The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 44 (43):12Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Thou hast given us up like sheep to be eaten: thou hast scattered us among the nations.

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

תִּ֭תְּנֵנוּ כְּצֹ֣אן מַאֲכָ֑ל וּ֝בַגּוֹיִ֗ם זֵרִיתָֽנוּ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

7 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

A different translator, Symmachus, remarks, “You have dispersed us. What does it signify to be devoured like sheep?” This refers to our vulnerability, illustrating our lack of worth. There are some sheep raised for breeding; meanwhile, others, rendered unfit due to age or barrenness, are destined solely for consumption. However, the most distressing aspect was their dispersion among the Gentiles, which proved deeply troubling as it hindered their ability to observe the law faithfully and distanced them from their ancestral practices. Moreover, they found themselves scattered not just among one people but across various lands, leading them to endure suffering without the ability to retaliate or resist. This vividly illustrates the analogy of sheep.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

The nations have consumed us. This speaks to individuals who, through their trials in the journey of assimilation, become integrated into the body of the Gentile world. The Church grieves for them, just as she laments the members of her own body who have been consumed.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

We find in the Scriptures: "And they that hate us have torn us in pieces to themselves: Thou hast given us up like sheep to be eaten, and hast scattered us among the Gentiles" (Psalm 43:11-12). It may astonish us that those who despised them dismembered them; however, the following verses reveal that these individuals also acknowledge the remarkable resilience of their faith. This realization should not unsettle us, as many endure trials in this life, but their worthiness before Christ cannot be diminished. The apostles faced anguish, were struck with rods, imprisoned, and separated from one another, yet they remained steadfast in their allegiance to Christ. Their sufferings, inflicted by nonbelievers, actually magnified their merits and invited heavenly grace.

Read more (1428 words)

Indeed, one who suffers at the hands of others is not necessarily overcome. Consider the Apostle Paul, who found joy in his persecutions, and how he gloried even when he escaped from a window in a basket. We must also remember how Saints Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and Daniel remained faithful despite their captivity and torment by the Assyrians; they upheld their trust in the Lord's covenant while ensuring compliance with divine laws, refusing to compromise even regarding prohibited foods. The translation by Theodotion expresses this well: "And they that hate us triumphed over us" (Psalm 43:11). For the derision of adversaries causes no harm to a righteous soul, nor does the pain they inflict. Confident that torment cannot damage him, the saint proclaims: "Who shall separate us from the love of God? Shall tribulation or distress?" (Rom. 8:35) But we conquer all these trials through the strength of Him who loves us, certain that neither death, nor life, nor angels, nor powers, nor present nor future can sever us from the love of God that exists in Christ Jesus our Lord (Rom. 8:37-39). Such a person remains devoted to Christ! Therefore, even when persecuted in the flesh, his spirit remains liberated, and such affliction cannot harm him; rather, he seeks a glorious suffering, like those referenced in the Scriptures: "From the days of John the Baptist the kingdom of heaven suffereth violence, and the violent take it by force" (Matthew 11:12). Thus, we may refer to someone who, while immersed in worldly matters, refuses to succumb to disbelief as a victor. Not only can no one strip this person of his glory, but he himself also elevates the eternal.

The subsequent verse speaks of being offered as sheep for consumption (Psalm 43:12). Our Lord Jesus Christ is indeed good as He became our Paschal Lamb. How did this occur? The Scripture states, "Our Passover, Christ, sacrificed for us" (1 Cor. 5:7), reminding us that when our ancestors sacrificed the lamb and consumed it, it foreshadowed the suffering of our Lord Jesus, whose sacrament nourishes us daily. Through the lamb, they became flocks destined for consumption, as Aquila expresses, or as Theodotion translates it, or the sustenance for those who partake, as Simmachus claims. A bountiful feast is not to frighten the saints but to be sought, for no other way can access the Kingdom of Heaven. Our Lord Himself declared, "Unless you eat My flesh, you have no life in you" (John 6:53). This affirms that Christ is our feast and sustenance, as He proclaimed, "I am the living bread that came down from heaven" (John 6:51). To emphasize that all of this happened for us, the apostle notes that from the moment He descended, we all partake of one bread (1 Cor. 10:17). Thus, we need not dread being sheep intended for consumption. Just as the Lord's body and blood redeemed us, so too did Peter suffer greatly for the Church, as did the holy Apostle Paul and the others, who endured much, being beaten, stoned, and imprisoned. Their perseverance in trials and acceptance of danger fortified the Lord's followers, leading to the growth of the Church, as many were emboldened toward martyrdom, witnessing that suffering did not strip the apostles of virtue; rather, through their ephemeral lives, they attained immortality. The concluding phrase of the verse reiterates: "Among the Gentiles Thou hast scattered us" (Psalm 43:12). Theodotion presents a similar translation, with Aquila and Symmachus stating, "In the Gentiles" or "among the Gentiles, Thou hast scattered us." For the holy apostles were sent to the Gentiles and dispersed among them, just as the holy prophets previously did, resulting in an abundance of spiritual fruit. Just as our Lord Jesus Christ fell to the earth as a seed and died to produce abundant harvests, so did the holy apostles scatter to sow good seed amongst the Gentiles, expecting that like fruit would arise. Scripture reminds us that the Lord commanded, "I chose you and appointed you that you should go and bear fruit and that your fruit should remain" (John 15:16). The Lord became like a seed, as was promised to Abraham, "And to thy seed" (Gen. 17:8), referring to Christ. Thus, Christ is the seed of all creation, allowing Himself to be cast to the earth and scattered, so that our humbled bodies might be transformed in accordance with His glory. From this seed emerged salvation for all, and the holy apostles, modeled after Him, were dispatched to various lands, gathering the Gentiles into the Church, thereby yielding a rich harvest for the world. Hence, we call this scattering; as noted in one of David's last psalms, "The Lord builds up Jerusalem and gathers together the outcasts of Israel" (Psalm 146:2). They were dispersed to generate fresh fruit, which must be gathered into the granaries of the Church like new wheat. This scattering occurs not below on earth, but rather in heaven. This truth is underscored in the law, where the Lord states, "If your outcasts are at the ends of the earth, I will gather them from there" (Deuteronomy 30:4). What does it mean to scatter from one end of heaven to the other? Who is so mighty as to scatter this widely? Since humanity is born of the earth, its origins are below, not above. If this notion unsettles you, return to the words of the holy prophet and inquire about the one who has managed to cultivate such abundant fields on earth that their bounty reaches the heavenly granaries. It is the Bridegroom who, like a mighty warrior, journeyed all the way, overcoming paths impassable to others. Following Him, humans were enabled to traverse that way, having ascended it, although He was the first to descend, permitting His saints to ascend that path on account of their merits.

Consider how the scattering from the ends of heaven came to pass. It is stated, "His going forth is from the end of heaven, and His circuit unto the ends of it" (Psalm 18:7). To whom does this refer? Moses ascended Mount Sinai at great difficulty, and that only because God called him with a voice from the heavens. Is there any other than Christ who has come down from heaven? Even as He descended to earth, He remained in heaven, as it is written, "No man hath ascended into heaven, but He that came down from heaven, even the Son of man which is in heaven" (John 3:13). This illustrates that in both descent and ascent, He remained in heaven. For He declared, "I fill heaven and earth" (Jer. 23:24). We have sufficiently examined the nature of this dispersion. It remains to address the translation of Aquila and Symmachus, "Thou hast sown us" (Psalm 43:12). Although different terminology is employed, the meaning remains consistent. Just as those who are dispersed may be seen as tested, so too do those who endure trials earn commendation. Just as wheat is winnowed and separated from the chaff to become pure—if left unrefined, it remains contaminated—likewise, the chaff, representing all that is unstable within a person, is not removed from one untested by trials. Thus, when addressing Peter, the Lord said, "Simon, behold, Satan has asked to sift you as wheat, but I have prayed for you that your faith fail not" (Luke 22:31-32). Let us contemplate these words: Peter is being tested and compelled to reject Christ. He confronts temptation and expresses thoughts that are clouded, yet the utterances he articulates only fortify him internally. In his grief, he weeps and purges himself of the chaff; through these tribulations, he secures Christ's intercession on his behalf. Such intercession is far more powerful than the momentary confusion wrought by temptation. Hence, his reward surpasses his sufferings, for he has gained the intercession of Christ. The adversary is compelled to seek to tempt the saints to his own detriment, as through his trials, he refines them, allowing the tempted to become mentors for others, despite any appearances of weakness or inadequacy. Thus, Peter ascended to the head of the church through the challenges posed by the evil one. The Lord foreshadowed His later actions by choosing Peter as the shepherd of His flock, stating, "When you are converted, strengthen your brethren" (Luke 22:32). St. Peter became good fruit, having been sown like wheat to become, alongside the Lord's saints, a single loaf of bread, which serves as sustenance for us. When we reflect on Peter's actions and absorb his teachings, he becomes for us the nourishing source of eternal life.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Like sheep without a shepherd, we are delivered into the hands of our foes; those who survive death are scattered, finding themselves sold into servitude in various places.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

You have delivered us like sheep to be consumed and dispersed us among the nations. You have turned us over to our adversaries, not as sheep to be owned and valued for their fruitfulness, but as sheep designated for slaughter, deemed lesser due to their inability to bear offspring or due to their age, as Chrysostom suggests. You have sent us, as servants and prisoners, into the hands of the peoples, referred to as the Hellenes and Macedonians, to whom many nations have aligned themselves. Through these expressions, the Maccabees, in their fraternal compassion, embrace the plight of their fellow brothers and fellow worshippers who have been taken captive by the Greeks.

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

You have allowed our adversaries to slay us easily and in large numbers, much like sheep herded to the market, slaughtered en masse without any opposition. Those among us whom the foes did not eliminate, You have dispersed among the nations, indicating the confinement and banishment to far-off lands, where the faithful, particularly the confessors of the new grace, were frequently sent.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

Regarding the title, Korey is referred to as Golgotha, or the site of the Throne, while the sons of Korey signify those endowed with patience; they who crucify their flesh with desires and lusts are indeed the sons of Christ (Galatians 5:24). This serves to illustrate that Christ endured suffering for everyone (1 Peter 2:21), as all have abandoned their former ways to walk in His footsteps, so that those who suffer alongside Him may also be glorified with Him (2 Timothy 2:2; Romans 8:30). Listen, those who disregard your children, permitting them to sing songs of wickedness while neglecting divine narratives.

Read more (314 words)

The ancients were quite different; they dedicated their lives to recounting the works of God, with parents shaping their children’s understanding through such stories, leading them to the knowledge of God (Chrysostom). Christ, the Son of God, will condemn the unrighteous but will fortify those who have faith in Him. You have caused bitterness among men, and you have cast me away, the Jews, for their lack of belief. This is the Mystery of the Holy Trinity. The Hand represents God the Father, the Strength symbolizes God the Son, and Enlightenment reflects God the Holy Spirit. The Cross of Christ bears His name, which terrifies demons. Horned creatures possess their horns as natural defenses, whereas we have received the name of Jesus Christ for our prayers (Theodoret). The demons, who despise Him, are ashamed of Christ. The entirety of human life on earth is marked by the day and extends into eternity in the realm of Heaven. God the Father has distanced Himself from the Jews due to their disbelief in Christ, resulting in their scattering across the world. Their lack of faith in Christ has led the Jews to experience disgrace, much like that of demons. The prophet portrays the suffering of the Jews in a lamentable way, illustrating the people's tribulations with great sorrow. All that they inflicted upon Christ has returned to them. They hurled insults, and now they face insults; they mocked Him, and they themselves are mocked; they shook their heads at Him, and others shake their heads at them (Athanasius). Turn away from the path of the Jews because of their lack of faith in Christ. The words of the holy martyrs resonate with the suffering and sacrifice for Christ. The voice of Adam speaks. Sleep symbolizes the patience of God. The righteous awaited the coming of Christ and the salvation offered on the cross through the Resurrection.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.