The Church Fathers on this verse

Romans 9:27Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And Isaias cried out concerning Israel: If the number of the children of Israel be as the sand of the sea, a remnant shall be saved.

Douay-Rheims

ησαιας δε κραζει υπερ του ισραηλ εαν η ο αριθμος των υιων ισραηλ ως η αμμος της θαλασσης το καταλειμμα σωθησεται

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

10 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

"But Isaiah," Paul continues, "cries out concerning Israel," that is, he proclaims boldly and openly. Why, then, do you accuse us, when the prophets proclaim the same thing more loudly than a trumpet?

What does Isaiah cry? "Though the number of your people, O Israel, be as the sand of the sea, only a remnant will return" (Is 10:22).

Do you see that, according to Isaiah also, not all will be saved, but only those worthy of salvation? "I do not fear the multitude," God says, "nor does a race so greatly multiplied intimidate Me.

I save only those who prove worthy." The Prophet did not mention the sand of the sea without purpose, but reminded them of the Old Testament promise, of which they had made themselves unworthy.

Read more (71 words)

Why, then, are you troubled, claiming that the promise has been broken, when all the prophets declare that not all are saved? Then he speaks also about the manner of salvation.

Do you notice the precision of the Prophet and the prudence of the Apostle, who cites the most fitting testimony? It not only shows that not all will be saved, but some; it also adds how they will be saved.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

He was not content with pointing to Hosea, but also brings Isaiah as a witness. Isaiah proclaims, that is, boldly and fearlessly, that not all Israelites will be saved, but those worthy of salvation. This is what "the remnant" means: the elect, whom God left and set apart as worthy. By saying "as the sand of the sea," he reminds them of the Old Testament promise, of which they had become unworthy. Therefore do not be troubled, as though the promise had been broken. All the prophets foretell that not all are worthy of salvation.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Therefore, even if Israel was as numerous as the sand, "the remnant will be saved," as the Apostle cites Is 10:27. This means those justified through faith in Christ. This happened when God had mercy on them.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Paul shows that the Lord is the cornerstone, joining in Himself both walls. The testimony of the prophet Hosea speaks of the Gentiles: "I will call those who were not My people My people, and her who was not beloved, beloved."

The testimony of Isaiah speaks of Israel: "Only the remnant will be saved," so that all who believed in Christ might be reckoned as the seed of Abraham.

The Lord also unites the Gentiles. Concerning them He says in the Gospel that He has other sheep, which are not of this fold, and that He must bring them, so that there may be one flock and one Shepherd (Jn 10:16).

If the remnant mentioned here is to be understood not as the election of those justified, but as the election of those who are to be justified, then such election is truly hidden from us.

It cannot be known by us. We must regard all men as parts of the same mass of clay. If anyone claims to understand this, I confess my weakness concerning this problem.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

He also brings a testimony from Isaiah, to show clearly that their rejection had been indicated from the days of the prophets, when he said: "Though the number of the sons of Israel should be as the sand on the seashore, only a few of them will be saved," Is 10:22-23.

Ambrosiaster

4th centuryChurch Father

Paul speaks this way because Isaiah cried out about those who would believe in Christ, Ex 9:27. They are the true Israel. The others departed from the law because they did not believe in Him of Whom the law said that He alone is sufficient for salvation. Thus they became apostates. By not receiving Christ, they transgressed the law. Therefore Paul says that from this great multitude of Jews only those believers will be saved whom God knew would believe.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

The Apostle cited this testimony with particular appropriateness, making known that the God of all foresaw from the beginning both those who would approach faith and those sick with unbelief.

Since the Jews said that not many of them accepted the preaching, while all the rest fled from it as deception, he showed that this had been foretold of old.

Even if they surpass every number by their multitude and become like the sand of the sea, not all will obtain salvation, but only those adorned with faith.

For the Prophet called faith a shortened word. What the law taught by many commandments and could not provide as perfect salvation, the confession of Christ accomplished and bestowed faith.

Faith is shortened and has no need of lengthy circuits. It is judged by the disposition of the soul and is preached by the tongue.

Michail Cheraskov

19th centuryChurch Father

In the third point the Apostle introduces a new objection in this form: "You will say to me, 'Why does He still find fault?'" That is, why does God accuse and appoint to punishment those rejected by Him, such as Esau, Pharaoh, and the mass of the Hebrews?

If everything in the world is ordered according to His will, "who has resisted His will?" (Rom 9:19-29).

First the Apostle teaches that, properly speaking, man has no right to raise such questions, because of his nothingness before God. "But who are you, O man, to answer back to God?

Will the thing formed say to Him who formed it, 'Why have You made me thus?' Does not the potter have power over the clay, from the same lump to make one vessel for honor and another for dishonor?" (Rom 9:20-21).

Read more (84 words)

Likewise, can anyone complain when the all-knowing and just God manifests some men as "vessels of wrath prepared for destruction," such as the rejected Jews?

Over others He manifests the riches of His glory, as over "vessels of mercy, which He prepared beforehand for glory" (Rom 9:22-23). The Apostle adds that this means us, the chosen.

He says of us, "whom He called, not of the Jews only, but also of the Gentiles," in accordance with the prophecies of Hosea and Isaiah (Rom 9:24-29).

Nikanor (Kamenski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The calling of the Gentiles was also an act of God's predestination, expressed more than once through the prophets. This was especially so because of the impiety of the Hebrews, who became worse than the Gentiles.

Among the Gentiles, the better people always expressed dissatisfaction both with pagan beliefs and with pagan life. Many such people appeared especially in the last times of the ancient world.

This explains the rapid spread of Christianity among the Gentiles. The Hebrews, by contrast, departed ever further from the essence of the faith and from the right expectation of the Messiah.

Read more (361 words)

Yet for this reason the "remnant" among them was all the more worthy. For its sake the others were endured, although, according to Josephus, they were very unworthy of this because of their corruption.

Thus the addition to the "remnant" that was to be accomplished through the calling of the Gentiles became a kind of new ground for the rejection of the Hebrews.

Without them there was found that great "seed," like the sand of the sea, concerning which the promise had been given to Abraham.

Therefore the Apostle's main thought, for which he cites prophetic predictions about the salvation of the believing remnant and the calling of the Gentiles, aims to show something with still greater force.

God's promise cannot be considered unfulfilled merely because some Jews were not vouchsafed the spiritual blessings indicated in the promise to their fathers.

Those blessings were inherited in Christ by believing Jews and by Gentiles who turned to the Lord. According to Blessed Theodoret, "The Apostle brought forward these testimonies to make known that the God of all foresaw from the beginning both those who would approach faith and those sick with unbelief.

Since the Jews, unreasonable and blinded, said that few of them accepted the preaching, while all the rest fled from it as deception, he showed that this had been foretold of old.

Not all would obtain salvation, but only those adorned with faith." The indication of faith is seen in Isaiah's prophetic word: "a shortened word."

"The prophet called faith a shortened word. What the law taught by many commandments and could not grant as perfect salvation, the confession of Christ accomplished. Faith provided this.

Faith is shortened and has no need of lengthy circuits. It is judged by the disposition of the soul and preached by the tongue." "As Saint John Chrysostom says, it contains salvation in few words.

For the Apostle says, 'If you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved' (Rom 10:9)."

Why many Jews did not have saving faith, and were therefore rejected, the Apostle explains further on (Rom 9:30-10:21).

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

Isaiah also cries out concerning Israel. The prophecies cited above concern the reception of the Gentiles. As for the Jews, who are called Israel, although not all are Israel, Isaiah cries out concerning them as follows.

“He cries out,” that is, “he boldly and openly proclaims” (Chrysostom). He thereby shows that he speaks an undoubted and decisive truth, one of the highest importance for all.

What then does Isaiah cry? “Though the number of the children of Israel be as the sand of the sea, the remnant shall be saved.” Looking directly at these words, everyone sees that no prophecy could be more definite. Not all Israelites will enter the saving inheritance of the promise.

Read more (934 words)

“Remnant” means few, as we also often say, “these are remnants,” meaning a small part of the whole. Therefore Chrysostom, turning to his hearers, says with feeling: “Do you see that, according to Isaiah, not all are saved, but those worthy to be saved? I do not fear the multitude, says God. I am not alarmed by such multiplication of the race. I save only those who prove worthy of it. Why then are you troubled, calling the promise broken, when the Prophets declare that not all will be saved?”

If we examine this prophecy in the place where Isaiah uttered it, it gives no different thought. In chapter 10, Saint Isaiah speaks of the Assyrian people. They were appointed to be God’s scourge against the impious and lawless.

They would indeed strike them and seize the lands beyond Babylon, Arabia, Damascus, that is Syria, Samaria, and Jerusalem, that is Palestine. But when Assyria had accomplished this work of God, it too would be punished.

It would be punished because it became proud of its successes and ascribed them to its own wisdom and strength. For this the Lord would bring dishonor upon its honor, and a burning fire upon its glory. Everything would be taken from it.

Then the sons of Jacob who remained after its blow would no longer trust in it. They would not turn their eyes to it, expecting thereby to be delivered from final destruction. Rather, they would trust truly in God, the Holy One of Israel.

“And the remnant of Jacob shall return to the mighty God” (Is 10:21). After these words come the words cited by the Apostle (see Is 10:22-23), namely, that only the remnant shall be saved.

At first it may seem that, in the Prophet, these words refer to the Israelites’ return from captivity. Indeed, not all returned. Those who did return came back by turning to the mighty God, from whom they no longer fell away to foreign gods.

Yet even if the prophetic words are understood this way, they could still be cited to confirm that not all will be saved in the Lord and Savior. They could be cited precisely as a prediction of this latter event.

For the return of the Israelites from captivity was a type of the return of mankind from spiritual captivity, accomplished by Christ the Lord. Types had predictive significance. Therefore everything said of the first may be referred to the latter as a prophetic prediction.

But if we look more closely at the course of the Prophet’s speech, we come to this thought. Here he points directly to what was fulfilled over Israel in Christ Jesus.

Let everyone consider why the Prophet needed again to repeat the word about the salvation of only a remnant. He had just said, “The remnant of Jacob shall return to God.”

There was no other reason than this. Using the occasion, he wished to transfer his hearers’ thoughts to the distant future, when the remnant would be saved not in type, but in reality.

Therefore, instead of saying, “the remnant shall return,” he said, “shall be saved.” By this he recalls the awaited Savior and Deliverer.

The structure of the Prophet’s speech directly suggests that he wished to say something particular here. This is especially suggested by the words, “for He is completing and cutting short the word,” and so forth (see Is 10:23).

Here we see the same thing that often occurs in the Psalms. The holy prophet David, while singing to God on the occasion of current events, was often caught up by the prophetic Spirit.

He was lifted to contemplate what was to be in the awaited Savior. Suddenly he uttered words that can be understood only when referred to the Savior.

The same occurs here. The Prophet mentioned the return to God of the remnant of Jacob after his sons had been struck by the Assyrians.

Then he was carried by the prophetic spirit to the ordering of salvation in the person of the awaited Deliverer. He foresaw that then also not all, but only some, would enter the inheritance of salvation.

Therefore he said, “Though the people of Israel,” that is, “the number of the children of Israel, be as the sand of the sea, their remnant shall be saved” (Is 10:22).

It is as though he said, “There will yet be another time when something similar will be repeated.” Those who heard the Prophet’s word might not at once understand when this would be or what the Prophet wished to suggest.

But later this had to become clear to them, especially after the “remnant of Jacob” (Is 10:21) actually returned to the mighty God during the return from captivity.

As already noted, the return from captivity was the clearest type of that deliverance from captivity which the awaited Deliverer was to accomplish. In the attention of true Israelites, the latter was always contemplated in the former.

Consequently, they also contemplated that only the remnant would be saved. By citing this passage, the Apostle said nothing that could trouble a reasonable Israelite.

Blessed Theodoret writes: “The Apostle cited this testimony with special aptness. He made known that the God of all foresaw from the beginning both those who would come to faith and those sick with unbelief. For the Jews, the unreasonable and blinded, said that few of them had received the preaching, while all the rest fled from it as deception. Therefore he showed that this had been foretold from of old. Not all would obtain salvation, but only those adorned with faith.”

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 21 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ἠσαΐας
    ēsaias
    Isaiah
    G2268 · Ἡσαΐας
  2. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. κράζει
    krazei
    I cry aloud
    G2896 · κράζω
  4. ὑπὲρ
    hyper
    in behalf of
    G5228 · ὑπέρ
  5. τοῦ
    tou
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  6. Ἰσραήλ
    israēl
    Israel
    G2474 · Ἰσραήλ
  7. Ἐὰν
    ean
    if
    G1437 · ἐάν
  8. ᾖ
    ē
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  9. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  10. ἀριθμὸς
    arithmos
    a number
    G706 · ἀριθμός
  11. τῶν
    tōn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  12. υἱῶν
    huiōn
    a son
    G5207 · υἱός
  13. Ἰσραὴλ
    israēl
    Israel
    G2474 · Ἰσραήλ
  14. ὡς
    hōs
    as
    G5613 · ὡς
  15. ἡ
    hē
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  16. ἄμμος
    ammos
    sand
    G285 · ἄμμος
  17. τῆς
    tēs
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  18. θαλάσσης
    thalassēs
    the sea
    G2281 · θάλασσα
  19. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  20. ὑπόλειμμα
    hypoleimma
    a vestige
    G9577 · ὑπόλειμμα
  21. σωθήσεται
    sōthēsetai
    I save
    G4982 · σῴζω