The Church Fathers on this verse

1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 1:21Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And Elcana, her husband, went up, and all his house, to offer to the Lord the solemn sacrifice, and his vow.

Douay-Rheims

וַיַּ֛עַל הָאִ֥ישׁ אֶלְקָנָ֖ה וְכָל־בֵּית֑וֹ לִזְבֹּ֧חַ לַֽיהוָ֛ה אֶת־זֶ֥בַח הַיָּמִ֖ים וְאֶת־נִדְרֽוֹ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

One Church Father comments on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

If I am not perceived as bothersome, I would like to revisit the topic I have shared with you. I will draw your attention to Anna and dedicate this discussion to the meadow of her virtues, a meadow not adorned with transient flowers, but filled with prayer, faith, and profound patience. These qualities are far more fragrant than the blossoms of spring, nourished not by flowing streams, but by the refreshing rains of tears. It is not merely the waters that cause gardens to flourish; rather, the currents of tears nurture the fruit of prayer, helping it to reach its fullest maturity. This was true for this woman. As soon as she uttered her heartfelt words, her prayer ascended to heaven and bore the blessed fruit, Samuel.

Read more (1410 words)

Let us not feel troubled if we revisit this subject; we shall not repeat ourselves but will instead present something new and refreshing. Just as different dishes can be created from a single table, so various beautiful objects can be fashioned from a single piece of gold. The material may be uniform, but the artistry is rich and innovative. If earthly things can be so diverse, how much more abundant is the grace of the Spirit? To illustrate this diversity, listen to Paul as he writes: “To one by the Spirit is given the message of wisdom, to another the message of knowledge... to another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing... But all these are the work of one and the same Spirit, and He distributes them to each one, just as He determines” (1 Corinthians 12:8-11). This shows the multitude of gifts. The rivers are many, yet the Source is one; the offerings may vary, but the Giver remains unchanged. Therefore, let us not lose heart. We observed her initial barrenness; we witnessed her transformation into a mother; we shared in her tears and now we partake in her joy. We sorrowed with her then; let us rejoice with her now, as Paul instructed - to celebrate with those who are joyful and mourn with those who weep (Romans 12:15). This principle applies not only to contemporaries but also to those of the past.

Do not wonder what value it brings to recall Anna. Those without children can learn to become mothers, while mothers can discern the best ways to nurture their offspring. Husbands, too, will gain significantly from this account, understanding how to treat their wives with kindness, even when confronted with the challenge of infertility, just as Elkanah treated Anna. Moreover, a greater truth emerges: all parents should raise their children in fervor for God. Thus, let us not view this story as trivial, as it does not promise worldly wealth. Instead, consider it valuable precisely because it does not offer gold or silver, but something profoundly more significant—spiritual devotion and heavenly treasures that guide us in overcoming adversities. Financial help can come from men, yet transforming our nature and alleviating sorrow is the work of the Creator alone. If you suffered from an ailment deemed incurable and sought relief throughout the city, exhaustively spending and consulting numerous physicians without finding a cure, and then encountered someone healed of the same affliction, would you not urgently plead with her to reveal her healer? Now, as Anna stands before us recounting her suffering and, without hesitation, directing us to the Healer, will you not approach and seek His aid? What more could you ask for? Many have traversed vast oceans and undertaken arduous journeys seeking physicians far away, uncertain of their healing. And you, woman, need not embark on any voyage; there is no need to step beyond your threshold. In the very comfort of your home, you can converse directly with the Physician, who assures us: “I am God who draws near... and not God from afar” (Jeremiah 23:23). Why, then, do you hesitate? What excuse can you offer? How will you justify your inaction when a straightforward and convenient path to your healing is at hand, yet you remain indifferent? For this Healer can remedy not only barrenness but every ailment of body and soul, if He desires. Astonishingly, He heals not through labor, cost, or pain—His mere command brings forth restoration. Unlike other physicians who apply instruments of pain, He need only offer a gentle touch to lift away every sorrow and affliction that plagues us.

Let us not linger or tarry, even if poor. Poverty does not preclude tender care. This Physician requires no monetary fee but seeks tears, prayers, and genuine faith. Come to Him with these, and you will undoubtedly receive your requests and depart with joy. This is surely evidenced in many accounts, and Anna's story serves as a powerful example: when she approached with prayer, faith, and tears instead of gold or silver, she received what she sought and left fulfilled. Therefore, it is wrong to think that this narrative holds no significance for us. “These things were written for our learning, that through endurance we may find hope” (Romans 15:4). Let us reflect on how she overcame her trials, what actions she took post-deliverance, and how she embraced the gift from God. “And the woman conceived,” as Scripture states, “and nourished Samuel with milk.” Notice how she regarded this child, not merely as her son but as an offering. Her love for him was twofold—natural and spiritual. Indeed, she honored him rightly! If those who prepare gold vessels to present to God do not treat them as ordinary items, but with reverence, how much more sacred must Anna have viewed her child prior to presenting him in the temple? Her love for him surpassed that of an ordinary mother; she cherished him as an offering, seeking to sanctify herself through him. Her household became a sacred space, housing both a prophet and a priest. Her devotion is evident not just in her promise to dedicate him, but in her careful approach; she did not dare enter the temple without the gift in hand: “I will not go up until the young child is with me; and when I have brought him, I will appear before the Lord and remain there forever” (1 Samuel 1:22). Observe the reverence—she felt it unsafe to leave him behind or to go before the Lord without her blessing. Consequently, she delayed her journey until she could present the gift.

When at last she brought him to the temple, the child, taken from his mother's breast, did not long for her comforting presence. In a remarkable display of grace, though separated from his mother, he turned his gaze toward the Lord who had made her his mother. Likewise, Anna did not mourn their parting. The grace connecting them surpassed the bond of nature, creating a sense of unity beyond physical presence. Much like a vine rooted in one place yet reaching out broadly, Anna remained in the city while extending her love to the temple, where she placed her treasured cluster. The distance mattered not, for God’s love ensured their connection. Though young, Samuel exhibited extraordinary virtue, serving as a guide in piety for all who visited the temple. When they learned of his miraculous birth, they discovered the hope instilled by God; no one left untouched, but all praised Him who had gifted this child beyond expectations. Thus, God delayed Anna's childbirth to amplify her joy and extend her glory. Those who bore witness to her suffering recognized the grace of God surging forth. Her ongoing barrenness made her more known to many, leading them all to rejoice and offer thanksgiving for her experience.

I share these insights so that we, upon seeing righteous women endure similar challenges, might not grieve, complain, or question: “Why has God overlooked such a virtuous woman, denying her a child?” No—the Lord does not scorn but understands what is truly best for us. Anna brought her lamb to the temple, offering her son as she planted a rose in the garden—a rose devoid of thorns, eternal in bloom, reaching toward heaven, whose sweetness knows no bounds even today. The passage of time has not diminished the fragrance of her virtues; this is the nature of spiritual gifts. Just as diligent cultivators first sow seeds, knowing they will one day thrive, so did Anna take the child, who was miraculously conceived, and entrust him to the temple, where he could grow nourished by divine waters. There, we witness the fulfillment of David’s prophetic words: “Blessed is the man who does not walk in the counsel of the wicked, nor stand in the path of sinners, nor sit in the seat of the scornful. But his delight is in the law of the Lord, and in His law he meditates day and night. He shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of water, that brings forth its fruit in its season” (Psalm 1:1-3). Samuel did not learn to turn from evil after experiencing adversity; rather, he chose righteousness from the very beginning. He shunned wicked counsel and was nurtured instead by his mother’s influence and then was reared on spiritual truths, maturing swiftly in his devotion, continually sustained by the living Word of God.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.