The Church Fathers on this verse

Hosea 14:9Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Ephraim shall say, What have I to do any more with idols? I will hear him, and I will make him flourish like a green fir tree: from me is thy fruit found.

Douay-Rheims

אֶפְרַ֕יִם מַה־לִּ֥י ע֖וֹד לָֽעֲצַבִּ֑ים אֲנִ֧י עָנִ֣יתִי וַאֲשׁוּרֶ֗נּוּ אֲנִי֙ כִּבְר֣וֹשׁ רַֽעֲנָ֔ן מִמֶּ֖נִּי פֶּרְיְךָ֥ נִמְצָֽא׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

5 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

For the initial context, see v. 8. What can be considered an idol to him? He asserts that if he is fulfilled and enjoys such valuable and exalted gifts, he will entirely relinquish his tendency toward falsehood and his attachment to the creations of his own making. Indeed, what other goods he lacks, he will seek from others. Is it not futile for the deceived to pursue these things? What can an inanimate object offer anyone? It was accurately stated about them by God, "You shall do good, and you shall do evil, and you shall be able to do evil, as if you were gods" (Isaiah 41:23)—yet man-made entities can never bring harm to people (in truth, how could they?), nor can they provide anything beneficial or useful.

Read more (269 words)

Thus, let them rightly hear, "the gods that have not made heaven and earth, let them perish from the earth, and from these things which are under these heavens" (Jeremiah 10:11). This very action, and the strengthening of love toward God, is illustrated by the phrase, "What further can he be an idol?" I will humble him, and I will bolster him. He declares, I can cause distress to those who show a lack of genuine disposition toward Me. I will also fortify those who act righteously and recognize the natural and true God. Therefore, the distress or weakening of Israel depended not on those false gods, and the shift to strength cannot be viewed as a gift from demons: it is a divine blessing, just as powerlessness arose from expressions of anger. Hence, the great David wisely and piously sings, "my strength and my song is the Lord" (Psalm 117:14). As the revival of the dead, from Me your fruit shall be found. The plant, "like a deadly storm," is so thick and lush that it appears to create a man-made canopy, blocking the sun's rays and the pouring rain from reaching the earth. Thus, those who obey God will experience peaceful shelter or assistance, as demonstrated in the phrase, "Az aki tornadicheski studious." And the fruitfulness of those who heed God is achieved solely in Christ or through Him, as He Himself affirms in the Gospel: "Without me you can do nothing" (John 15:5). Therefore, may He confidently address any believer, if he is noble, honorable, and adorned with virtue: "from Me your fruit shall be found."

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Ephraim will express, “Shall I also become an idol? I will bring him low; I will extol him like a full quiver.” The prophet highlights the triumphs of those who strike with arrows.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

I will heal their woundedness and embrace them with grace; my anger is now turned away from them. I will be like the dew. Israel will bloom like a lily, sending out roots similar to those of Lebanon. Its branches will extend, and its beauty will resemble that of the olive tree, with a scent as inviting as that from Lebanon. Those who have found refuge under its shade will return, nourished by wheat, and they will flourish like the vine; their remembrance will be reminiscent of the wine of Lebanon. Why should Ephraim concern itself with idols? I will listen and lift him up like a flourishing fir tree; the fruitfulness that comes to you is from Me.

Read more (969 words)

I will bring comfort to its inhabitants; I will love them openly, for My wrath has been turned aside from them; I will be like the dew. Israel will thrive like the lily, rooting deeply like Lebanon's trees. Its branches will spread, and it will become a fruitful olive tree, with its fragrance akin to that of Lebanon. They will return to find rest in its shade; they will consume and be filled with grain, and Ephraim will bloom like a vine; its remembrance will be like the wine of Lebanon. What further need has he for idols? I have brought him low, but I will strengthen him. I will be like a sturdy juniper tree; your fruit comes from Me.

As they turned back in repentance, recognizing the Father they once abandoned, God responded, promising to restore their brokenness and heal the communities they inhabited, where they were wounded and lived in scarcity. I will love them according to the grace I have abundantly shown, without hesitation or uncertainty. The Lord loves those who love Him, as stated in another passage: I love those who love Me (Proverbs 8:17). Though I had once expressed anger due to their sins, I will now show them mercy rooted in My goodness. I will be to them as the dew, refreshing and quenching their thirsty souls, and I will bring relief from the fiery struggles symbolized by Babylon's furnace.

To My servant Jacob, I spoke through Isaac: By the dew of heaven shall your dwelling be (Genesis 27:39). For to those believing in Him, He is light, the way, truth, bread, vine, fire, shepherd, lamb, and door. Thus, for us who desperately seek His mercy, He manifests as dew, as Isaiah states: The dew that comes from You is their healing (Isaiah 26:19). In Moses' song, he proclaimed: Let my words drop down like dew (Deuteronomy 32:2). When the Lord sprinkles us with His dew and with His rains alleviates the dryness of our hearts, we will bloom like the lily, reflecting the nature of our Savior, who in the Song of Songs declares: I am the flower of the field, and the lily among thorns (Song of Songs 2:1). To His beloved bride, without blemish, He says: As the lily among thorns, so is My beloved among the daughters (Song of Songs 2:2).

As we grow rooted in the Lord, we will be steadfast like the trees of Lebanon, their roots deep and their tops soaring high, remaining unshaken through every storm. The branches of these trees extend widely, providing shelter for the birds of the air. However, let us not equate this with barren trees; the faithful who return to the Lord are likened instead to a bountiful olive tree, which joyfully states: But I am like a green olive tree in the house of God (Psalm 52:8).

Its fruits nourish the wise virgins; it soothes wounds and restores health; it illuminates the dark; it is also employed in the races. This olive tree exudes fragrance akin to Lebanon, or frankincense, both of which share names with the mountain. Thus, the olive tree declares: We are the fragrance of Christ (2 Corinthians 2:15). Those returning to the Lord will see the rewards of their repentance; they will sit beneath His protective shadow proclaiming: Under His shadow I will dwell and His fruit will be sweet upon my lips (Song of Songs 2:3).

Those once dead will now thrive; they will be abundantly nourished, for they shall partake in all that He provides. This abundance signifies not a rationale lost in intoxication, but rather a fullness of all good things, evident in the verse: You visit the earth and water it (Psalm 65:10). Even Joseph's feast for his brothers is described as them having partaken of drink (Genesis 43). Jesus commands His apostles to: Eat, my friends, and drink your fill, brethren (Song of Songs 5:1).

Jesus is the wheat and the vine; thus, all believers are recognized as partaking in Him. Therefore, it follows: and they shall flourish like the vine; their remembrance will be as the exquisite wine of Lebanon. The wine of Lebanon is enriched and spiced, creating a delightful aroma, or perhaps that which is offered in God’s temple, as Zechariah cries: Open your doors, O Lebanon (Zechariah 11:1). You shall experience fullness in all things, O Ephraim, as you turn back in repentance; forsake idols and cast aside false gods. For I have humbled you, but I will lift you up, or I will hear him and elevate him like a thriving fir tree, as noted in the Hebrew text: His dwelling place is in the fir tree (Psalm 104:17).

Or I will be as a robust juniper, so that you may find rest in my shade. Solomon constructed the temple doors from juniper wood, suggesting that Christ, our way to the Father, is perpetually fruitful, ever green, and continuously bearing abundant fruit. This juniper tree provides fruit for those resting in its shade, shielding them from the oppressive heat of this world and nourishing them against the sun’s scorch, as was the case with Jonah. The allegorical interpretation of these messages regarding the coming of our Savior and the conversion of true Israel also extends to heretics, Jews, Gentiles, and all false teachings. When they repent, they too shall experience forgiveness. While the complete promise was realized with the Savior's arrival and is continually manifest in the Church, we must trust in a fuller revelation to come when the perfect arrives and that which is partial is set aside (1 Corinthians 13:10).

It’s crucial to remember that Israel's salvation, return to the Lord, and liberation from bondage should not be taken literally, as the Jews may suppose, but understood spiritually, as is evidently demonstrated.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Why should Ephraim turn to false gods? Therefore, Ephraim, having come to understand the nature of true piety, should shun idolatry. I have thus brought you low, and through a deep love for humanity, I will empower you; I shall be to you as the revitalizing storm, and you will bear fruit from Me. The storm is a plant that remains ever verdant, not withering, adorned with prickly thorns. In this way, God conveys the message: I will safeguard you, having made all necessary arrangements for your protection, as if through thorns I would wound those who rise against you. Concluding the entire prophecy, the Prophet offered a final remark beneficial to all who are attentive to these words:

John Cassian

5th centuryChurch Father

The holy servants of God never relied on their own efforts to chart the course they should follow in their pursuit of wholeness and virtue. Instead, they consistently sought the Lord's guidance: Lead me to Your truth (Psalm 24:5), make straight before me Your path (Psalm 5:9), teach me, O Lord, the way I should go (Psalm 142:8). Another prophet affirms that he came to this understanding not solely through faith but also through personal experience and observation of reality: I know, O Lord, that man does not possess the ability to direct his own steps, and it is not within the strength of those who walk to determine their journey (Jeremiah 10:23). Furthermore, the Lord conveys to Israel: I will hear him and regard him; I will be like a flourishing cypress; from Me will come your fruit.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.