The Church Fathers on this verse

John 20:17Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Jesus saith to her: Do not touch me: for I am not yet ascended to my Father. But go to my brethren and say to them: I ascend to my Father and to your Father, to my God and to your God.

Douay-Rheims

λεγει αυτη ο ιησους μη μου απτου ουπω γαρ αναβεβηκα προς τον πατερα μου πορευου δε προς τους αδελφους μου και ειπε αυτοις αναβαινω προς τον πατερα μου και πατερα υμων και θεον μου και θεον υμων

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

16 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Perhaps someone will ask: How is it known that the angels were amazed, and that for this reason Mary turned back? In that case one must also ask: How is it known that Mary touched Christ and fell at His feet?

Just as the latter is revealed by the words, "Do not touch Me," so the former is evident from the statement, "having turned."

But why did Christ say, "Do not touch Me"? Some say that Mary asked Him for spiritual grace, since she had heard Him say to the disciples: "If I go to the Father, I will pray Him, and He will give you another Comforter" (Jn 14:3, 16).

But how could she, who was not then with the disciples, have heard these words? Besides, in her own understanding she was far from such a desire. And how could she ask this when He had not yet gone to the Father?

Read more (672 words)

What then does this mean? It seems to me that even now she wished to associate with Him as before. From joy she imagined nothing great, though He had become far more perfect according to the flesh.

Therefore Christ wished to turn her away from such an opinion. He taught her not to speak with Him without any caution, for, as is clear, He no longer associated with the disciples as before.

He raises her thoughts and thereby teaches her to approach Him with greater reverence. If He had said, "Do not come near Me as before; circumstances have changed, and I shall no longer associate with you as before," this would have been unpleasant.

It would have sounded like boasting and vainglory. But the words, "for I have not yet ascended to the Father," were not burdensome, and yet they expressed the same thing.

By saying, "for I have not yet ascended to the Father," Christ makes clear that He hastens there and longs for it. One who is already ready to depart for heaven and will no longer associate with men should not be regarded with the same thoughts as before.

That this explanation is correct is clear from the following words: "Go and tell My brethren that I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God."

Yet He was not going to do this immediately, but after forty days. Why then does He speak in this way? In order to raise Mary's thoughts and assure her that He is ascending into heaven.

The words, "to My Father and your Father, to My God and your God," refer to the Incarnation, since the ascent belongs only to the flesh. Christ speaks thus because He is speaking with a woman who imagined nothing great.

Then is God His Father in one sense and ours in another? Exactly so. If God is not God of the righteous and God of other men in the same sense, how much more is He not God of the Son and of us in the same sense.

Since Christ said, "Tell My brethren," He shows the difference so that no one would infer some equality between Him and the disciples from these words. He Himself will sit upon the Father's throne, while they will stand before that throne.

Therefore, although Christ, according to His human nature, became our brother, nevertheless in glory He is exceedingly different from us. He is so different that it cannot even be expressed.

When at last she recognized His voice, for this was already the second time she saw Him, she again fell at His feet, as she had the first time. But He did not receive her as favorably as then.

He put her away with the words: "Do not touch Me!" At that earlier time two women embraced and kissed His honorable and most pure feet, and they heard nothing of this kind from Him.

Do you see that the Savior rightly puts away from Himself the one who did not believe, saying, "Do not touch Me"? At His first appearance He freely allowed them to touch His feet and kiss them.

Through touch, even more than through sight and hearing, He wished to assure them that He, the crucified and buried One, had risen.

But now He puts Magdalene away from Himself. After such strong assurance, she had abandoned her conviction. Therefore she hears: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father."

These words contain both a rebuke for her unbelief and an awakening of her mind. He reminds her of the heavenly Father and persuades her not to think that He is only what she sees.

That is, He is not merely a man risen from the dead. He is also God, the true Son of God, Who for our sake became man.

"Go to My brethren and say to them: I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God."

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

"Do not touch Me," that is, circumstances are no longer as they were before, and I will no longer associate with you as before.

Although He did not say this in words, such is the meaning of the words: "I am ascending to My Father." I hasten there.

And since I hasten there and no longer have such a body as belongs to earthly life, one must be more reverent toward Me.

I am above ordinary conversation and touch, that is, above ordinary association. See how many thoughts the Evangelist expressed briefly.

The Lord said, "Do not touch Me." Then, as though someone asked, "Why?" He answers: because My body is no longer such as belongs to earthly life.

Read more (163 words)

It is such as befits heaven and the dwellings above. Then the questioner, as it were, continues: Why then do You walk on earth, when You have such a body?

He answers: because I have not yet ascended to My Father, but I will ascend. For He expresses this in the following words: "Go to My brethren and say to them: I am ascending to My Father and your Father."

Yet He will not ascend immediately, but after forty days. Why then speak this way?

In order to raise her mind and persuade her that He is departing to the heavens, and by this to comfort her.

Having called the disciples brethren, He adds: "and your Father." God is Father also to us, but by grace. To the Lord He is Father by nature.

Conversely, He is God to us by nature, and God to the Lord according to His humanity. For He became His God when He took upon Himself human nature.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Jesus said to her, “Touch Me not, for I have not yet ascended to My Father.”

The meaning of this saying is not clear to all, for it contains a mystery. Yet it must be examined for our profit, since the Lord will grant us understanding of His words.

He forbids the woman to approach Him and does not allow her desire to embrace His feet to be fulfilled. Explaining the reason, He says, “For I have not yet ascended to My Father.” We must ask how these words are to be understood.

Why, if He had not yet ascended to the heavenly Father, was this a sufficient reason that those who loved Him should not touch His holy flesh? Would it not be groundless to think that the Lord said this because He feared defilement from her touch, or wished to ascend pure to the heavenly Father? Would not such a thought be utterly foolish and senseless?

The divine nature can in no way be subject to defilement. The light of a sunbeam may touch filthy heaps or other impurities of the earth, yet it suffers no harm. It remains what it is, plainly unstained and in no way sharing their foulness. So also the divine and most pure nature can in no way receive impurity from defilement.

What, then, is the meaning of His stopping Mary as she came to Him and wished to touch His holy flesh? What does the Lord wish to indicate by the words, “For I have not yet ascended to My Father”? This we must consider, as far as we are able.

We point out that there were many and various causes of the coming of our Savior. Yet one of them is especially important, and He Himself indicated it when He said, “I came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance” (Mt 9:13).

Therefore, before the saving Cross and the Resurrection from the dead, while the divine economy concerning us had not yet received its fitting completion, He had fellowship with both righteous and unrighteous. He ate with publicans and sinners. He gave free access to those who wished to touch His holy flesh, that He might sanctify all, call them to the knowledge of the truth, and restore to health those who were sick and crushed by the diseases of sins.

For this reason He also said to them, “Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick” (Lk 5:31). Thus, before the Resurrection from the dead, He entered without distinction into fellowship with righteous and sinners. He absolutely rejected none who approached Him.

Thus, when He once reclined in the house of a Pharisee, a woman approached weeping, “who was a sinner in the city” (Lk 7:37), as it is written. Loosening the hair she had always arranged, and having barely left her former sins, she began to wipe His feet. He is not shown to have forbidden her.

Likewise, when He was going to raise the daughter of the ruler of the synagogue, “a woman who had a flow of blood approached and touched the hem of His garment” (Lk 8:43-44). We see that He was not at all angry with her. On the contrary, He counted her worthy of a gracious word: “Daughter,” He said, “your faith has saved you; go in peace” (Lk 8:48).

At that time, for a providential purpose, even those still unclean, and those whose bodies and souls were defiled, were allowed unhindered to touch the very holy flesh of our Savior Christ. They received every blessing from Him.

But when He had fulfilled the divine economy concerning us, had endured crucifixion itself and death on the Cross, and had come to life again, manifesting His nature as superior to death, He then forbids this. He no longer readily permits all who approach to touch His holy flesh.

By this He gives an example to the holy churches and to His mystery, the Eucharist. The law of wise Moses also indicated this example when it commanded that the lamb be slain as a type of Christ. For it says, “No uncircumcised person shall eat of it” (Ex 12:48), calling the unclean uncircumcised.

Humanity must be understood as unclean by its own nature. For what is human nature when compared with the purity proper to God? Therefore those still uncircumcised, that is, unclean, must not touch the Holy Body. Rather, those who have been made pure by the circumcision understood in the Spirit may do so. “For circumcision is of the heart, in the Spirit” (Rom 2:29), according to Paul.

Yet there would be no circumcision in the Spirit in us unless the Holy Spirit dwelt in us through faith and holy baptism. Therefore was it not fitting that Mary should for the moment remain kept from touching the Holy Body, since she had not yet received the Spirit?

For although Christ had risen from the dead, the Spirit had not yet been given by the Father through Him to humanity. After His ascent to God and the Father, He sent Him down to us. Therefore He said, “It is to your advantage that I go away; for if I do not go away, the Advocate will not come to you. But if I go, I will send Him to you” (Jn 16:7).

Thus, since the Holy Spirit had not yet been sent, because the Savior had not yet ascended to the Father, He restrains Mary as one who had not yet received the Spirit. He says, “Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father.” That is, “I have not yet sent the Holy Spirit to you.”

From this comes an example for the churches. For this reason we also keep from the sacred table those who have known His Godhead and have already confessed the faith, that is, the catechumens. They have not yet been enriched by the Holy Spirit, for He does not dwell in those not yet baptized.

But when we become partakers of the Holy Spirit, then nothing prevents us from touching our Savior Christ. This is why the ministers of the divine mysteries proclaim to those who wish to partake of the mystical blessing, “Holy things for the holy.” They teach that communion in the Holy Gifts is wholly fitting only for those sanctified in the Spirit.

“But go to My brethren, and say to them: I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God.”

For the reasons already given, He does not allow Mary to touch His flesh, though she greatly desired this because of her love for God. Yet He repays her attachment to Him and appoints a double reward for such great faith and love. He shows that piety toward Him does not remain fruitless in those who advance in it.

More important still, in Mary first, speaking generally, the whole female sex is crowned with a double honor and receives deliverance from its ancient infirmities. She was the first to lament Christ in this way and to make Him the cause of tears. She turned sorrow into joy when she heard from Him, who once condemned woman and made her easily subject to the assaults of grief, that she must not weep.

For God had said to the woman, “In sorrows you shall bring forth children” (Gen 3:16). As He once subjected her to sorrows in paradise, when she followed the serpent’s suggestions and obeyed the devil’s devices, so again in a garden He commands her no longer to weep.

Releasing her also from the very curse by which sorrows were assigned to her, He commands her to become the first herald of great blessings. He bids her proclaim to the disciples the ascent into heaven.

This was so that, just as the first and most ancient of all women followed the devil’s suggestions and was condemned, and in her the whole female sex, so this woman, obeying the words of our Savior and announcing what leads to eternal life, might free the whole female sex from blame.

Thus the Lord grants Mary no longer to weep and no longer to be easily accessible to sorrows in her heart. He grants her to acquire beautiful feet. For according to the prophet, “How beautiful are the feet of those who preach good things” (Rom 10:15 from Is 52:7). The first woman did not have beautiful feet, for she preached no good thing when she advised the forefather to transgress the divine commandment.

You may see that Mary is worthy of honor from the fact that she was counted worthy of prophetic mention. What did the prophet say concerning her and the women with her, who announced the Savior’s Resurrection to the holy disciples? “Women coming from the sight, come; for the people are without understanding” (Is 27:11).

Here the Word of God commands these women, truly lovers of God, to hasten swiftly and announce what they had seen. He also condemns the senselessness of the Jews, because they mocked even the very report of the Resurrection of our Savior Christ.

There were other women, as the other Evangelists report (Mt 28:1; Mk 16:1; Lk 23:55; 24:1). Yet wise John mentioned only Mary. We must not regard this as a contradiction among the words of the holy Evangelists.

John naturally mentioned Mary Magdalene alone, because she had a more fervent love for Christ. She saw the tomb before the others, came into the garden, and searched all the surrounding place to find the body. For she thought that the Lord had truly been moved.

The outcome and completion of intentions and deeds are usually attributed to the principal persons, even if there were other advisers and fellow workers. Therefore, for Mary’s honor, glory, and perpetual praise, the Savior granted her to announce to the brethren, “I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God.”

Again receive from me this deep and great mystery. Do not allow your heart to turn aside from the faithful rule of the divine doctrines.

Do you not hear how the Only-begotten Word of God became like us, that we also might become like Him, as far as this is accessible to our nature and as far as it may be said concerning our renewal by grace? He humbled Himself in order to raise what is low by nature to His own height. He bore the form of a servant (Phil 2:6-7), though by nature He is Lord and Son, that He might transfer what is servile by nature into the glory of sonship, according to His image and likeness (Gal 4:4-5).

As He became like us, that is, man, so that we might become like Him, that is, gods and sons (Jn 10:34; 1 Jn 3:1), He takes into Himself what is ours and gives us in return what is His own.

How does this happen? You will reasonably wish to ask. I shall answer as I can.

First, those who by condition and nature are servants, since creatures are servants of the Creator (Ps 118:91), He calls His brethren. He names God as His common Father and ours. Since He made human properties His own because of His likeness to us, He called our God His God, though He is Son by nature.

This was so that, just as we, through likeness to Him, were raised to a dignity above our nature, so also He, because He took our form and became man according to the Scriptures (Jn 1:14; 1 Tim 3:16), has God as His God. Yet by nature He is God from God, and true God.

For we are not sons of God by nature, yet we are called sons of God, because through His Spirit He cries in us, “Abba, Father!” (Rom 8:15).

Therefore do not be scandalized if you hear that He calls God His God. Rather, as one eager to learn, focus your attention and carefully consider the precision of the expression.

He says that God is His Father and our God, speaking the truth in both respects. The God of all is by nature and in reality the Father of Christ. He is not our father by nature, but rather God, as Creator and Lord.

Yet, as though mingling Himself with us, the Son grants to our nature the dignity proper and particular to Himself. He calls His own Begetter our common Father. Again, because of His likeness to us, He takes into Himself what is innate to our nature, for He calls His own Father His God. He does not wish to dishonor His likeness to us, because of His own love for mankind and mercy.

If, therefore, in your ignorance you wish to accuse this expression, and if it seems unbearable to you that the Lord calls the Father and God His God, then you must senselessly accuse the divine economy that took place for your sake. When you ought to give thanks, you will dishonor the Benefactor and irrationally slander the form of God’s love shown to us.

Indeed, if He humbled Himself (Phil 2:7), despising the shame (Heb 12:2), and became man for your sake, then this, beloved, is because of your lowliness. To Him who wished to undergo this for your sake, great and complete reverence is due.

Read the full text in the app

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Let us consider, with the help of the Lord Himself, what these words of His mean. When did He ascend to the Father? According to the testimony of the Acts of the Apostles, on the fortieth day after His Resurrection.

That is the day we shall yet celebrate in His name. Then He ascended to the Father. Then the disciples, who had handled Him with their hands, followed Him with their eyes.

Then the angelic voice was heard: "Men of Galilee, why do you stand looking up into heaven? This Jesus, Who was taken up from you into heaven, will come in the same way as you saw Him go into heaven" (Acts 1:11).

Read more (980 words)

If He ascended to the Father then, what shall we say, brethren? How could Mary, who could not touch Him while He stood on earth, touch Him when He sits in heaven? If she could not do so here, then how much less there?

What then do these words mean: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father"? Will some senseless person say that, before His ascent to the Father, men could touch Him, but women could do so only after His ascent to the Father?

Such a thought is absurd, and such an opinion is perverse. What then do these words mean: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father"?

You, seeing Me, honor Me only as man, and you do not yet know My equality with the Father. Do not touch Me as a mere man. Do not receive Me with such faith, but understand in Me the Word equal to the Father.

I shall ascend to the Father, and then touch Me. For you, I shall ascend when you understand Me as equal to the Father. As long as you honor Me as lesser, I have not yet ascended for you.

Let the Church, of which Mary bore the image, hear what Mary heard. Let us all touch Him when we believe. He has already ascended to the Father and sits at the right hand of the Father.

This the whole Church now confesses, believing in Him Who ascended into heaven and sits at the right hand of the Father. Those being baptized hear this and believe it even before Baptism. When they believe, Mary touches Christ.

This understanding is obscure, but saving. It is closed to unbelievers, but open to one who interprets by faith. Therefore the Lord Jesus Christ Himself is both there and with us.

He is with the Father and in us. He does not depart from Him and does not abandon us. As Teacher He teaches us to pray, and as Son He hears our prayer together with the Father.

In these words there is something we must consider, briefly yet with due attention. By answering her in this way, Jesus instructed in faith the woman who recognized Him and called Him Teacher.

This Gardener sowed the mustard seed in her heart as in His own garden. For what does "Do not touch Me" mean? As though revealing the reason for this prohibition, He added: "For I have not yet ascended to My Father."

What does this mean? If one cannot touch Him standing on earth, how can people touch Him sitting in heaven? Yet it is certain that before He ascended, He allowed the disciples to touch Him.

As the Evangelist Luke testifies, He said: "Handle Me and see; for a spirit does not have flesh and bones, as you see that I have" (Lk 24:39).

And He said to the disciple Thomas: "Put your finger here, and see My hands; put out your hand, and place it in My side" (Jn 20:27).

Who would be so foolish as to say that He wanted the disciples to touch Him before He ascended to the Father, but did not want a woman to touch Him before He ascended to the Father?

Let us not permit someone who wished to think this to be so unreasonable. We read that women also touched Jesus after His Resurrection and before His Ascension to the Father. Among them was Mary Magdalene herself.

According to Matthew's account, Jesus met them and said, "Rejoice!" And they, he says, came up and took hold of His feet and worshiped Him (Mt 28:9). John passed this over in silence, but Matthew stated it quite clearly.

One conclusion remains: some mystery is hidden in these words. Whether we open it or cannot discover it at all, we must in no way doubt that it exists.

Thus this, "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father," was said either because this woman serves as a type of the Church from the Gentiles, which did not believe in Christ before He ascended to the Father.

Or Jesus wished that faith in Him should be precisely of this kind, so that He would be touched spiritually. One must understand that He and His Father are one.

For He ascends to the Father, as it were, in the inward sense of the one who has advanced so far in receiving Him that he confesses Him equal to the Father.

Otherwise He is not touched rightly. That is, otherwise He is not believed in rightly. Perhaps Mary believed in such a way that she did not consider Him equal to the Father. This was certainly forbidden her by the words: "Do not touch Me."

That is: Do not believe in Me as you still understand. Let your senses not reach only to what I became for your sake, without rising to that through which you came to have being.

For in what way, if not carnally, did she still believe in Him Whom she mourned as a man? "For I have not yet ascended to My Father," He said, where you will touch Me when you believe in Me as God equal to the Father.

"Go to My brethren and say to them: I ascend to My Father and your Father." He did not say, "to our Father." That is, in one sense it was proper to say "My," and in another sense "your": by nature, "My"; by grace, "your."

"To My God and your God." Here too He did not say, "to our God." Therefore here also, in one sense, "My," and in another, "your."

"To My God," that is, under Whom I too abide as man. "To your God," that is, between Whom and you I stand as Mediator.

Gregory of Nyssa

4th centuryChurch Father

Suddenly I feel myself struck by the light-bearing garment of the Angel. My heart is shaken with joy by that longed-for earthquake, which rolls away the heavy stone of the human tomb and opens to all the door of resurrection. Let us also run to this sight of the extraordinary wonder. For the Sabbath has already passed; let us not remain behind the women. Let spices be in our hands: faith and conscience, for this is the fragrance of Christ. Let us no longer seek the living among the dead. The Lord repels the one who seeks in this way, saying, “Do not touch Me” (Jn 20:17). But when I ascend to the Father, then you may touch Me.

Gregory the Theologian

4th centuryChurch Father

For we have both known and preached the Godhead of the Son, guided by great and exalted words. Which words? These: God, Word, in the beginning, with the Beginning the beginning: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (Jn 1:1).

And: "The beginning is with You" (Ps 103:4). And again: "Who calls forth the generations from the beginning?" (Isa 41:4).

There are also the names: Only-begotten Son, "The Only-begotten Son, Who is in the bosom of the Father, He has declared Him" (Jn 1:18); Way, Truth, Life, Light, "I am the way, the truth, and the life" (Jn 14:6), and again, "I am the light of the world" (Jn 8:12).

Read more (688 words)

Wisdom, Power: "Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God" (1 Cor 1:24). Radiance, Image, Character, Seal: "He, being the radiance of His glory and the character of His hypostasis" (Heb 1:3).

And again: "The image of goodness" (Wis 7:26). And again: "God the Father has set His seal on Him" (Jn 6:27). Lord, King, He Who Is, Almighty: "And the Lord rained fire from the Lord" (Gen 19:24).

And again: "A scepter of uprightness is the scepter of Your kingdom" (Ps 44:7). And again: "Who is and Who was and Who is to come, the Almighty" (Rev 1:8).

These are clearly ascribed to the Son, as are other names of equal force and belonging to the same class. None of them is something acquired and afterward assigned to the Son or to the Spirit, just as none is acquired by the Father Himself.

For He is not perfected by addition. There was no time when He was without the Word. There was no time when He was not Father. There was no time when He was not true, or wise, or almighty, or lacking life, brightness, or goodness.

Now enumerate, in opposition to these words, the ones your ingratitude searches out. Such are: "My God and your God," "greater" (Jn 14:28), "created" (Prov 8:22), "made" (Acts 2:36), "sanctified" (Jn 10:36).

If you wish, add these: "servant" (Isa 49:3), "obedient" (Phil 3:7), "gave" (Jn 5:22; 10:29), "learned" (Heb 5:8), "commanded" (Jn 14:31), "sent" (Jn 10:36; 17:3).

Add that He "can do nothing of Himself" (Jn 5:30), nor speak (Jn 12:49), nor judge (Jn 12:47), nor grant (Mt 20:23), nor will (Mt 26:39).

Add also the passages in which ignorance (Mk 13:32), subjection (1 Cor 15:28), prayer (Lk 6:2), questioning (Jn 11:34), advancement (Lk 2:52), and perfection (Heb 5:9) are attributed to the Son.

Add, if you wish, expressions still more lowly than these: He sleeps (Mt 8:24), hungers (Mt 4:7), grows weary (Jn 4:6), weeps (Jn 11:35), is in agony (Lk 22:44), and hides Himself (Jn 8:59).

Perhaps you will even turn death and the Cross into reproach. For you will not touch, I think, the Resurrection and Ascension, since in them something favorable to us will be found.

Besides these, you can gather much else, if you wish to fashion for yourself a God who shares only the name and is counted among creatures. But we have God, true and equal in honor to the Father.

If each of these expressions is examined separately, it will not be difficult to explain them to you in a pious sense. We can remove everything in the Scriptures that serves as a stumbling block for you, if indeed you truly stumble and do not intentionally distort them.

In general, refer the more exalted expressions to the Godhead and to the nature above sufferings and the body. Refer the more lowly expressions to Him Who is composite, Who emptied Himself for you and was incarnate, or, to speak no worse, became man.

Afterward He was exalted, so that you might destroy in your doctrines everything fleshly and crawling upon the earth. You must learn to be more exalted and to ascend in mind to the Godhead.

Do not halt at what is visible. Rise to what is intelligible, and know where the discourse concerns the divine nature, and where it concerns His divine economy.

Strive to be the first to see the stone taken away, and perhaps the angels, and Jesus Himself. Say something, listen to the voice, and if you hear, "Do not touch Me," stand at a distance and honor the Word. Do not grieve, for He knows to whom He should appear before others.

In a word, refer the more exalted sayings to the Godhead and to the nature that surpasses sufferings and the body. Refer the lower ones to Him Who is composite, Who for your sake humbled Himself and was incarnate, or, to speak no worse, became man, and then was exalted.

Gregory often speaks of the composite nature of man. In the present context, the reference is exclusively to the God-manhood of Christ.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

"Do not touch Me." This was said, first, because this body is the firstfruits of the tomb. The Lord Himself, as priest, carefully guarded it from all hands, so that He might give it to the hand able to receive such a gift and render a like gift for it.

Second, He commanded that she not touch Him in order to teach that His body had already been clothed with honor and glory. By this He showed that only while He was a servant was authority over His body given to all people, since tax collectors and sinners came and approached Him.

Further, He did this to show that His enemies had no power to lay hands on Him. His friends, however, can approach Him in another way, namely, in love and fear.

Read more (997 words)

Since they, His friends, in a certain sense subject Him to suffering, because they partake of Him, or of the mystery of His Body, He thereby taught those who partake. Imitating Him, they too should subject their bodies to suffering.

As He comforted them by His suffering, so they should comfort Him by their suffering.

In addition, some say that He did not allow Mary to touch Him because she had not yet received the Mystery of His Body and Blood. This was to provide an example. Not only enemies, like Judas, but also friends who, like Mary, had not yet been sealed, did not approach His mystery.

Here sealing means the reception of the Eucharist, according to the custom of the Eastern Christians, among whom the Eucharist is offered immediately after Baptism.

Then, because Eve, by stretching out her hand, subjected the human body to death and filled it with every illness, the Lord did not permit Mary to approach His body. He preserved this body for the arm that set Him at His right hand.

He preserved it also for the hand that, after the Ascension, surrounded Him with every blessedness. That is, the Lord did not allow His body to be touched before He ascended into heaven and was crowned with glory by the Father.

Then, because Mary doubted when she heard that He had risen, she came, saw Him, and asked, "If you have taken Him" (cf. Jn 20:15). Therefore He said this to show her that He had truly risen.

"I ascend to My Father." By these words He did not confirm that no one should approach Him because He was ascending to the Father. Rather, since she doubted, He said to her: Do not come near Me until I ascend to My Father.

It is like the other saying: "A sword will pass through your own soul also," that is, denial (cf. Lk 2:35).

Yet if He forbade her to touch Him because she had doubted His Resurrection, behold Thomas doubted and nevertheless touched Him. To this we shall say the following.

As He foretold His suffering before He suffered, and His Resurrection before He rose, so in this place He wished to foretell His Ascension.

Thus, when He said, "Do not touch Me," a new proclamation of His Ascension, entire and complete, was given to Mary. For He says further: "Go, tell My brethren: I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God."

He says: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father." Yet He blessed the actions of Cleopas and his companion, ate with the disciples, and showed Thomas His side. Why then did He forbid Mary to touch Him?

Perhaps because He had entrusted her in the Gospel to John in His own place, saying, "Woman, behold your son" (Jn 19:26). Earlier the discourse spoke of Mary Magdalene: Jn 20:1, 11, 17-18; Lk 23 and 24:10; Mt 27 and 28:1. Yet afterward Saint Ephrem has the Theotokos in mind.

Neither was the first sign accomplished without her, nor did the firstfruits of the tomb remain without her. Just as the first miracle in Cana of Galilee took place in Mary's presence, so also did Christ's departure from the tomb.

"I have not yet ascended to My Father." By His answer He seems to have rejected Mary's false thought. He taught her, as He taught the disciples, that He would ascend into heaven and at the end of the world would come and give her the promised gifts.

Because Mary suddenly recognized Him, her thought was carried away to His last coming, and she thought that the Kingdom of Heaven had arrived. Therefore He said: "I have not yet ascended to My Father."

Further, since Christ, born in a wondrous manner, is the firstborn from the tomb, in which tribes, generations, and peoples perish, He thereby taught something about the Resurrection. There neither fathers turn to children nor children to fathers, but all turn to this one thing.

If they are found worthy, they ascend by mercy to the Father.

"I go to My Father and your Father, to My God and your God." If this is understood just as it is written, then it will appear that the Father is in heaven and not on earth.

For if He were on earth, why would the Son have to go to heaven? If you say that the Son was not in heaven, I shall answer that neither is the Father on earth.

He said, "And I go to You, My Father" (cf. Jn 17:11), not "My God." When He spoke with Him, He called Him Father, in order to show that He is from Him.

But when He sent a messenger to His disciples, saying, "I go," He called Him "My God," to show His weakness while He was with them.

Yet He also says: "I am not alone, because My Father is with Me" (Jn 16:32), and, "I am in the Father and the Father in Me, and We are one" (cf. Jn 14:11; 10:30).

"I go to My Father and your Father, to My God and your God." It should be noted that He first said, "to My Father," and then, "to your Father." He first said, "to My God," and then, "to your God."

If He had used the same words, perhaps their interpretation would also have had some force. The author refutes interpreters who used this passage to deny the Godhead of Christ.

"My Father and your Father" and "My God and your God." Both are said concerning His humanity. He said that He was going in reference to His body, not to the Word of God, just as in the words "to your Father," since they were men.

In the same way, His human nature is spoken of in the place where He said: "Our Father, Who art in heaven" (cf. Mt 6:9).

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

How is it that in the Gospel of John, after the Resurrection, Christ says to Mary Magdalene, "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father," while in Matthew, on the contrary, it is said that the women clasped the Savior's feet (Mt 28:9)?

In any case, touching His feet after the Resurrection and not touching them are not one and the same.

Mary Magdalene is the very one from whom Jesus Christ had cast out seven demons (Mk 16:9), so that where sin abounded, grace might abound all the more.

And now, when she took the Lord for a gardener, spoke with Him as with a mere man, and sought the Living among the dead, she rightly heard from the Lord: "Do not touch Me."

Read more (128 words)

This is the thought of these words: You are not worthy to touch My feet. You are not worthy to worship Me as Lord and fall at His feet if you do not believe His Resurrection.

For you, I have not yet ascended to My Father. But the other women, who touch the feet of Jesus Christ, confess Him as Lord.

They are deemed worthy to fall at His feet because they believe that He has ascended to the Father.

If different Gospels relate that one and the same woman both touched the feet and did not touch them, this is easily resolved.

At first she could receive rebuke as one who did not believe. Later she could also not be rejected, when she replaced error with confession.

John Damascene

8th centuryChurch Father

You called Him Father according to the divine essence, and, having become man by nature, You called Him God, O Most High, condescending to servants. Having risen from the tomb, You appointed the Father by grace for those born on earth, who by nature is God and Master. With Him we all magnify You. You called Him Your Father according to the divine essence, and, since You Yourself became man by nature, You called Him God, O Most High, coming down to servants. Having risen from the tomb, You declared as Father by grace for those born on earth Him who by nature is God and Master. With Him we all magnify You.

Maximus the Confessor

7th centuryChurch Father

He who considers the Lord to be the Creator only of what is born and perishes takes Him, like Mary Magdalene, for a gardener (Jn 20:15).

Therefore, for the benefit of such a person, the Lord avoids his touch, since that person considers the Lord incapable of ascending to the Father. For this reason He says to him: "Do not touch Me" (Jn 20:17).

For the Lord knows that harm may befall the one who approaches Him with so ordinary a disposition of soul.

Jesus says to her: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father." The words "Do not touch Me" were spoken by the Lord to Mary Magdalene, who thought Him to be the gardener.

Read more (328 words)

By them He manifests and reveals this mystery: every thinking soul that has not yet gained mastery over the hut grown together with it takes the Word only as Creator of things that arise and perish.

Such things differ in nothing from vegetables being cultivated. For in both are observed the flux of their nature, limitation by time, and periodicity.

Such a soul thinks that for these and to these the Word came and descended. It is unworthy of spiritual touch with the Word.

Therefore it seeks Him in visible things. It knows Him only as having become flesh for our sake, but does not fittingly know Him as God, begotten of God the Father.

In all likelihood, the words "I have not yet ascended to My Father," spoken to a soul so disposed, compel us to think of this.

Such a soul has not yet been raised to the heights of contemplation by higher theology and faith, by which the nature of visible things is bounded.

Like a Galilean woman, it still needs a more perfect understanding of this. It needs the Lord, as Teacher, to raise it through contemplation toward the capacity to receive the revelation of divine things.

It needs to understand, as far as possible, Him together with the logoi which He brought into being as prototypes of visible things.

This soul also still needs to become such as the Lord was, who became and was manifested like us in all things except sin.

If we are deemed worthy of this gift, we shall be with Him, deprived only of the sinfulness of nature.

Now, receiving this gift through hope and glorifying it by the proper works of the commandments, you can already taste the joy of this gift, since you have believed and labored.

Your joy is without end and overflowing, because the Giver of this gift, in a supersubstantial manner, surpasses both the movement of nature and the comprehensibility of every age.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

Jesus says to her: "Do not touch Me." Mary rushed to embrace the feet of Jesus Christ, as had happened before. Jesus Christ restrains her from treating Him as before, because His body had already become divine.

"For I have not yet ascended to My Father." Chrysostom says that Jesus Christ said this to Mary for no other reason than that she might know He is now higher and must be honored more greatly.

He who wishes to ascend with His body to God the Father has clearly already rejected bodily corruption.

But a little earlier she and the other Mary took hold of the feet of Jesus Christ, as the Evangelist Matthew said (Mt 28:9), and He did not restrain them from this.

Read more (286 words)

He gave them the possibility, through touch, to be convinced that He was not a phantom. But now He does not allow it, because Mary had already forgotten that vision and touch, and had not believed.

"But go to My brethren and say to them: I am ascending to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God."

But Jesus Christ was not to ascend immediately, but after forty days. Why, then, does He say, "I am ascending"?

Certainly in order to raise Mary's thoughts still more, to confirm that He is now higher and more divine, and to persuade her that she must now look upon Him with greater reverence.

Moreover, "I am ascending" here means, "I desire to ascend." Therefore this action can refer also to a later time.

Jesus Christ reminds the disciples of what He had often told them before He was handed over to death.

He called the disciples brethren because He Himself was man and was akin to them according to His humanity.

Jesus Christ called God His Father in one sense, and the Father of the disciples in another. He is His Father by nature, since He is consubstantial with Him.

He is Father of the disciples by creation and providence, since they are His creatures and have been deemed worthy of His providence.

He also called Him both His God and the disciples' God, as of men in general. But why did Jesus Christ not say directly, "and our God," but separated Himself here?

Because, although He was man and brother of the disciples according to His human nature, He far surpassed them by reason of His union with the divine nature and His sinlessness.

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

But the Evangelist no longer adds what this woman did. Yet the inference is drawn from what she heard. She is told: "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to My Father."

By these words it is shown that Mary wished to touch the feet of Him Whom she had recognized. But the Teacher says to her: "Do not touch Me."

This is not because the Lord, after the Resurrection, rejected the touch of women. Of the two who came to His tomb it is written: "They came and took hold of His feet and worshiped Him" (Mt 28:9).

Why she must not touch Him is explained by the reason added afterward: "For I have not yet ascended to My Father." Jesus ascends to the Father in our heart when He is confessed to be equal to the Father.

Read more (504 words)

For in the heart of one who does not believe that He is equal to the Father, the Lord has not yet ascended to the Father. Therefore he truly touches Jesus who believes that He is coeternal with the Father.

Jesus had already ascended to the Father in Paul's heart when Paul said: "Being in the form of God, He did not consider equality with God a thing to be grasped" (Phil 2:6).

Therefore John touched our Redeemer with the hand of faith when he says: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God" (Jn 1:1-2).

Thus one touches the Lord who believes that, according to the eternity of His being, He is equal to the Father.

But perhaps someone has a hidden question ready: How can the Son be equal to the Father? In this matter, what human nature cannot understand because of wonder, it must know as certain from another wonder.

It has a brief answer to give itself. It is known that He is the One Who created the Mother in whose virginal womb He was created according to His humanity.

What wonder is it, then, if He Who existed before His Mother is equal to the Father? By Paul's witness we know that Christ is "the power of God and the wisdom of God" (1 Cor 1:24).

Therefore whoever declares the Son lesser partly takes away from the Father, whose Wisdom he confesses to be unequal to Him. What powerful man would calmly endure it if someone said to him, "Though you are great, your wisdom is less than you"?

The Lord Himself says: "I and the Father are one" (Jn 10:30). And again He says: "My Father is greater than I" (Jn 14:28). It is also written of Him that He "was subject to them," that is, to Joseph and the Ever-Virgin Mary (Lk 2:51).

What wonder is it, then, if according to His humanity He declares Himself less than the Father in heaven, when according to that same humanity He was subject even to His parents on earth?

According to this humanity He now says to Mary: "Go to My brethren and say to them: I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God."

When He says "My" and "your," why does He not say generally, "our"? By speaking separately, He shows that He has the same Father and God differently from us.

"I ascend to My Father," that is, by nature, "and to your Father," by grace. "To My God," because I have descended; "to your God," because you ascend.

Since I too am man, He is God for Me. Since you have been freed from error, He is God for you. Therefore for Me He is Father and God in a different way, because Him Whom He begot as God before the ages, He made man in Me at the end of the ages.

Antonius (Chrapowizki)

19th centuryChurch Father

The Octoechos says: "But since, as a weak woman, she still minds earthly things, therefore she is sent away and not allowed to touch Christ" (ninth Gospel sticheron).

What does this mean? Of course, there can be no question here of any attempt at a passionate touch. No.

Simply, the complete unexpectedness of seeing the Teacher she had mourned alive seized Mary's soul with such immediate joy that before thinking of the mysterious Resurrection or His Godhead, she simply surrendered to ecstatic gladness.

It was as over a dear person who had escaped mortal danger. Forgetting that she was a woman, she wished to embrace the Teacher and kiss Him whom, in the preceding moments, she had considered dead and stolen.

Read more (153 words)

The Lord reminds her that such an expression, though of perfectly pure joy, is unfitting. Yet that very evening He invites His still doubting male disciples to handle His wounds.

The Lord's relation to the worship of this same Mary Magdalene and the other Mary was different an hour or two after His first appearance.

Here both Marys already knew that the Lord appears to believers as the Conqueror of death and Hades. He ascends to the heavenly Father into the eternal Kingdom.

He also sends the apostles with authority to preach and to wage victorious battle against the world.

Now both women, meeting Him as He says to them, "Rejoice," no longer "mind earthly things." They worship Him as the living Holiness, as the Son of God.

Therefore He does not prevent them from doing what they did: "And they came and held Him by the feet and worshiped Him" (Mt 28:9).

Makarios (Bulgakow)

19th centuryChurch Father

When He said, “I ascend to My Father and your Father, and to My God and your God,” He spoke both as Son of God and as man. For God is His Father by nature, and became His God by divine economy, since the Son took human nature upon Himself. With regard to us, however, the opposite is true: God is Father only by grace, but Master and God by nature.

Theophan the Recluse

19th centuryChurch Father

Why did the Savior, after His Resurrection, say to the weeping Mary Magdalene, “Do not touch Me”? Since this is not indicated, we may decide as follows: surely Mary’s disposition required it, either her usual disposition or the one she had at that moment. For touching itself is not forbidden, as the Lord showed with the other women. Let us be content with this.

Roshdestwenski W.G.

Teacher of the Church

Mary’s tears are not poured out fervently in vain. Behold, she was counted worthy both of Angels who taught her and of the vision of Jesus Himself. Yet she still thinks earthly things, as a weak woman. Therefore she is sent away and told not to touch Christ. Yet she is sent as preacher to Your disciples, bearing good tidings to them and announcing the ascent to the Father’s inheritance. With her, count us also worthy of Your manifestation, O Master and Lord.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 35 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Λέγει
    legei
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  2. αὐτῇ
    autē
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  3. Ἰησοῦς
    iēsous
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  4. Μή
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  5. μου
    mou
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  6. ἅπτου
    haptou
    I kindle
    G681 · ἅπτω
  7. οὔπω
    oupō
    not yet
    G3768 · οὔπω
  8. γὰρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  9. ἀναβέβηκα
    anabebēka
    I go up
    G305 · ἀναβαίνω
  10. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  11. τὸν
    ton
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  12. Πατέρα
    patera
    father
    G3962 · πατήρ
  13. πορεύου
    poreuou
    I travel
    G4198 · πορεύω
  14. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  15. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  16. τοὺς
    tous
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  17. ἀδελφούς
    adelphous
    a brother
    G80 · ἀδελφός
  18. μου
    mou
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  19. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  20. εἰπὲ
    eipe
    to say
    G2036 · ἔπω, ἐρῶ, εἶπον
  21. αὐτοῖς
    autois
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  22. Ἀναβαίνω
    anabainō
    I go up
    G305 · ἀναβαίνω
  23. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  24. τὸν
    ton
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  25. Πατέρα
    patera
    father
    G3962 · πατήρ
  26. μου
    mou
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  27. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  28. Πατέρα
    patera
    father
    G3962 · πατήρ
  29. ὑμῶν
    hymōn
    you
    G4771 · σύ
  30. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  31. Θεόν
    theon
    God
    G2316 · θεός
  32. μου
    mou
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  33. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  34. Θεὸν
    theon
    God
    G2316 · θεός
  35. ὑμῶν
    hymōn
    you
    G4771 · σύ