The Church Fathers on this verse

Genesis 37:28Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And when the Madianite merchants passed by, they drew him out of the pit, and sold him to the Ismaelites, for twenty pieces of silver: and they led him into Egypt.

Douay-Rheims

וַיַּֽעַבְרוּ֩ אֲנָשִׁ֨ים מִדְיָנִ֜ים סֹֽחֲרִ֗ים וַֽיִּמְשְׁכוּ֙ וַיַּֽעֲל֤וּ אֶת־יוֹסֵף֙ מִן־הַבּ֔וֹר וַיִּמְכְּר֧וּ אֶת־יוֹסֵ֛ף לַיִּשְׁמְעֵאלִ֖ים בְּעֶשְׂרִ֣ים כָּ֑סֶף וַיָּבִ֥יאוּ אֶת־יוֹסֵ֖ף מִצְרָֽיְמָה׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

8 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 9 commentaries

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

What a wretched transaction! What a devastating profit! What an unlawful bargain! How can you sell someone who shares blood ties with you, dearly cherished by his father, who has come to visit you, and who has never wronged you, to savages heading to Egypt? What sheer folly! What animosity! What jealousy! If you act out of fear of his dreams, believing they will come true, why pursue the impossible and provoke the God who revealed these visions to him? And if you dismiss dreams as meaningless, why engage in actions that will lead to your everlasting shame and your father's ongoing torment? Yet, oh, the relentless power of passion, or more aptly, of blood-stained resolve!

Read more (279 words)

Once one succumbs to unlawful actions and immerses themselves in wicked thoughts, they cease to recognize the vigilant Eye before them, nor do they feel shame for the nature they defy, or for anything else that might evoke compassion, as was the case here. They failed to see that he was their brother, young and precious to their father; they disregarded the reality that he had never experienced life among strangers. Driven solely by a desire to satisfy their envy, they turned their intentions fratricidal, while the one who suffered bore it all with grace. The right hand of the Almighty protected him, making every hardship bearable. Thus, when we are blessed from above, even in the company of strangers and in a foreign land, we can lead a more fulfilling life than those who dwell in comfort yet lack divine assistance; conversely, even in our own homes, if deprived of heavenly support, we may be the most wretched of all. The strength of virtue is profound, while vice proves utterly powerless, something this narrative exemplifies vividly. Tell me, who do you deem truly wretched and deserving of many tears - those who inflicted harm on your brother, or he who was sold into slavery to foreigners? Surely, it is those who brought harm. Consider, then, how this remarkable young man, raised among many servants and forever in his father's embrace, abruptly found himself enduring harsh slavery among savages no better than beasts. Yet the Lord of all subdued these people and endowed him with remarkable patience. After selling their brother, Joseph's siblings felt as though they had triumphed, believing they had successfully rid themselves of their despised brother.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

After having been rescued from the pit, the sacred Joseph journeyed briefly to Egypt, where he was purchased by the Ishmaelites, who were traders of incense. Similarly, Christ resurrected and emerged from the abyss. Departing from Judea, He ventured into the land of the Gentiles, motivated by the thoughts of the Ishmaelites—those who live in accordance with God, as the name suggests. Who are they? They may be understood as the blessed disciples, who attentively listened to Christ's teachings and became the foundation of those honored through their obedience and faith, praising Him beyond the confines of the law.

Read more (119 words)

In righteousness, these individuals can be likened to merchants of incense, for they embody the fragrance of the mystery of Christ and vividly reflect every virtue within their souls. They acquired Christ by abandoning all the splendid aspects of the law, possessing that one priceless pearl, as depicted in the Savior's parable (Matt. 13:46). They carried Christ to the Gentiles, sanctifying the gospel, and proclaiming Him throughout the regions flourished with sunflowers, recognizing Him as God and Lord, the chosen stone rejected by those adhering to the law and the worldly wisdom of builders, yet exalted and honored by God, serving as the cornerstone (Ps. 117:22; cf. Matt. 21:42; Mk. 12:10-11; Lk. 20:17; cf. Is. 28:16; 1 Pet. 2:6).

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

They sold him without clothing to the Ishmaelites, while they themselves lamented for him in front of the Canaanites. They shackled Joseph's wrists and ankles and sent him on his journey, while they remained silently in their home, mourning for him. Thus, Joseph arrived in Egypt, where he was sold and soon changed masters twice.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

In the Hebrew text, it refers to “pieces of silver” rather than “gold.” This emphasizes that it is inappropriate for the Lord to be valued at a lesser price than Joseph.

Chromatius of Aquileia

5th centuryChurch Father

Let us delve into this profound mystery: Joseph was sold for twenty pieces of gold, while the Lord was betrayed for thirty pieces of silver (Matt. 26:15). The unfortunate servant was valued more highly than the Master, yet it is evident that human perception misjudged the Master’s worth, as the One sold is beyond price. Let us examine this significant mystery further. The Jews paid thirty pieces of silver for the Lord, while the Ishmaelites offered twenty pieces of gold for Joseph. To the Ishmaelites, the slave was of greater value than the Lord was to the Jews. The former recognized in Joseph a foreshadowing of Christ, whereas the latter disregarded Christ, the embodiment of Truth Himself (cf. Jn. 14:6).

Read more (147 words)

Consequently, the Jews offered a lesser amount for the Lord, as they deemed Christ's sufferings to be of lesser significance. But how could the sufferings of Christ, for which the entire world was redeemed, be considered less? For through Christ's sufferings, the entire human race has been liberated from death. Consider what the apostle states: For ye are bought with a dear price (1 Cor. 6:20). Similarly, the apostle Peter affirms this truth: You have not been redeemed from your empty way of life with corruptible silver or gold, but with the precious blood of the pure Lamb of God (1 Pet. 1:18-19). If our redemption were secured with gold or silver, it would indeed be trivial, for humanity holds greater worth than all precious metals. However, we have been redeemed at a cost beyond measure, for priceless is He who has saved us through His suffering.

Dimitri of Rostov

17th centuryChurch Father

The merchants who bought Joseph traveled to Ephrathah, the site of Rachel's grave, where she passed away during Jacob's return from Mesopotamia. Upon seeing his mother Rachel’s burial place, Joseph hurried over and fell before it. With a loud cry and bitter tears, he lamented, "Rachel, my mother! Arise from the earth and behold your beloved Joseph! Witness my plight: I am being taken captive to Egypt by strangers. My brothers have sold me into slavery, exposing me like a vile man. Jacob remains oblivious to my sale. Open your tomb to me, dear mother, and embrace me. Let our resting places converge as one. O Rachel! Receive your son, so he might not face death in a foreign land. Rachel, draw me to you! My separation from Jacob was as abrupt as my severance from you, my mother.

Read more (558 words)

Let the sorrow and distress of my heart be heard by you, that you might welcome me into your tomb. I have no tears left to shed; my soul is exhausted with grief. O Rachel, Rachel! Will you not heed your son Joseph's cries? They are taking me from you against your will, and you cannot hold me back. I called out to Jacob, yet he did not hear me. Now I cry out to you, and you remain unresponsive. Should I perish here by your grave, I refuse to die like a rogue in a land that is not my own. When the Ishmaelites who bought Joseph spotted him weeping at the tomb, they exchanged glances and said, "This young man seeks to escape us through sorcery. We must bind him tightly to prevent any trouble!" Approaching him angrily, they warned, "Get up, cease your enchantments, or we will kill you here at this grave. We will not forfeit the money we spent on you!" When Joseph rose, the Ishmaelites noticed his swollen eyes from crying. One by one, they began to inquire with compassion, "Why did you weep so hard at this grave? Fear not, share your story with us—who are you, and why were you sold? The shepherds who sold you have told us, 'Take care of him lest he flee; but if he escapes, it is not our fault, as we warned you.' Tell us the truth: whose servitude do you endure? Is it to those shepherds or another master? And explain the deep affection you hold for this tomb. We are your masters now because we purchased you. As a servant, you must tell us everything. If you conceal anything, who else can you confide your sorrow to? You belong to us, do you not? Those shepherds have warned us that you might try to flee, which troubles us. Compose yourself and speak openly about your identity. You appear to be noble, and we desire to regard you not just as a slave but as our cherished brother. Your fine bearing and intellect suggest that you deserve to stand before kings and be esteemed among the elite. Your many virtues indicate you will attain greatness. Be our ally wherever we go. Who could possibly resist loving such a wise, noble, and handsome young man?" With a sigh, Joseph responded, "Though you have bought me, I am neither a slave, thief, nor sorcerer, nor have I committed any wrongdoing. I am my father's favored son, and I was my mother’s favored son while she was alive. Those shepherds are my brothers; my father dispatched me to inquire about their well-being. They had not returned for a considerable time, which concerned my affectionate father, prompting him to send me after them. In their jealousy over my father's love for me, they captured me and sold me into your hands. The coffin before you is my mother’s. When my father Jacob moved from Haran back to his homeland, my mother died here and was laid to rest in this tomb." Upon hearing this, the Ishmaelites replied sympathetically, "Do not despair, young man! Great honor awaits you in Egypt. Your appearance speaks of your nobility. Rather than mourn, rejoice in the fact that you are now distanced from your envious brothers who held unjust hatred towards you.

Ignatij (Briantchaninow)

19th centuryChurch Father

The sound of gold coins echoed... Joseph had been retrieved from the pit and was quickly sold to merchants from Arabia. No arguments arose between the parties concerning the ransom or the captive. The Scriptures would not remain mute if significant words had been exchanged in this instance. In this narrative, the Scriptures also overlook any statements worth noting. The goldsmiths counted, totaling twenty. This chime bears a striking resemblance to the clinking of thirty pieces of silver... O blessed youth, sold for twenty pieces of gold! You carry the honor of symbolizing the one who was betrayed for thirty pieces of silver!

Abba John Kolov posed the inquiry: Who was it that sold Joseph? A monk replied: his brothers. However, the elder countered: it was not his brothers who did this, but rather his humility. Joseph had the option to proclaim himself as their brother and resist the sale. Instead, he remained silent, and through his humility, he was sold; yet that same humility ultimately led him to become the ruler of Egypt.

Philaret of Moscow (Drosdow)

19th centuryChurch Father

The individuals previously referred to as Ishmaelites are now designated as Midianites, illustrating a mix-up in terminology since the former is the more recognized and familiar name for the group, while the latter denotes the specific name of a lesser tribe. It is noted that, according to the Mosaic law, a price of thirty pieces of silver should be sought for a slave who is unintentionally killed; however, Joseph was sold for merely twenty pieces. This reflects the low value attributed to the savior of Israel and Egypt at that time. Just as Joseph was sold to outsiders, so too was Jesus betrayed for thirty pieces of silver (Matt. 26:15) and handed over to the nations (Matt. 20:19).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.