The Church Fathers on this verse

Genesis 1:12Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And the earth brought forth the green herb, and such as yieldeth seed according to its kind, and the tree that beareth fruit, having seed each one according to its kind. And God saw that it was good.

Douay-Rheims

וַתּוֹצֵ֨א הָאָ֜רֶץ דֶּ֠שֶׁא עֵ֣שֶׂב מַזְרִ֤יעַ זֶ֙רַע֙ לְמִינֵ֔הוּ וְעֵ֧ץ עֹֽשֶׂה־פְּרִ֛י אֲשֶׁ֥ר זַרְעוֹ־ב֖וֹ לְמִינֵ֑הוּ וַיַּ֥רְא אֱלֹהִ֖ים כִּי־טֽוֹב׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

8 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

“And the earth produced,” it is stated, “the green herb, the herb that sows seed after its kind, and the tree that bears fruit, in which is its seed after its kind.” Reflect, dear ones, on how the earth brought forth all things solely through the command of the Lord. At this time, there was no laborer, no plow, no oxen to toil, nor any other concern for cultivation; the earth merely received the command and promptly fulfilled its role. This teaches us that even now it is not the efforts of farmers, their toil, or their exhausting labor that yields the harvest, but rather the divine word of God spoken at the very beginning.

Read more (304 words)

On the other hand, to address the folly of people later on, Holy Scripture provides a detailed account of the creation to counter the misleading claims of those who maintain that only sunlight is needed for fruit to ripen. Some even go so far as to credit certain stars with this process. Thus, the Holy Spirit instructs us that prior to the creation of these elements, the earth, responding to His word and command, produced every type of seed without requiring any further aid. One simple decree from God was enough: “Let the earth bring forth herbs, herbs.” Therefore, let us adhere to the teachings of Scripture and disregard those who recklessly speak their minds. Let men cultivate the land, utilize the help of animals, and attend to their responsibilities; however, if the Lord does not give His blessing, all will be in vain, and no success will follow from countless efforts unless the hand of the Most High intervenes to bring to fruition what has been sown. Who would not marvel at how the Lord’s command—“Let the earth grow green, let it produce grass”—descended into the depths of the earth and clothed it with a splendid mantle of diverse colors? Once ugly and chaotic, it was transformed into a beauty that could almost rival the heavens. Just as the sky has a multitude of stars to embellish it, the earth was similarly adorned with such a variety of hues that even the Creator was moved to declare, “God saw that it was good.” Observe how Moses, in recounting the creation of each being, illustrates the Creator’s approval, so that in turn, humanity may rise from the creatures to the Creator. If the created beings are so magnificent that they surpass human capacity for praise, what then can be said of the Creator Himself?

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

The fulfillment of the divine command is demonstrated in the created order, as shown in Genesis 1:11: "And it was so." The earth produced vegetation, yielding seed-bearing plants according to their kind, as well as fruit trees that bear fruit with seeds in them, each according to its kind. Finally, it is noted that God observed how good these creations were.

Read more (149 words)

In this context, it appears that the distinction lies not between the sea and the earth, but between the nature of the living beings that arise and pass away, perpetuated through their seeds. While both the sea and the land could simultaneously come into being in the mind of the divine, where all creation exists at once, and even within the physical realm, trees and plants could emerge only after the earth had already been established. The reiteration of God's command signified various acts of creation, occurring on the same day due to their dependence on the earth's foundation.

One might wonder why God chose not to assign names to these creations. Perhaps their abundance made this impractical. This inquiry may be more thoroughly addressed later when we encounter other entities that remained unnamed, in contrast to the light, sky, earth, and sea, which were explicitly named by God.

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

And God declared, "Let the earth bring forth a plant yielding seed according to its kind, and a tree bearing fruit, in which is its seed, after its kind." After the earth, having released its water, had settled, it was fitting for it to be instructed to grow first grass and then trees, a process that continues even now. The command from that time formed a natural law, enduring throughout time and granting the earth the ability to produce and bear fruit. "Let the earth sprout." At the inception of vegetation, the beginning manifests as a sprout; subsequently, as these sprouts rise, they witness the emergence of the "former" and later develop into grass, showcasing the gradual maturation of the plant towards completion, which includes the process of seeding. For greening and ripening are universally consistent. "Let the earth bring forth the sprouting grasses." The earth innately generates growth without external help. Although some attribute the growth to the sun, which by its warmth draws out the latent energies from the depths, the earth outshines the sun in adorning life, encouraging the misguided to cease their sun-worship and recognize it as merely a part of life. When one understands that the earth was adorned before the sun’s creation, admiration for the sun’s role diminishes, as it follows after grass and greenery. Yet, when sustenance is prepared for livestock, did we alone not warrant attention? On the contrary, He who nourishes animals also prepares blessings and enjoyment for us. For He who tends to your cattle increases your provision. The very essence of seed is essentially a reservoir for your sustenance. Moreover, many herbs and greens are, in themselves, nourishment for humanity. The scriptural word stands firm: "Let the earth bring forth herbs that yield seed according to their kind." Thus, while some plants benefit others, ultimately their contributions return to us, and we utilize the seeds. The intention of the declaration is, “that the earth may sprout birdseed-harboring herbs." This serves to realign speech, indicating the natural order in which creation operates. First the sprout, then the greenery, followed by the herb’s growth, and finally, the fulfillment emerging from the seed. One might question, "How does the Scripture depict that all which arises from the earth is inseminated, when reeds, meadows, mints, saffrons, garlics, and countless other plants appear not to produce seed?" To this, we respond that many earthly plants possess seed potential within their roots and lower parts. For instance, a reed, after a year, generates offspring from the root, effectively standing in as a seed for future plant generations. The same applies to numerous plants that, while scattered, harbor the ability to propagate through their roots. Thus, it is clear that every plant either possesses seed or conceals some seed potential, embodying the term "by the genus." The offspring of reeds don’t give rise to olive trees; rather, reeds reproduce reeds, and seeds yield their kin. Hence, all that sprouted from the earth during creation continues to do so today, maintaining the preservation of its kind through succession. "Let the earth sprout." Visualize how, with a simple utterance and soon command, the cold, barren earth suddenly prepares for birth, transforming into fertility, shedding its mournful state, dressed anew, and presenting a multitude of plant life. My hope is that you will forever treasure the marvel of creation, allowing the image of the Creator to arise in your thoughts whenever you encounter any plant. Therefore, when you behold the lushness and vibrancy in the grass, reflect upon human existence, evoking the wise words of Isaiah: "All flesh is as grass, and all the glory of man as the flower of grass" (Isaiah 40:6). The brevity of life and the fleeting nature of human happiness find a fitting metaphor in the Prophet’s words. Today, one flourishes in body, caught up in transient pleasures, embodying youthful vigor and blossoming potential; yet in the morning, may swiftly find themselves withered by time or ailments. Another, adorned with wealth, is surrounded by a throng of sycophants, pretenders keen to win his favor, an entourage of disguised relatives, and numerous servants attending to every desire, inciting envy in those who see him. Should he boast civil power, royal honors, lead the populace or command the armies, beholden to fearsome followers who instill dread, what remains after a fever or an unforeseen ailment? He departs from existence, leaving behind an echo of glory that proves but a fleeting phantasm. Thus, the Prophet compares human majesty to the most fragile flower. "Let the earth bring forth herbs, sowing seed in accordance with their kind." The sequence of vegetation still attests to the original command, for each green sprout is preceded by the manifestation of a budding shoot. Whether emerging through roots or seeds, there must first be a sprout, then greenery, followed by lush growth, only to yield fruit on a tired stem. "Let the earth germinate the sprouting herbs." When the seed embeds itself in the receptive earth paired with moisture and warmth, it expands, producing roots that draw nourishment from its surroundings, while the delicate earth particles increase the seed's volume. From it, roots extend and upward shoots arise, yielding stems in proportion to the roots. With continual warmth, moisture drawn by the roots nourishes the stem, splitting vital nutrients into the skin, grains, and ears. Thus, as plants flourish, each attains its proper growth, be it wheat, legumes, vegetables, or shrubs. The design of a single herb or stalk occupies much thought, granting insight into the artistry of its creation – consider how a stalk of wheat has bulgings that support the weight of the ears laden with grain. In contrast, the oats lack such bulges, being lightweight, while the wheat's sheath protects its grains from birds and little creatures with its spiky appendages. What else shall I dwell upon? In the vast treasury of creation, one finds it challenging to single out any superiority, as each entity serves a purpose. "Let the earth sprout herbs." Alongside nutritious herbs, harmful plants exist in a delicate balance, with both wholesome and toxic varieties. Should we reject gratitude for the beneficial while blaming the Creator for that which harms? Can it be imagined that all was crafted solely for our consumption? What is beneficial for our nourishment remains within reach; the blood of an ox may prove poisonous to you. Should we have then not created such creatures, or crafting them without blood? Yet, the ox is vital for various purposes in our lives. It suffices to possess reason and prudence to safeguard against dangers. Should sheep and goats discern what endangers them through instinct, is it too much to expect from you, endowed with rationality and wisdom, to recognize what is helpful and what to avoid? Even these elements, none exist without intention or value, be it for sustenance for animals or curative remedies. Starlings consume hemlock but remain unaffected by its poison due to their unique physiological design; quails feed on the same and likewise endure. Ultimately, what might seem to incriminate the Creator serves only to amplify our gratitude. "Let the earth sprout former herbs." How many foods does the Scripture allude to, awaiting us in roots, greens, and fruits? Countless others are borne of our labor and cultivation! God commanded the earth not to produce fruit and seeds abruptly, but first to yield sprouts and greenery before culminating in seeds, shaping nature’s order for the future. They may question, "How can the earth yield seeds according to their kind, when often, having sown wheat, we harvest this black grain of wheat?" This is not a transformation into a different genus but represents affliction and disease of the seed. Here, wheat remains wheat; rather, it has suffered through burning, altering its appearance and taste through the cold. However, it is noted that with proper conditions, it can revert to its original form. Therefore, nothing in plants defies this command. The so-called tares and all other seeds not meant for consumption originate not from wheat but carry their own distinct lineage, embodying those who distort the Lord's teachings, ignorant of the Scriptures, tainted by malevolent doctrine, yet infiltrate the Church to subtly spread their corruption amongst the uninformed. The Lord likens the growth of believers to that of seed, stating, "As a man sows seed in the earth and sleeps and rises, and the seed sprouts and grows, he knows not how. The earth brings forth first the grass, then the ear, and after that the full grain in the ear" (Mark 4:26-28). "Let the earth germinate the former." The earth, abiding by its Creator’s decree, swiftly experiences various growth stages, reaching maturity almost instantaneously. Lush meadows overflow with grass, fertile plains sway with ripened stock, resembling the undulating sea. In abundance, every green entity, every edible shoot, all shrubs, and pod-bearing plants appeared upon the earth. None of this growth was hindered by inexperience in agriculture, unyielding weather, or other factors; all came to fruition before the condemnation that incited mankind’s toil – the curse compelling us to earn bread by the sweat of our brow. Yet it was said, "And the fruitful tree that bears fruit, in which is its seed, after its kind and after its likeness upon the earth." At this decree, bushes multiplied, and towering trees—firs, cedars, cypresses—burgeoned from the ground. Young trees suddenly flourished with numerous branches; the plants recognized for their crowns—roses, myrtles, and laurel—emerged. None of these existed before, all appeared in an instant, each uniquely defined and distinct from others. The rose, initially thornless, later bore thorns alongside its beauty, a reminder of the sorrow of our sin that resulted in the earth's production of “thorns and thistles” (Genesis 3:18). Skeptics may question, "Why does the earth produce 'a fruitful tree that bears fruit,' yet many trees lack fruit or seed?" The answer lies in the understanding that these plants are those deemed superior. Closer inspection reveals that every tree possesses either seed or an equivalent. Even willows, reeds, and other trees seemingly barren, upon scrutiny, exhibit seeds nestled beneath leaves, aptly termed μισχος. Branchless trees draw life from their myriad roots, with root shoots potentially serving as seeds and contributing to the propagation of their kind. Primarily, those trees highlighted are those that sustain our lives—grapevines producing wine that "gladdens the heart," and the olive tree, providing oil that "anoints the face" (Psalms 103:15). Consider the swift creation of such productive wonder! The vine's roots, sprawling branches, buds, and green grapes form a tapestry that enhances your thoughts; surely you recognize the Lord's likeness in calling Himself "the vine," with the Father as the "vinedresser," and each of us as "the branches" through faith nurtured within the Church, urged to bear fruit lest we face the fire of worthlessness (John 15:1-6). In every aspect, human souls are likened to vines; it is noted, "The vine was to the beloved as a rose, in a place where it thrived." Additionally, "I will plant the vine and build a fence around it" (Isaiah 5:1, 2). Indubitably, the vine symbolizes human souls, enclosed within a protective hedge—commandments delineating a pathway and guardian angels watching over. "The angel of the Lord encamps around those who fear Him" (Psalms 33:8). Like a fortified refuge, "He set in the Church first apostles, second prophets, third teachers" (1 Corinthians 12:28). Through the roles of ancient and revered individuals, our thoughts are raised upwards, not left to languish beneath contempt. He wishes for us to entwine with one another in love’s embrace, aspiring to heights like the twisting branches of grapevines, striving for the peaks of highest virtue.

Read the full text in the app

Gregory of Nyssa

4th centuryChurch Father

At the outset of creation, as revealed in the Scriptures, the earth first yielded vegetation, such as herbs and grass. Subsequently, the seed emerged from the sprout, and when it fell to the ground, it produced more seeds of the same kind. Therefore, it is not the ear that comes from the seed, but rather the seed that arises from the ear, leading to the ear developing from the seed.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

At the moment of their creation, cereals emerged instantaneously, yet their maturity suggested they took months to develop. Similarly, the trees were formed in a single day, yet their fullness and the fruit adorning their branches gave the impression of years of growth. The grains intended for nourishment were designated for the animals, created two days later. The Lord also made the fruit-bearing clusters meant for Adam and Eve, whom He expelled from paradise after four days. Thus, while the grains were brought into existence in a single moment, they appeared to be the results of long seasons. Likewise, the trees were generated in one day, but their flourishing and the abundance of fruit on their limbs implied a lengthy process of cultivation. The grains to sustain life were prepared for the animals, created two days thereafter; the Lord also fashioned the clusters set aside for Adam and Eve, who were driven from paradise after the four-day period.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

Let it be made clear that the sun does not bring forth life. It is the grace of God that has stirred the earth, allowing it to bear fruit through divine will. Does the sun play a role in the creation of living beings when they were formed by God’s life-giving power even before the sun was established for their advantage?

Philaret of Moscow (Drosdow)

19th centuryChurch Father

When the Lord expresses His affirmation of the entire plant kingdom, humanity ought not to oppose this by deeming some plants detrimental or toxic. Had the fall of humanity not tainted creation, we would perceive only blessing and goodness within them. Augustine remarks on animals, yet his insight can be applied to all living things: if you find them beneficial, give glory to God; if they serve no purpose, entrust them to their Creator; and if they are harmful, reflect, O sinner, on the benevolence of God, who transforms punishment into an opportunity for your achievements.

Vissarion (Nechaev)

19th centuryCommentator

And the Lord observed the goodness found in vegetation. In what ways are plants good? They serve as sustenance for countless beings, materials for shelter, sources of warmth, textiles, and various products, pigments for artists and craftspeople, and healing remedies for the ill. They cleanse and rejuvenate the atmosphere, releasing the oxygen that sustains us while absorbing carbon, an excess of which would be detrimental to our health. Furthermore, flora adorns the earth splendidly, akin to a tapestry that blankets the ground, their forms, diversity, and symmetry inspiring the highest spiritual joy and a deep respect for the Creator. As for those plants deemed seemingly useless or harmful, such as thorns, thistles, and toxic species, they were not created without an underlying purpose.

Read more (43 words)

Many toxic substances hold medicinal properties. Additionally, plants that may seem detrimental to humanity often provide benefits to other creatures. The proliferation of harmful vegetation for humans was ultimately a result of the Fall, serving both as punishment and a means for instruction.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.