The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 109 (108):16Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

because he remembered not to shew mercy,

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

יַ֗עַן אֲשֶׁ֤ר ׀ לֹ֥א זָכַר֮ עֲשׂ֢וֹת חָ֥סֶד וַיִּרְדֹּ֡ף אִישׁ־עָנִ֣י וְ֭אֶבְיוֹן וְנִכְאֵ֨ה לֵבָ֬ב לְמוֹתֵֽת׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

8 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

After discussing Judas—his condemnation, the death sentence he imposed on himself, his execution, and the transfer of his apostleship to another—the focus shifts back to the initial topic. This reflects a common trait of prophecy, where the narrative may pause to incorporate another event before returning to the original theme. This prophecy remained concealed due to the ungratefulness of the Jewish people. It specifically alludes to a certain individual who spoke ill of the priesthood following the Jews' restoration from Babylonian exile, a detail that those well-versed in history are likely to recognize. The Psalmist foretells severe misfortunes for this person, asking that all avenues of refuge be closed to him, and that no forbearance, compassion, or forgiveness be extended his way.

Read more (134 words)

While this may seem like a curse, it serves as a prophecy highlighting the anger of God towards those who slander the priesthood. The Psalmist goes on to elaborate on the afflictions, stating, "because he did not think to show mercy, and persecuted a man poor, and destitute, and broken-hearted, to put (him) to death." Such behavior exemplifies extreme cruelty and tremendous inhumanity, especially when one not only maligns but attacks someone who is capable of mercy and compassion. Individuals who engage in this are demonstrating a brutal savagery that descends even below that of wild beasts. While beasts may exhibit a certain kindness and gentleness towards members of their own kind, these men are unashamed, having rejected not only their duty to support and uplift but also the very bond of shared humanity.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Anyone who diligently studies the Acts of the Apostles can discern that this Psalm holds a prophecy regarding Christ. It is clear that the phrase, “let his days be short, and let another take his office,” refers to Judas, the one who betrayed Christ. While Peter had a significant standing among the disciples, the context here is somewhat ambiguous unless it pertains to the Church, which he symbolically represented due to his leadership role. As it is written, “I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven” (Matthew 16:19, among other similar passages). Conversely, Judas symbolizes those Jewish adversaries of Christ who despised Him during His time and continue to embody this enmity through their descendants. This allows us to comprehend not only the explicit intentions reflected in this Psalm but also the more straightforward truths about Judas himself.

The Psalm opens with a plea: “O God, be not silent to my praise; for the mouth of the wicked, yea, the mouth of the wicked, is opened against me” (Psalm 107:1). From this, it follows that the reproach from deceitful individuals is baseless, and the praise granted by God is genuine. God is indeed truthful, while every man is a liar (Romans 3:4). Only those in whom God speaks can be considered truly honest. The utmost praise belongs to the only begotten Son of God, who is revealed as exactly that. This truth was obscured until His weakness became apparent, hidden when the deceitful spoke against Him. Thus, His mouth was opened as a result of the concealed nature of His virtue; and the deceitful voices arose from a hatred disguised by pretense.

“They have spoken against me with lying tongues” (Psalms 108:2) chiefly reflects their flattery, which they used when they falsely praised Him as a good Teacher. It is said in another verse, “And they that praise me together swear against me.” This deceitful praise culminated in their shouts of “Crucify Him, crucify Him” (John 19:6), as they surrounded Him with words of animosity. Those who cunningly spoke words of feigned affection instead of true hatred encircled Him with open hostility, waging a groundless battle against Him. Just as the righteous love Christ unreservedly, so too do the wicked hate Him freely; for while the finest individuals seek truth solely for its own sake, the most wretched aggressively pursue what is evil. Thus, secular authors describe a truly vile man as being wicked and cruel without cause.

Instead of expressing love, he says, “stole from me” (Psalm 107:3). There are six discernible actions that are easy to remember: (1) responding with good to evil, (2) refraining from reciprocating evil with evil, (3) returning good for good, (4) reciprocating evil with evil, (5) failing to respond to good with good, and (6) returning evil for good. The first two belong to the righteous, with the first being the more commendable; the last two belong to the wicked, with the last being the most reprehensible; the middle two are attributed to intermediates, though the first leans toward the good while the second leans toward the bad. This principle is evident in Scripture. Our Lord exemplified this by returning good for evil, justifying the ungodly (Romans 4:5), and even while being crucified, He prayed, “Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do” (Luke 23:34).

But after stating, “Instead of loving me, they belittled me,” what does He add? “But I gave myself to prayer.” He does not specify what He prayed for, but it can be inferred to refer to those who belittled Him. They mocked the One they crucified as though they had defeated Him, yet from the Cross, He proclaimed, “Father, forgive them; for they know not what they do.” While they returned evil for good from a place of deep malice, He, from His supreme goodness, returned good for evil. The divine words teach us through the example of our Lord that when we feel unappreciated by others—not just in terms of receiving no good in return but also facing evil in response to good—we ought to pray. Indeed, He stands with those who rebel against Him, whether in sorrow or in trials of faith. However, we must focus first on ourselves, seeking by the grace and aid of God to triumph over our own inclinations to seek vengeance when we feel wronged.

He continues, “Thus have I been repaid evil for good” (Psalm 107:4). When we inquire about what constitutes this evil, it is rooted in hatred towards my goodwill. This encapsulates their grave offense. How could they harm Him who willingly laid down His life? The animosity itself represents the most significant wrongdoing of the persecutors, even though it is the voluntary suffering of the victim. The preceding phrases, “Instead of love to me,” encompass a duty of love they ought to have fulfilled in return for His affection. This love is referenced in the Gospel, where He lamented, “How often have I gathered your children together, and you would not!” (Matthew 23:37).

Next, He begins to foretell the punishment they will receive for their profound wickedness, describing their fate as though he relished the thought of retribution. Some, misunderstanding this prophetic style, assume that malice engenders malice, and evil results from evil will; yet, in reality, it is rare for someone to comprehend how the wicked’s punishment serves the accuser, who longs for vengeance, contrasting with how the judge, possessing a righteous spirit, punishes sin. The former takes revenge by returning evil for evil, whereas the judge, in dispensing justice, does not reciprocate evil because he administers equitable retribution to the unrighteous; such justice is inherently good. Hence, the judge punishes not out of joy for another’s misfortune but out of a love for what is just, which turns evil into good.

“Set the wicked ruler over him; and let Satan be at his right hand” (Psalm 108:5). While the previous text spoke of many adversaries, now the Psalm focuses on one individual. Here, it refers to the traitor Judas, who, as noted in the Acts of the Apostles, was destined to receive appropriate punishment (Acts 1:20)—indicating that a wicked man should govern him, in addition to the one referenced in the following verse with the mention of Satan at his side. Thus, one who refused to submit to Christ warranted being subjected to the devil, becoming his servant. This extends to those who, choosing the fleeting pleasures of this world over God, recognized as blessed those who possess worldly gain, sealing their fate as subjects of iniquity.

“When he is judged, let him be condemned, and let his prayer be turned into sin” (Psalm 107:6). Prayer can only be considered righteous through Christ, who was sold in his grievous sin. A petition offered outside of Christ neither absolves sin nor transforms into righteousness but becomes itself sin. One might wonder how Judas could pray in such a manner that his prayers were counted as sinful. It seems likely that before betraying the Lord, as he contemplated the betrayal, he could no longer offer prayers through Christ. After the betrayal, if he had prayed through Christ, he would have sought forgiveness; if he had genuinely sought forgiveness, he would have embraced hope; with hope, he would have awaited mercy; and in seeking mercy, he would not have succumbed to despair by taking his own life.

“Let his days be short” (Psalm 108:7). By “days,” he refers to the brief duration of Judas's apostleship, which concluded with his treachery and demise before the Passion of our Lord. One might question the fate of the sacred count of twelve, which the Lord intentionally established for His first apostles. The response follows: “Let another take his office,” meaning let him receive punishment befitting his actions, while allowing the count of apostles to increase.

“Let his children be orphans, and his wife a widow” (Psalm 108:8). Following his death, both his offspring were left without a father, and his spouse bereaved. “Let his children be wanderers, and be driven away, and ask for their bread” (Psalm 107:9) indicates those who are lost, devoid of guidance. He elaborates on this, stating, “Let them be driven from their dwellings,” elucidating the prior claim that they should be “carried away.” The ensuing verses reveal how this fate befell his family.

“Let the extortioner search all his possessions, and let strangers spoil his labor” (Psalm 108:10). “Let there be no one to help him” (Psalm 107:11)—indicating that there would be no one to protect his children, thus they would receive no pity. Even if orphans grapple with hardship and scarcity without a guardian, he pronounces, “Let his posterity be destroyed; let the next generation let his name be removed” (Psalm 108:12)—indicating that what he fathered would cease to bear fruit and quickly vanish.

Then he adds, “Let the wickedness of his fathers be remembered before the eyes of the Lord, and let the sin of his mother not be blotted out” (Psalm 108:13). Should this imply that even the sins of his ancestors will be held against him? Those transformed in Christ are not judged for their ancestry but must also refrain from imitating their deeds (Ezekiel 18:4, 20). The directive, “I will punish the sins of the fathers upon the children” (Exodus 20:5), pertains only to those who hate Me; that is, they mirror their fathers’ hatred toward God. Thus, as the act of emulating goodness obliterates even one’s own transgressions, the imitation of evil inflicts suffering not just for one’s own actions but also for the actions of others.

“Let them always be against the Lord” (Psalm 108:14). “Against the Lord” indicates in the presence of the Lord; this line has alternative interpretations as “Let them always be in the sight of the Lord” or “Let them always be before the Lord.” This signifies that such significant transgressions remain unforgiven, both now and in what is to come. “Let the memory of them,” referring to his mother and father, “vanish from the earth” reflects the idea that such remnants will disappear from history. Judging by his prophecy, his descendants, serving as reminders of his lineage, faced destruction within a single generation.

This fate resonates because “he remembered not to show mercy” (Psalm 108:15)—whether of Judah or the people as a whole. However, “remembered not” seems to pertain more to the people; if they had slain Christ, they might have recalled their actions in repentance and shown mercy to those members of His body whom they relentlessly pursued. Thus, it states, “And they persecuted the poor and the needy” (Psalm 108:16). This could also refer to Judas, for Christ, rich in His glory, embraced poverty to enrich us through His sacrifice (2 Corinthians 8:9). How else can we interpret the term “beggar,” other than Christ’s appeal to the Samaritan woman, “Give Me a drink” (John 4:7), and His exclamation on the Cross about His thirst (John 19:28)? It is challenging not to see the Savior of His body, who Judas persecuted, in the mention of the “poor man and the beggar.” When it states, “to kill,” it signifies the intent to destroy Him, which reflects Judas’ treachery, often associated with the remorse of past sins and the sorrow of repentance, echoing the remorse of those who confronted the Apostles after witnessing Christ’s ascension.

Read the full text in the app

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

For I will not remember to show compassion. He was reluctant, he states, to embrace the mercy that the Father extended to all humanity, not merely to the lost sheep of Israel. The term 'create' is used in place of 'accept.' The one who is destitute and wretched comprehends the Lord Himself, who, though He was rich, chose to become poor so that through His poverty we might experience abundance. And with a heart moved towards reconciliation, He is grieved, that is, He mourns. For He felt sorrow at witnessing their downfall. For He was saddened to observe their destruction.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Observe the humility of the Lord. He perceives Him walking alongside His followers, notices their weapons, and greets Him with a kiss. Though He approaches to betray, the Lord offers the kiss, so that he who lacks reverence for the Master may be struck by His graciousness. "And he persecutes the poor and the wretched." "Who, being rich, for our sakes became poor" (2 Cor. 8:9). The Lord identifies Himself as poor and afflicted. And who takes pride in their wealth! Take heart, you who are destitute: the Lord was among you. "And the broken-hearted to put him to death." What do these words signify? They bear the same meaning as expressed in the Gospel: "My soul is sorrowful even unto death" (Matt. 26:38). Then, when He says, "Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass me by" (Matt. 26:39).

Read more (48 words)

Or: it grieved Me, and I grieved My oppressors, for they would not repent. I was nailed to the cross and cleansed their impurities with My blood, yet they refused to change their ways. Thus I wept and felt anguish because I was unable to rescue my persecutors.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

They will face this consequence, as declared by the prophet, because of their heinous and brutal acts of murder, and for their relentless persecution of Him who approached them with utmost humility and gentleness. Both the Apostle and the Lord affirm these truths. The Apostle proclaims that He who was affluent became poor for our sake, so that we might find richness through His impoverishment (2 Cor. 8:9); and he further asserts that He, who is the likeness of God, did not seek to grasp equality with God, but rather humbled Himself by taking on the nature of a servant (Phil. 2:6-7). The Lord also teaches us in one passage: Learn from Me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will discover rest for your souls (Matt. 11:29); and in another, He remarks: Foxes have their dens, and birds of the air have nests; but the Son of Man has nowhere to lay His head (Matt. 8:20).

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

Judas will endure all of the aforementioned suffering because he not only refused to show mercy to Christ, who faced unjust accusations from the Jewish authorities, but also assisted those accusers. He failed to recall the blessings he had received from Christ, blessings that could have led him to extend mercy and compassion in return. Instead, he persecuted the Lord by leading a large crowd armed with swords and clubs from the chief priests and elders to capture Him. Jesus lived in poverty and distress, lacking even a place to lay His head.

Read more (288 words)

Refer to the insights in Psalms 40:2, which state: “Blessed is he that knoweth the poor and the needy,” illustrating that the ancients referred to a beggar as one who had lost wealth, and a poor man as one striving through labor to secure the essentials of life. Christ exemplified humility of heart, as reflected in His words, “Learn from Me, for I am meek and lowly in heart” (Matthew 11:28). As noted by Athanasius, the Lord experienced profound sorrow for the fate of the Jews and the tribe of Judah; witnessing their ruin brought Him grief, and He led a humble existence among humanity. Furthermore, the Lord affirmed, “who being rich, became poor for you; that ye might be enriched by His poverty.” Isychias suggests that Judas neglected to show grace to himself, as he did not turn to repentance to receive mercy. How could one who lacked mercy for himself hope to be forgiven by the Lord? The Lord was indeed in a state of poverty and neediness, for although He was rich, He embraced poverty for our sake, reaching such depths that He stated, “Foxes have holes, and birds of the air have nests; but the Son of man hath not where to lay His head,” revealing the depths of His destitution. Yet for us, He was also filled with compassion, for He expressed, “My soul is sorrowful to death.” Eusebius notes that Judas was responsible for His death, labeling Him as guilty of this act. Theodoret comments that those who rushed in a savage and brutal manner towards such a horrific murder would face death, and the one who exhibited all virtues of modesty and meekness was cruelly persecuted to the point of death.

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

In these words, David reveals that his desire for the fierce punishment of his adversaries is well-founded. Their brutality was not diminished, for they pursued the afflicted man with a savagery that resembled that of wild beasts. Even those regarded as wise by worldly standards recognize that it is lowly and despicable individuals who unleash their rage upon the defenseless, as true envy arises only among equals. Thus, the Prophet heightens the wickedness of his foes by stating, “They have driven out the poor and the wretched.” The subsequent phrase is even more striking: she was filled with joy in her heart. There exist individuals who take pride in their own poverty, and the more egregious their behavior, the more they provoke the wrath of the strong.

Read more (89 words)

Conversely, when a humble heart is present, any attack upon it signifies extreme cruelty. Engaging with such a humble soul is akin to battling a mere shadow. The severity of the adversary is underscored by the assertion that “I will not remember to show mercy.” This implies that the enemy remained unsoftened by the trials faced by an innocent and impoverished person, showing no regard for human compassion, and failing to temper their beastly ferocity. Herein lies the stark contrast between human callousness and the unyielding justice of God.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

At the culmination of the law, which is Christ the Lord (Rom. 10:4), this psalm was revealed to David by the Holy Spirit. In it, he implores God for assistance against his relentless adversaries who surround him with harsh oaths born from deep anguish and suffering. These enemies serve as a foreshadowing of the true enemy of Christ the Savior—Judas the traitor, alongside other ungrateful Jews, and all those who oppose Christ and His Church, to whom the prophet foretells severe judgment (Chrysostom, Athanasius, Theodoret).

Read more (263 words)

This psalm glorifies the Passion of Christ, who called out to God the Father, “Now glorify Me, Father.” The voice of the sinner—Satan—and the deceptive tongue of Judas testify against the innocent Christ, betraying Him to His death. The Jews accused Him of preventing Caesar from receiving tribute, uttering hateful cries of “Crucify, crucify Him!” and spreading lies that He led the people astray, while Christ interceded, saying, “Father, forgive them.” His humility, meekness, gentleness, and reverence of spirit serve as the most powerful weapon and an unbeatable plea (Chrysostom).

Christ demonstrated His love for the Jews, desiring to save them, yet they chose to reject the light of truth for the comforts of darkness. In their treachery, Satan entered into Judas during the act of sharing bread, ultimately casting him away. Despite Judas proclaiming, “We have sinned by betraying the innocent blood,” he met his doom in despair, choosing to end his own life. Gradually, Judas turned against Christ until he disappeared into ruin, and Matthias was chosen to take his place among the apostles (Acts 1:23). This fate befell not only Judas but all unfaithful Jews.

Among those who opposed, some faced destruction while others were taken captive. The dignity that was theirs was bestowed upon the Christians (Theodoret, Epiphanius). Judas's thoughts became disconnected from God’s grace, leaving his soul desolate from its divine source. His labors turned to wickedness, consumed by avarice, leading to the decline of the Jews due to their iniquity throughout the world. The devil fed Judas's malice, arranging the demons' plots without concern for Judas's salvation.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.