunning, deceit, or negligence.

But a man who does not have the fear of God in his heart cannot accomplish these affairs prosperously and conscientiously.

In plowing he will be lazy, or excessively and paganly anxious. In selling he will be crafty. In buying he will be careless, or foolishly lavish.

In hiring he will be oppressive. In work he will be negligent. In assisting another's poverty he will be cruel and without compassion.

In lending to another he will be stingy and insensitive to his needs.

For this reason, when someone wrongs us, refuses to help us in our poverty, works negligently, or acts deceitfully, we are accustomed to say: 'Do you not fear God?'

By this we indicate that if he feared God, he would not act toward us in such a lawless manner.

Deceits, wrongs, disagreements, idleness, drunkenness, and other disorders arise chiefly from the absence of the fear of God.

The pious and God-fearing man, on the contrary, will be diligent in agriculture, but without pagan anxiety, relying more on God's providence.

In selling he will be just and without cunning. In buying he will be prudent, not having an evil and wasteful character.

In hiring he will not be oppressive. Toward another's poverty he will be compassionate and generous.

In helping another in need he will be quick and merciful. For the pious man has mercy even on his cattle.

He is eager for work without compulsion, faithful without hypocrisy, sincere without concealment, diligent and industrious in gaining his own good without envy.

Is it surprising, then, that a man zealous for God will be prosperous, while one who does not fear God will be unfortunate?

The one succeeds in all his undertakings. The other fails in everything. The one is beloved and pleasing to all. The other is avoided and despised by all.

Is it surprising that the pious man abounds in everything, is content with everything, and all day long shows mercy and lends?

But the man who does not hold to piety is poor in everything, lacking, and often compelled to beg for daily bread.

'The curse of the Lord is in the houses of the ungodly, but the courts of the righteous are blessed'; Prov 3:33.

'Possessions hastened with lawlessness are diminished, but he who gathers for himself with piety shall abound. The righteous man is generous and gives,' writes Solomon, famed for wisdom.

And Saint David, having learned this truth by his own experience, cries: 'I have been young, and now am old, yet I have not seen the righteous forsaken, nor his seed begging bread.'

He further sings: 'The rich have become poor and hungry, but those who seek the Lord shall not lack any good thing'; Ps 36:25; 33:11.

The word of God presents Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Job to us as examples of such worshipers of God.

God blessed them with every kind of wealth so greatly that, because of the multitude of their cattle, they were compelled to move their dwellings from one place to another.

So that we might not attribute this righteous enrichment of the righteous to chance, Sacred Scripture warns us.

It specifically declares that every bodily sufficiency is a blessing of God and a reward for keeping His holy law.

'If,' says the Lord God, 'you walk in My commandments, and keep My commandments and do them, then I will give you rain in its season.

The land shall yield its fruits, and the trees of the field shall give their fruit. The threshing of grain shall overtake the gathering of wine, and the gathering of wine shall overtake the sowing.

You shall eat your bread to the full'; Lev 26:3-5.

It is true that the ungodly sometimes become rich and receive good things in their life. Yet a little for the righteous is better than the great wealth of sinners.

The rich man is not the one who has much, but the one who is content with little. He is rich who lives in friendship even with poverty.

When poverty is joined with safety and peace, it must be esteemed above wealth disturbed by unrest and hourly fear.

The unrighteous are sometimes, and not rarely, gifted with wealth, but it is restless. Most often, however, they suffer every want.

The pious, on the contrary, rarely suffer want. Though sometimes, according to God's judgments unknown to us, they are tried by poverty, they are meanwhile consoled and satisfied by the quiet of a peaceful spirit.

Thus we see that piety, profitable for all things, is profitable in every public affair.

Let us consider spiritual affairs as well.

Spiritual affairs are these: to teach, to preach the word, to convert those who err, to strengthen the weak, to console the despondent, to be an example to others by one's life.

They also include celebrating the divine service with fear and reverence, and doing the work of God without negligence.

But how all this could possibly be accomplished prosperously without a pious and God-fearing spirit cannot even be understood.

Without piety, teaching will be ineffective, preaching useless, and service in God's work scandalous.

Instead of a guide there is a corrupter. Instead of a shepherd there is a hireling. Instead of a light of the Church, he becomes a blind leader.

When the clergy adorn themselves with true piety, then we see the Church in a better state.

Then the church shepherd leads the sheep wherever he wishes, and the sheep follow him everywhere willingly. Thus they fulfill the law of Christ.

If we may grieve that some shepherds are not sufficiently enlightened by learning, how much more must we grieve if some are also little zealous toward God.

Their hard soul is not deeply pierced by the fear of God.

A pious shepherd, even without extensive learning, will benefit by his example. A learned man without piety will benefit not at all.

Or what he builds by teaching, he will destroy by his bad life.

God even forbids such men to take His most pure word into their mouths.

'But to the sinner God said: Why do you declare My ordinances, and take My covenant in your' impious 'mouth? For you have hated instruction,' and so forth; Ps 49:16-17.

The Israelites, though they had harps and organs in Babylon, did not dare play them simply because they were in a foreign land.

How much more unfitting is it for a shepherd to sing God's word in the midst of the Church, when the organ of his tongue does not agree with the harps of his soul's virtues.

We have sufficient examples. Many were unlearned according to the opinion of this world, yet they shone forth as great lights of the Church.

Blessed Augustine heard that Antony of Egypt, though simple, had become so renowned by his life that all Africa could not contain his glory.

Moreover, he was counted worthy by God of the power to work miracles.

Hearing this, Augustine examined himself as a man very learned, but at that time still deficient in life.

He cried out: 'The unlearned rise up and seize heaven, while we with our learning fall down to Hades.'

And why? Because there is much learning, but little conscience.

For this reason also many were very learned according to worldly opinion, though not according to God's. Yet they ended their life to the great scandal of the Church.

Still, there is no doubt that nothing can be more precious, more beloved, or more fitting than a shepherd in whom learning is joined with piety.

'For whoever does and teaches, he shall be called great in the Kingdom of heaven'; Mt 5:19.

See, then, the very great benefit of piety even in spiritual affairs.

But let us also look at civil affairs.

Civil affairs are these: to judge, to defend the innocent, to condemn the guilty, to govern others, examining every matter for every satisfaction.

They also include firmly observing justice in everything and striving for every kind of welfare.

But I do not know how one whose soul is not restrained by piety and the fear of God can fulfill all this without wronging another.

His eyes will quickly be blinded by silver so that he does not see justice. His heart will be weighed down by gold so that he becomes insensitive to the plea of the innocent.

His hands will scarcely be restrained from seizing another's goods.

On the contrary, however inclined anyone may be toward injustice, when he brings to mind God, that impartial Judge, the strict avenger of violated justice, he trembles and comes to some feeling.

For this reason the Gospel calls that judge who paid little heed to the poor widow's plea one who 'did not fear God.'

Especially in the laborious and great rule of the state, piety and the fear of God have surpassing power and very great benefit.

There one needs a hundred eyes to examine the circumstances of every matter, and a hundred ears to hear each person's petition.

There are a thousand knots hard to untie, and countless difficulties scarcely to be overcome.

How, then, can all this be resolved? How can all these labors be borne without being weighed down, without God's special help?

If He Himself does not invisibly strengthen and make wise, it is utterly impossible.

Read the full text in the app

Eusebios (Orlinski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The Apostle Paul said: "Piety is profitable for all things, having promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come" (v. 8). Or, "Piety is profitable for all things, having promise of the present and future life."

That is, true happiness in the present and future life belongs to piety. How is this so, someone may think? Many suppose that for a man to become pious, he must renounce the happiness of the present life.

Whoever thinks that piety deprives one of the happiness of the present life understands happiness perversely. He does not understand his true needs or his purpose in this life.

True happiness belongs to piety even here on earth. The pious man, devoted to works of piety and growing more in spiritual life day by day, enjoys the true peace of conscience.

Read more (128 words)

He joyfully lifts his eyes to the heavenly Father, to the invisible God. Amid all difficult and sorrowful circumstances of life, he always places his hopes in God and finds rest in Him.

According to His promise, he awaits eternal life and the heavenly blessings. What happiness on earth can be higher than this?

Compared with this state of the pious man, what are all forms of external happiness? They appear and vanish like a shadow or like pleasing phantoms.

Moreover, by God's blessing, what is necessary for outward life is given to the pious, as the Lord and Savior teaches: "Seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things shall be added to you." That is, food, clothing, and other necessities (Mt 6:25-33).

Ignatij (Briantchaninow)

19th centuryChurch Father

Bodily struggles are profitable for little, that is, they can only tame the passions, not uproot them. But piety, which consists in the invisible exercise of mind and heart within the Orthodox faith, is profitable for all things. Only with it can a man sense eternal life, which the saints taste here in part, as in betrothal, and which is fully revealed after the soul's separation from the body. Eternal life consists in the manifold action of grace in the soul, which is perceived according to its purification from the passions.

Ivanov A.V.

19th centuryChurch Father

"Bodily training is of little profit," σωματική γυμνάσια. The Apostle does not speak here without intention about bodily exercise, which is wholly opposed to exercise in piety, yet was held in special regard among the heretics.

Every bodily exercise could have an external meaning. The Apostle wishes to say that those occupied with fasts and abstention from marriage pay attention to the body and exercise it, while they forget inward piety.

But piety is profitable for all things. Piety is nothing other than the true worship of God. It consists in a correct understanding of Him, a worthy judgment concerning His properties and actions, and true fear and reverence before His holy name.

Read more (40 words)

Such piety is profitable for everything: for avoiding the deceptions of heretics, and for receiving the promises of the present and future life. It has "the promise of the life that now is and of that which is to come."

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

Of what bodily training is he speaking here? He means strengthening the body by gymnastic exercises and accustoming it to swift and agile movements. For he says, somatike gymnasia, bodily exercise.

Why is this brought to mind here? It is so that, through this comparison, he may stir up greater zeal for exercise in the works and labors of piety.

The Apostle speaks as though saying this. Those who wish to receive crowns at the games train diligently in bodily gymnastics, to strengthen their body and accustom it to agile movements. But if they labor so much in bodily gymnastics for corruptible crowns, should we not labor far more in spiritual gymnastics, that is, in training ourselves in piety for incorruptible crowns?

Read more (597 words)

That bodily training or exercise is profitable for a little. This means that it is useful for something small, or for a short time, “that is, only for the body and only for the present life” (Oecumenius).

It is useful for something small, namely, for strengthening the body, accustoming it to easy movements, and thereby obtaining crowns in contests at public games. Both are of little importance.

It is useful for a short time, only for the present life, and not even for all of it. But piety is profitable for all things, both for well-being in the present life and for eternal blessedness in the life to come. It has the promise of the present life and of the life to come.

“Having the promise” indicates that God Himself, according to His unchanging righteousness and inexhaustible goodness, was pleased to join temporal well-being and eternal blessedness to piety, or to life in the spirit of faith in Christ.

By “life” is meant not life merely as existence, but the quality of life, a desirable, happy, and blessed life. Without this, life is not life.

If piety is such, then exercise in it must be conducted accordingly, with a zeal as much greater as its fruit surpasses the fruit supplied by bodily exercise.

Apart from the context, some, especially the ascetic Fathers, understand bodily training as bodily ascetic labors. In the Apostle’s words they see a determination of their relative value compared with spiritual labors. But in the context, according to the course of the discourse, bodily gymnastic exercises are meant here.

Chrysostom says: “Some think this is said about fasting. But this cannot be accepted. Fasting is not bodily exercise, but spiritual exercise. If it were bodily exercise, it would nourish the body. But if it exhausts, refines, and dries the body, then it is not bodily exercise.

Therefore he is not speaking of this, but of bodily gymnastic exercises. Some engage in them even apart from competitions and, like fighters, do everything, abstain from everything, and endure heavy toil.

But why, you ask, does he mention bodily gymnastic exercise here? In order, through comparison, to show the superiority of spiritual labors in piety. The former, bodily gymnastics, though joined with great labors, brings no great profit and nothing worth speaking of. The latter, the labors of piety, bring unchanging and abundant profit.

The first kind of exercise brings no gain, but only gives the body some benefit. Exercise in piety bears fruit for the future life as well. It gives consolation both here and there.”

Explaining this last point, blessed Theophylact adds: “Here also, he says, piety supplies a man. For when his conscience accuses him of nothing evil, he rejoices in spirit even here, having faithful promises of future good things. There he will truly live the true life in very deed.”

The first part of this explanation, however, he took from the same Chrysostom, where it is set forth more fully: “Here also we remain in good hope. For the one who knows no offense in himself and does good works rejoices even in the present life.

But a wicked man endures punishment not only there, but also here. He constantly lives in fear, not daring to look boldly at anyone, trembling, growing pale, and wasting away.

Are not the covetous and thieves like this, who are not sure of what they possess? Do not adulterers and murderers live a most burdensome life, looking with mistrust even at the sun itself? Is this life? It is not life, but rather the heaviest death.”

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 23 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. ἡ
    hē
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  2. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  3. σωματικὴ
    sōmatikē
    bodily
    G4984 · σωματικός
  4. γυμνασία
    gymnasia
    physical exercise
    G1129 · γυμνασία
  5. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  6. ὀλίγον
    oligon
    small
    G3641 · ὀλίγος
  7. ἐστὶν
    estin
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  8. ὠφέλιμος
    ōphelimos
    profitable
    G5624 · ὠφέλιμος
  9. ἡ
    hē
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  10. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  11. εὐσέβεια
    eusebeia
    piety
    G2150 · εὐσέβεια
  12. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  13. πάντα
    panta
    all
    G3956 · πᾶς
  14. ὠφέλιμός
    ōphelimos
    profitable
    G5624 · ὠφέλιμος
  15. ἐστιν
    estin
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  16. ἐπαγγελίαν
    epangelian
    a promise
    G1860 · ἐπαγγελία
  17. ἔχουσα
    echousa
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω
  18. ζωῆς
    zōēs
    life
    G2222 · ζωή
  19. τῆς
    tēs
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  20. νῦν
    nyn
    now
    G3568 · νῦν
  21. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  22. τῆς
    tēs
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  23. μελλούσης
    mellousēs
    I am about to
    G3195 · μέλλω