Augustine of Hippo
When discussing the deceit of the midwives who misled Pharaoh to spare the newborn Israelite boys by claiming that Hebrew women deliver more quickly than Egyptian women, there arises a question of whether this falsehood was sanctioned by Divine approval. The Scriptures indicate that God showed favor to the midwives, but it remains uncertain if He pardoned their deception out of compassion or regarded the falsehood itself as commendable. While the midwives acted rightly by saving lives, their deceit directed at Pharaoh complicates the issue. The act of preserving life reflects mercy, yet their untruth served self-interest to evade Pharaoh's ire, which lacks true commendation, although it may be forgiven.
Read more (160 words)
It seems inappropriate, therefore, to justify lying to those described as having no deceit in their mouths (Rev. 14:5). The lives of individuals distant from the holiness of the saints may include such sinful behavior as lying; they follow their natural inclinations, particularly if they are yet to learn to seek heavenly blessings and are focused solely on earthly pursuits. Conversely, those whose citizenship is in heaven, as the apostle states, should not shape their speech like that of the midwives, attempting to communicate truth while evading falsehood. This matter warrants deeper exploration with further examples from Scripture.
Lying may often be utilized for one's benefit or safety, motivated by compassion, as demonstrated by the midwives in Exodus who spoke untruths to protect the children of Israel from death. However, it is not the act of lying itself that is admirable but rather the underlying intention. One who resorts to such deception may ultimately be granted freedom from all lies.