The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 44 (43):10Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

But now thou hast cast us off, and put us to shame: and thou , O God, wilt not go out with our armies.

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

אַף־זָ֭נַחְתָּ וַתַּכְלִימֵ֑נוּ וְלֹא־תֵ֝צֵ֗א בְּצִבְאוֹתֵֽינוּ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

8 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

One translator observes that despite your denial, you have not turned away. Another expresses it by saying that even though you have rejected, there remains the acknowledgment that you do not go out, O God, in our strength. Another translation conveys this idea by stating that you do not advance with our forces. The theme of rejection leads swiftly into the experience of shame and peril—confronting calamity from every side. The prophet refers to his armies as "forces" because it is through them that the king’s might is displayed, following God’s wise design, which fosters a connection between the leader and his followers. The ruler relies on his subjects, while they depend on his guidance, creating a mutual benefit.

Read more (94 words)

To prevent hubris, the Lord has ordained that those in high positions often require the assistance of those in lowly situations. This principle also applies to inanimate objects; for instance, a weak pillar may be supported by a small stone, and a heavily laden vessel is deftly navigated by a tiny rudder, avoiding disaster. What does it signify that, "You have now cast us off"? The prophet indicates that in the midst of such trials, we remain steadfast in our devotion to You; we offer our praise, sing in adoration, and glorify Your name.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Given that we have received the assurance of a future for all these matters, and recalling the accounts from our forebears about events of the past, we must ask ourselves about our current state. Yet, You have turned away from us and brought us disgrace (Psalms 43:10). This shame is not merely internal but is evident before others. There was a time when Christians faced persecution, seen as outsiders wherever they went, labeled as ‘He is a Christian!’ as if it were a mark of derision. Where is our God, our Sovereign, who grants deliverance for Jacob? Where is the One who performed the works that our ancestors recounted to us? Where is He who will realize in the future all that He has revealed to us through His Spirit? Has He undergone a change? Absolutely not.

Read more (130 words)

This is intended for the understanding of the descendants of Korea. We ought to grasp the reasons behind His choice for us to endure these trials at this time. What do these trials entail? Yet You have forsaken us and brought us to shame, and You do not go forth, O God, with our might. We venture out to confront our adversaries, and You do not accompany us. We observe their strength—they are formidable, and we lack power. Where is Your might? Where is Your righteous hand and strength? Where is the drying up of the sea, the engulfing of the Egyptian pursuers by the waves? Where is Amalek’s defeat, vanquished by the emblem of the cross? (Exodus 17:12) And yet, O God, You do not advance with our strength.

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

O God, we have received your words through our ears. But now you have turned away from us and have caused us disgrace, not advancing with us, O God, in our might. You were once our guide in the fight, yet now you not only remain behind, but have you also led us back once more?

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

You have now abandoned us and brought us shame, and, O God, You will not accompany us with our strength (Ps. 43:10). If King David himself stated in another instance, For the Lord will not abandon His people (Psalm 93:14), why does he assert here that You have cast us off, especially when he recounts the many virtues of the very people he describes? The mention of adversities and various trials faced by the people, along with the fact that they remained faithful to the Lord their God and upheld His covenant, is significant. The Apostle provides clarification, stating that the Lord has not yet rejected His people, referencing the Lord's assertion: All day long I have stretched out My hands to a disobedient and obstinate people (Is. 65:2; Rom. 10:21).

Read more (1391 words)

Based on these profound words, the Apostle asserts, “Has God rejected His people? Certainly not. For I too am an Israelite, of the lineage of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin. God has not rejected His people, whom He foreknew” (Rom. 11:1-2). It can be argued that God did not reject His people because through His grace a remnant was saved (Rom. 11:5). Hence, while a small portion remains steadfast, the majority may have turned away, yet not all were forsaken. The Apostle continues, noting that God preserved not just a few but also “seven thousand who have not bowed the knee to Baal.” This aligns with the Gospel, illustrating that God reached out to the Gentiles, and this response should be seen in a time when zeal for faith was fervent and prophetic grace was plentiful among the Jewish people. If the Lord proclaimed He had not forsaken His people in Elijah's time, it was even more valid in the time of David or the sons of Korah, when the faith of the chosen people still radiated brightly.

Let us inquire of St. David how the Lord has not forsaken His people. God is one who draws near to humanity, not away, as the Scriptures reveal (Jer. 23:23); and one who draws near cannot cast aside. A compassionate God does not condemn any to death, finding all worthy of redemptive grace. However, we must exercise caution; those who turn away from the Lord will be denied, as David states, “For behold, those who remove themselves from You shall perish; You have destroyed all who commit themselves to idolatry” (Psalm 72:27). What does it mean to commit idolatry against You? It signifies forsaking You due to vile passions, turning away from Your guidance. In another passage, we find, “But God judges fornicators, distancing them from Himself” (Hebrews 13:4), implying that by pushing them away from You, they have faced destruction. Thus, anyone who alienates themselves from the Lord separates themselves from salvation; whoever does not know the Lord cannot truly know themselves, and those who fail to understand God will find no understanding from Him. The Lord proclaims, “Depart from Me, all you who practice iniquity; I never knew you” (Matt. 7:23), because He deems the agents of injustice and wrongdoing unworthy of such knowledge. Hence, God does not reject the sinner; rather, the sinner chooses to distance oneself from God. This is how we interpret the words, “Today You have rejected and shamed us” (Psalm 43:10). Furthermore, the notion of God seeming to withdraw is evident in the latter part of the verse: “You will not go out, O God, with our strength” (Psalm 43:10). When God does not provide assistance, it may appear as rejection; those who do not perceive God's aid might feel abandoned, left alone. The question arises, what does it mean that “You will not go out, O God”? How can it be said that God sometimes goes out or withdraws? God does not move physically from one location to another, as He transcends all. He does not literally ascend as if resting or sitting upon a throne. Such expressions serve to help us grasp the circumstances: when He departs or whom He visits.

In the same psalm, it states: “Arise, why do You sleep, O Lord?” (Psalm 43:24). This is a reflection, for because of our sinful actions, we must not assume He is indifferent. In the Gospel, we read that when the apostles' faith was still wavering, Jesus, present among them, appeared to be asleep. When they were overcome by fear of shipwreck, they awakened Christ. Thus, for non-believers, the Lord seems to be asleep, while for the faithful, He is very much alive. Therefore, the faithful draw near to the Lord, while those who neglect Him perceive God as withdrawing. Naturally, the Lord attracts those who are imperfect and still growing in their faith, as expressed in the words of the bride: “Draw us in! For the fragrance of Your perfumes we will run” (Song 1:3). Concerning Moses, whose faith had matured and who was appointed by the Lord, it is recorded that he ascended to commune with God, as it is written: “And Moses went up the mountain, and the glory of the Lord descended upon Mount Sinai, encompassing it with a cloud for six days, and the Lord called to Moses on the seventh day” (Ex. 24:15-18). As Moses initially entered the cloud, so later, as he entered the tabernacle, a cloud descended and stood at the entrance of the tabernacle, prompting the people to worship at its entrance (Ex. 33:9-10). The cloud represented the Lord, who envelops all in darkness (Psalm 17:12). The reference to the Lord is reinforced when it states, “And the Lord spoke to Moses” (Ex. 33:1). It is not contradictory to understand that the tabernacle Moses constructed to meet God was placed outside the camp. For those who seek God metaphorically enter into Him and begin to know Him fully. In this way, the righteous enter into the Lord as Moses did into the cloud, where God resides. The Scriptures say, “Behold, the Lord appears in a light cloud” (Isaiah 19:1). The Gospel instructs, “But when you pray, go into your room, and shut the door, and pray to your Father in secret; and your Father, who sees in secret, will reward you” (Matthew 6:6). Thus, God dwells within us, as if in a room. Another text declares, “Behold, the Lord comes forth from His place, and shall come down and march upon the heights of the earth; the mountains shall tremble beneath Him, and the valleys shall dissolve” (Micah 1:3-4). This passage also alludes to God leaving the Jewish people to reach out to the Gentiles. Finally, we also discern this sentiment in the Psalm, expressed by David: “He is like a bridegroom coming out of his chamber, joyful as a champion to run his course” (Ps. 18:6). This explains how we should interpret God’s movements of coming forth or withdrawing.

The Lord Jesus also states that He will come to those who revere God: “Behold, I stand at the door, and knock; if anyone hears My voice and opens the door, I will come in to him, and dine with him, and he with Me” (Rev. 3:20). All our reflections connect to the words of the prophet, “You have abandoned us, and will not go out, O God, with our strength” (Psalm 43:10). These concluding remarks should be taken to mean that God accompanied His people when Joshua praised the Commander of the heavenly army; this is how He achieved victory without weapons and caused the formidable walls of Jericho to collapse. When God fights with His servants, they prevail. Accordingly, in response to Hezekiah’s prayers, an angel was sent out and defeated the vast Assyrian army. Yet at times, the Lord seems to withdraw from those He wishes to see prevail in faith, allowing them to gain victory through unwavering belief; favorable circumstances should not lessen their dedication. Frequently, those who fall during times of success have been rehabilitated through trials. The history of the Jewish people reveals many instances of decline after triumph, and restoration subsequent to their pleas for God's return. This also aligns with the well-known lamentation embodying human nature and emotion: “My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?” (Matt. 27:46; Ps. 21:2). This does not imply that the Lord was truly forsaken, for He also asserted, “For I am not alone, for the Father is with Me” (John 16:32). This call reflects the sentiment of a soul enduring great trials, perceiving abandonment; such is the weakness of our flesh and senses. Thus, it is no coincidence that the Scriptures convey that after the initial temptation, the devil retreated until the appointed moment (Luke 4:13), only to return when the time came for His supreme test: the Holy Passion. In times of distress, humanity often perceives abandonment by God. We comprehend that this sensation of abandonment stems from our bodily experiences, just as Christ experienced in His flesh, even though in His divine essence, He recognized that the Father would never forsake Him. After all, He affirmed, “I am in the Father, and the Father is in Me” (John 14:10), plainly indicating that He could never be alone.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

In times of old, You acted on our behalf; however, now we feel abandoned by Your care, living in disgrace and without the direction of Your favor. It is declared that You will not march forth in our power, implying that You will not lead us, nor will You, as You once did, enable us to triumph over our foes.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

But now, O God, You have cast us aside and brought us shame; You will not come forth in our might. He states, You, O Lord, have deemed us unworthy and have brought us to a state of shame, meaning that You do not assist us in our times of great suffering and do not enable us to triumph over our adversaries through our armies, for that signifies true strength. Here, a transition takes place; the present context is spoken of in a future sense: rather than declaring, You will not go forth, it is expressed, You do not go forth. This is why Symmachus rendered it as: You do not follow with our soldiers, implying that You do not engage in battle alongside our forces. According to Chrysostom, the term forces refers to armies, as they embody the king's power.

Read more (79 words)

Indeed, God has orchestrated the relationship between the great and the small, demonstrating that the powerful are in need of the humble, just as the humble depend on their leaders. This design extends even to the inanimate. Frequently, a sturdy pillar supports a mere pebble, and a vessel that carries many can be steered by a small helm, guiding it away from peril. Thus, the Preterist observed, In many a people is the glory of the king (Proverbs 14:28).

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

Thus begins the astonishment and sorrow of the people, deeply troubled by their adversaries, questioning why the very God and the people they once knew have acted so contrary to their cause. The same God who earlier granted them victory now allows their foes to prevail against them. Why, O Lord, do you now reject us and bring us to disgrace? You who once favored us, why have you turned away and shamed us? In the days of Antiochus, being identified as a Jew was a mark of dishonor; similarly, in later times under tormentors, being known as a Christian became a source of shame, with the faithful appearing abandoned by God. Why do you not come forth in our strength? When we seek to confront our enemies, why do you not rally to our aid as you once did for your people?

Read more (121 words)

The term "forces" refers to armies, as clearly stated in the Hebrew text; for a well-armed army represents the strength and stronghold of nations. Yet, during the persecutions under Antiochus and the pagan rulers, the people of God displayed such weakness that none dared to stand against them, either in action or speech. Consequently, the faithful could only equip themselves with patience. But while they overcame their visible foes, they achieved a glorious victory over spiritual adversaries. Even though they appeared forsaken in the eyes of men, they were secretly sustained by God’s abundant grace. What was revealed occurred outwardly, while the inner workings are left for the sons of Korah to comprehend. Following this, the narrative of the persecution continues.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

Regarding the title, Korey is referred to as Golgotha, or the location of the Throne, while the sons of Korey symbolize those who embody patience—those who crucify their flesh along with its passions and desires, the sons of Christ (Galatians 5:24). The purpose is to make it clear that Christ suffered on behalf of everyone (1 Peter 2:21), as all have left behind an old image to follow His example, so that those who endure suffering with Him may also share in His glory (2 Timothy 2:2; Romans 8:30). Listen, you who neglect your children, allowing them to indulge in wicked songs while disregarding Divine narratives. This was not the way of the ancients.

Read more (306 words)

They dedicated their lives to recounting the acts of God, so much so that parents became the storytellers, guiding their children toward the knowledge of the Lord (Chrysostom). Christ the God will vanquish the wicked but will fortify those who place their faith in Him. You have embittered mankind, and you have cast me out, the Jews, for their lack of belief. Contemplating the Mystery of the Holy Trinity: the Hand represents God the Father, Muscle signifies God the Son, and Enlightenment embodies God the Holy Spirit. The Cross of Christ is adorned with horns, and the name of Jesus Christ strikes fear into demons. While horned creatures possess horns by nature instead of weapons, we have been given the name of Jesus Christ as our means of prayer (Theodoret). Demons who hate Him feel shame before Christ. Every day encapsulates the entirety of human existence on earth and eternity in the heavenly homeland. God the Father has rejected the Jews due to their disbelief in Christ. The Jews are dispersed across the world because of their unbelief. In every place, the Jews, like demons, are embroiled in scandal because of their rejection of Christ. The prophet vividly illustrates the lamentable state of the Jews, prophetically acknowledging their afflictions. Whatever they inflicted upon Christ is repaid to them in kind. They reviled Him, and they are reviled; they mocked Him, and they themselves are mocked; they shook their heads at Him, and others now shake their heads at them (Athanasius). Depart from the righteous path because of the Jews' unbelief in Christ. This is echoed in the words of the holy martyrs who suffered and died for Christ, echoing the voice of Adam. Sleep symbolizes the divine patience of God. The righteous longed for Christ's coming and the salvation brought through the cross and His resurrection.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.