The Church Fathers on this verse

Genesis 8:21Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And the Lord smelled a sweet savour, and said: I will no more curse the earth for the sake of man: for the imagination and thought of man's heart are prone to evil from his youth: therefore I will no more destroy every living soul as I have done.

Douay-Rheims

וַיָּ֣רַח יְהוָה֮ אֶת־רֵ֣יחַ הַנִּיחֹחַ֒ וַיֹּ֨אמֶר יְהוָ֜ה אֶל־לִבּ֗וֹ לֹֽא־אֹ֠סִף לְקַלֵּ֨ל ע֤וֹד אֶת־הָֽאֲדָמָה֙ בַּעֲב֣וּר הֽ͏ָאָדָ֔ם כִּ֠י יֵ֣צֶר לֵ֧ב הָאָדָ֛ם רַ֖ע מִנְּעֻרָ֑יו וְלֹֽא־אֹסִ֥ף ע֛וֹד לְהַכּ֥וֹת אֶת־כָּל־חַ֖י כּֽ͏ַאֲשֶׁ֥ר עָשִֽׂיתִי׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

9 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Observe how the sacrifice's aroma transformed the smoke, banishing all unpleasantness associated with the burning of the animals. This is precisely what Paul conveyed in his epistle: 'For we are Christ's fragrance to God in those who are being saved and in those who are perishing: to some an odor deadly to death, and to others an odor life-giving to life' (2 Cor. 2:15-16). The expression refers to a 'pleasing aroma' perceived by the Lord. Do not be misled by the coarseness of the term; recognize that the weakness of humanity prompts such language and comprehend that the offering of a righteous individual was indeed acceptable to God. We can experience that the Lord requires nothing for Himself; He accepted Noah's sacrifice not out of necessity but to inspire mankind to express gratitude.

Read more (1107 words)

Thus, the complete consumption of the offerings through fire was permitted, allowing the offerers to understand that these acts were ultimately for their own benefit.

Why, then, does He permit sacrifices to be made to Him? Once again, it is because He accommodates human frailty. As humanity gradually succumbed to indifference, turning to the invention of idols and offering sacrifices to them, God first permitted that they offer their sacrifices to Him, aiming to redirect those entrenched in wickedness away from destructive errors. This concession becomes more evident when we consider how He later established circumcision—not as a means of salvation, but so that the Jews might bear it as a sign and seal of their gratitude, thus maintaining their separation from the Gentiles. This is why the blessed Paul referred to circumcision as a sign, stating, 'And the sign of circumcision he received as a seal of righteousness' (Rom. 4:11).

The notion that it serves any justifying purpose is refuted by Noah, who achieved such virtue long before circumcision was instituted. Moreover, even Abraham, prior to the establishment of circumcision, was justified solely by faith. The Scripture attests to this: 'Abraham believed God, and it was accounted to him for righteousness' (Rom. 4:3). To you, O Jew, who takes pride in circumcision, remember there were many righteous individuals before your time. Consider Abel, who offered a sacrifice by faith, as Paul notes, 'By faith Abel offered a better sacrifice to God than Cain' (Heb. 11:4); Enoch, who was taken up; and Noah, who was spared from the cataclysmic flood due to his righteousness. Even Abraham, before circumcision, was honored for his faith. Thus, throughout history, salvation has come to humanity through faith alone.

For this reason, the loving God permitted sacrifices to be made to Him, allowing those who were less perfect at the time to express their gratitude and distance themselves from the allure of idolatry. If many failed to escape ruin even with this leniency, who could have avoided such grave errors without it? 'And the Lord smelled a pleasant fragrance,' yet such was not the case for the ungrateful Jews. How so? Listen as the prophet explains, 'Smoking is an abomination to Me' (Isaiah 1:13), indicating the impurity of the inner state of the offerers. Here, as the virtue of the righteous transformed smoke and stench into a pleasing aroma, the wickedness of the offerers rendered even fragrant incense repulsive. Therefore, let us strive to maintain pure intentions in all our actions, as this is the foundation of all good. The Lord focuses not merely on our sacrifices but on the inner spirit with which they are offered, determining their acceptance or rejection based on that disposition.

Whether we pray, fast, or give to those in need—our spiritual sacrifices—we must approach all with a pure heart so that we may be rewarded for our efforts. It would be quite unusual to endure hardship only to lose our reward, especially if our virtuous acts are not aligned with God's commandments. Indeed, due to God's ineffable mercy, one might even receive a reward for their good disposition, even absent concrete deeds. For instance, when you observe someone in distress in the marketplace and feel compassion, directing your thoughts towards Heaven and expressing gratitude for your own circumstances as well as for the endurance of that poor soul, though you may not fulfill their physical needs, you shall nonetheless receive a full reward for your good intent. This is why the Lord declared, 'And whoever gives one of these little ones a cup of cold water in the name of a disciple, truly I say to you, will not lose his reward' (Matthew 10:42). What could be simpler than offering a cup of cold water? Yet the good intention behind it carries significant merit.

It is my duty to communicate this to you, dear friends, so that you may cultivate a pure heart within yourselves. Remember the words of Christ: 'Anyone who looks at a woman with lust has already committed adultery with her in his heart' (Matthew 5:28). Here again, we see condemnation of impure intentions, emphasizing that the mere immodest gaze bears the weight of actual sin. Thus, let us guard carefully the purity of our hearts, so our offerings may be pleasing to God. If the righteousness of Noah made the smoke and stench a fragrance, how much more will our pure dispositions enrich our spiritual sacrifices and gain us favor in Heaven? 'And the Lord smelled,' the Scriptures say, 'a pleasant fragrance.' Observe how a righteous man's sacrifice, though seemingly insignificant, becomes immensely valuable through the purity of his heart.

Consider the boundless goodness of our compassionate Lord. 'And the Lord said in His heart, I will no more curse the earth for man's sake, because the thoughts of man's heart are evil from his youth; neither will I smite any more all that live, as I have done: henceforth all the days of the earth' (Gen. 8:21, 22). Reflect on the extraordinary significance of divine benevolence, the depth of humanity, and the unparalleled kindness in His words, 'the Lord said in His heart.' This expression is a condescension to our human nature. God had once cursed the earth on account of humanity’s transgressions, proclaiming, 'Thorns and thistles shall it produce for you' (Gen. 3:18), and further cursing it for Cain. Yet now, following such widespread destruction, and wishing to comfort Noah, lest he despair over the futility of divine blessings amid past calamities, the Lord reassures him in His infinite compassion: 'I will not curse the earth for man anymore.'

This acknowledgment clearly indicates that the initial curse was rooted in human wickedness. For clarity, He emphasizes He makes this proclamation not due to any improvement in mankind, stating, 'Because the thought of man's heart is evil from his youth.' What astounding mercy! As understanding of humanity's persistent inclination towards evil leads Him to declare, 'I will curse the ground no more.' Though He has performed great deeds of judgment, seeing that malice continues to thrive, He promises never again to curse the earth.

Furthermore, wishing to exhibit the depth of His compassion, He adds, 'And I will no more smite all that live, as I have done: henceforth all the days of the earth.' Here God grants immense comfort, not only to Noah, the righteous man, but to all of humanity descended from him. His statements, 'I will no longer afflict all living things,' and 'henceforth, all the days of the earth,' indicate that there will never again be a flood of such magnitude nor a universal destruction of creation.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Upon emerging from the ark with his family and all who had taken refuge within it, Noah observed the land liberated from the waters. In response, he promptly erected an altar and sought to offer sacrifices of both clean animals and birds, expressing what I believe to be gratitude to God for his deliverance. Likewise, the Lord Jesus became our High Priest, granting us ‘access to the Father’ (Eph. 2:18) and restoring us to our original state, free from the curse that was placed upon humanity—this will be further elaborated upon. Consequently, as Christ took on the role of our Shepherd, we were led by Him into the sweet aroma of worship (2 Cor. 2:15) before God the Father.

Read more (65 words)

We have been abundantly blessed with His favor and hold the steadfast assurance that death will no longer hold dominion over us. The consequences of divine judgment have also been lifted, abolishing the weight of that ancient curse. We are blessed in Christ, through whom and with whom all glory is given to God the Father, along with the Holy Spirit, forever and ever. Amen.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

The Lord did not take notice of the aroma from the meat offerings or the smoke of the wood, but He beheld the sincerity of heart in the one who made sacrifices to Him from all things and for all things. The Lord God conveyed to Noah the message that he longed to hear: ‘Due to your righteousness, the rest of creation is safeguarded and will not be lost in the floodwaters; and because of your offering, given from all beings and for all beings, I will not again bring a flood upon the earth.’ God essentially commits Himself to the assurance that He will refrain from sending another flood upon humanity, even if they again pursue the wicked inclinations that are constantly inclined toward evil.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

Let us reflect more deeply on the reason behind the statement that the Lord, after contemplation, declared He would no longer curse the ground for mankind's sake, acknowledging that the inclinations of the human heart are wicked from an early age. God resolved not to afflict humanity any longer as He had done throughout history. His discipline of the human race served to instill reverence and understanding, fostering growth rather than altering the essence of individuals—a transformation that may happen in some, but not all. Thus, God chastised us to evoke fear, yet offered forgiveness for the sake of life; His punishment aimed to cultivate a healthy fear while His mercy provided hope, preventing the despair of sin from prevailing indefinitely.

Read more (62 words)

Indeed, one who seeks to punish transgressions too frequently may become harsh rather than just. Consequently, the Lord proclaimed He would no longer bring a curse upon the earth for humanity's sake. In essence, He desired to extend compassion to all humanity, while simultaneously ensuring that people do not become complacent or indifferent. Hence, He disciplines a few while rescuing the many.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

What is the significance of the phrase, 'The Lord smelled the sweet aroma' (Gen. 8:21)? In this passage, God praises Noah’s offerings not because He delights in the smoke—since nothing stinks more than charred remains—but rather for the heart of the one making the offering. God lacks a physical form, so it is impossible to ascribe nostrils to Him, yet nostrils are essential for the act of smelling. Thus, God blesses Noah, who represents the heritage of humanity, the foundation of our nature, and the figure reminiscent of the second Adam. He grants Noah the same favor He bestowed upon the original Adam: 'Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it.

Read more (92 words)

The fear of you and the dread of you shall be upon every beast of the earth…and upon every bird of the air, and upon every creature that moves on the ground, and upon all the fish of the sea: they are delivered into your hand' (Gen. 9:1-2). The fulfillment of His word became evident, as all creatures—beasts of the land, fish of the sea, and birds of the sky—dread the mere presence of humanity. God also provided Noah with guidelines regarding food, commanding him to partake in both meat and plants.

Nilus of Sinai

5th centuryChurch Father

It is indeed both sinful and irreverent to claim that evil stems from one's nature rather than from choice. The Scriptures declare that 'the imagination of man’s heart is evil from his youth' (Genesis 8:21), which reveals the truth that humanity's inclination towards wickedness is not inherent but a result of choice, not dictated by the divine principles God initially instilled in our hearts. Such a notion must be rejected! The text indicates that this tendency arises 'from the youth of man,' highlighting that our participation in malevolence is influenced by the pervasive presence of the adversary, leading us easily toward wrongdoing as we fall prey to deception. For it is stated, ‘the enemy sowed tares among the wheat’ (Matthew 13:25-28), illustrating how the Lord identifies the origin of our struggles with evil.

Philaret of Moscow (Drosdow)

19th centuryChurch Father

The assurance of the creatures' safety following the flood stands in sharp contrast to the earlier decree of their destruction (Gen. 6:13) and is linked to Noah's sacrificial act of atonement. Through the command of God, the natural laws, which originated from His word, were disrupted and subsequently reinstated and affirmed by that same divine word. As Noah's devotion was the initial visible means of sparing the creatures from the flood, the result of that faithfulness now becomes the reason for the promise of their continued preservation. And the Lord delighted in the aroma of comfort. This imagery relates to a person who savors the scent of a meal and symbolizes God's approval of the offering, or more correctly, of the individual presenting it (Leviticus 26:31).

Read more (542 words)

It is significant to observe that the phrase "reeking of repose" hints at Noah's prophetic name, which means a place of rest. The Lord resolved in His heart, that is, in His secret counsel, to ensure the future safety of His creation. From this point, I will no longer place a curse upon the earth because of humankind, for the inclinations of the hearts of men are evil from their youth. At first glance, these words present a perplexing complexity, as though God refrains from cursing the earth precisely for the reasons He had previously condemned it (Gen. 6: 5-7), seemingly indicating that He was appeased merely because His attempts at retribution were unfulfilled, which is unworthy of His divine nature. A clearer interpretation emerges: I will no longer curse the ground on account of humanity, meaning, due to the evil thoughts of their hearts; nor will I smite every living thing as I did before. God does not assure absolute impunity for wrongdoing but chooses not to curse the earth and all life nor inflict punishment as He did during the flood; thus, He allows for private forms of discipline and different kinds of punishments. Consequently, without compromising the sanctity of His Providence, only the manner in which it operates changes. Previously, justice was manifested universally, and mercy through a particular avenue; from now on, justice will be expressed privately, as seen in the instances of Sodom and Pharaoh, while mercy will be displayed universally. Since God does not merely desire external sacrifices and burnt offerings (Psalm 50:18, Hebrews 10:4-10), it was essential for Noah's offering to possess a hidden significance that made it acceptable. This significance stemmed from the fact that it was a universal offering from all of creation and intended for the salvation of all, thus representing the most perfect embodiment of the singular, universal sacrifice of Christ. The burnt offering upon the altar signified the ascension of Jesus Christ, by which He draws all unto Himself (John 12:32), and the sweet aroma that God perceived from afar was the love of the Redeemer, who gave Himself for us as an offering and sacrifice, a sweet-smelling savor to God (Eph. 5:2). He is also regarded as an altar since He presented our offerings to God (Heb. 13:10, 15). This reveals that God renews and blesses the entirety of creation in Christ.

Was Noah's sacrifice in itself pleasing to God? No, it found favor because God, perceiving the deepest intentions of the heart, recognized it as a genuine expression of obedience and thankfulness from this esteemed Patriarch. We, who exist in the New Testament and are more blessed than Noah, should present to God the ultimate sacrifice. In accordance with the teachings of the Apostles: present your bodies as a living sacrifice, holy, acceptable to God, which is your reasonable service; build yourselves into a spiritual temple, a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices pleasing to God through Jesus Christ (Rom. 12:1, 1 Pet. 2:5). To fulfill our spiritual needs, there exists a sacred act, greater than the sacrifices of the Old Testament, celebrated daily in the Divine Liturgy: the sacrifice of the cross. Let us ensure we receive this extraordinary gift of God’s mercy with the reverence it deserves!

Nicephoros (Theotokis)

18th centuryCommentator

God declared that "the thought of man shall be diligent to think evil from his youth" (Gen. 8:21). This assertion highlights a fundamental truth: the disobedience of humanity's original ancestors has significantly marred human nature, leading our will to naturally gravitate towards sinful actions from a young age. The result of this inclination is a struggle to live in accordance with the principles of the Gospel. Nevertheless, as stated by the Apostles, "I live not because of this I live, but Christ lives in me." Therefore, the suppression of desires, resistance to wrongdoing, and the discipline of one's passions are achievable within human nature.

Vissarion (Nechaev)

19th centuryCommentator

The biblical phrase signifying that Noah's offering was pleasing to the Lord indicates that it was acceptable and delightful to Him, just as the fragrance of incense brings joy to a person. This should not be interpreted in a literal sense, as the scent of burning animals is typically burdensome and not inherently pleasing. What was it about Noah's sacrifice that brought joy to God? It was the heartfelt intention with which Noah made his offering. As the flames of the sacrifice ascended towards heaven, Noah's spirit was lifted to God, ignited by faith, love, and hope in Him.

Read more (325 words)

This passage reflects God's promises and directives to Noah following the flood. After Noah exited the ark, the Lord, appeased by the sacrifice he made, assured him that He would not repeat the curse upon the earth due to the sins of its inhabitants, thus avoiding a repeat of the destruction caused by the flood. God's commitment to this promise stemmed not only from Noah's offering but also from His understanding that resorting to such an extreme punishment was not in line with His wisdom, goodness, and justice. God foresaw that the earth would continue to be tainted by the same transgressions that had led to its previous devastation, recognizing that the punishment of those before the flood would not prevent their descendants from pursuing similar wrongdoings. Indeed, because "the intent of man's heart is evil from his youth," it is clear that the root of sin lies in human nature, tainted by original sin; humanity is inherently sinful from birth and is predisposed to wickedness from an early age.

However, why then did God bring about the flood? It was necessary to demonstrate the severity of human sinfulness and to instill a sense of gravity concerning their transgressions. The memory of the catastrophic judgment on their ancestors was intended to serve as a deterrent to the young descendants, curbing the relentless tide of sin at least to some degree. This memory endured, not only within the chosen people but also in the traditions of pagan nations, likely playing a role in fostering an environment for the coming of the Redeemer among a select few. Yet, the Lord, while promising not to subject the earth to another widespread catastrophe, established specific forms of punishment for sin moving forward. While floods and other forms of discipline would still occur, they would not be as far-reaching. For it is clearly stated, "I will not smite, I will not destroy all flesh that dwells, as I have done."

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.