The Church Fathers on this verse

Job 10:18Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Why didst thou bring me forth out of the womb? O that I had been consumed, that eye might not see me!

Douay-Rheims

וְלָ֣מָּה מֵ֭רֶחֶם הֹצֵאתָ֑נִי אֶ֝גְוַ֗ע וְעַ֣יִן לֹא־תִרְאֵֽנִי׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

3 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Hesychius of Jerusalem

5th centuryChurch Father

To prevent many from falling into sorrow and despair at the conclusion of his life, it is understandable that this just man inquires about the outcome of his sufferings. Thus, Job declared, “Before I depart, I will go away,” and he added, “I will not return;” which indicates he was referring to his earthly existence. It might be interpreted as saying: “Indeed, should I come back here and find the fruit of my endeavors, I will not be wearied, nor will I abandon my fight against death in my afflictions. Those who witness my righteousness will recognize that I am rewarded upon my return. However, if they observe me now perishing in my trials, they will either conclude that Job is wicked or doubt the value of being righteous.”

Didymus the Blind

4th centuryTeacher of the Church

It may be assumed that his remarks stem from a place of despair, yet such an interpretation is countered by God's statement, “Do you want to accuse me to justify yourself?” (Job 40:3). Thus, the one who earlier lamented, “If I am guilty, woe is me” (Job 10:15), does not voice a conflicting stance but rather reveals the weight of his existence, something a wicked person would not do since they find delight in this life. Furthermore, Job seeks to clarify to his companions the reason for his survival from birth, emphasizing that there is a reason for endurance amid suffering. The transient nature of earthly life is also highlighted, as Paul notes: “And if in this life alone we hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable” (1 Cor. 15:19).

Read more (348 words)

Job underwent both the joy and grief intrinsic to human existence. Those who are detached from the flesh do not revel in wealth or sinful pleasures nor do they suffer from distress. He faced the temptations of this life, blessed as he was with abundance and health, yet when his fortunes shifted, he came to understand the emptiness of worldly delights. He admonishes us against yearning for such things, asking, “And why hast Thou brought me forth from the womb? Let me die, that no eye should see me, that I should be as one who has not existed...” This was his plea. Heavy tribulations beset him, and he did not experience sorrow without feeling deeply. For if he had remained unaffected, it would have held no fortitude. Through prayer infused with gratitude, Job demonstrates that he withstood all afflictions by divine strength. Paul echoes this sentiment, stating, “Not I, however, but grace with me” (1 Cor. 15:10). Job offers this prayer before departing to a realm from which he cannot return, not solely for his own sake, but to guide his friends, who misjudged those in adversity as wicked and the fortunate as righteous. He wished for their fair assessment of him. It should not be concluded that Job refuted the resurrection of the dead when he stated, “Where there is no light, and it is impossible to see the life of mortals.” As the boldest of men, he still proclaimed a coming age even in tribulation. Thus, when he mentioned, “Before I depart; from whence I shall not return,” he did not deny the resurrection, but rather referred to the somber and shadowy realm of eternal despair devoid of light and mortal existence. He called that dismal existence life first, to signify his profound affliction. It would not be appropriate for him to speak of “before I enter the kingdom of heaven and the promised land of God.” Additionally, he intended for his listeners to glean a proper understanding of events that have yet to unfold, urging them to amend their actions according to this knowledge.

Ireneus (Orda)

19th centuryCommentator

Job is perplexed by the fact that the Lord, who is all-powerful and all-knowing, not only created humanity but also diligently sustains life and upholds moral integrity. He questions why God harshly punishes His creation for trivial wrongdoings and inflicts such suffering upon him (Job 10:1-12). Faced with the mystery of his undeserved anguish and his struggle to defend himself before God, Job again expresses a preference for death over life, pleading for relief from the remaining days of his painful existence (Job 10:13-22).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.