Augustine of Hippo
He did not declare, "He rejected the dwelling of Reuben, the firstborn of Jacob" (Genesis 49:3), nor did He dismiss those from Judah who were born before her. Thus, they were overlooked and not selected, while the tribe of Judah was chosen. It could be argued that their rejection was warranted since even in Jacob's blessing of his sons, he alludes to their transgressions (Genesis 49:5) and disdains them; although among them, the tribe of Levi was deemed worthy of the priestly honor, from which Moses descended (Exodus 2:1). Moreover, He did not state that the dwelling of Benjamin was rejected, nor did He overlook that tribe, from which Saul arose to kingship (1 Samuel 9:1).
Read more (225 words)
Given the proximity of the time when Saul was cast aside and David was anointed (1 Samuel 16:1), it may have been fitting to mention this. However, He specifically highlighted those distinguished by greater merit. For Joseph preserved his father and brothers during a famine in Egypt, and despite being wrongfully sold due to his virtue, chastity, and wisdom, he was justly elevated (Genesis 41:40). Likewise, Ephraim received preference over his older brother by the blessing of their grandfather Jacob. Yet, God still chose not to select the dwelling of Joseph, nor the tribe of Ephraim. Under these symbols of notable merit, we comprehend that all those with ancient greed, seeking earthly rewards from the Lord, are cast aside, and the tribe of Judah is not favored for the merits of Judah himself. While Joseph's merits are indeed significantly greater, the tribe of Judah was the lineage through which Christ was brought forth in the flesh. The Scriptures affirm that the new people of Christ surpass the old covenant community, and the Lord speaks in parables for their understanding. Additionally, on Mount Zion, which He chose, we discern the Church of Christ, not honoring God for the sake of temporal wealth, but rather, gazing with faith towards the eternal rewards that lie ahead; for Zion may also be understood as a place of divine vision.