The Church Fathers on this verse

Genesis 1:11Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And he said: let the earth bring forth green herb, and such as may seed, and the fruit tree yielding fruit after its kind, which may have seed in itself upon the earth. And it was so done.

Douay-Rheims

וַיֹּ֣אמֶר אֱלֹהִ֗ים תַּֽדְשֵׁ֤א הָאָ֙רֶץ֙ דֶּ֗שֶׁא עֵ֚שֶׂב מַזְרִ֣יעַ זֶ֔רַע עֵ֣ץ פְּרִ֞י עֹ֤שֶׂה פְּרִי֙ לְמִינ֔וֹ אֲשֶׁ֥ר זַרְעוֹ־ב֖וֹ עַל־הָאָ֑רֶץ וַֽיְהִי־כֵֽן׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

11 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Consider the profound wisdom of the magnificent Creator-God revealed through the subsequent creation of the earth. As He has unveiled the world to us, He imparts to it a unique beauty through His divine command, endowing it with diverse seeds. “And God said,” as it is recorded, “let the earth bring forth herbs, grass sowing seed, a fruitful tree yielding fruit after its kind, in which his seed is,” and likewise, “after his kind: and it became so.” What does it signify, “and it became so”? It indicates the Lord’s command: the earth, touched by the processes of procreation, began to prepare for the generation of seed.

Read more (390 words)

In the instance when the earth lay barren, the Creator commanded: “and God said, Let the earth bring forth green herbs, grass sowing seed after its kind and after its likeness, and a fruitful tree bearing fruit after its kind, in which its seed is on the earth. And it became so” (Gen. 1:11). This truth fails to dishearten the heretics. While plants, trees, and grass reproduce in their likeness, does God generate the unlike? Similarly, at the genesis of terrestrial creatures, reptiles, and birds, God proclaims, “Let the water bring forth reptiles, the living soul; and let the birds fly over the earth, upon the firmament of the heavens” (Gen. 1:20). Every creature—beasts, creeping things, birds, fish, plants, herbs, and trees—produces according to its kind and its likeness; yet, does God alone engender those unlike Himself? In fashioning humanity, God declared: “Let us make man in our image, and in our likeness” (Gen. 1:26); the creative act is an expression of likeness; how then can the Creator be unlike?

Moreover, take note of a wondrous occurrence. Heretical arguments often exploit such nuances. They assert, if you claim the Son bears likeness as we do, we can concede that point. However, likeness in essence is distinct from likeness in grace. We share a likeness, yet He is the true likeness. “He that hath seen Me hath seen the Father” (John 14:9); we share in that likeness. The servants of God must discern the variations in expression. God commands, “let the earth bring forth green herbs, grass sowing seed after her kind and after her likeness, and a fruitful tree”; then He continues, “let the earth bring forth a living soul after her kind, cattle, and creeping things, and beasts of the earth after their kind” (Gen. 1:11, 24). Why is it that God instructs, “let it bring forth” in one context, yet says “let it produce” in another? Plants, trees, and fruits grow annually, with their seeds originating from the earth; hence it is stated, “that he may bring forth.” Regarding animals, the phrase “that he may produce” is employed because, once born of the earth, they do not originate again from the earth but propagate from one another. “And it became so,” the command transformed into action, and the earth was adorned. What remained was to beautify the heavens.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

The land started to be enveloped, becoming adorned with a multitude of green plants, and in an extraordinary manner, it produced robust and fruitful trees from within itself.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Here is a paraphrase of the provided text:

In the twelfth chapter focusing on Genesis 1:11-13, God commanded the earth to produce vegetation, specifically herbs that yield seeds and fruit-bearing trees whose seeds are within them, each according to its kind. This indeed occurred as the earth generated various herbs and trees, each replicating its own form, and God deemed this creation good. The evening passing into morning marked the completion of the third day.

Read more (307 words)

The author notes that herbs and trees differ from the elements of water and land. They are distinctly described as emerging from the earth, using the phrase "and it was so" to emphasize their origin. This repetition highlights that God's good creation began on the same day and is interconnected with the earth through their roots.

In another discussion, it is stated that after the creation of the earth and sea, which is not meant to suggest a slow process, a new command is given for the earth to yield life. This command is unique; unlike light, the heavens, or the waters, which do not propagate in succession, the phrase concerning the earth's produce reflects the generational continuity found within creation.

The thirteenth chapter addresses concerns about why the earth also produces harmful plants. It raises the question of why, if God intended for food to come from the earth, there are thorns and poisonous plants. It is asserted that after humanity's fall, the ground was cursed, leading it to yield thorns—this serves as a reminder of sin's consequences for mankind rather than suggesting that the earth suffers. The poisonous vegetation is considered a means of reminding humans of the tragic result of sin, prompting reflection and a return to God’s commandments.

The presence of thorny and barren trees serves as a warning to individuals about the importance of good deeds within the community of faith, urging them to avoid neglecting their spiritual responsibilities. Prior to the fall, the earth only produced beneficial plants and trees; the emergence of harmful vegetation is seen as a direct consequence of human transgression. God’s proclamation to Adam in Genesis 3:17-19 illustrates this curse and its implications, as he is told that he would toil and suffer in order to eat, bringing forth thorns as a perpetual reminder of his disobedience.

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

And God commanded that the earth bring forth vegetation, specifically herbs that yield seeds according to their species and trees that bear fruit according to their kinds, each with its seed within it. Once the earth, having shed its waters, settled down, it was fitting to command it first to generate grass and subsequently trees—an ongoing process evident today. This command, like a law of nature, has been ingrained in the earth for ages, enabling it to produce and bear fruit. "Let the earth bring forth." The emergence of plants begins with the sprouting of a shoot; as it rises, it develops further into grass, achieving maturity through systematic growth until it can reproduce. The greening and ripening of plants occur universally. "Let the earth yield the first herbage." The earth naturally produces shoots, independent of outside aid. While some attribute the growth of plants to the sun, believing it draws forth hidden powers from the depths, the earth's splendor exemplifies its existence before the sun, reminding observers to acknowledge that life itself arises from the earth and not merely the sun. Consequently, recognizing the earth's beauty predates the sun's creation reframes the wonder it inspires, as it came into being before the green and flowering plants.

When food was offered for livestock, were humans deemed unworthy of the same? On the contrary, the One who supplies sustenance for oxen and horses also provides abundance and delight for you. He who nurtures your animals multiplies your provisions. Indeed, the production of seeds serves as a bounty for your nourishment, for many herbs and greens are also meant for human consumption. "Let the earth bring forth herbs that yield seed according to their kind." While some herbs serve others, ultimately their usefulness returns to humanity through the seeds granted to us. Thus, the intention of this command is clear: the earth is to sprout vegetative herbs and seeds that reproduce after their kinds. In this manner, order in creation is articulated clearly as it pertains to nature's yielding. Thus, the sequence must be observed: first the sprout, then the greenery, followed by the herb's maturation, and finally, the fulfillment of what is borne from the seed.

Yet one might ask, how do the Scriptures assert that everything from the earth is sown with seeds, given that certain plants like reeds, meadows, mints, saffron, garlic, and countless others seem seedless? Our response acknowledges that many plants, particularly at their roots, indeed harbor the capacity for seeding. For instance, a reed, after a year, can produce offspring from its roots, essentially taking the place of seeds. Numerous plants scattered across the earth possess this capacity for propagation within their roots. Hence, it becomes evident that every plant either produces seeds or conceals within it the power to create them. The term "by the genus" is meant to convey this. A reed can produce only a reed, just as olive trees stem from their own kind, reflecting the preservation of each species from the initial creation.

"Let the earth sprout." Contemplate how, through a simple decree, the once cold and barren earth swiftly embraces the time for fruition, shedding its grief and donning a vibrant attire, exulting in an array of plants. I wish to instill in you a lasting amazement at creation, so that wherever you are and whatever plants you encounter, you may continuously remember the Creator. Thus, when you observe the lush greenery and hues of grass, think of humanity, recalling the insights of the wise Isaiah: "all flesh is grass, and all the glory of man as the flower of grass" (Isaiah 40:6). The fleeting nature of life and the transitory joys of human prosperity find fitting parallel in the Prophet’s words. One may bloom physically, being buoyant in desires, full of youthful vitality, yet in the blink of an eye face the frailty brought by time or ill health. Another may attract attention through wealth, surrounded by flattering connections and false friends who vie for favor, surrounded by relatives in disguise and servants fulfilling various needs—all provoking envy in onlookers. Yet what remains when sickness strikes, pain overwhelms, or circumstances alter, leaving behind the emptiness of past grandeur? This does indeed expose the biblical contemplation that human glory resembles the frailty of a simple flower. "Let the earth sprout a former herb, sowing seeds according to its kind and likeness."

Even today, the order of plant life attests to the initial decree, as every green thing and herb still begins as a sprout. No matter the source, whether from roots in the earth or seeds, growth begins with a sprout, transitions into greenery, matures into grass, and ultimately yields fruit on a worn stem. "Let the earth germinate the former herb." As seed falls into soil imbued with the right warmth and moisture, it swells and multiplies, drawing from the earth to establish roots and shoot upwards, producing stems in line with its roots. The consistent warmth nurtures the sprout, with roots absorbing vital nutrients, which nourish the plant's structure, sheathes, grains, and ears. Hence, each plant matures into its own anticipated form, whether grain, legumes, or shrubs. The simplest stalk may occupy your mind with its remarkable artistry; the wheat stem, for instance, is girded with joints, supporting the weight of the kernels bending to the ground. Meanwhile, the oat stem remains hollow, needing no such support since it bears little weight, while the wheat grain is secured within a sheath to protect it from birds, aided by long spikes that deter small animals.

How can one express the breadth of creation's treasures? In gratitude, we should acknowledge that even as beneficial plants grow alongside harmful ones—wheat and hemlock, or other plants—it would be unjust to thank God solely for the good while blaming Him for the detrimental. Are we not to reason that not everything is created for our consumption? What serves as nourishment for one may be unwholesome for another. Like the blood of an ox, which is harmful to us, should it not have existed at all? Instead, we ought to exercise our faculties of reason to guard against harm. If sheep and goats can discern danger through instinct, ought we not, with reason and knowledge of medicine that guides us toward the useful while advising caution with the harmful, to follow suit? Every aspect of creation bears intention; all things either feed animals, or through medicinal use prove advantageous to us, alleviating ailments. While starlings consume hemlock without harm, differing anatomy allows them to process what would poison others, just as quails safely ingest certain plants. Some have utilized plants like mandrake to induce sleep or hemlock to quell lust, and in doing so transformed concerns over creation into reasons for gratitude.

"Let the earth sprout former herbs." The Scripture speaks of the vast range of foods readily available to us in roots, greens, or fruits. The land is not commanded to yield seeds and fruits instantaneously but, rather, sequentially; beginning first with sprouts and leaves, culminating in seeds—this serves as a lesson to maintain natural order in future generations. Questions may arise: if the earth is meant to produce according to the respective kind, how do we find that sowing wheat can yield black grains? Such occurrences do not indicate a shift in genus but rather suggest an affliction or ailment of the seed. Here, wheat is still wheat, albeit injured by excessive cold, discoloration, and taste. It is noted that when provided with suitable soil and favorable air, it can revert to its original character.

Thus, nothing in vegetation opposes the command, for what is commonly deemed tares do not stem from changes in wheat but rather derive from their own origins. They illustrate those who distort the truth of the Lord’s teachings and, corrupted by false doctrine, deceptively mingle with the healthy body of the Church to impart their poison to the unsuspecting. Paralleling this, the Lord likens the growth of believers to the development of seed, illustrating: "As a man sows seed into the ground and sleeps, rising day and night, and the seed sprouts and grows—he knows not how. The earth produces first the shoot, then the ear, and then the full grain in the ear" (Mark 4:26-28). "Let the earth germinate the former." Obedient to the Creator’s command, the earth experiences rich growth, swiftly maturing to fruition. The meadows overflow with lush grass, while the bountiful fields, reaped in the harvest, sway like the sea. Everything green, every vegetable, every plant and pod now flourished abundantly. No hindrance from lack of skill or adverse weather impeded growth as the ground remained fertile prior to the fall that condemned humanity to toil in labor.

Yet, it is said, "And the fruitful tree that yields fruit, whose seed is within itself after its kind." At this instruction, the bushes thickened, and trees recognized for their height—firs, cedars, cypresses, and all varieties—burst forth from the soil. They flourished alongside thornless roses, myrtles, and laurels, previously unseen and now manifest, each possessing innate qualities that set them apart, instantly identifiable by unique characteristics. However, it is noted that the rose was thornless at that time, soon to wear prickling thorns alongside its beauty, a reminder of the sin that condemned the earth to produce "thorns and thistles" (Genesis 3:18).

Some will inquire, "The earth is directed to bring forth a fruitful tree that bears fruit, and yet many trees yield neither fruit nor seed." The answer lies in the acknowledgment that those plants highlighted are inherently preferable, and scrutiny reveals that all flora possesses either seeds or equivalents. Trees like rushes, willows, elms, and poplars seemingly have little fruit; however, diligent examination uncovers their hidden seeds. Even rootless trees can reproduce abundantly, while gardeners propagate varieties through root divisions. Primarily, it is stated, those trees deserving mention are those most beneficial to our lives and capable of sustaining us with their abundant yields. Such are the grapes that produce wine, said to "gladden a man's heart," and the olive tree, which yields fruit to "anoint the face with oil" (Psalms 103:15).

What variety abounds! The vine's roots, sprawling branches, buds curling forth, green berries, and ripe clusters manifest rapidly. With a glance, the vine evokes the image of the Lord, who calls Himself "the vine" and His Father "the farmer," urging each of us to bear fruit and avoid judgment (John 15:1-6). He parallels human souls to vines, for it is written, "the vine was to the beloved in the rose, in a place of fatness," and "I will plant the vineyard, and fence it" (Isaiah 5:1, 2). It is evident that by the vine, He refers to human souls, which He has surrounded with a protective hedge of commandments and guardians. The "angel of the Lord encamps around those who fear Him" (Psalms 33:8), serving as a fortified command against evil.

As if encircling us, "He places in the church first apostles, second prophets, and third teachers" (1 Corinthians 12:28). Through ancient examples, He elevates our thoughts, inspiring us to weave connections of love and to aspire toward the divine heights, much like grapevines intertwining. He encourages us to endure the pruning process, shedding worldly burdens that weigh heavily on our hearts. Thus, one who sheds desires for earthly gain and recognizes the futility of pursuing fleeting glory shall renew strength, casting aside the trivialities of worldly wisdom. According to the parable’s teachings, do not live superficially for glory's sake, but labor sincerely, rendering tangible proofs of good works to the true Vinedresser. Yet flourish as a "fruitful olive tree in the house of God" (Psalms 51:10), harboring the hope of salvation perpetually through faith. In doing so, you emulate the persistence of the evergreen, engaging abundantly in charity.

Read the full text in the app

Gregory of Nyssa

4th centuryChurch Father

Let us consider the previous discussion, as we remain mindful of the divine order of creation. Initially, plants emerge from the soil, followed by the silent creatures, and ultimately, after their governance, comes humanity. This sequence reveals more than a simple observation that the Creator deemed it necessary for animals to consume vegetation and for mankind to feed on livestock, establishing beforehand the nourishment for herbivores and suitable provisions for human existence. I believe that Moses conveys a deeper truth here, revealing a mystery concerning the soul, which even those outside sacred scripture have contemplated, though not with full clarity. The Scripture illustrates three distinct expressions of life and the soul's essence.

Read more (346 words)

There exists a basic vegetative and nourishing force: it seeks what is beneficial for the growth of the nourished, labeled as natural, and this is particularly evident in plants, wherein we can discern a type of life force, devoid of sensation. Yet, there exists another classification of existence, inclusive of the initial form, one that possesses sensory perception. This is the life inherent in the voiceless creatures which not only consume and develop but also engage in sensory activities and understanding. The most complete expression of life manifests in those endowed with speech – namely, human beings, who are nurtured, capable of feeling, articulate, and guided by reason. Let us acknowledge this categorization: there are creatures that can be represented in thought and others that are material, while the finer distinctions of the cognitive beings shall be set aside for our purposes. Among the corporeal forms, some possess no vitality, whereas others actively participate in life. Furthermore, among living beings, some have senses, while others do not. The sensitive beings can be classified into the articulate and the non-articulate. Hence, the Lawgiver indicates that following the formless matter, which serves as the foundation for living beings, the first manifestation of life came to be in the sprouting of plants, subsequently leading to the emergence of sentient beings. Thus, according to this design, among those that possess physical existence, some are sentient without a fully developed sensory nature, and verbal expression in the corporeal form can only coexist with sensory experience. Consequently, mankind was purposefully created last, after the plants and animals, so that creation ascended towards perfection through a gradual progression. All forms of souls converge in this articulate being – humanity. Through its natural essence, it is nourished; the vegetative aspect is intertwined with the sensory, which inherently occupies a space between the conceptual and the material essence, being denser than the former but purer than the latter. Furthermore, the subtle and light-giving element within the sensory nature facilitates an integration and blending of the cognitive essence, culminating in humanity's composition of these three natures.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Once both of these aspects are fulfilled, God instructs the earth at dawn to yield all varieties of grains, herbs, and fruit-bearing trees.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Question: Why did God instruct the earth to bring forth plants that are not suitable for consumption? There exists a variety of mute creatures, categorized as wild animals, livestock, reptiles, and birds. God has ordained sustenance for each of them, creating them for humanity's benefit, hence it is stated that they exist for our provision. This is reflected in the scripture, 'He that treadeth the grass for cattle, and the grain for the service of man' (Psalm 103:14). Thus, what may lack utility for one may serve another purpose, and what is deemed unnecessary for people can indeed fulfill the needs of those made for man's benefit.

Read more (68 words)

Furthermore, the Lord, in His foreknowledge of the afflictions that would arise from sin's decree of death, commanded the ground to yield herbs not only for nourishment but also for medicinal healing. This is further supported by those skilled in the practice of medicine, who recognize that what initially appears to be harmful can facilitate healing when combined with other herbs, transforming them into remedies that restore health.

Theophilus

2nd centuryChurch Father

God has designed and embellished creation with a multitude of herbs, seeds, and flora. Consider their diversity, remarkable beauty, and plentifulness, for they serve as a symbol of the resurrection, mirroring the future resurrection of humanity. Who would not marvel at how a fig tree emerges from a tiny seed, or how towering trees rise from the smallest of seeds?

Philaret of Moscow (Drosdow)

19th centuryChurch Father

God instructs the earth to bring forth vegetation, since the roots of their existence are embedded deep within its nurturing essence, and they will later depend on it primarily for sustenance. Moses identifies three categories of plants: דשא, the tender herbs; עשב, the grass that bears seeds; and עצ, the trees that encompass the shrubs. This clearly points to the entirety of the plant kingdom. Additionally, the fossil realm can closely relate to this aspect of creation, as all living beings must trace their origins back to the Creator. However, the writer focuses on what is more evident and comprehensible.

Read more (74 words)

When reflecting on the creation that occurred on the third day within the broader context of the six-day framework, it is noteworthy that the emergence of life transitions from the simple to the complex, and from the rudimentary to the sophisticated. The emergence of plants prior to the sun, essential for their survival, showcases the all-powerful nature of the Creator, as does their appearance before animals, which are intended to derive nourishment from them.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryCommentator

Although the arrangement of land and sea was quite favorable, the earth still lacked the intended purpose of its creation: it was devoid of life, with only barren, lifeless rocks casting a somber gaze upon the waters below. However, once the separation of water and land had taken place and the essential conditions for life were established, the initial signs of life soon emerged in the form of greenery. "And God said, Let the earth bring forth green herbs, grass sowing seed (after its kind and after its likeness), and a fruitful tree bearing fruit after its kind, in which its seed is on the earth, and it became so."

Vissarion (Nechaev)

19th centuryCommentator

God directs the earth, once it has been cleared, to generate vegetation, specifically herbaceous varieties such as culinary herbs, grains for sustenance, vegetables, flora of meadows, marshland plants, and even weeds, alongside woody species like shrubs and upright trees flourishing in forests. The Creator has equipped all these plants with the ability to perpetuate their kind through the generation of similar offspring. While individual plants may vanish, the seed endures, leading to the emergence of new plants that share the same essence and form.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.