The Church Fathers on this verse

John 11:46Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

But some of them went to the Pharisees and told them the things that Jesus had done.

Douay-Rheims

τινες δε εξ αυτων απηλθον προς τους φαρισαιους και ειπον αυτοις α εποιησεν ο ιησους

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

12 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

When the miracle had been accomplished, some marveled, while others went and told the Pharisees. Instead of being astonished and amazed, they took counsel to kill Him, the One who had raised the dead man.

What madness! They thought to give over to death the One who conquered death in the bodies of others.

"What are we to do? This Man performs many signs," they say. They still call Him a man, after receiving such assurance of His Godhead. "What are we to do?" They ought to have believed, served, and worshiped, and no longer considered Him a mere man.

Read more (1687 words)

When the Pharisees heard all this, they formed a new council, saying among themselves, "What are we to do? This Man performs many signs." A great accusation! The dead are awakened, death is put to death, Lazarus rises from the dead, and the Jews are drawn toward spiritual death.

Therefore do not leave your council unfinished. Continue the accusation and say: What are we to do when, a few days later, the sun in heaven is darkened, the earth quakes, unable to endure what is being done upon it, the veil within the temple is torn, and a multitude of the dead returns to life?

Say again: What are we to do when the temple is destroyed, the service ceases, the city is burned, we are driven out, and others become heirs in our place?

What are we to do when everything passes to others: prophets, apostles, priesthood, fasting, feasts, and service, and God permits it? Think about this. Take counsel about this.

The words of your speeches are useless to you. The decree is unchangeable: "Speak a word, but it shall not stand" (Isa 8:10). Once for all God has granted to those to whom He granted it always to triumph.

He has granted them always to celebrate, and from year to year to renew the celebration, in Christ Jesus our Lord. To Him be glory unto ages of ages. Amen.

On Holy and Great Tuesday.

The beloved children of the Church are like infants at the breast. Every day they are fed from their mother's breast, and every day they do not cease to desire it.

We ourselves may be compared to a poor mother whose milk has dried up from the exhaustion of hunger. A loving mother, having no milk, may be moved by the crying of her child and give him her breast.

She does this not to feed the child, but only to calm him. As you see, we too experience the same thing and act in the same way.

Seeing this new assembly of the Church's children surrounding us and awaiting the pure milk of the word from us, we stretch out our word to them. We do this not to nourish them, for we are poor and unskilled in speech, but to quench their dust and thirst.

Come then, beloved, let us listen to the herald of the Sun, and see what wicked ambush the chief priests and Pharisees prepared for the Lord.

"The chief priests and Pharisees," he says, "gathered a council and said, What are we to do?" The Evangelist John has just told us this.

Though he does not now speak with us mouth to mouth, nevertheless in spirit he spoke into the ears of those standing here. "The chief priests and Pharisees gathered a council and said, What are we to do?"

"They gathered" is good, but "a council" is evil. They gathered not for love, but for strife. They did not call to peace, but stirred up enmity.

They gathered an assembly not to glorify God, but to dishonor Christ. They gathered a council not to establish the faith, but to reject the cornerstone.

They gathered a council not to gather the wandering sheep into the fold, but to strike the Shepherd and scatter the sheep of His pasture.

They gathered a council not to receive the snow-white pearl with faith, but to hide the radiant stone, as they supposed, in the darkness of their unbelief.

They gathered an assembly not wisely to draw out the treasure hidden in the field, but senselessly to destroy the temple of God.

They gathered a council not to gather sweet clusters of grapes, but to raise the True Vine upon the tree of the Cross. They prepared destruction for themselves, and salvation for us.

O council gathered by the devil against Christ! O deliberation filled with malice! O assembly more of bloodthirsty wolves than of God-bearing men!

Why do I say fierce wolves? They are worse than savage lions. The lions saw no sign from Daniel and received him as an ordinary man. Yet they honored him and closed their mouths before him.

But the chief priests and Pharisees had been eyewitnesses of such and so many signs. They were therefore driven by still greater envy toward murder and said, "What are we to do?"

O reasonings inspired by malice! O groaning and cry born of envy! O lamentation and wailing over an evil plot! Not even Rachel, weeping for her children, groaned so.

"What are we to do?" They ought to have rejoiced over the afflicted. They ought to have established a public feast because the dead are raised, life triumphs, death is destroyed, the devil is put to shame, the army of demons is scattered, mankind is set free, and the resurrection of the dead is proclaimed to all.

But, on the contrary, such blessings do not gladden them, but grieve them. They take counsel to kill the Cause of all these blessings.

And what do they say? "What are we to do?" Let us turn in repentance, fall down before Him, and believe. This is the one thing they could have said.

Indeed, what else could they have said but this? "What are we to do," after transgressing the commandment of God and not keeping the law of God given to us?

It says, "The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet from among you, from your brethren, like me. Him you shall hear" (Deut 18:15), in all that he commands you.

But they did not mean repentance when they said, "What are we to do?" No, they meant something altogether different. "What are we to do? How shall we kill this Righteous One?"

Your mind has been darkened, O Israel. Did you not hear the commandment, "Do not put to death the innocent and righteous" (Dan 13:53)? Or was the blood of the prophets already shed not enough for you?

Even to the present day it cries to God, awaiting recompense from Him. But to surpass all that has been done, you prepare to shed holy and innocent blood, and you say, "What are we to do?"

O mad thought and senseless counsel! The four-days-dead man was brought to life among them. The bonds of sins were torn apart, and they plot treachery against Him.

They ought to have said something altogether different: "What are we to do? We have insulted the Holy One. We did not believe the Son of God.

"What are we to do? He healed the wounds of lepers by a single word, and we did not believe in Him.

"What are we to do? He opened the eyes of those born blind, and even this did not persuade us.

"What are we to do? We knew that with five loaves He fed five thousand in the wilderness, and we did not believe in Him.

"What are we to do? By His word He set the paralytic on his feet, the man lying on his bed, held by illness for thirty-eight years of his life, and we did not believe in Him.

"What are we to do? We saw Him walking upon the sea as on dry land. We knew that with one motion of His hand He calmed the terrible swellings and blasts of untamed winds, and still we remained in our unbelief."

But they uttered these words, "What are we to do?" not with a disposition toward repentance, but while seeking a way to commit the evil deed.

The earth without labor produced their dead as living, like ripe ears of grain, and they groaned. Did you Jews not reap what you sowed? Was anyone among you burdened by receiving the Lord?

In what respect were you burdened when you were punished? What injustice did you suffer from God? Why do you remove the dead from life, troubled by envy?

Why do you strive to destroy the inexhaustible streams of the sweet spring, from which those who drink would thirst no more? Why do you kill your sick by gathering to destroy their Physician?

The cause of all this, however, was most wicked envy. O envy, mother of murder, invention of the devil, cause of death!

O envy, you do not allow those whom you attack to live, and you punish still more those whom you possess. O envy, companion of the devil!

O envy, enemy of friendship, opponent of peace, rival of love, offspring of the devil, flower of the gloomy abyss! Whoever is possessed by you comes to the murder of Christ.

From the beginning you wounded Adam in paradise. You handed over the one who had tasted sweet delights to most bitter death. For death was not in the world until you, envy, brought it forth.

This is also witnessed by the divine word, which says, "God did not create death, and He does not delight in the destruction of the living." "But through the envy of the devil death entered the world" (Wis 1:13; 2:24).

You deprived Cain of the white garment of brotherly love and armed him with the knife of treachery. You taught him murder and at once made the wretched man shake and tremble.

You dwelt in Pharaoh and destroyed the newborn children of the Hebrews by untimely death. O envy, even when you are shown kindness, you rise up still more against your benefactors.

So Saul, while benefiting from David's service, was stirred up by you and armed himself still more for murder. At your prompting, the sons of Jacob sent beautiful Joseph into dizzying Egypt and sold him, though free, as a slave.

Even his dreams did not frighten them. Yet the divine vision showed that he was a type of Christ. Eleven stars bowed before him in the vision, eleven because the betrayer Judas hanged himself, having served envy.

But let us escape envy, the ancestress of death. Having risen, we shall glorify God, worshiped in the Trinity. To Him belong dominion, honor, glory, and majesty, now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Others reported it to the Pharisees, undoubtedly with the aim of slandering Him as one who had done something unlawful, since He had ordered the grave of a buried man to be opened.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Many, struck by the miracle, believed. But others, wounded by envy, turned the miracle into a pretext for doing what belongs to the envious. They reported what had happened to the rulers, so that, by grieving them also over the work accomplished by Christ, they might find some consolation for their own grief in having others like-minded with them and sharing in this irrational sorrow. And since they themselves were unable to harm the One who had done no wrong, they sought to stir up those more powerful against Him.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Not all the Jews who had come to Mary believed, but nevertheless many did. Some of them, whether of the Jews, or of those who had come, or of those who had believed, went to the Pharisees and told them what Jesus had done. This was either to inform them so that they too might believe, or, more likely, to denounce Him so that they might become indignant. For one reason or the other, the matter reached the Pharisees.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

They went not to express their amazement, but to slander Jesus Christ as though He were a sorcerer. These were the ones who had said: “Could not He who opened the eyes of the blind man have caused that even this man should not die?” (Jn 11:37).

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryChurch Father

But what consequences did this event bring? Although it did not take place in Jerusalem, it soon became known there through eyewitnesses. The passions of the Jewish rulers had already been stirred against Jesus to the highest degree. The time of a new and populous gathering of the people in Jerusalem was approaching: Passover. They thought that the report of Lazarus’s resurrection, which anyone could verify because Bethany was near Jerusalem, would rouse the whole people in favor of Jesus. Yet they did not wish to reason that, if Lazarus had truly been raised by Jesus, then Jesus had to be acknowledged as a divine Messenger. Thus in Jerusalem this event occupied all the attention of the members of the Sanhedrin. They appointed an assembly.

Read more (75 words)

There the passions knew how to cover themselves with a plausible mask. However corrupt anyone may be, he never wishes to appear wholly corrupt in the eyes of others. And the Pharisees, the chief party in the Sanhedrin, were not ignorant of the art of playing the role of holy men zealous for the people’s welfare. Perhaps they also feared opposition from those favorably disposed toward Jesus (Jn 7:50), if they proceeded directly against Him.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

The great miracle of Lazarus’s resurrection produced a powerful effect on all who saw it and heard about it. Many of the Jews who witnessed this miracle, until then indifferent to the Lord, now believed in Him. But the Jews hostile to the Lord were all the more troubled by it. They went to Jerusalem and told the Pharisees everything that Jesus had done. Then the chief priests and Pharisees gathered a council and began to deliberate. What should they undertake against Jesus? He works many miracles, and if they leave Him thus, all will believe in Him. Then the people will rise in revolt against the Romans, but it will end with the Romans utterly destroying Jerusalem and the temple.

Read more (217 words)

They will also take from the Jewish people even the small political independence it had so far enjoyed under Roman rule. Then the high priest Caiaphas said: “Why so much discussion? It is better, of course, that one man should die for the people than that the whole nation should perish in the event of an uprising. Therefore, whoever this Jesus may be, He must be put to death as soon as possible.” These words came from a malicious heart. But the thought expressed in them, that Jesus should die for the people, was true. Thus the impious lips of Caiaphas, because he was high priest that year, involuntarily uttered a prophecy. For in antiquity the high priest was an organ of divine revelation (Ex 28:30; Num 27:21). For by the decree of God, Jesus Christ truly had to die for the salvation of mankind. “And not for the nation only,” the Evangelist observes, “but also to gather into one the children of God who were scattered abroad.” That is, Christ had to die not only for the salvation of the Jewish people. He died in order to make one universal Church of Christ from all people throughout the whole world (cf. 10:16). After this judgment of Caiaphas, the Sanhedrin made the final decision to kill Jesus.

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

This miracle made a shattering impression on the people. Even many of the Jews believed in Him. But some of them, concealing their malice, silently withdrew and hastened to Jerusalem to announce to the Sanhedrin what had happened.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

Then, raising His voice to a shattering and commanding authority, He cried out in the strong and brief words usual with Him in all such cases: “Lazarus, come forth!” To the terror of all present, the dead man rose from the tomb and came out again into God’s light, in his fearful burial clothing. Christ commanded that the burial bands be removed from him, and Lazarus could go home freely. The whole crowd present, in fear and amazement, watched the man who had been raised and reasoned about Him who had performed so great a miracle. Many believed in Him. But there were also some whose stubborn unbelief could not be conquered even by Lazarus returned from the life beyond the grave. They merely hurried to Jerusalem to report what had happened to the Sanhedrin.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

They went to the Lord’s worst enemies, the Pharisees, and told them what Jesus had done. Since, after their denunciation, a council of the Sanhedrin was immediately gathered, at which it was resolved to kill the Lord (Jn 11:47, 53), their denunciation must unquestionably be regarded as evil and made with a malicious purpose. “They reported it to the Pharisees, undoubtedly with the aim of slandering Him, as though He had done something unlawful, since He had commanded the buried man to be uncovered” (Theophylact). Such malicious unbelief and blindness are astonishing in the face of the greatest and most unquestionable miracle. The Evangelist himself marvels at such unbelief and blindness (Jn 12:37 and following). Probably they distorted this miracle too, as they distorted other miracles.

Read more (41 words)

They explained them either by saying that He worked miracles by an unclean power, or by suspecting some trick, and the like. How far can the blindness of a man go when his heart is filled with malice, envy, and prejudice?

Philaret (Gumilevski)

19th centuryChurch Father

Verses 46-50. A remarkable scene opened in the Sanhedrin when those who had been in Bethany reported everything that had happened to Lazarus. The full assembly of respected members gathered. However much some of them had formerly assured themselves and others that Jesus was not a messenger of God, they now confess: “This man performs many signs.” They confess that, despite all their efforts to humble Jesus before the people, the people show ever greater respect for Him, receiving Him as the expected Messiah. One would think there was no reason for alarm here. The members of the Sanhedrin themselves awaited the Messiah. Therefore they should have rejoiced that the One awaited for ages had appeared. But the majority of the Sanhedrin did not need the Messiah of the prophets.

Read more (330 words)

They did not need such a One as Christ Jesus, who preached self-denial, turned hearts not to earth but to heaven, and exposed the vices of the people’s leaders. “If we let Him alone,” they say, “the Romans will come and take away both our place and our nation.” Base hypocrites attribute their own unclean thoughts and desires to Jesus. They say that Jesus wants to be an earthly king, and that His followers are ready to rebel against Roman authority. Therefore they received the very thing they expected. Thirty years later the Romans truly took and destroyed the city, and scattered the people throughout the whole world. This happened precisely because, after slandering heavenly innocence and putting Him to death, they rebelled against Roman authority. “But one of them, Caiaphas, being high priest that year, said: You know nothing at all, nor do you consider that it is better for us that one man should die, and not that the whole nation should perish.” “High priest that year” means that Caiaphas was presiding that year, as in verse 51. But this does not exclude the thought that he had also been high priest before that. Caiaphas held power throughout the whole proconsulship of Pilate. After Pilate’s removal, he was deposed by the proconsul Vitellius (Winer, Realworterbuch, 2nd ed., 1, 759). “You know nothing at all”: you understand nothing; you are darkened men. The words are sharp and reveal a troubled soul. Who, then, troubled Caiaphas? Since this was now a full assembly of the Sanhedrin, there were certainly such members as Nicodemus (Jn 3:2; 7:50; 9:16), Joseph of Arimathea, and others like them. The resurrection of Lazarus strengthened the respect of such members for Jesus, verse 45. They did not fail to say a few words on behalf of Jesus in the Sanhedrin. These very words drove Caiaphas out of himself. In a movement of anger, he pronounced the sentence that Jesus must die, lest the whole nation perish.

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryChurch Father

Every word of the Lord, every deed and sign of His, brought after it that “division on earth” (Lk 12:51) which the Lord foretold. Believers were separated from unbelievers, for, as the Baptist said, “His winnowing fork is in His hand” (Mt 3:11). The winnowing fork used for grain threshed on the floor serves to separate the light chaff from the heavy grain. Such was the meaning of this image. The sheep were separated from the goats, the sons of light from the sons of the devil and of darkness. The great act of creation, which revealed the unity of the Lord Jesus with the Father, kindled the fire of faith in many chosen hearts. Having flared up, it undoubtedly brought them to Christ the Savior. But among the Jews there were also sons of perdition.

Read more (182 words)

Those who go to the Pharisees know that they are going to the Lord’s enemies. The great miracle stirs in their deadened hearts not compunction, not tears of joy and love, but bitterness. They cannot deny that from now on they are unable to fight or contend with this man. Yet in Him they also cannot deny the Godhead. And now the word of the Lord is fulfilled upon them: “A bad tree cannot bear good fruit. Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire” (Mt 7:18-19; cf. Mt 3:10; Lk 3:19). And another word of the Lord: “If anyone does not abide in Me, he is cast out as a branch and withers. Such branches are gathered, thrown into the fire, and burned” (Jn 15:6). And Jerusalem burned, and with it the people once belonging to the promise. For it rejected the Lord, withered, and was thrown into the fire. Only those were saved from the fire who cried out: “Blessed is He who comes in the name of the Lord” (Mt 23:37-39).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 14 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. τινὲς
    tines
    any one
    G5100 · τις
  2. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. ἐξ
    ex
    from out
    G1537 · ἐκ
  4. αὐτῶν
    autōn
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  5. ἀπῆλθον
    apēlthon
    I come or go away from
    G565 · ἀπέρχομαι
  6. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  7. τοὺς
    tous
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  8. Φαρισαίους
    pharisaious
    a Pharisee
    G5330 · Φαρισαῖος
  9. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  10. εἶπαν
    eipan
    to say
    G2036 · ἔπω, ἐρῶ, εἶπον
  11. αὐτοῖς
    autois
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  12. ἃ
    ha
    who
    G3739 · ὅς, ἥ
  13. ἐποίησεν
    epoiēsen
    I do
    G4160 · ποιέω
  14. Ἰησοῦς
    iēsous
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς