Some scholars suggest that this Simon and the Simon the Pharisee mentioned by Luke (Luke 7:36) are the same individual. However, Simon the Pharisee was opposed to Jesus, showed Him no basic courtesy, did not instruct Him to wash His feet, and failed to greet Him with a kiss; he resided in Galilee, while Simon the leper was favorable towards Jesus and lived in Judea, specifically in Bethany. Hence, they must be different individuals.
The Jewish leaders were aware that even if the populace did not see Jesus as the Messiah, they regarded Him as a remarkable prophet and an extraordinary miracle worker. It would be exceedingly foolish and perilous to apprehend and eliminate Him at this moment, especially with Jerusalem bustling with people in town for the Passover, as they might advocate for Him. If His disciples stirred the crowd even slightly, their support could erupt into a disturbance that the Roman authorities would swiftly suppress, leading to the chaos that the Sanhedrin feared. This was the logic guiding the chief priests, who resolved to seize Jesus through treachery and eliminate Him, but only after the Passover celebrations concluded, allowing the crowds to disperse.
As they dined, with everyone reclining at the table, a woman entered bearing an alabaster jar filled with precious nard (regarding the nard and alabaster, refer to Luke 7:37-50). The Gospel writers do not disclose the woman’s identity. Historically, three women have been noted for anointing Jesus at distinct moments: one was in Simon the Pharisee's house, traditionally believed to be Mary Magdalene; another was Mary, Lazarus's sister; and the third was in Simon the leper's home. Church fathers such as John Chrysostom and Augustine speculate that the same woman may have anointed Jesus on two occasions: once at Simon the Pharisee’s and once at Simon the leper’s. This assumption may indeed hold merit, suggesting that the woman who appeared in Simon the leper's home was likely Mary Magdalene. The Gospel writers Matthew and Mark do not mention her name, possibly for the same reasons Luke refrained from naming the sinful woman who entered Simon the Pharisee’s home (see Luke 7:37-50).