Augustine of Hippo
When discussing the deceit of the midwives who misled Pharaoh to prevent the slaughter of newborn Israelite boys by claiming that Hebrew women gave birth unlike Egyptian women, a question arises about the Divine judgment on such deception. It is recorded that God favored the midwives, leading to the inquiry of whether He pardoned their falsehood out of grace or deemed the deception itself deserving of commendation. While the midwives acted justly in safeguarding the lives of infants, their lies to Pharaoh were a different matter. Their act of preserving life was merciful, but their motivation for lying stemmed from self-preservation, which is objectionable, though potentially pardonable.
Read more (185 words)
Thus, one might argue that it is inappropriate to deceive those characterized as having, “in their mouth no deceit” (Rev 14:5). The lives of certain individuals differ greatly from those of the saints if they are tainted by the sin of lying; they often live according to carnal desires, particularly if they have not yet come to expect Divine blessings and are preoccupied with worldly concerns. Those who, as the Apostle states, have their citizenship in heaven should not mold their speech like that of the midwives, even when attempting to communicate the truth and avoid falsehood. This topic merits deeper exploration using additional Scriptural instances.
Deception may sometimes be employed for the sake of one's salvation or welfare, not for malicious intent, but rather from compassion, as illustrated in the account of the midwives in Exodus who misled Pharaoh to protect the lives of the Israelite children. Nevertheless, the merit lies not in the act of lying but rather in the underlying inclination, for those who resort to such lies with the intent of goodness may eventually be honored with deliverance from all falsehood.