The Church Fathers on this verse

John 19:38Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And after these things, Joseph of Arimathea (because he was a disciple of Jesus, but secretly for fear of the Jews), besought Pilate that he might take away the body of Jesus. And Pilate gave leave. He came therefore and took away the body of Jesus.

Douay-Rheims

μετα ταυτα ηρωτησεν τον πιλατον ιωσηφ ο ιωσηφ ο απο αριμαθαιας ων μαθητης του ιησου κεκρυμμενος δε δια τον φοβον των ιουδαιων ινα αρη το σωμα του ιησου και επετρεψεν ο πιλατος ηλθεν ουν και ηρεν το σωμα του ιησου

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

12 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

"After this came Joseph, who was from Arimathea," being a disciple, not among the twelve, but perhaps among the seventy.

Thinking that the cross had finally softened the frenzy of the Jews, Christ's followers come without fear and take care for the burial.

Joseph, appearing before Pilate, asks permission from him, and Pilate permits it. Why, indeed, would he not permit it?

Nicodemus also takes part in Joseph's work. They perform a splendid burial, because they still thought of Christ as a mere man.

They bring such aromatic spices as had special power to preserve the body for a long time and keep it from quickly yielding to corruption.

This shows that they had no great conception of Christ. Nevertheless, in this their great love for Him is visible.

Read more (137 words)

But why did none of the twelve come, neither John, nor Peter, nor any other of the prominent ones? The Evangelist does not conceal this either.

Perhaps someone will say that they feared the Jews. Yet those men, Joseph and Nicodemus, were also held by fear.

It is said specifically of Joseph that he was secret for fear of the Jews. Therefore one cannot say that he did this because he utterly disregarded the Jews.

No, he too was afraid, and nevertheless he came. John, though he was present at the cross and saw Christ's death, did nothing of the sort.

What, then, does this mean? It seems to me that Joseph was among very distinguished men, as is clear from the burial itself, and that he was known to Pilate.

For this reason he obtained permission.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Why did none of the Twelve come to Pilate, but Joseph dared to do such a thing, perhaps being one of the Seventy? If someone says that the disciples hid for fear of the Jews, Joseph was possessed by the same fear. One may say that Joseph was a very distinguished man, and because of his distinction was known also to Pilate.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

This report greatly accuses and exposes the impiety of the Jews, showing that becoming a disciple of Christ was dangerous and not altogether without peril.

It clearly presents to us this most prudent Joseph as making every effort to remain hidden.

Yet he had chosen what was truly true, more excellent than the Law, and more pleasing service to the God who loves the good.

At the same time it confirms what we must believe. Yes, we must believe precisely that Christ laid down His soul for us.

For where there is burial, is it not necessary to be firmly persuaded that there was also death?

Not without reason may one accuse the pride, inhumanity, and malice of the Jews of extreme savagery.

Read more (113 words)

They do not render to Christ even the honor due to the dead. They do not perform their duty when they see a breathless corpse lying there.

They even know that He is the Christ and often marvel at the Wonderworker. Yet strong envy in no way allowed them to implant in themselves the true benefit from His miracles.

Therefore, to condemn the inhumanity of the Jews and to convict the people of Jerusalem, the disciple who was from Arimathea comes.

He shows honor through proper care for the One whom he revered, though not yet with open faith, but with secret faith, "for fear of the Jews," as the blessed Evangelist says.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

Why was the burial performed not by the Apostles, but by Joseph and Nicodemus?

The first was righteous and faithful, and in the second there was no guile. In Christ's burial too there is neither guile nor lawlessness.

The Jews are overcome by the testimony of their own fellow believers, and the path is blocked for slanderous attacks.

If the Apostles had buried Him, they would have been accused of deliberately not burying Christ, but simply stealing His body.

Only in John do I read of Joseph that he came secretly to Pilate because of fear of the Jews.

Why did a righteous man hide because of the danger? I think he asked secretly so that the Lord's body would be given to him without hindrance, not so that he might avoid danger.

Read more (357 words)

What is surprising if a righteous man hid, when the Apostles themselves, the teachers of the righteous, also hid?

Come also yourself. Come late, come by night, come at any time, and you will always meet Jesus. He is ready to look upon you and does not lessen the wage for those who come late.

The one who came at the sixth hour was not deprived of the wage, and the one who came at the eleventh received it in full (cf. Mt 20:1-9).

Nicodemus came by night (cf. Jn 3:2). It was night because the Resurrection had not yet taken place.

But when Christ rose, the righteous man said, "The night is far spent, the day is at hand" (Rom 13:12).

Luke calls Joseph righteous, Matthew rich. Worthily is he called rich who received the body of Christ. Receiving the Rich One, he could not be poor in faith.

Therefore he is rich who is righteous. He wraps Christ in a linen cloth and, being truly an Israelite, pours out a hundred litrae of aloe.

By mixing various aromatic spices of virtues, he pours out the measure of perfect faith.

Who is this Joseph, in whose tomb Christ is laid? Certainly he is a righteous man.

The body of Christ is entrusted to the tomb of a righteous man, so that the Son of Man may have somewhere to lay His head. Thus He may find rest in the dwelling of righteousness.

It is good that it was laid in a new tomb. In the literal sense, this prevents unbelievers from slandering by saying that someone else rose.

Apart from the spiritual sense, the words cannot be understood: "Their throat is an open grave" (Ps 5:9).

An open grave is the throat of man. There destructive unbelief and deadening words gather. It grows old and decays from age, as though from the assault of wild beasts.

There is another tomb, in the inner man. The Word hews it for Himself by penetrating the hardness of the Gentile heart and smoothing it through works of faith and teaching.

Thus the power of Christ appears among the nations.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

"After these things Joseph of Arimathea, being a disciple of Jesus, but secretly for fear of the Jews. Asked Pilate that he might take away the body of Jesus." Read the explanation of these words in the interpretation of the place in the twenty-seventh chapter of Matthew where it says, "When evening had come, there came a rich man from Arimathea, named Joseph" (Mt 27:57). "And Pilate gave permission. So he came and took the body of Jesus." See the interpretation on Jn 19:39.

Justin Martyr

2nd centuryChurch Father

It was not by chance that the prophet Moses, while Hur and Aaron supported his hands, remained in that posture until evening. For the Lord also remained on the tree almost until evening, and toward evening they buried Him. Then He rose on the third day. See Ex 17:12.

Beda Venerabilis

7th centuryChurch Father

Thus, by providence, it was necessary that he be wealthy, so as to have access to the governor, and that he be righteous, so as to perform worthily the burial of the Lord's body.

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

The taking down of Jesus' body from the cross.

Evening was approaching, when it was necessary to take the bodies down from the crosses so that they would not hang during the days of the Passover feast.

Then there came to Pilate a rich man, Joseph, from Arimathea, a Jewish city. He was an eminent member of the council (Mk 15:42), that is, of the Sanhedrin.

He was good and righteous, and had taken no part either in the conspiracy of the chief priests and Pharisees against Jesus, or in the sessions of the Sanhedrin where the sentence of death was pronounced upon Him.

The Evangelist Luke attests this (Lk 23:50-51).

Read more (199 words)

Joseph was a disciple of Jesus, but a secret one. He feared to join Him openly, because the Sanhedrin threatened all open disciples of Jesus with excommunication from the synagogues.

Though he was a secret disciple, Joseph believed in the imminent coming of the Kingdom of God and awaited it. He now came to Pilate to ask for Jesus' body for burial.

When Pilate heard Joseph's request, he was surprised that Jesus had died so soon.

Probably the order to break the legs had only just been given and could not have been carried out by the time Joseph arrived.

Perhaps, as Joseph was entering Pilate's presence, he met those leaving him who had been sent by the chief priests to ask that the death of the crucified be hastened.

To make certain that Jesus had truly died, Pilate sent for the centurion who was at Golgotha.

While the messengers went for the centurion, Pilate's order had already been carried out at Golgotha. The legs of the two thieves were broken, and Jesus' side was pierced.

The centurion who came at Pilate's summons certified that Jesus had truly died. Then Pilate ordered him to give Jesus' body to Joseph.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

The elders did not concern themselves with the burial of the crucified criminals. They left it to friends and relatives, if there were any, to bury the executed men in their unknown graves.

But one important person did concern himself with Christ's burial. He asked Pilate for permission to bury Him according to his own zeal and desire.

This was Joseph of Arimathea, a rich man of noble soul and blameless life, and a prominent member of the Sanhedrin.

He was one of those secret disciples of Christ who sympathized with Him in soul, but did not have enough courage to confess their faith in Him openly because of their public position.

Only now did the Teacher's terrible death drive all fear from him. He appealed to Pilate with a request for permission to bury Christ's body.

Pilate, out of respect for the dignified petitioner, agreed to his request, after first making certain of the reality of the Crucified One's death.

Then the honorable Joseph quickly set about the work.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

In the account of the taking down from the cross and the burial of the Lord, John supplements the narratives of the first three Evangelists with several new details. Joseph of Arimathea, and so forth: see the notes on Mt 27:57-60; Mk 15:42-46; Lk 23:50-53. Secretly, for fear of the Jews: see the notes on Jn 9:22 and Jn 12:42.

Philaret (Gumilevski)

19th centuryChurch Father

"He came and took the body of Jesus. Nicodemus also came, who had first come to Jesus by night" (Jn 19:38-39).

Joseph appeared on Golgotha to take Jesus down from the Cross when the soldiers, executors of the Sanhedrin's will, had barely finished their work over the Savior's breathless body.

At the same time Nicodemus also appeared on Golgotha. He was another Joseph. He had once come to Jesus and heard His lofty teaching on spiritual regeneration (Jn 3:1-21).

He belonged to the sect of the Pharisees, but he did not share its irrational zeal for the letter of the Law. He even sometimes moderated the irritation of his companions against Jesus.

Read more (1143 words)

When the Pharisaic party of the Sanhedrin, after hearing an unpleasant report about Jesus from those sent to seize Him, poured out blasphemies and threats, Nicodemus said in everyone's hearing:

"Does our Law judge a man before it hears him and knows what he has done?" (Jn 7:51).

From the spirit of the Gospel accounts it is clear that Joseph and Nicodemus acted in the matter of the Savior's burial by mutual agreement. If only Joseph came to Pilate with the request, this was surely because the cave where they wished to bury Jesus belonged to Joseph.

He therefore acted before Pilate as a kindly host, asking Pilate's permission to receive a dear guest. Thus Joseph and Nicodemus took down from the Cross the body of the Lord Jesus.

Two members of the Sanhedrin, two men respected among the whole people for wealth, knowledge, and personal worth, take down with their own hands the body of Jesus from the Cross.

They take down the very body which the Sanhedrin had made an object of general contempt. Is this not a loud proclamation, not only of the innocence, but also of the high dignity, of Jesus persecuted by the Sanhedrin?

The Sanhedrin repaid Nicodemus as it had repaid Joseph. It drove Nicodemus too from its assembly and from Jerusalem.

My listeners, two features especially strike us in Joseph and Nicodemus: their compassionate love for Jesus Christ, and their resolve, despite dangers, to fulfill the duty of compassion.

Shall we refuse to follow their beautiful example? They are blessed, highly blessed, because they were able to render the service of compassion to the Lord Jesus Himself. But can the same honor and the same blessedness not belong to us?

By love for our neighbors we can express our love for the Lord. What you do for the poor, you do for Me; and what you do not do for the unfortunate, you do not do for Me (Mt 25:37-40).

So our Lord told us. See how much compassionate love means. How can we refuse works of mercy and labors of compassion?

How can we fail to take upon ourselves the hardest labors and the most unpleasant tasks for self-love, for the sake of the poor and suffering? For we know that when we labor for them, we labor for the Lord.

In whatever form suffering humanity appears before us, and in whatever form we must offer help or consolation to poor humanity, let us not miss a single occasion to do good.

Let us hold the firm thought that the Lord refers our service to men to Himself, and will undoubtedly repay us for a work of love with love in eternity.

We do not have the means to do much for the suffering. Let us do what we can. There will be a reward even for our little, provided it comes from a sincere heart.

Believe that even a tear shed over one who suffers will not be forgotten. A kind word spoken to a poor man will be remembered there.

A piece of bread, perhaps unnecessary for us but sweet to the hungry man to whom we give it, will not be lost for us. An old garment with which we cover the nakedness of the helpless will benefit us ourselves.

Joseph and Nicodemus performed a work of compassion, having in view neither glory nor gain. On the contrary, for their deed the hatred of men awaited them.

Let us not be sad if we too must endure unpleasantness for our good. Then our reward is doubled, both for the work of love and for patiently bearing sorrow.

There is little benefit for us when on earth they give us what is ours. There is little benefit when we sound a trumpet about our charity (Mt 6:11-41).

But if we gather to a feast the poor, the maimed, the lame, and the blind, then we are blessed because they have nothing with which to repay us. We shall be repaid at the resurrection of the righteous (Lk 13:13-14).

Glory to our God. Amen.

For the last time, my listeners, it remains for us to speak of the Savior's sufferings. Behold, His tomb is before us. His tomb is not a tomb of earthly greatness. It is a tomb clothed with divine majesty.

Thanksgiving to You, humbled heavenly Goodness, for deeming us unworthy ones worthy to behold the works of Your self-emptying to the end.

"Nicodemus also came, bringing a mixture of myrrh and aloes, about a hundred litras. Then they took the body of Jesus and bound it in linen cloths with the spices, as the custom of burial is" (Jn 19:39-40).

Among the Jews, the preparation of a body for burial, when they wished to give the rite splendor and solemnity as a sign of honor to the dead, consisted in costly spices.

Nicodemus brought a full hundred litras, or a hundred pounds, of spices. This was a mixture of myrrh and aloes. Myrrh is a costly resin from a fragrant Arabian tree.

Even more costly is aloe, a product of India, a fragrant plant that grows in the form of a reed. Myrrh and aloe were used in burial both as aromatic substances and as means of preserving the body from rapid decay.

These spices were used both dry and in the form of fragrant ointment. For the Savior's body they were used in the latter form, as the word "mixture" shows.

"The perfumer," says the son of Sirach, "makes a mixture from these" (Sir 38:8). Long before His death, the Savior foretold this preparation of His holy body for burial.

He did so when He spoke of Mary, who had anointed His feet with pure nard: "Leave her alone; she has kept this for the day of My burial" (Jn 12:3, 7).

While Nicodemus's zeal supplied so many costly spices, Joseph bought a new, clean shroud (Mk 15:46). It was a linen cloth, the finest and very costly, called a sadin or sindon.

The Savior's body was washed, anointed with spices, wrapped in the sindon, tied with cords, and the head and face were covered with a sudarium, a narrow cloth.

"From everything," says Saint Chrysostom, "it is clear that they did not think very highly of Jesus, yet they showed complete love for Him."

Notice also, listeners, how the signs of deep respect for the great Dead One later became faithful heralds of Christ's Resurrection.

In the ordinary course of things, it could not happen that the cloths wrapped around the body with ointment, and firmly stuck to the body by the ointment, would separate from the breathless body.

Yet on the morning of the Resurrection John precisely saw the linen cloths lying alone in the tomb. Therefore, having come before Peter, he saw and believed (Jn 20:4-5, 8).

Tertullian

3rd centuryTeacher of the Church

Joseph certainly knew that what he handled so reverently was a body. This is that Joseph who did not support the Jews in their crime. He is that blessed man who does not walk in the counsel of the ungodly, nor stand in the way of sinners, nor sit in the seat of destroyers (Ps 1:1). And it was fitting that the man who buried the Lord should become the object of prophecy, and now be counted worthy of blessing. See Lk 23:51.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 38 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Μετὰ
    meta
    with
    G3326 · μετά
  2. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. ταῦτα
    tauta
    this
    G3778 · οὗτος
  4. ἠρώτησεν
    ērōtēsen
    I ask
    G2065 · ἐρωτάω
  5. τὸν
    ton
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  6. Πιλᾶτον
    pilaton
    Pilate
    G4091 · Πιλᾶτος
  7. Ἰωσὴφ
    iōsēph
    Joseph
    G2501 · Ἰωσήφ
  8. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  9. ἀπὸ
    apo
    from
    G575 · ἀπό
  10. Ἁριμαθαίας
    harimathaias
    Arimathea
    G707 · Ἀριμαθαία
  11. ὢν
    ōn
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  12. μαθητὴς
    mathētēs
    a learner
    G3101 · μαθητής
  13. τοῦ
    tou
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  14. Ἰησοῦ
    iēsou
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  15. κεκρυμμένος
    kekrymmenos
    I hide
    G2928 · κρύπτω
  16. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  17. διὰ
    dia
    through
    G1223 · διά
  18. τὸν
    ton
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  19. φόβον
    phobon
    fear
    G5401 · φόβος
  20. τῶν
    tōn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  21. Ἰουδαίων
    ioudaiōn
    Jewish
    G2453 · Ἰουδαῖος
  22. ἵνα
    hina
    in order that
    G2443 · ἵνα
  23. ἄρῃ
    arē
    I raise
    G142 · αἴρω
  24. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  25. σῶμα
    sōma
    body
    G4983 · σῶμα
  26. τοῦ
    tou
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  27. Ἰησοῦ
    iēsou
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  28. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  29. ἐπέτρεψεν
    epetrepsen
    I allow
    G2010 · ἐπιτρέπω
  30. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  31. Πιλᾶτος
    pilatos
    Pilate
    G4091 · Πιλᾶτος
  32. ἦλθεν
    ēlthen
    I come
    G2064 · ἔρχομαι
  33. οὖν
    oun
    therefore
    G3767 · οὖν
  34. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  35. ἦρεν
    ēren
    I raise
    G142 · αἴρω
  36. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  37. σῶμα
    sōma
    body
    G4983 · σῶμα
  38. αὐτοῦ
    autou
    he
    G846 · αὐτός