The Church Fathers on this verse

Numbers 20:10Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And having gathered together the multitude before the rock, he said to them: Hear, ye rebellious and incredulous: Can we bring you forth water out of this rock?

Douay-Rheims

וַיַּקְהִ֜לוּ מֹשֶׁ֧ה וְאַהֲרֹ֛ן אֶת־הַקָּהָ֖ל אֶל־פְּנֵ֣י הַסָּ֑לַע וַיֹּ֣אמֶר לָהֶ֗ם שִׁמְעוּ־נָא֙ הַמֹּרִ֔ים הֲמִן־הַסֶּ֣לַע הַזֶּ֔ה נוֹצִ֥יא לָכֶ֖ם מָֽיִם׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Although Moses should have displayed courage in response to such words, he exhibited a lack of fortitude when he stated: “Hearken, ye disobedient, shall we draw water for you out of this rock?” It is essential, then, to understand how the water was provided. When the elders of the community gathered together and Aaron stood before them, words were directed at the rock, and Moses struck it twice. This mirrors the time when the elders and the priests came together, during which the children of the law, representing the Israelites, began to speak ill of Christ, bringing charges against Him before Pilate, and shouted maliciously: “take, take, crucify Him!” (John 19:15).

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

Upon observing that he engaged in disputes at the water not over anything else, but solely regarding the matter of addressing the people who were complaining about the absence of water, asking, "Shall we bring forth water for you from this rock?" I recognize that he prays yet does not receive absolution. Furthermore, I see that despite his righteous deeds, he is not granted even a minimal acknowledgment for this brief statement. This leads me to truly perceive, as the Apostle indicates, the sternness of God (Rom. 11:22). I am indeed convinced of the validity of the assertion: "And if the righteous is scarcely saved, where will the ungodly and sinner appear?" (1 Pet. 4:18).

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Due to Moses failing to honor the Lord and demonstrate His might on the rock, he criticized the people; furthermore, he faced criticism for striking the rock two times, which went against earlier instances when water had already been provided.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

And they provoked Him at the waters with their disputes, which distressed Moses deeply. His spirit was troubled, and his words were conflicted. It is said that the Israelites offended God in the wilderness of Kadesh. The people were irritable, grumbling, and arguing, leading to the water from the rock being referred to as the waters of strife. Moses endured hardship because of the people, as God instructed him to take his staff, gather the congregation, and command the rock to yield water. Instead of following God’s command, he addressed the people in frustration and carelessness, asking, "Listen, you rebellious ones! Should I bring water from this rock for you?" In response, he struck the rock twice with his staff, resulting in a significant flow of water.

Read more (466 words)

Due to failing to honor God's command and for speaking to the people in anger, he faced consequences from God, who said to Aaron and Moses, "Because you did not believe in me, to sanctify me before the children of Israel, you shall not bring this congregation into the land I have given them." The reason behind Moses’ words stemmed from the Israelites having previously troubled him with their complaints and harsh words, which led him to neglect the divine instruction he received. The term "divided in his mouth" indicates that Moses spoke with uncertainty, doubting whether the water would truly emanate from the rock; he perhaps believed that the rock might not yield water because the people had repeatedly shown ingratitude towards God, who had blessed them greatly. Moses lamented his situation, telling the Israelites that God was angry with him because of their behavior and swore that he would not cross the Jordan or enter the land promised to them (Deuteronomy 4:21). He further noted, "And the Lord despised me because of you, and did not listen to me, and the Lord said, 'Enough! You shall not speak of this to me any further'" (Deuteronomy 3:26). This serves as a warning: if even the lawgiver was punished for his transgression, imagine the suffering that awaits those who persist in wrongdoing. It is evident that someone who commits a great sin in secret will face lesser punishment than someone who sins openly and leads others astray. The great Basil, in astonishment, remarks that Moses, despite being a great servant of God, was barred from the promised land simply for asking the murmuring people if he should draw water from the rock. This punishment for such a singular act prompts one to understand the severity of God’s judgment; the Apostle illustrates this: "If the righteous is scarcely saved, where will the ungodly and the sinner appear?" (1 Peter 4:18). The Creator, though He seemingly punished Moses by not allowing him to enter the holy land, orchestrated this for Moses’ ultimate good; He recognized the folly of the Jews and withheld the full promise to prevent them from viewing Moses as divine. For this reason, God concealed Moses' burial place. Additionally, this act was meant to highlight the temporary nature of the law. In a deeper sense, Cyril interprets Moses as representative of the law, Aaron as the priesthood, and Miriam as the figure who serves the divine law. Thus, neither the law, nor a lesser priesthood, nor symbolic worship can lead us into the realm of the holy or the truest promise. We cannot please God through sacrificial blood; instead, we are summoned to inherit the eternal city and the legacy of our ancestors under the leadership of Christ, much like the Israelites under Joshua’s guidance.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.