The Church Fathers on this verse

John 13:36Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Simon Peter saith to him: Lord, whither goest thou? Jesus answered: Whither I go, thou canst not follow me now: but thou shalt follow hereafter.

Douay-Rheims

λεγει αυτω σιμων πετρος κυριε που υπαγεις απεκριθη αυτω ο ιησους οπου υπαγω ου δυνασαι μοι νυν ακολουθησαι υστερον δε ακολουθησεις μοι

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

11 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Love is a great good. It is stronger than fire, ascends to heaven itself, and there is no obstacle capable of restraining its powerful impulse.

Take the most ardent Peter. After he heard, "Where I go, you cannot come," what does he say? "Lord, where are You going?" He said this not so much because he wished to learn where Christ was going, but because he wished to follow Him.

He did not yet dare to say directly, "I will go." Instead he says, "Where are You going?" And Christ answered not his words, but his thought. Therefore Peter's desire is evident from the very words of Christ.

What did He say? "Where I go, you cannot follow Me now." Do you see that Peter wished to follow Him, and for this reason asked?

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

Peter, having become bold from great fervor, heard the Lord say, “Where I am going, you cannot come,” and asked, “Where are You going?” It is as though he were saying to Christ: What is this path on which I cannot go? He asks this not so much because he wishes to know where He is going, but because he covertly expresses this thought: even if You go by the hardest path of all, I will still follow You. So much did he always love to be with Christ. Therefore Christ answers Peter’s thought: you cannot follow Me now, but afterward you will follow Me.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Simon Peter said to Him, "Lord, where are You going?" Peter again inquires from eagerness to know. He seeks to learn the meaning of Christ's words, still not understanding, it seems, what Christ had said. Yet he shows a burning desire to follow Christ.

The order among the disciples is worthy of wonder here also. Peter, who held the first place among them, does not ask because he alone failed to understand while the others understood. Rather, they yield to him, as the one who had precedence, the first place in speech and boldness in questioning the Lord.

Read more (988 words)

For even to distinguished men it is not without danger to address the Teacher, as Gal 2:6 suggests. Peter deserves great admiration because he did not fear appearing slow to understand. He sought to know what he did not know, and quickly hastened to acquire wisdom.

He placed the profit gained from inquiry above misplaced shame. Thus, in this also, he became an example for those who came after him. I think it is not fitting to disregard the words of teachers, even if they are not very clear.

We must not do this from a desire to appear very perceptive and inclined to good sense. Rather, we must inquire and examine precisely what was first handed down for our benefit. Knowledge of what is useful is far better than empty cleverness.

To learn something truly is higher than seeming to know something.

Jesus answered him, "Where I am going, you cannot follow Me now, but you shall follow afterward." He knew that it would bring His disciples heavy and unbearable grief if He said plainly that He was going up to heaven.

He knew they would grieve if He said that He was leaving them deprived of His presence on earth, though He would again be with them as God. Therefore He uses veiled speech here, slightly withholding its direct meaning.

Seeing that they do not know, He leaves them in that same state. It belongs to the wise sometimes to cover with difficult words what may cause sorrow.

So also Christ was lifting Himself up to God the Father and ordering His departure into heaven as the firstfruits of humanity. This was done for the benefit of all, for He renewed for us the way which human nature had not known before.

Yet for the holy disciples, who desired always to be with Him, separation from Christ was unbearable. This was so even though He would always be present with them by the power and operation of the Holy Spirit.

Therefore He profitably leaves blessed Peter, who did not know the meaning of Christ's words, in that same state together with the other disciples. He does so until He completes the discourse that could strengthen them.

As we shall see, He does the same afterward when He says to them, "It is to your advantage that I go away; for if I do not go away, the Comforter will not come to you" (Jn 16:7).

Yet, as God, He hastens to foretell to the eager disciple that he will gladly follow Him and will soon be with Him, when nothing will hinder his zeal. He says, "Where I am going, you cannot follow Me now, but you shall follow afterward."

This saying contains a twofold meaning. One meaning is very simple and easily accessible. The other is somewhat obscure and enigmatic. He says that Peter could not now follow Him who was going to God and returning to heaven.

Yet he would follow afterward, that is, when the glory and honor promised by Christ to the saints would come. Then they will ascend to the City above and reign with Him.

But besides this, the saying means something else, which I shall also state. They had not yet been clothed with power from on high (Lk 24:49). They had not yet received the Holy Spirit, who strengthens and transforms human nature toward courage.

Therefore they were unable to contend against death and resist terrors so irresistible. Otherwise it would be incredible that others should accomplish this before our Savior Christ alone, to whom it was fitting and appointed to crush the dominion of death.

For what could not fearing death mean, if not despising death as unable to cause any harm? This is why, as we think, the blessed prophets themselves trembled before the approach of death, since it had not yet been abolished through Christ's Resurrection.

Understanding this rightly, Paul said that the Word, who is from God the Father and in God, took hold of the seed of Abraham. He did this so that through the death of His holy flesh He might abolish death.

He also did this "to deliver those who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage" (Heb 2:14-16). The first overthrow of death was the saving Passion.

The beginning of bold courage against death among the saints was Christ's Resurrection. Therefore, when the Life by nature had not yet abolished death and crushed the fear it casts upon our souls, the disciples were still very weak before dangers.

For this reason the Lord, with careful concealment, hints that in due time Peter will undergo crucifixion and in this will follow Him. But Peter does not yet have firmness of spirit for so great a contest.

He indicates this in the words, "Where I am going, you cannot follow Me now, but you shall follow afterward." If Christ were not giving us an enigmatic indication of Peter's death, why would He apply the meaning of the saying to Peter alone?

The other holy Apostles also had the promise of being with Him and following Him, evidently at the resurrection, when endless life and the promised blessings would come to them. It is clear that He foretells to Peter what would later happen to him.

He indicated this more plainly in another saying: "When you were young, you girded yourself and walked where you wished. But when you are old, you will stretch out your hands, and another will gird you and carry you where you do not wish."

"This He said," it says, "signifying by what death he would glorify God" (Jn 21:18-19). For the saints, it is certainly pleasant to suffer for Christ. Yet the danger of death is not desired.

Nevertheless, it is endured when imposed by necessity. Therefore He also commands us to pray that we not enter into temptation (Mt 26 and parallels).

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

After the Lord Jesus entrusted to the disciples the holy love by which they were to love one another, Simon Peter said to Him: "Lord, where are You going?" The disciple spoke thus to the Teacher, and the servant to the Lord, as though he were ready to follow Him.

Therefore the Lord, who certainly knew his soul and why he asked this, answered him in this way: "Where I go, you cannot follow Me now." It was as though He said: "Regarding what you ask, you cannot now."

He did not say, "You cannot," but, "You cannot now." He indicated a delay, but did not take away hope. The same hope which He did not take away, but rather gave, He confirmed in the following phrase, adding and saying: "but afterward you shall follow Me."

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

Peter asked this question not so much because he wanted to know what he was asking about, but because he strongly desired to follow Jesus Christ. Therefore the Savior, knowing Peter’s thoughts, answered those thoughts directly. He did not say where He was going, but said, “You cannot follow Me now.” By these words, of course, He was alluding to death.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

From the farewell discourse of Jesus Christ with the disciples, the first three Evangelists transmit only the prediction of dangers: temptation for all the Apostles and denial for Peter. In the Evangelist John this is found in the section Jn 13:31-38.

As is evident from this latter passage, this prediction was occasioned by Peter's question: "Lord, where are You going?" After answering this question, that Peter cannot follow Him now but will follow afterward (v. 36), the Lord receives a new question from Peter: "Lord, why can I not follow You now?" (v. 37).

In response to this He begins to foretell what will happen to the disciples and to Peter now: "Simon, Simon! Behold, Satan asked to sift you as wheat" (Lk 22:31 and following).

Read more (320 words)

As the Lord, who knows the mysteries of the spiritual world, sees, Satan asked God for permission to deal with the disciples in a way similar to Job. In the impending dangers to their faith, he sought not only to leave them to themselves, but also to hand them over to his influence.

He assured that he would completely destroy their bond with Christ and with one another, disturbing and scattering them like wheat driven across a field. "But," the Lord says, "I have prayed that your faith may not fail."

This means that Peter most of all needed this intercession of Jesus Christ. A particularly great danger of temptation lay before him.

Having said this, Jesus Christ further foretells Peter's denial, and at the same time his conversion, as the fruit of Christ's intercession for him before God. At the same time the Lord foretells temptation for all the disciples.

He says that they will need Peter's encouraging example, which will strengthen their faith (Lk 22:31-32).

Revealing this danger for all the disciples, Jesus Christ says directly that all of them will be scandalized because of Him that night. Then the prophecy about the death of the Messiah and the confusion of His followers over it will be fulfilled (Zech 13:7).

But at once He also consoled the disciples by foretelling His Resurrection and His appearance to them in Galilee: "I shall be struck. But before you return home after the feast to Galilee, whence you came with Me to Jerusalem for Passover, I shall already go before you there" (Mt 26:31-32; Mk 14:27-28).

Then Peter begins to assure Him that, even if all are scandalized, he will not be scandalized and is ready to lay down his soul for his Teacher. All the disciples said the same. In response, the Lord gives Peter a direct prediction of his threefold denial (Mt 26:33-35; Mk 14:29-31; Lk 22:33-34; Jn 13:37-38).

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

In Peter's ardent and loving heart, the thought of the impending separation resounded painfully. "Why separate?" he thought. "If He must depart from this world, then I too will go after Him."

"Lord," he said, "where are You going?" Jesus understood what this question was leading to and answered Peter: "Where I go, you cannot follow Me now, but afterward you shall follow Me."

To what He had said before, that the Apostles could not go after Him, Jesus now added: "but afterward you shall follow Me." This addition means that the time would come when he, Peter, would suffer the same martyr's death that awaited Jesus.

At the present time such a death would have been premature for him. He had to fulfill the lofty calling of a preacher of the new teaching. Moreover, he was not yet capable of suffering voluntarily for that teaching.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

But Peter was not satisfied with this. He wished at all costs to go where the Teacher was going. When the self-willed disciple began to insist with self-confidence that no obstacles could keep him from following his Teacher, and that he would "lay down his soul for Him," the Savior rebuked this self-confidence by foretelling that, before the rooster had time to crow, he would deny Him three times.

Having revealed still more clearly to the disciples the horrors that awaited Him, the Savior foretold that all of them would abandon Him that night and be scattered. Yet He would meet them in Galilee after the Resurrection.

Philaret (Gumilevski)

19th centuryChurch Father

It was grievous for the loving heavenly Teacher to see a betrayer among His chosen disciples. Yet it was not easy to look upon the fact that, in the time of His calamities, even the most ardent and apparently firmest of His disciples, Peter, would deny Him.

The Savior saw this beforehand. Painful as it was for Him to see the sorrowful future, He cared for His disciples. He instructed and warned them, so that His followers might reflect concerning themselves.

"Simon Peter said to Him, Lord, where are You going? Jesus answered him, Where I go, you cannot follow Me now; but afterward you shall follow Me." Before this, the Lord had announced that He would not be with His disciples much longer (Jn 13:33).

Read more (241 words)

Peter, always ardent and open, was not only troubled by this, as the others were troubled, but did not delay in expressing the movement of his soul by the question: "Where are You going?" On one side, the question is more than excusable, because love proposed it.

This love grieved over separation from the Teacher and desired not to be separated from its Lord, as Elisha did not wish to be separated from Elijah (4 Kgs 2:4-6). Yet on the other side, there was also something mistaken in Simon's question.

Peter could have known from the Lord's words where his Teacher was going. The Lord had pointed in v. 33 to His instructions on this matter given in the temple (Jn 7:33; 8:21).

In His answer to Peter, the Savior repeats about Peter what He had said about all the disciples. Yet by saying, "You cannot now," He expressed more definitely what had been said before.

"You cannot follow now." Why? Because he was not yet mature in the spiritual life, like the others. He did not yet have the firmness and strength needed to follow the One who was going to the Cross.

"But afterward you shall follow Me." In time there would come spiritual maturity, and Peter would go by the path on which his Lord had gone. He would endure a martyr's death without trembling. The Savior spoke to him of this also after His Resurrection (Jn 21:18-19).

Tichon (Pokrovski)

19th centuryChurch Father

In saying this, Jesus Christ meant His departure through suffering and death to His Father, in order to sit at the right hand of His glory. Peter, however, still had to remain on earth and fulfill his calling by preaching the Gospel. Therefore he could not now follow the Lord. Later he too completed his ministry, also by suffering, as was fulfilled.

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryChurch Father

John Chrysostom says beautifully: "What are you saying, Peter? Christ says, You cannot, and you say, I can! Therefore you will learn by experience itself that your love without help from above is nothing."

Peter's question arose from the most ardent love for the Lord and from a sincere desire to go after Him wherever it might be. It was not merely a wish to know where the Lord was departing. Therefore the Lord answers not his words, but his thought, saying: "You cannot follow now; but afterward you shall follow Me."

Yet Peter expressed a certain self-reliance. Therefore, "the Lord, restraining his impulse, left him for a time without help during the temptation and denial, so that he might know his own weakness," as Chrysostom says.

Read more (228 words)

This is one of the most important indications for the practical moral life of the Christian. He cannot act by his own strength, mind, or love, however strong it may be. All his moral powers are insignificant if the grace of God does not strengthen them.

The Christian's chief task is to submit to God's commands, to fulfill His laws of love, and to place all his hope in God. From Him alone he must expect help in his weaknesses.

When God's will has been revealed to him, the Christian must consciously renounce his own will. This is a great ascetic labor, but one must strive for it unceasingly.

Concerning Peter's question, "Lord, where are You going?" there exists a very touching and very ancient tradition. It is found in the so-called Histoire apostolique d'Abdias dans les Apochryptes (Bibl. Theol. De Migne), book 2, ch. 19, col. 713. The Apostolic History of Abdias was apparently written in the tenth century, but its compiler probably used an ancient tradition.

It relates that Peter, fleeing Nero's persecutions, was leaving Rome and met the Lord in the flesh. Then, turning to the Lord, he repeated the same words to Him: "Lord, where are You going?" The Lord answered: "Follow Me. I am going to Rome to be crucified again."

And Peter returned to Rome and sealed his faith with his blood.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 20 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Λέγει
    legei
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  2. αὐτῷ
    autō
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  3. Σίμων
    simōn
    Simon
    G4613 · Σίμων
  4. Πέτρος
    petros
    Peter
    G4074 · Πέτρος
  5. Κύριε
    kyrie
    lord
    G2962 · κύριος
  6. ποῦ
    pou
    where
    G4226 · ποῦ
  7. ὑπάγεις
    hypageis
    I go away
    G5217 · ὑπάγω
  8. Ἀπεκρίθη
    apekrithē
    I answer
    G611 · ἀποκρίνω
  9. αὐτῷ
    autō
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  10. Ἰησοῦς
    iēsous
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  11. Ὅπου
    hopou
    where
    G3699 · ὅπου
  12. ὑπάγω
    hypagō
    I go away
    G5217 · ὑπάγω
  13. οὐ
    ou
    no
    G3756 · οὐ
  14. δύνασαί
    dynasai
    I am powerful
    G1410 · δύναμαι
  15. μοι
    moi
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  16. νῦν
    nyn
    now
    G3568 · νῦν
  17. ἀκολουθῆσαι
    akolouthēsai
    I accompany
    G190 · ἀκολουθέω
  18. ἀκολουθήσεις
    akolouthēseis
    I accompany
    G190 · ἀκολουθέω
  19. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  20. ὕστερον
    hysteron
    later
    G5306 · ὕστερος