The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 73 (72):1Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

A psalm for Asaph. How good is God to Israel, to them that are of a right heart!

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

מִזְמ֗וֹר לְאָ֫סָ֥ף אַ֤ךְ ט֭וֹב לְיִשְׂרָאֵ֥ל אֱלֹהִ֗ים לְבָרֵ֥י לֵבָֽב׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

7 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 8 commentaries

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

For God is compassionate towards Israel, particularly to those who are pure in heart. The psalmist admits that his steps were nearly led astray, expressing his confusion and doubt. Why was this the case? It stemmed from his envy of those who are unrighteous, observing how well they seemed to thrive. Indeed, to whom does God extend His goodness if not to the blameless in heart? In my distorted heart, I found myself discontented with the Lord, troubled by the apparent blessings showered upon the wicked. This caused my feet to waver—was my service to the Lord in vain? The very reason my stability faltered was because I lacked a right heart.

Read more (146 words)

But what does it mean to be right in heart? It signifies adherence to the divine will. One individual may experience prosperity while another diligently labors; one may live unjustly yet enjoy happiness, while another may strive for righteousness and face sorrow. Let those who lead a righteous life and toil not be disheartened; for within them lies what the joyful person does not possess. Thus, they shouldn't feel distressed, tormented, or discouraged. The joyful person may have material wealth, while the righteous one possesses God within their conscience.

Consider the contrast between gold and God, between material wealth and spiritual integrity. What the one holds is fleeting and will ultimately vanish, while the other harbors the eternal God, who cannot be taken away, provided the individual is pure in heart. For in such a state, they enter into an everlasting communion and do not depart.

This psalm carries the title, "The hymns of David, the son of Jesse, have become scarce," attributed to Asaph. While many psalms bear the name of David, this is the only one that specifically includes the phrase "son of Jesse." This detail cannot be without significance, as God consistently guides us and invites us to engage in a devout exploration of love. What does it imply that the hymns of David, the son of Jesse, are unfulfilled? Hymns are expressions of worship directed toward God, often accompanied by singing; they consist of songs that convey praise. If there is praise that does not honor God, it cannot be considered a hymn; similarly, if praise is offered to God but not sung, it is also not a hymn.

Read more (1129 words)

Thus, a true hymn must encompass three essential elements: the act of praising God, acknowledgment of His glory, and the medium of song. Therefore, what does it mean that hymns have become rare? It suggests that the praises sung unto God have not thrived. The psalmist appears to allude to something sorrowful and even tragic, as one who sings in praise not only voices their admiration but does so with joyous love for the subject of their song. In praise, there is the expression of a believer, and in singing, the heartfelt emotion of one who loves. When he states, "Then the hymns of David were not sung," he adds, "the son of Jesse," highlighting David's role as king of Israel, son of Jesse, during a specific era of the Old Testament when the New Testament was still concealed within him like fruit hidden in a root. If one seeks fruit only in the root, they will not find it, and in the branches, they will discover only what has emerged from the root. Just as Christ was, in His human birth, concealed in the lineage of the Patriarchs and would be revealed in time, so too the New Covenant realized in Christ was veiled in those earlier days, known only to a few righteous prophets and faithful souls. For instance, when Abraham commissions his loyal servant to find a wife for his only son, he makes him swear an oath by placing his hand under Abraham's thigh. What lies in Abraham's thigh that he swears by, if not the promise he received: "In thy seed shall all nations be blessed"? The term "thigh" refers to flesh, through which our Lord Jesus Christ emerged from Abraham, through Isaac and Jacob, and eventually Mary.

How do we confirm that the root lies with the Patriarchs? Let us turn to Paul. The Gentiles believe in Christ now and wish to boast before the Jews who crucified Him; the same people who formed a barrier now encounter Christ, who bridges that divide with the Gentiles coming from the other side. When the nations arose, lifting their spirits, He oppresses them. Paul writes, "If you are cut from the natural wild olive tree and grafted among them, do not boast against the branches, for it is not you who supports the root, but the root supports you." Thus, he refers to branches broken off from the Patriarchs due to disbelief and the wild olive tree that has been grafted in to share in the fruitful olive tree, which represents the forthcoming Church of the Gentiles. Who performs this grafting? Typically, wild olive trees are grafted onto cultivated ones, not vice versa. The result will always reflect the nature of what is grafted, as what is incorporated will produce fruit in its true form. The fruit of this new grafting does not come from the original root but from the new integration. The Apostle clarifies that such an act of God’s omnipotence enables the unworthy wild olive to take root in the cultivated olive tree, yielding not wild fruit but a true olive. Paul emphasizes, "If you are cut off from the natural wild olive tree and, contrary to nature, are grafted into a good olive tree, do not boast against the branches."

In the times of the Old Testament, God made promises to a physical people that were earthly and transient. They were promised a tangible kingdom and a land, which they entered after their deliverance from Egypt under Joshua. They received their inheritance in the earthly Jerusalem where David reigned, celebrating their exodus through the Red Sea. These promises were never meant to last indefinitely but instead foreshadowed the eternal promises to come, serving as figures and prophecies of the future. Thus, when the kingdom ruled by David, the son of Jesse, began to decline, remember that he was a man, a prophet, and a saint who foresaw Christ’s arrival from his lineage. Yet, he was merely a man, and not yet Christ, our divine King, the Son of God; King David remained the son of Jesse, for at that time, his realm was destined to fail. Carnal people glorified God for their temporary deliverance from oppressors and rejoiced in their rescue from foes during their journey through the desert, eventually finding their homeland and sovereignty. However, they did not understand the divine plan behind these events and promises. Therefore, when the carnal men under David’s reign sought to glorify God, the hymns of David—the son of Jesse—did not flourish.

As for whose voice resonates in this psalm, it is that of Asaph. The name Asaph, translated from Hebrew to Greek and then Latin, signifies "Synagogue." Thus, it represents the voice of the Synagogue. However, do not instinctively reject this term, viewing the Synagogue as solely responsible for the Lord’s opposition, as many do. The Synagogue indeed played a role in Christ’s crucifixion, but it also produced many of His followers, including us. The psalm suggests, "Bring to the Lord the sons of rams." These rams refer to Peter, John, James, Andrew, Bartholomew, and the other apostles. Asaph's lineage includes Saul, who would later become Paul, signifying a transformation from pride to humility. Therefore, Paul too emerged from the Synagogue, as did Peter and the other apostles. As you hear the voice of the Synagogue, do not dwell on its past failings but acknowledge its offspring. The psalm communicates the sentiments of the Synagogue after the decline of hymns from David the son of Jesse—the loss of earthly accolades for glorifying God. But why did these manifestations fade? So that they might seek deeper truths? These truths were not absent; rather, they were concealed within symbols, not void yet obscured within divine mystery. These mysteries, as the Apostle describes, served as our examples.

Consequently, the Synagogue reflects those who worshipped God in ways aligned with the earthly, often influenced by worldly desires. However, even so, this group sought such blessings from the one true God, the Creator of all things, both seen and unseen. Observing the Synagogue comprised of outwardly righteous men, who followed temporary paths rather than eternal ones, we note that though they understood God's promises of abundant earthly goods—land, peace, happiness—they failed to grasp the deeper meaning hidden within these gifts. They presumed that God had granted these for their temporal fulfillment, oblivious to the more profound blessings awaiting those who genuinely loved and served Him. They noticed unworthy individuals prospering in carnal pursuits and, thus, a troubling thought took root in their hearts, causing them to waver from God's path. This sentiment was prevalent among the Old Covenant believers, a narrative we should strive to avoid, especially in light of the blessings now promised through the New Covenant.

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

In this psalm attributed to Asaph, the prophet illustrates the irrationality of human perspectives regarding God's judgments, which are profound, unfathomable, and filled with immense mystery. Those lacking understanding of the foundational principles behind God's judgments concerning His household often succumb to misguided beliefs. The psalm initially confronts the very thoughts that arise due to the apparent success of the wicked, as indicated by the phrase: “These are the sinners and the arrogant” (Psalm 72:12). The prophet then reveals the ultimate fate awaiting the wicked, ensuring that we understand this truth clearly, so we are not dismayed by the seeming contradictions of life’s circumstances. It is affirmed that the God of Israel is benevolent toward the pure in heart.

Read more (85 words)

While discussing the success of the unrighteous and the severe consequences that lie ahead for them, the psalm emphasizes that God’s goodness is reserved for those who are righteous. Thus, those who embrace the path of the godly should take comfort in knowing that God is favorable to the upright, not to those who engage in sin. Even if the wicked appear to thrive, believers need not be perturbed by this illusion, for they must keep in mind the impending judgment that awaits the unrepentant.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

The psalms attributed to David, the son of Jesse, conclude with a composition for Asaph. It has been previously noted that Asaph is referred to by some as a psalmist and by others as a leader and teacher among the singers; some even propose that these psalms were authored by David, with Asaph being the one to compose them. However, each person may embrace this understanding as they see fit, for it will not cause harm to those who accept either viewpoint. In the light of divine grace, we will elucidate the meaning of this psalm. The people exiled in Babylon faced myriad tribulations.

Read more (176 words)

Observing that the Babylonians thrived in wickedness and immorality while they themselves endured suffering, the Jews reflected on God’s Sovereign Plan, questioning why the unrighteous often experience prosperity and joy amidst their trials. The grace of the Holy Spirit, observing these circumstances from a distance and orchestrating them for the benefit of the captives in Babylon and humanity at large, inspired this psalm, articulating their contemplations and providing answers to their queries. Thus, the teachings of this psalm are beneficial for those who engage in similar reasoning or express sentiments like the exiles in Babylon, presented as if those returning from captivity are recounting their earlier struggles with divine Providence. "If the God of Israel be good." The Prophet uses "good" not in a comparative sense, but to emphasize the abundance of God’s goodness, demonstrating His profound care for Israel. "With a right heart." This understanding, however, is not evident to all, but only to those with sound and righteous thoughts. Therefore, having extolled the upright in heart, He conveys the turmoil within His own mind.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

The compositions authored by David, son of Jephthah, have reached their conclusion. This psalm is dedicated to Asaph. Some have mistakenly linked the phrase, "The songs of David the son of Jephthah have come to an end," to this psalm; however, it rightly concludes Psalm 71, which is associated with it, forming a part of the expression of gratitude for the answering of David's petitions. Editions produced in Leipzig recognize this phrase as the twentieth verse of the seventy-first psalm. In different listings, there is an addition: Song to the Assyrian. We have established in the introduction to the Book of Psalms that all psalms are ascribed to David. Therefore, how can it be said that the songs have concluded?

Read more (413 words)

The response is that it is indeed the songs of David that have ceased, not the psalms themselves. Among the psalms he authored, some he performed to glorify God with the assistance of his harp, while others he entrusted to the foremost singers for them to render. The current psalm and the succeeding ten were given to Asaph for him to sing. Similarly, he assigned the other compositions to other psalmists, as explained in the fifth chapter of the introduction. The term "ended" signifies that although these psalms were composed by David, they were not all sung by him. It is notable how Divine grace, through the Psalms, provides various remedies for a multitude of human afflictions, as expressed in this particular psalm. This psalm aims to comfort those who are feeble-hearted and may find themselves troubled by the inscrutable purposes of God, as noted by Athanasius and Theodoret. They ponder how God permits the wicked to flourish while seemingly neglecting the righteous who suffer. This psalm is particularly relevant for the Jewish people enslaved by the Babylonians, especially for the most virtuous and God-fearing among them, as specified by Theodoret. It serves to uplift every timid Christian, providing solace in moments of weakness. St. Ephrem highlights that our minds, often swayed by worldly delights, necessitate vigilant care of our senses. For the adversary of goodness confounds temptations, blurring the lines between good and evil, making it imperative to sing this psalm alongside the prophet David before spiritual darkness descends, as its teachings offer us clarity amidst confusion. It elucidates life’s disparities, temptations, and delineates who prevails over them, as well as the rewards for enduring trials patiently. Theodoret further indicates that the term "kol" (as) here implies the utmost degree, affirming that indeed, God shows mercy to the people of Israel. Through their afflictions and hardships, He guides them toward salvation, showing that His discipline comes from love, not malice, and serves to amend those being corrected. He grants favor to the Israelites with sincere hearts, signifying that it is only those with sound intentions who receive His grace. Consequently, those who possess a sound mind can truly comprehend these truths, as religion and righteousness are keys to understanding God’s goodness. Athanasius notes the intention behind discussing the prosperity of the wicked and their destined retribution at life’s end, reminding believers that God favors the righteous, encouraging them to remain steadfast amidst apparent injustice, with the assurance that eventual reckoning will occur.

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

SUPERSCRIPTION AND CONTENTS. A Psalm of Asaph. Reference to this superscription appears in Psalm 49 (Psalms 49:1). This Psalm serves as an encouragement to the faithful who may feel weak, urging them not to rejoice when witnessing the success and abundance of the wicked in this life. Such encouragement is both valuable and necessary, particularly in times when the righteous face persecution while the unrighteous enjoy a false sense of peace and security. Stanza 1) A Psalm of Asaph. If the God of Israel is gracious to those upright in heart. The abruptness of this beginning is noteworthy. It indicates that the Prophet, prior to articulating these words, wrestled profoundly with conflicting thoughts.

Read more (325 words)

Like a valiant ascetic, he faced numerous struggles and, after enduring much toil, achieved a complete triumph that confirmed God’s grace towards His faithful servants and His unwavering protection over their salvation. Thus, these words suggest a deep-seated contrast between the empty deceptions that Satan injected into his mind and the affirmation of faith that he relies on, almost as if he were renouncing the carnal doubts that challenged God’s Providence. Hence, we recognize the strength of this declaration: how good is the God of Israel toward the pure in heart! For David does not approach the throne to engage in philosophical debate or to please the ears of men with accusations, but he emerges as one revitalized from despair, expressing gratitude for the victory he has secured. In doing so, he aims to inspire others through his example, revealing that although God may seem absent from His servants, His love for them endures, and His Providence is especially attentive to the faithful. This is why the Prophet refers to God as the God of Israel and promptly connects His name to those who possess a sincere heart. Many may arrogantly claim the title of Israel, presenting themselves as the most esteemed members of the church, yet in reality, they are no different from Ishmaelites and Edomites. Therefore, the Prophet, wishing to exclude such impostors from the company of the true heirs of Abraham, considers only those with pure and righteous hearts to be genuine Israelites, or those who honor God with sincerity. In essence, when I proclaim that God is kind to Israel, I do not refer to an Israelite who, merely satisfied with a superficial acknowledgment of God, claims the title falsely. Rather, I speak of the spiritual descendants of Abraham, whose hearts are sincere and who remain steadfast in their devotion to God. This is echoed in Christ’s words: This is truly an Israelite; in him, there is no deceit (John 1:47).

Ireneus (Orda)

19th centuryCommentator

This Psalm, which poses challenges for interpreters in both Hebrew and Greek versions, connects thematically with Psalms 36 and 48, and to some extent with Psalm 39. The psalmist grapples with a profound dilemma that frequently troubled the righteous of the Old Testament: how to reconcile the apparent prosperity of the wicked and the trials faced by the godly with the goodness and justice of God. The title of the psalm attributes it to Asaph; however, arguments suggesting its later composition or its connection to the Maccabean conflicts are not persuasive. The devout Israelite, in verses 1, 13, and 28, reflects on this issue during dire moments of hardship depicted in verses 14 and 26.

Read more (79 words)

This leads him to undergo a tumultuous battle between unwavering faith and deep-seated doubt regarding God’s goodness and righteousness. After this soul-searching, he emerges more firmly convinced that God remains benevolent toward His faithful, even when He seems to abandon them. In our psalm, he expresses the insights gained from his experiences during these trying times. The psalmist asserts in verse 1 his steadfast belief that God is indeed good to Israel, meaning to all sincere and devoted believers.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

The Psalm, inspired by the Holy Spirit and given to David, was entrusted to Asaph, the head of the singers, to be sung in his own voice for the encouragement of the gathered congregation before God. Its purpose is to alleviate their fears concerning the ungodly, who may prosper in this world with an abundance of earthly pleasures, and the faithful, who endure hardship and various trials, emphasizing that both have only a brief time here: the wicked for the enjoyment of earthly goods, and the righteous for their period of suffering. However, the ultimate fate of the wicked is eternal destruction, while the righteous shall experience everlasting joy.

As the feet move, the mind trembles in recognition of sin. Those who have begun to stumble should seek to avert their downfall through repentance, remembering to maintain hope in the compassion of the One who restores the fallen.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.