The Church Fathers on this verse

Amos 6:5Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

You that sing to the sound of the psaltery: they have thought themselves to have instruments of music like David;

Douay-Rheims

הַפֹּרְטִ֖ים עַל־פִּ֣י הַנָּ֑בֶל כְּדָוִ֕יד חָשְׁב֥וּ לָהֶ֖ם כְּלֵי־שִֽׁיר׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

5 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 6 commentaries

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Observe the careful nature of the statements: after admonishing them for their excessive eating and drinking, he added, “as standing and not as running,” indicating that the pleasure derived from food and wine is confined merely to the throat and mouth—it does not extend beyond that. Such pleasure is fleeting and ephemeral, whereas the sorrow that can stem from it is persistent and unending. He recognized this through experience, as they viewed everything “as standing,” meaning enduring, “and not as fleeing,” signifying that it departs and never halts momentarily. This reflects the essence of all that is human and worldly: as soon as it emerges, it swiftly departs.

Read more (235 words)

This is the nature of earthly enjoyment, the fleeting accolades and might of humanity, the treasures, and the overall success of this present life; it possesses nothing lasting, nothing enduring, nothing substantial, but rather slips away like rushing water, leaving those who grasp it empty and forlorn. Conversely, the spiritual realm stands distinct: it is steadfast and unyielding, impervious to change, and endures forever. How foolish it would be to exchange the firm for the ever-changing, the eternal for the temporary, and the source of profound joy in the age to come for that which leads to severe distress. With this understanding, dear friends, as we hold our salvation dear, let us turn away from fruitless and destructive pleasures; let us embrace fasting and other forms of virtue, prompt a significant transformation in our lives, and diligently pursue good deeds each day. Thus, throughout this holy season, having cultivated a spiritual harvest and amassed great virtues, we may be granted the privilege to approach the day of the Lord with confidence, ready to partake in the solemn and spiritual feast, to share in the indescribable and everlasting blessings with a pure heart, and to be filled with divine grace, through the prayers and intercession of those who have served Christ our God, who is compassionate toward humanity, to whom be all glory, power, and honor, now and forever, and unto the ages of ages. Amen.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Woe to those who rest upon beds made from elephant bones and engage in both these practices. A stern admonishment is directed toward those in Samaria, who, because of their noble status and abundant resources, indulged excessively in joy and pleasure. They were oblivious to any impending calamity and failed to consider that the Almighty might harbor anger toward those living such lifestyles and deliver punishment upon sinners. He elaborates on their indulgence and excess: they possess lavish ivory beds, enjoy choice lambs and milk-fed calves for nourishment, and their gatherings are filled with songs, performances, and various forms of entertainment, alongside revelry and splashing. Yet, what is even more alarming is that they viewed these vile acts as established rather than transient.

Read more (250 words)

Indeed, these fleeting worldly pleasures lack permanence, vanishing like shadows, and it is written that 'the image of this world passes away' (1 Cor. 7:31); with the death of individuals, so too does pleasure come to an end.

In the case of the Samaritans, the message can be understood in another light. As they were soon to face captivity, what they imagined as joyful recreation was, in truth, fleeting and hollow, for it would soon vanish. They revel in games of spear-throwing and partake in exquisite, aromatic wine, adorning themselves with fragrant myrrh to enhance their appearance, all while disregarding the impending destruction of Joseph. Though they were forewarned about the forthcoming downfall of Samaria and the eventual devastation of Joseph, they clung to their habitual pleasures. It becomes evident that it is perilous for those in positions of authority over cities or nations to succumb to physical gratification. Rather, their focus should be on seeking beneficial objectives, guiding their charges toward their responsibilities, and striving to appease the wrathful God. Is it not utterly foolish to immerse themselves in indulgence while disregarding the grave consequences of carnal desires? Concerning such individuals, the holy prophet declares: 'O shepherds who destroy and scatter the sheep of My pasture' (Jeremiah 23:1)! And the negligence of those shepherds endangers their flocks; God's words further confirm this reality: 'For the shepherds are become brutish, and have not sought the Lord: therefore they shall not understand, and all their flock shall be scattered' (Jeremiah 10:21).

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Like David, who was inspired by the Spirit to play the strings, they create instruments for themselves to use in their ecstatic celebrations. Those who partake in refined wine remain indifferent to the suffering of the broken-hearted Joseph, focused solely on their amusement, unwilling to reflect on the trials of his captivity. In another light, the prophet admonishes them for their insatiable desire for pleasure, pointing out that, while they are engrossed in their entertainments, they remain unmoved by the plight of the impoverished, symbolized by Joseph, who suffered rejection from his own kin as the destitute do. Furthermore, those who indulge in refined wine represent those who grasp the significance of the Divine Scriptures but neglect to safeguard the lives of the common people. The initial voices are those spiritual leaders who, despite their knowledge of the Scriptures, remain shackled by sin and fail to live out the teachings they impart to others.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Travel over to Halan and take a look, then proceed onward to Emath the great, and descend to Geth of the Philistines, to examine the finest of their realms: are their boundaries broader than yours? You who are designated for the day of calamity and approach the throne of wickedness; you who recline on beds of ivory and lounge about: you indulge in the finest lambs of the flock and the choicest calves of the herd, and you make music to the sound of stringed instruments, believing yourselves to be master musicians like David: you drink wine from large vessels, anoint yourselves with the finest oils, and remain completely indifferent to Joseph's misery.

Read more (886 words)

House of Israel, traverse all of Halan, which is now known as Ctesiphon, and observe everything. Who are these? Those mentioned earlier, ‘the nobles, leaders of the nations, and the wealthy in Zion, those who find hope in the mountain of Samaria.’ Therefore, go to the heart of Jerseia and survey diligently, then travel on to Emath the great, now identified as Antioch. The term great is used in contrast to the lesser Emath, which is associated with the Epiphany. For those journeying to Mesopotamia, the first stop is called ‘Emmas,’ a name that, despite its modification, retains traces of its original designation, while the nearby region is known as ‘Reblatha,’ where the sons of Zedekiah, king of the Jews, met their demise in the presence of Nebuchadnezzar, and his own eyes were blinded (4 Sam. 25).

‘And go down,’ it continues, ‘to Geth of the Philistines.’ You who dwell on Mount Zion and Mount Samaria, descend to the Philistines situated in the plains, and to all their finest kingdoms, which include notable cities such as Gaza, Ascalon, Azotus, and Akkaron, and ascertain whether their boundaries are greater than yours. Are you of the people of Israel, set apart for a day of suffering—specifically the day of captivity—and are you approaching the throne of lawlessness, the king of Babylon? While this fate approaches, you remain reclined on beds of ivory, comfortably ensconced in indulgence.

Your feasting is not to quell hunger but to indulge in pleasure, extravagantly preparing the tenderest cuts from herds for your gluttony; it seems never enough for your lasciviousness. You take delight in the music from flutes and lyres, and where David served God (1 Chron. 23-26) by organizing choirs of Levites, you partake only for your own enjoyment. You drink wine not to quench your thirst, but to satiate your spiritual cravings, and you adorn yourselves with the richest ointments, neglecting the sufferings of those around you.

The prophet Ezekiel expresses this sentiment with the metaphor of shepherds who consume the milk of the sheep, clothe themselves in wool, and devour the best parts, yet they do not heal the broken or seek out the lost (Ezekiel 34:3-4). Let us apply what has been discussed in a historical context to the darker allegorical interpretation.

O house of Israel, you who have strayed from Me and placed your faith in the mountain of Samaria, regard the many fortified walls, for this signifies Emath Rabbah. From there, quietly descend into the pit of those who, inebriated, collapse—Geth and the Philistines symbolize this pit. Consider all the best cities in all kingdoms and reflect on whether their limitations surpass your own.

If we contemplate the philosophy of nations such as the Egyptians, Indians, and Persians, we observe that their borders are already within the scope of Scripture, for ‘their voice has gone out into all the earth, and their words to the ends of the world’ (Psalm 18:5). From what vices are those instructed above—‘house of Israel, pass over all and see’—commanded to advance to better things? This is clarified in the following words: ‘you who come to the evil day,’ preparing for a day of reckoning through your sins—not in the sense that an evil day exists outside of one's own making, but that each individual cultivates their own misfortune, in line with Ecclesiastes, “Do not say, ‘Why were the former days better than these?’ For you do not inquire wisely concerning this” (Eccl. 7:11); it is folly to reference times when you have the power to shape the day into good or ill.

These are those who approach and touch the false Sabbaths. Just as there are both physical and spiritual circumcisions among Jews, with one being rejected and the other embraced, there are Sabbaths that are pure and grounded in truth, and there are other Sabbaths—false Sabbaths, steeped in emptiness. The subsequent phrase, ‘sleep on beds of ivory,’ illustrates that a true servant of the Lord, preparing for the battle against adversaries, sleeps on the bare ground, following the example of Jacob (Gen. 28), using a stone—once rejected by builders, but now the cornerstone (Luke 20:17)—as a pillow.

In contrast, those who indulge in sensual pleasures, who act solely for the gratification of their desires, rest on beds made of ivory, their comfort derived from the remains of unclean creatures, becoming entrapped by the allure of their vices that seem beautiful in this moment. They do not consume simple and nutritious fare characteristic of wrestlers, which strengthens those committed to the fight; instead, they indulge in delicacies—lambs and tender calves, oftentimes fattened on milk, as inferred from the word μοσχάρια γαλαθηνά.

They become entranced by music from the psaltery, pursuing pleasure alone, neglecting any undertaking that does not serve their desires. Yet let not the discerning reader rush to dismiss our interpretation by referencing Scripture’s praises of creation and unity in worship (Psalms 98:7, 46:2, 80:1); these affirm not applause for mere entertainment but collective glorification of God. The subsequent remark, ‘they thought them as steady, not as fleeing,’ contrasts with the original Hebrew, which speaks of them believing they had instruments like those of David.

It appears that the translators added this nuance while illustrating pleasure, inferring judgment on such vices, rather than providing a straightforward translation of the original.

The lengthy discourse on the contributions and omissions made by the Seventy illustrates a complex history, marked in church manuscripts with symbols and signs. It is common for Jews to mockingly respond when they hear us read Isaiah: "Blessed is he that hath a tribe in Zion, and yuzhiks in Jerusalem" (Isaiah 31:9) and in Amos, "'as if they were standing me, and not as if they were running away'" (Am. 6:5). These are indeed eloquent expressions reminiscent of classical rhetoric. Yet, we face the challenge of ensuring our texts align with the authentic versions, which do not contain these phrases, revealing that to encapsulate all these variations would necessitate an endless array of writings.

Read more (197 words)

Furthermore, the multitude of omissions in the Seventy can be identified through the previously mentioned markings or through careful comparison with ancient translations. Nevertheless, the translation of the Seventy has rightfully been held in esteem within the churches, not only for being the earliest version created prior to Christ's arrival but also for its use by the apostles, who found it consistent with Hebrew texts. In contrast, the proselyte translator Aquila, who sought to render not just the words but the etymological nuances as well, is justly overlooked. For instance, how could anyone understand terms like χέυμα, όπωρισμόν, and στελπνότητα – which convey pouring, gathering fruit, and shining – instead of the familiar symbols of bread, wine, and oil? The Hebrew language possesses not only articles but also precursors, and Aquila’s misguided zeal leads him to translate both syllables and letters awkwardly, as seen in his phrase "σύν τόν όυρανόν και σύν τήν γήν," which fails to resonate in Greek and Latin. We can observe a wealth of elegant Greek expressions that fall short when translated literally into Latin and vice versa, where phrases that are effective in our language may falter if directly rendered in theirs.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

They appeared as if standing rather than in motion. They experienced no pain amidst the brokenness of Isiphas. They boldly committed such wrongs and faced them without remorse. The prophet referred to them as Joseph, since Ephraim was Joseph's son, and he designates the ten tribes as Ephraim.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.