The Church Fathers on this verse

Luke 10:42Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

But one thing is necessary. Mary hath chosen the best part, which shall not be taken away from her.

Douay-Rheims

ενος δε εστιν χρεια μαρια δε την αγαθην μεριδα εξελεξατο ητις ουκ αφαιρεθησεται απ αυτης

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

18 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 25 commentaries

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

It is not said of Mary simply that she sat near Jesus, but at His feet, to shew her diligence, stedfastness, and zeal, in hearing, and the great reverence which she had for our Lord.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Our Lord does not then forbid hospitality, but the troubling about many things, that is to say, hurry and anxiety. And mark the wisdom of our Lord, in that at first He said nothing to Martha, but when she sought to tear away her sister from hearing, then the Lord took occasion to reprove her. For hospitality is ever honoured as long as it keeps us to necessary things. But when it begins to hinder us from attending to what is of more importance, then it is plain that the hearing of the divine word is the more honourable.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

By His own example then He teaches His disciples how they ought to behave in the houses of those who receive them, namely, when they come to a house, they should not remain idle, but rather fill the minds of those who receive them with sacred and divine teaching. But let those who make ready the house, go to meet their guests gladly and earnestly, for two reasons. First, indeed, they will be edified by the teaching of those whom they receive; next also they will receive the reward of charity. And hence it follows here, But Martha was cumbered about much serving, &c.

Or else, when certain brethren have received God, they will not be anxious about much service, nor ask for those things which are not in their hands, and are beyond their needs. For every where and in every thing that which is superfluous is burdensome. For it begets weariness in those who are wishing to bestow it, while the guests feel that they are the cause of trouble.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Now mystically, by Martha’s receiving our Lord into her house is represented the Church which now receives the Lord into her heart. Mary her sister, who sat at Jesus’ feet and heard His word, signifies the same Church, but in a future life, where ceasing from labour, and the ministering to her wants, she shall delight in Wisdom alone. But by her complaining that her sister did not help her, occasion is given for that sentence of our Lord, in which he shews that Church to be anxious and troubled about much service, when there is but one thing needful, which is yet attained through the merits of her service; but He says that Mary hath chosen the good part, for through the one the other is reached, which shall not be taken away.

But the Lord, who came to his own, and his own received him not, (John 1:12.) was received as a guest, for it follows, And a certain woman named Martha received him into her house, &c. as strangers are accustomed to be received. But still a servant received her Lord, the sick her Saviour, the creature her Creator. But if any should say, “O blessed are they who have been thought worthy to receive Christ into their houses,” grieve not thou, for He says, For inasmuch as ye have done it to the least of my brethren, ye have done it unto me. (Matt. 25:40.) But taking the form of a servant, He wished therein to be fed by servants, by reason of His condescension, not His condition. He had a body in which He was hungry and thirsty, but when He was hungry in the desert, Angels ministered to Him.

Read more (60 words)

(Matt. 4:11.) In wishing therefore to be fed, He came Himself to the feeder. Martha then, setting about and preparing to feed our Lord, was occupied in serving; but Mary her sister chose rather to be fed by the Lord, for it follows, And she had a sister called Mary, which also sat at Jesus’ feet, and heard his word.

Now as was her humility in sitting at His feet, so much the more did she receive from Him. For the waters pour down to the lowest part of the valley, but flow away from the rising of the hill.

Martha was well engaged in ministering to the bodily wants or wishes of our Lord, as of one who was mortal, but He who was clothed in mortal flesh; in the beginning was the Word. Behold then what Mary heard, The Word was made flesh. Behold then Him to whom Martha ministered. The one was labouring, the other at rest. But yet Martha, when much troubled in her occupation and business of serving, interrupted our Lord, and complained of her sister. For it follows, And said, Lord, dost thou not care that my sister hath left me to serve alone? For Mary was absorbed in the sweetness of our Lord’s words; Martha was preparing a feast for our Lord, in whose feast Mary was now rejoicing.

Read more (249 words)

While then she was listening with delight to those sweet words, and was feeding on them with the deepest affection, our Lord was interrupted by her sister. What must we suppose was her alarm, lest the Lord should say to her, “Rise, and help thy sister?” Our Lord therefore, who was not at a loss, for He had shewn He was the Lord, answered as follows, And Jesus answered and said unto her, Martha, Martha. The repetition of the name is a mark of love, or perhaps of drawing the attention, that she should listen more earnestly. When twice called, she hears, Thou art troubled about many things, that is, thou art busied about many things. For man wishes to meet with something when he is serving, and can not; and thus between seeking what is wanting and preparing what is at hand, the mind is distracted. For if Martha had been sufficient of herself, she would not have required the aid of her sister. There are many, there are diverse things, which are carnal, temporal, but one is preferred to many. For one is not from many, but many from one. Hence it follows, But one thing is needful. Mary wished to be occupied about one, according to that, It is good for me to cling close unto the Lord. (Ps. 73:28.) The Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, are one. To this one he does not bring us, unless we being many have one heart. (Acts 4:32.)

What then? Must we think that blame was cast upon the service of Martha, who was engaged in the cares of hospitality, and rejoiced in having so great a guest? If this be true, let men give up ministering to the needy; in a word, let them be at leisure, intent only upon getting wholesome knowledge, taking no care what stranger is in the village in want of bread; let works of mercy be unheeded, knowledge only be cultivated.

Our Lord then does not blame the actions, but distinguishes between the duties. For it follows, Mary hath chosen that good part, &c. Not thine a bad one, but hers a better. Why a better? because it shall not be taken away from her. From thee the necessary burden of business shall one time be taken away. For when thou comest into that country, thou wilt find no stranger to receive with hospitality. But for thy good it shall be taken away, that what is better may be given thee. Trouble shall be taken away, that rest may be given. Thou art yet at sea; she is in port. For the sweetness of truth is eternal, yet in this life it is increased, and in the next it will be made perfect, never to be taken away.

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

Now every work and word of our Saviour is a rule of piety and virtue. For to this end did He put on our body, that as much as we can we might imitate His conversation.

It is foolish also to take food for the support of the body, and thereby in return to hurt the body, and to hinder it in the performance of the divine command. If then a poor man come, let him receive a model and example of moderation in food, and let us not prepare our own tables for their sakes, who wish to live luxuriously. For the life of the Christian is uniform, ever tending to one object, namely, the glory of God. But the life of those who are without is manifold and vacillating, changed about at will. And how in truth canst thou, when thou settest thy table before thy brother with profusion of meats, and for the pleasure of feasting sake, accuse him of luxury, and revile him as a glutton, censuring his indulgence in that which thou thyself affordest him? Our Lord did not commend Martha when busied about much serving.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Since she acquired for herself a treasure to gain entry into the realm of the Only-begotten, she “chose the good part alone,” namely, the good Christ, so that “forever,” as stated, “it shall not be taken away from her.”

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

May you then like Mary be influenced by the desire of wisdom. For this is the greater, this the more perfect work. Nor let the care of ministering to others turn thy mind from the knowledge of the heavenly word, nor reprove or think indolent those whom thou seest seeking after wisdom.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

There is but one essential thing you require: to heed my words. I did not come to partake in feasting, but to impart knowledge to you. Mary selected the better portion, which shall remain with her forever. There exist two commendable ways of living: one that is active and one that is reflective. Martha and Mary exemplified these choices; Martha engaged in active service, tending to the physical needs of the Lord, while Mary embraced the contemplative path, attentive to His teachings. Since Christ embodies both aspects—providing solace to His visible presence and attending to His hidden nature—He did not reproach Martha's fervor but instead praised Mary's decision. Although Martha's service was undoubtedly valuable, Mary's choice was of a higher calling.

Read more (133 words)

You may choose to emulate either approach: serve the Lord's body by aiding those in need, for as He stated, ‘Inasmuch as ye did it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye did it unto me’ (Matthew 25:40), or spend time listening to His words and contemplating His doctrines, or perhaps you can find a balance between the two, engaging in both as the moment allows. He referred to the good part not because the other sister’s work was lacking, but to highlight that what Mary chose was indeed the superior good. Both actions are commendable, yet one surpasses the other; while the act of hospitality is beneficial, resting in the presence of God is even more profound. The former is physical labor, while the latter is a spiritual pursuit.

Origen of Alexandria

3rd centuryChurch Father

The name of which village Luke indeed here omits, but John mentions, calling it Bethany. (John 11.)

Macarius the Egyptian

4th centuryChurch Father

The tears that flow from deep sorrow and a heavy heart, when illuminated by truth and stirred from within, nourish the spirit, derived from the bread of heaven. Mary, who sat at the feet of the Lord and wept, was especially blessed to partake of this. As the Savior affirms, “But Mary chose the good portion, which shall not be taken away from her.” What an abundance of precious gems these tears are in the outpouring of grace! What a receptive and obedient heart! What courage and wisdom in the mind! What clarity bestowed by the Holy Spirit, and what a profound love drawn towards the Pure Bridegroom! What a deep yearning of the soul for God the Word! What intimate fellowship exists between the bride and her heavenly Bridegroom!

John Cassian

5th centuryChurch Father

Our primary pursuit, the unwavering aspiration of our hearts, should be for our spirits to remain connected to divine realities and to God. Anything that diverges from this focus, regardless of how significant it may appear, ought to be viewed as secondary or even detrimental. This dynamic is beautifully illustrated in the Gospel through the figures of Martha and Mary (Luke 10:38-42). Martha was engaged in a sacred task, serving the Lord and His disciples, while Mary devoted herself entirely to spiritual teachings, sitting at Jesus' feet, reverently honoring Him. Nevertheless, the Lord favored Mary over Martha, noting that she had chosen the superior path, one that could never be taken from her.

Read more (348 words)

As Martha busied herself with sacred duties, overwhelmed by the demands of her service, she pleaded with the Lord for her sister's assistance, saying, “Lord, do you not care that my sister has left me to serve alone? Tell her to help me” (Luke 10:40). Although Martha was not inviting her sister to a trivial task but rather to a commendable service, the Lord responded, “Martha! Martha, you are anxious and troubled about many things, but few things are needed, or indeed only one. Mary has chosen the good portion that will not be taken away from her” (Luke 10:41-42). Here, the Lord identifies the ultimate good as being found in divine contemplation.

Thus, while we may recognize other virtues as beneficial and essential, we contend that they should be seen as lesser in rank, as all are aimed at the singular goal of contemplation. When the Lord states, “You are anxious and troubled about many things, but you need few things, or only one,” He affirms that the highest good lies not in productive, though commendable, labors teeming with results, but rather in the simple, singular act of contemplating God. This act is the essential basis for attaining perfect happiness—it begins with meditating on a few sacred truths and, through this ascent, culminates in the vision of God alone. By excelling in the works and extraordinary services inspired by the saints, one may ultimately delight in the knowledge and glory of God. Hence, Mary made the wise choice—the portion that remains hers eternally.

It is crucial to examine this more thoroughly. When the Lord remarked that Mary had chosen the good portion, He was silent regarding Martha, seemingly offering no rebuke; yet in honoring Mary, He implied that she surpassed Martha. Moreover, in stating that it would not be taken from Mary, He indicated that Martha's portion was subject to loss. The physical service, though noble, cannot be sustained perpetually, while Mary's spiritual devotion endures eternally. The central pursuit must align with the contemplation of divine truths, as evidenced in the contrasting examples of Mary and Martha.

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

Or by Mary who sat and heard our Lord’s words, is signified the contemplative life; by Martha engaged in more outward services, the active life. Now Martha’s care is not blamed, but Mary is praised, for great are the rewards of an active life, but those of a contemplative are far better. Hence Mary’s part it is said will never be taken away from her, for the works of an active life pass away with the body, but the joys of the contemplative life the rather begin to increase from the end.

Beda Venerabilis

8th centuryChurch Father

The love of God and our neighbour, which was contained above in words and parables, is here set forth in very deed and reality; for it is said, Now it came to pass, as they went, that he entered into a certain village.

Tichon of Zadonsk

18th centuryChurch Father

You inquire about the phrase ‘one is for the asking.’ It can be understood as referring to eternal life. This is highlighted as the sole necessity; it is the one thing we truly require in life, eclipsing all other needs. We are brought into this world, baptized, and renewed specifically to embrace this gift. The Word of God has been revealed so that we may come to know God and His Son, Jesus Christ, and through this knowledge, achieve everlasting salvation. This is the purpose for which Christ our Lord entered our world, lived, endured suffering, and ultimately died, thereby unlocking the door to eternal life—something we had jeopardized through our sins. He demonstrated how to secure this precious gift. Clearly, eternal life stands as an essential need, one we cannot do without.

Read more (734 words)

While we are existing in this world, we face many demands: we need sustenance, clothing, shelter, rest, and other essentials for daily living, and we plea to our Heavenly Father for these needs: “Give us this day our daily bread.” However, eternal life holds a necessity that renders everything else insignificant. “What profit is it to a man if he gains the whole world, but harms his soul” (Matt. 16:26)? The preservation of the soul, which embodies eternal life, is far more valuable than all earthly possessions combined. For this reason, we must earnestly pursue this singular eternal salvation, turning away from the fleeting and empty pursuits of this world. A heart consumed by worldly vanity will lose sight of this essential need; when it pursues the temporal, it forgets the eternal. Conversely, when one’s focus shifts to eternity, the concern for worldly pursuits dissipates. The human heart can only fully engage with one of these two aspects at a time. If the desire for eternal life inhabits the heart, distractions from worldly vanity will recede; if vanity takes hold, the longing for eternity will diminish. Seek salvation.

One thing is necessary (Luke 10:42). These words, “One thing is necessary,” were spoken by our Savior to all believers. Many Christians devote themselves to various concerns, often oblivious to their true significance. To prevent this aimless pursuit, the Lord clarifies: “There is one thing that fulfills all our needs.” What is this essential need? It is eternal salvation. This is the foundational work of a Christian and the primary focus that should occupy our thoughts. While we require resources such as food, garments, shelter, and these are matters we bring before God, eternal salvation is so crucial that without it, everything else falls short. “What profit is it to a man if he gains the whole world, but harms his own soul” (Matt. 16:26)? None at all; without salvation, all else is meaningless. Thus, we must value the eternal life that surpasses all worldly notions of abundance.

Just as every person has duties tied to their role—judges are to judge, farmers to cultivate, merchants to trade, teachers to instruct, and students to learn—so too should a Christian's primary obligation be to honor God through faithfulness and truth, hoping for the eternal life He promises. This singular focus defines our calling. Beloved, we were not created merely for this temporary existence but for eternal life; we were renewed through holy Baptism for this purpose and called to it through the Word of God. Christ, the Son of God, entered the world, suffered, and lay down His life for eternal life. This reveals the depth of God’s commitment to our salvation. He crafted everything for this goal and came Himself for this reason. We must be vigilant and devoted to this cause, as Satan seeks to rob us of our eternal life and lead us astray. It pains us to see many Christians indifferent to this profound truth. They ignore the plight of sinners—those who engage in immorality, blasphemy, drunkenness, theft, deceit, and slander—choosing instead to focus on worldly desires over spiritual well-being.

The true value of eternal salvation, won through Christ's trials and sacrificial death on the cross, cannot be overstated, yet many fail to hold it in high regard. Today’s Christians often prioritize what brings them honor, glory, wealth, and comfort, relegating salvation to the background. Eternal salvation is indeed “one for all,” as affirmed by Christ, and in our lives, it is either embraced or forfeited. It is obtained through repentance and faith, and lost through a life devoid of repentance. Listen, fellow sinners and redeemed believers! Eternal salvation is singularly ours, a reality we either embrace or reject. Let us reflect on this deeply. Let us remember the commitments made at our Baptism and turn to God in repentance, striving to stand before Him truthfully. With each consideration of our mortality, let us repent so that we do not depart this world without hope. With an awareness of Christ’s final judgment, let us repent, ensuring we do not meet Him clothed in our sins. Let us meditate on the joy of eternal life versus the dread of eternal separation, turning to God in prayerful sorrow so He may grant us access to His mercy and His eternal kingdom. O Lord God Almighty, turn your face toward us, and we shall be saved. Amen.

Ignatij (Briantchaninow)

19th centuryChurch Father

The narrative of the Lord’s visit to the two sisters is commemorated by the Church during all the celebrations of the Mother of God. Thus, the reflections on the occurrences and teachings expressed in this account hold profound significance and serve as a source of spiritual upliftment. Serving and honoring God in Spirit and in Truth represents that 'good part', a blessed condition that begins in earthly existence yet continues beyond it, unlike bodily endeavors, which cease with physical life. The 'good part' becomes an inseparable aspect of the soul for eternity and receives its complete unfolding in that realm. It is not an entity separate from the soul that possesses it; rather, it remains forever the soul's own.

Read more (270 words)

When the grace of God resoundingly envelops the ascetic, an abundance of spiritual achievements emerges within them, steering them toward Christian maturity. It is at this moment that the soul recognizes its sinfulness, previously hidden from its awareness. The veil is lifted from its vision, and the vast, glorious eternity, which was once obscured, shines forth upon the soul. The hour of death, once a distant concern, draws near and presents itself before the soul. The earthly existence, once perceived as limitless, shrinks to mere moments: the life that has passed now resembles a fleeting dream. The remaining span of life converges into that singular hour of death.

From the depths of the soul arise cries that had never been felt before; a lamentation surfaces, along with a prayer that has never been articulated previously. Such prayer and sorrow emerge from the very core of the soul, expressed silently by both mind and heart, fervently ascending to heaven, prostrating the repentant before the feet of the Saviour, and maintaining that humble position of worship. In acknowledging its sinfulness and the boundless grandeur of God, the soul moves into perfection, guided into wholeness by the hand of the all-good God, who both formed humanity and renews it. “Bless the Lord, O my soul, and forget not all His benefits, who forgives all your iniquities, who heals all your diseases, who redeems your life from destruction, who crowns you with lovingkindness and tender mercies. Your youth is renewed like the eagle's” (Psalm 102:2-5) through the omnipotence of the Saviour, who transforms our nature within Himself and revitalizes us by His presence. Amen.

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

Mary selected the better choice. The Assumption of the Mother of God symbolizes the positive culmination of this choice. The Saviour Himself received Her soul at Her passing. Numerous saints have also experienced similar grace; all those who choose the good path encounter it in various forms and measures. In the moment of decision, this destination is only perceived through hope and somewhat anticipated; yet after that, labors, trials, and self-discipline follow sequentially, often obscuring the chosen journey. The guiding principle remains the favorable conclusion of the good choice. It is akin to a radiant beacon for a traveler lost in darkness. Faith acts as the source of strength and the sustainer of patience and perseverance in the journey embarked upon, fortified by trust. Through faith, they are designated, through trust, they stand firm in their selection, and through endurance, they attain a favorable conclusion.

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryCommentator

With a tone of sincere compassion, Christ addressed the worried Martha, saying, “Martha! Martha, you are troubled and anxious about many things, believing they are essential; yet you are mistaken: your worries and efforts are focused on matters that are unnecessary and fleeting distractions. There is but one thing that is truly needed: to pay attention to the Word of God and to fulfill His purpose. Mary, whom you criticize, has chosen the better path, and what she gains from listening to me will never be taken from her, remaining with her in this life and the next. Martha cherished Jesus as much as Mary did; she loved to hear Him and was obedient to His foremost teachings. However, she felt the need to prioritize worldly matters before turning her attention to the Word of God.

Read more (94 words)

In her preoccupations and distractions, she overlooked what Christ had proclaimed previously: “But seek first the Kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added to you” (Matthew 6:33). Jesus frequently visited the home of Lazarus, Martha, and Mary; during His travels to and from Jerusalem to Galilee, He would stop there. While in Jerusalem, He often sought respite from the bustling crowds by retreating to their home. This close relationship of Jesus with the family indicates that all its members, including Martha, were virtuous individuals deserving of His love.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryCommentator

Blessed is the one who listens to God's word and practices it (Lk. 11:28), and this is precisely what Mary is engaged in at this moment; this is the singular necessity, while everything else holds little significance (cf. Mt. 6:33, 1 Tim. 4:8). - "The good portion she has chosen" is far better than what Martha has to offer - to absorb the message of the Kingdom of God, to dedicate more time to the Lord than to the routine matters of life, even those well-intentioned and admirable. - "Which shall not be taken away from her" indicates a lasting possession, as what is gained through this means is not fleeting but everlasting.

Read more (164 words)

Martha's concerns, though good, provide only temporary satisfaction and comfort for the physical need of nourishment; these will quickly fade after offering momentary relief to the body. In contrast, Mary’s actions yield a spiritual benefit that is eternal and cannot be removed from her. Thus, the Lord skillfully uses every earthly situation to convey profound truths of His teachings. "The generosity of hospitality that Martha exhibited is indeed valuable and should not be disregarded; yet, the advantage of engaging in spiritual dialogues is even greater. For through these discussions, the body is supported, and the soul finds vitality.... He had no words of admonition for Martha until she attempted to divert her sister from listening, prompting the Lord to address her. Hospitality is commendable as long as it does not divert our attention from what is truly essential; however, when it becomes an obstacle in pursuing divine matters, we must choose it over the pursuit of spiritual truths" (Theophilus, cf. Vas. V. 5, 379-381).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 14 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. ἑνός
    henos
    one
    G1520 · εἷς
  2. δέ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. ἐστιν
    estin
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  4. χρεία
    chreia
    need
    G5532 · χρεία
  5. Μαριὰμ
    mariam
    Mary
    G3137 · Μαρία
  6. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  7. τὴν
    tēn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  8. ἀγαθὴν
    agathēn
    good
    G18 · ἀγαθός
  9. μερίδα
    merida
    a part
    G3310 · μερίς
  10. ἐξελέξατο
    exelexato
    I choose
    G1586 · ἐκλέγω
  11. ἥτις
    hētis
    whosoever
    G3748 · ὅστις, ἥτις
  12. οὐκ
    ouk
    no
    G3756 · οὐ
  13. ἀφαιρεθήσεται
    aphairethēsetai
    I take away
    G851 · ἀφαιρέω
  14. αὐτῆς
    autēs
    he
    G846 · αὐτός