The Church Fathers on this verse

Luke 7:33Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

For John the Baptist came neither eating bread nor drinking wine. And you say: He hath a devil.

Douay-Rheims

εληλυθεν γαρ ιωαννης ο βαπτιστης μητε αρτον εσθιων μητε οινον πινων και λεγετε δαιμονιον εχει

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

9 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 10 commentaries

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Consider the parallel verses found in Matthew 11:18-19.

*****

However, you may wonder if it is reasonable for opposites to coexist. Are you not aware that the actions of eating versus abstaining, drinking versus refraining, giving versus withholding are fundamentally opposing? Yet, a physician often employs both actions simultaneously, not contradicting his own principles, but rather aligning with a singular focus: the well-being of the patient. Similarly, the evangelists operated with this understanding. While summer is indeed the antithesis of winter, both seasons serve a common goal—the nurturing and maturation of fruit. The world itself consists of contrasting elements, yet there is an overarching design that benefits our existence.

Read more (83 words)

Christ took a different path than John the Baptist; He indulged while the latter refrained. As He stated, “John the Baptist is come, neither eateth bread, neither drinketh wine: and ye say, There is a demon in him. The Son of man came: he eats and drinks; and you say, Behold a man that loveth to eat and drink wine, a friend of publicans and sinners.” Though their behaviors appeared divergent, they shared the same aim: the redemption of those ensnared in sin.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Neither did they grieve and follow John, who lived a life of sorrow and called for repentance, nor did they heed and align themselves with Jesus, who demonstrated a joyful life. Instead, they distanced themselves from both, displaying no compassion toward John in his mourning or toward Jesus in his joyous approach.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Christ observes that the Jewish people and their leaders remain in a similar predicament as they do now: ‘For John came, saith he, neither to eat bread nor to drink wine, and they say, he hath a devil; the Son of man came to eat and to drink, and they say, Behold a gluttonous man and a wine drinker, a friend of publicans and sinners.’ By what evidence will you affirm your faith, O misguided Pharisee, if you dismiss all with equal disdain and recognize nothing as worthy of commendation? The blessed John the Baptist was the herald of the Savior, proclaiming, ‘Repent, for the kingdom of God is at hand.’ He was a figure who inspired trust and persuasion, as even from among you the acknowledgment arose that his life was noble and virtuous.

Read more (323 words)

He led a life in the wilderness, garbed in simple, coarse attire, struggling to satisfy his physical needs with locusts and wild honey. Yet you approached him as a saint who exemplified the fullness of virtue. How could you dare to speak ill of such an esteemed individual? Should he not be held in the highest regard? Do you truly claim that he is possessed, he who, through fasting, overcomes the law of sin that lies within our flesh, contending against the law of our reason? What could be more commendable than a life of abstinence? The mere capacity to wisely criticize the indulgences that lead to wrongdoing, and to restrain them through diligent temperance, reflects greatness and excellence! The blessed John the Baptist was wholly devoted to the reverence of Christ, entirely disinterested in the desires of the flesh or the allurements of this world. Thus, having completely renounced the fleeting vanities and trivial amusements of life, he focused solely on fulfilling the pivotal ministry bestowed upon him. For he was charged with proclaiming, ‘Prepare the way of the Lord.’ Tell me, do you genuinely believe this man is possessed? — One who remained untouched by Satan’s tyranny; who was not enslaved by sinful passions; who triumphed over the temptations of base desires; who commanded the forces of evil to silence and bravely resisted their advances. He could not have attained such glory and virtue except through Christ, who reigns supreme over Satan, who tempts and desires to undermine the well-being of the saints. Are you not ashamed to defame him who has achieved such remarkable patience and strength, adorned with the crowns of noble virtue? Did you even dare to use your tongue against him, to slander him in such a despicable manner, and claim he is insane, contemptible, and out of his senses? Let us consider what lies on the other side and what may arise from the Baptist's conduct.

Alas for those who proclaim wickedness as righteousness and righteousness as wickedness, who equate darkness with light and light with darkness, who declare bitter things as sweet and sweet things as bitter! (Isa 5:20). This was true of the Israelites, particularly those in leadership, such as the scribes and the Pharisees. Jesus questioned, "To what shall I liken the people of this age?" (Luke 7:31).

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Let us refrain from emulating those who observed John abstaining from food and drink, declaring that he was possessed (Mt 11:18, Lk 7:33). Likewise, we should not mirror those who, upon finding Christ feasting and drinking, remarked, "Look at this man, indulging in food and wine, a companion to tax collectors and sinners" (Lk 7:34). In response to such judgments, our Lord offers a crucial insight, stating, "And wisdom is justified by her children" (Mt 11:19).

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

And the prophets danced, affirming that Wisdom is vindicated by all her offspring (Lk 7:35). Indeed, it is evident amongst all, since righteousness prevails universally. In embracing the faithful, there is an inevitable exclusion of the unfaithful. Hence, many Greeks recognize that ‘Wisdom is justified by all her works,’ for it is the role of justice to assess the merit of each individual. Thus, it is rightly said: we played for you, and you did not dance (Luke 7:32). Moses sang when the deep waters of the Red Sea froze in preparation for the passage of the Israelites, while the protective wall remained intact and ultimately drowned the Egyptian horses and their riders.

Read more (108 words)

Isaiah composed a song for His cherished vineyard, foreshadowing a future disobedient nation that had once flourished with great virtues. The Jewish people sang when their steps were invigorated by the holy fire, which enveloped them both internally and externally, yet the purifying flame caused them to flourish rather than to burn. Additionally, the wise prophet Habakkuk, in a song that lifted the general gloom, foretold the suffering of the Lord, which would be sweet to the faithful. In this way, the prophets expressed spiritual hymns to proclaim the prophecies of comprehensive salvation. Through tearful prophets, softened by heartfelt weeping, the hardened hearts of the Jews were moved.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

To whom shall I liken… In the twentieth chapter referenced earlier, you will discover all of this elaborately.

Notes: This verse is introduced in some translations with phrases like "Then the Lord said" or "But the Lord spoke." Certain manuscripts, however, do not include these words, suggesting they may have been added later due to a misunderstanding of verses 29-30, which are often interpreted as comments from the Evangelist rather than the words of Christ. This is consistent across nearly all manuscripts, as well as in the Greek text of the Gospel, the ancient translations, and St. Alexius of Moscow's version. Matthew 11:16-19.

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryCommentator

What peculiar individuals! To what can I compare them? They resemble disobedient children who, when joining their peers, remain dissatisfied with any song, whether joyful or sorrowful. The Pharisees refused to approach John, branding him as demon-possessed and using his ascetic life as evidence. Similarly, they rejected the Son of Man, labeling him a glutton and a drunkard, associating him with tax collectors and sinners. However, the children of wisdom, as the Savior noted, validated God's wisdom through their actions. They embraced both the severity of John in his call for repentance and the merciful grace of the Son of Man in facilitating reconciliation with God.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryCommentator

We can envision the remarkable scene of John's sermon to the vast crowds that gathered around him, an event that left a lasting impression in the collective memory. In later times, Christ Jesus posed the question, “What did you go out to see in the wilderness—a man dressed in soft garments?” Individuals from all walks of life came in droves to hear this new prophet. Initially a local phenomenon, the movement quickly expanded throughout the region (Matthew 3:5). People first came from the vicinity of Jerusalem, Judea, and Perea. However, word soon reached the Galileans, those dwelling in the foothills of Lebanon, and the eastern territories of Jordan, prompting even more to journey to John.

Read more (768 words)

Large caravans made their way along the roads of Galilee and Judea, all drawn to the same focal point. Laborers set aside their work for this purpose, and the throng included merchants, Roman tax collectors, as well as soldiers both local and foreign. In this assembly were the noble and the lowly, the devout and the worldly, the just and the unscrupulous, the earnest and the hypocritical, supporters of Rome and its adversaries, all seeking spiritual insight. This crowd featured proud rabbis, long-sleeved Pharisees, composed Sadducees, dignified priests, and humble Levites, alongside elders of the community, wealthy landowners, struggling settlers, soldiers of Antipas, and likely proselytes from the Roman garrison in Jerusalem, who preferred baptism in the Jordan to circumcision. Tax collectors, despised for their collaboration with Rome and their unjust practices, were also present. Numerous Jewish women attended as well, including many ensnared by vice (Matthew 3:7, Matthew 21:32, Luke 3:10ff., John 1:19ff.). Everyone was eager to partake in the redemption of Israel or at the very least to outwardly manifest their longing for it—even those groups whom the meticulous Pharisees and Essenes deemed unclean. Many sought genuine spiritual renewal through John’s teaching, although some attended merely out of curiosity, to critique, to gossip, or to report their observations to the authorities. What they encountered was nothing short of astonishing, particularly as it marked the first emergence of a prophet in 500 years. Captivated by what they witnessed, the crowds listened intently to John's messages, accepted his baptism, and their faith in the imminent kingdom of heaven, as proclaimed by this new prophet, began to ignite, along with their belief in the Messiah whose arrival he heralded. By the rite he established, he became known as the Baptist, though many referred to him as a teacher and prophet (Luke 3:12, Matthew 11:9, Matthew 21:26). Although he did not perform miraculous wonders, his words and baptism carried profound power, leading people to continue believing in his prophetic role and the heavenly nature of his baptism even after his imprisonment and eventual death, in spite of the malicious derision from the Pharisees and Sadducees (Matthew 21:25). Wondering at what they observed and heard, many even questioned whether he might be the Messiah or at least a prophet like Moses, whom they anticipated (Luke 3:15, John 1:19). His teachings resonated deeply with the people, granting him an influence that could have been utilized for political gain had he chosen that path. However, his purpose was not political fervor but rather a moral and spiritual revival. Therefore, he confined himself to the role of moral and religious teacher or prophet. His words struck like a hammer, breaking the hardest hearts and burning like fire, penetrating deep into the thoughts of those who listened. He was not satisfied with general admonitions but addressed the crowd with prophetic boldness. To the Pharisees and Sadducees gathering to hear him more for scrutiny than for repentance, he exclaimed, “You brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the coming wrath?” According to the Evangelist, “the Pharisees and the experts in the law rejected God’s purpose for themselves, because they had not been baptized by John” (Luke 7:30), thus denying his role as a messenger and even labeling him as demon-possessed (Luke 7:33). He laid bare the emptiness and futility of their trivial ceremonial disputes and legalistic reasoning, for which they despised him in return. Yet John derived his authority not from them but from above, and rather than flatter them, he addressed them with the same prophetic clarity directed at the multitude they looked down upon, calling for them to “produce fruit in keeping with repentance.” In their narrow-minded arrogance, they believed that their lineage from Abraham alone secured them a place in the kingdom of the Messiah, thinking his righteousness would automatically cover them. They viewed the kingdom of heaven as an exclusive domain for Jews, with all other nations shut out. However, John boldly dismantled this erroneous viewpoint: “Do not think you can say to yourselves, ‘We have Abraham as our father,’ for I tell you that out of these stones God can raise up children for Abraham,” reminding them that they would be excluded from the kingdom unless they repented. Such a message surely struck a chord with the scribes and Pharisees, who enjoyed widespread respect. They had anticipated him to be a weak figure, yet he stood firm like an oak tree. Neither flattery nor fear had any place in his noble spirit, just as his coarse garment would have appeared out of place among the fine robes of royalty.

Paul Matwejewski

19th centuryCommentator

Despite their obstinacy, these unruly individuals did not respond favorably to the preaching of Jesus Christ. Therefore, to clarify their lack of faith caused by their thoughtlessness and rebellion, He utilized a familiar analogy from daily life to illustrate their unbelief. They are akin to 'foolish and willful children, who will not be pleased, even if you cry to them or play the flute' (Bl. Theophylact): to what can I compare this generation?

Read more (138 words)

It resembles children sitting in the marketplaces, calling out to their companions, saying, ‘We played the flute for you, and you did not dance; we sang a lament, and you did not mourn.’ The Lord Himself elucidated the significance of this poignant saying: John came neither eating nor drinking, abstaining from certain foods and wine, living as a strict ascetic and Nazarene, yet they accused him of having a demon; the Son of Man, however, came eating and drinking, sharing meals and wine, associating with others, and they declared, ‘Behold, a glutton and a drunkard, a friend of tax collectors and sinners.’ The wisdom of God, in various ways, vindicated itself through its children—simple, believing souls who embraced John's stern call to repentance and the Lord’s comforting message of the advent of His gracious kingdom for their salvation.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 15 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ἐλήλυθεν
    elēlythen
    I come
    G2064 · ἔρχομαι
  2. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  3. Ἰωάννης
    iōannēs
    John
    G2491 · Ἰωάννης
  4. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  5. Βαπτιστὴς
    baptistēs
    the baptizer
    G910 · Βαπτιστής
  6. μὴ
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  7. ἐσθίων
    esthiōn
    I eat
    G2068 · ἐσθίω
  8. ἄρτον
    arton
    bread
    G740 · ἄρτος
  9. μήτε
    mēte
    nor
    G3383 · μήτε
  10. πίνων
    pinōn
    I drink
    G4095 · πίνω
  11. οἶνον
    oinon
    wine
    G3631 · οἶνος
  12. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  13. λέγετε
    legete
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  14. Δαιμόνιον
    daimonion
    an evil-spirit
    G1140 · δαιμόνιον
  15. ἔχει
    echei
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω