The Church Fathers on this verse

John 20:19Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Now when it was late the same day, the first of the week, and the doors were shut, where the disciples were gathered together, for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in the midst and said to them: Peace be to you.

Douay-Rheims

ουσης ουν οψιας τη ημερα εκεινη τη μια των σαββατων και των θυρων κεκλεισμενων οπου ησαν οι μαθηται συνηγμενοι δια τον φοβον των ιουδαιων ηλθεν ο ιησους και εστη εις το μεσον και λεγει αυτοις ειρηνη υμιν

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

13 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Yet it could easily have happened that the disciples, hearing this, would either not believe the woman or, believing her, would grieve that Christ had not counted them worthy of His appearance, although He had promised to appear to them in Galilee.

Therefore, so that they would not be troubled by such thoughts, Christ did not allow even one day to pass. He had stirred in them the desire to see Him, both by what they already knew of His resurrection and by the woman's account.

On that same day, when evening had come, they were burning with desire to see Him and were possessed by fear. This made their desire still stronger. Then He stood before them, and in a wondrous manner.

Why did He appear in the evening? Because at that time, most likely, they were in the greatest fear.

Read more (264 words)

But this is remarkable: how did they not take Him for a phantom, when He entered through locked doors and suddenly? Undoubtedly because Mary had already managed to produce strong faith in them. Besides, He appeared to them in a radiant and gentle form.

He did not appear by day, so that the disciples might all be gathered together, for they were in great fear. Therefore He did not even knock at the door, but suddenly stood in their midst. He showed them His side and His hands.

At the same time He calmed their troubled thoughts by His voice, saying, "Peace be unto you," that is, do not be troubled. By this He reminded them of the words spoken before the Passion: "Peace I leave with you, My peace I give to you" (John 14:27). And again: "In Me" have peace; "in the world you will have tribulation" (John 16:33).

[...] Since they were to have an irreconcilable warfare with the Jews, He often repeats, "Peace be unto you," offering them consolation equal to the warfare. This was the first word Christ spoke after the resurrection. Therefore Paul also says everywhere, "Grace to you and peace."

To the women the Lord proclaims joy, since the female sex was in sorrow and was condemned to sorrow by the first curse. Thus, quite fittingly, He proclaims peace to the men because of warfare, and joy to the women because of sorrow.

Having destroyed everything that was a cause of grief, Christ next speaks of the beneficial results of the Cross. Such a result was peace.

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

When Mary announced this to the disciples, it was natural that they either did not believe her or, having believed, regretted that they had not been counted worthy to see Him themselves.

Therefore He appears to them on the same day. On the one hand, after hearing from the woman that He had risen, they thirsted to see Him themselves. On the other hand, they feared the Jews, and this made them desire all the more to see this, their only consolation.

He appears "in the evening," so that all would have time to gather together. He appears "when the doors were locked," to show that He also rose while the stone lay upon the tomb.

Read more (241 words)

Someone may wonder how they did not take Him for a phantom. First of all, the woman who had gone before them had produced strong faith in them. Then He appeared to them in a gentle form, and by His very voice He calmed their troubled thoughts, saying, "Peace be unto you," that is, do not be troubled.

By this He reminds them of the word He had spoken to them before His Passion: "My peace I give to you" (John 14:27).

It is worth knowing why He appears to the disciples not in Galilee but in Jerusalem. For Matthew (Matt 26:32) and Mark (Mark 14:28) say that He promised to meet them in Galilee. How, then, does He appear in Jerusalem?

Some answer: "What of it? He did not say, I shall meet you only in Galilee and shall not meet you in Jerusalem. Therefore this is the wealth of His love, not an occasion to accuse Him of falsehood."

Then one may say that He promises to appear in Galilee to all the disciples, whereas in Jerusalem He appeared only to those belonging to the Twelve. Thus there is no disagreement here. In Galilee He appeared to all, but in Jerusalem to the Twelve.

Since the appearances were many, some Evangelists described certain appearances, and others described others. Sometimes two Evangelists report one and the same event, but what is stated briefly by one is completed by the other.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

On that same day, when He appeared and spoke with Mary, He also shone forth to the holy disciples themselves. They feared the savage assaults of the impious Jews and had therefore gathered in one house.

It is incredible that, after so many instructions and frequent commands, they should have lacked proper understanding of events and failed to avoid the fury of the murderers.

He appears to them in a wondrous manner. “The doors being shut,” as it is said, Christ unexpectedly “stood in the midst.” By an ineffable and divine power He rose above the natural order of things. He showed Himself higher than the mode of action and reason proper to man.

Read more (1007 words)

Let no one ask how the Lord, being in a material body, entered unhindered though “the doors were shut.” Rather, let him attend to this: the divine Evangelist says this not about one of us, but about Him who sits together with God the Father and easily accomplishes whatever He wills.

For it was fitting that He who is God by nature and true should not be subject to the natural order of things. These things, without doubt, came from Him. Rather, He rules over necessity itself and over all that takes place according to the natural law of nature.

Otherwise, how did He subject the sea to His feet and walk upon the waves as upon dry land, although our bodies cannot walk freely upon water? Or how did He perform His other wonders by His divine omnipotence?

You will certainly acknowledge that those things surpass our reason. Add this also to them. Do not, like some who are prone through their light-mindedness to improper thoughts, suppose because of this that the Lord rose not with this body, but without flesh and without the temple He had assumed.

If you cannot understand the operation of the Ineffable Nature, why do you not rather accuse human weakness? This, I think, is far more reasonable. But you prefer to be silent about the limitation assigned to you by the Creator.

As though rejecting sound sense, you object to the great mystery of the resurrection, on which we set all our hope. Indeed, let everyone remember Paul’s cry: “If the dead do not rise, then Christ is not risen. And if Christ is not risen, your faith is vain, and you are still in your sins” (1 Cor 15:16-17).

And again: “We are also found false witnesses of God, because we testified of God that He raised up Christ, whom He did not raise up, if indeed the dead do not rise” (1 Cor 15:15).

But what is restored, if not what had fallen? And what is raised, if not what had undergone death? How shall we expect resurrection if Christ did not raise His own temple, setting Himself before us as the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep and the firstborn from the dead?

Or how shall this corruptible put on incorruption if, as some think, it is subjected to total destruction? And why should it not undergo this, if it has no hope of being brought to life?

Therefore, do not disturb the correctness of the faith because of the miracle that occurred. Rather, wisely add this also to the other miracles. Notice how, by His wondrous entrance “when the doors were shut,” He showed again that He is God by nature.

He is not someone other than the One who had formerly dwelt with them. By uncovering the very side of His body and showing the wounds from the nails, He clearly certified that He had raised the temple which had hung on the cross.

He raised again that very body which He had borne. He plainly abolished the death proper to flesh, since He is by nature Life and God. Otherwise, what need was there to show His hands and side, if, according to the senseless opinion of some, He did not rise with His own flesh at all?

If He wished the disciples to think something else about Him, why did He not appear to them in another form? Why did He not, disregarding bodily appearance, produce other thoughts in them?

But behold, He shows great care that they believe in the resurrection of His flesh. Even when the time was already calling Him to transform His body into a certain ineffable and supernatural glory, He condescended providentially to appear with it again as it had been.

He did this so that He might not be thought to have another body, different from that in which He also suffered death on the cross. That the glory of the holy Body would have been unbearable for our eyes is easy to understand.

This would be clear if Christ had willed to disclose it before His ascent to the Father. Recall the transfiguration once shown to the holy disciples on the mountain.

The blessed Evangelist Matthew writes that He once took “Peter, James, and John, went up on the mountain, and was transfigured before them. His face shone like lightning, and His garments became white as snow” (Mt 17:1-2). They, unable to bear the vision, fell down.

Therefore, for providential reasons, our Lord Jesus Christ, not yet transforming His temple into the glory proper and fitting to Him, continued to appear in His former form. He wished to impart faith in no other kind of body than the one He received from the Holy Virgin.

In that body, crucified, He died according to the Scriptures, since death has power over flesh alone, and from flesh it has been driven out. For if His dead body did not rise, what death has been conquered? In what has the power of corruption been weakened?

Was one of the rational creatures subjected to death? Was the soul? Was an angel? Was the very Word of God? Therefore, if the power of death extends only to what is subject to corruption, the power of resurrection must justly apply to that alone.

Thus the might of the tyrant, the devil, is destroyed. Therefore, prudent people must number the Lord’s entrance “when the doors were shut” among His other miracles.

But He also greets the holy disciples. “Peace be to you,” He says, calling Himself peace. Indeed, those with whom Christ is present must undoubtedly abide with an undisturbed spirit.

Paul also prayed that this might come from God to those who believe in Him, saying: “The peace of Christ, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds” (Phil 4:7). By the peace of Christ, which rises above every mind, he means no one other than His Spirit. Whoever receives Him will be filled with every good thing.

Maximus the Confessor

7th centuryChurch Father

“On the evening of that same first day of the week, when the doors of the house where His disciples were gathered were locked for fear of the Jews.” Those sitting in Galilee behind closed doors in the upper room, from danger of the Jews, are those who dwell safely in the land of revelation. Guarding themselves from evil spirits, they have ascended to the height of divine contemplations, and, according to custom, have shut the doors of the senses. They receive the Word of God, who comes to them in an unknown manner and appears without operation upon the senses. Through spiritual peace He grants them dispassion, and through the distribution of the Holy Spirit He grants inspiration. He presents authority over evil spirits and reveals to them the symbols of His mysteries.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

"Then, the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where His disciples were gathered for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in the midst."

Jesus Christ came in the evening, because then the disciples were especially afraid, and then all were gathering together. He did not knock at the door, so as not to frighten them, but passed through the locked doors as God. This also happened because His body had already become subtle, light, and pure.

He stood in the midst, so that all might see Him. "And He said to them, Peace be unto you." That is, do not be troubled. When He was dying, Jesus Christ likewise left peace to the disciples: "Peace I leave with you," He said (John 14:27).

Before every conversation, Jesus Christ granted joy to the women, His disciples, because that sex had been condemned to sorrow. To the disciples He grants peace, because they expected hostility from Jews and Gentiles.

Marcus the Ascetic

4th centuryChurch Father

Those sitting in Galilee in the upper room “for fear of the Jews,” with “the doors shut” (Jn 20:19), are those who live safely in the land of revelations through fear of the spirits of malice. They are on the height of divine contemplations and have shut the senses like doors. They receive the Word of God, who comes in an unknowable manner. He appears to them without sensory operation, and by the proclamation of peace (verses 19, 21) He grants them dispassion. By His breathing (verse 22) He grants the distributions of the Holy Spirit. He gives power over evil spirits (Mk 16:17) and shows them the signs (Jn 20:20) of His mysteries.

Peter Chrysologus

5th centuryChurch Father

It was evening more because of grief than because of the hour. Evening had fallen upon the mind, darkened by the joyless cloud of sorrow and anguish. Although the report of the Resurrection gave a kind of half-light, the Lord had not yet shone forth in the full measure of His glory. The measure of fear and confusion at once closed both the house and the hearts of the disciples. It entirely blocked every access of light, so that the darkness of night grew ever thicker for their senses, increasingly seized by grief. No gloom of night can be compared with the darkness of grief and fear, because neither the light of consolation nor the light of counsel can subdue them.

Caesarius of Arles

6th centuryChurch Father

You ask me and say, "If He entered through locked doors, where then was His body?" And I answer, "If He walked upon the sea, where then was the weight of His body?" Cf. Matt 14:25.

He did this as Lord. Did He cease to be Lord now that He had risen? And what of the fact that He caused Peter also to walk upon the water? Cf. Matt 14:29.

What the Godhead did in the one case, faith accomplished in the other. Christ did it because He was able; Peter did it because Christ willed it.

Therefore, when you begin to examine the essence of miracles with a human mind, beware lest you lose your faith. Do you not know that nothing is impossible for God?

Read more (47 words)

If someone says to you, "He entered through locked doors because He was not in a body," answer with the contrary: "If He was touched, then there was a body. If He ate, then there was a body. He did one thing miraculously, and the other naturally."

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

The first question that arises in the mind at this Gospel reading is this: how was the Lord's body after the resurrection a true body, when it could enter to the disciples through locked doors?

But we must know that a divine action is not wondrous if it is understood by reason. Nor does that faith have merit for which human reason supplies proof.

Yet these very works of our Redeemer, which in themselves cannot be understood at all, must be considered through another of His works. In this way deeds still more wondrous give credibility to wondrous deeds.

For that body of the Lord entered to the disciples through locked doors which, at His birth, came forth before human eyes through the closed womb of the Virgin.

What wonder is it, then, if after the resurrection He entered through locked doors, He who was already to live forever? When He came forth to die, He came forth without opening the womb of the Virgin.

Nicephoros (Theotokis)

18th centuryChurch Father

The first Sabbath is one. Yet by "Sabbaths," or even by "Sabbath," the Hebrews mean the whole week, according to the words: "I fast twice in the Sabbath" (Luke 18:12), that is, twice in the week. Thus "the first of the Sabbaths" here means the first day of the week, namely Sunday.

On this Sunday, therefore, on which the resurrection took place, "when it was late," that is, very late in the evening or at the beginning of the night, our Lord Jesus came. He entered the house whose doors were locked, where the disciples had gathered, fearing the Jews who persecuted them.

Why did He come "when it was late"? Why did He enter while the doors were locked? Also, why did He stand in the midst and say, "Peace be unto you"?

Read more (489 words)

He came "when it was late," that is, very late in the evening, because the Apostles, fearing the Jews, generally gathered in their lodging in the evening. For this reason He came there to them in the evening, so that He might find them all assembled.

Yet the Lord also arranged this for another, mystical reason. Before the Savior's resurrection, the whole human nature lay in the darkness of sin and sat in the shadow of death. Therefore David, prophesying its illumination, said: "Light has risen in the darkness for the upright" (Ps 111:4).

And Isaiah says: "The people walking in darkness have seen a great light" (Isa 9:2). Elsewhere he says: "Then your light shall rise in the darkness" (Isa 58:10). Likewise Zechariah says: "The Dayspring from on high has visited us, to give light to those who sit in darkness and the shadow of death" (Luke 1:78-79).

Therefore Christ rose in the night and came to His disciples at the beginning of the night. By fulfilling such prophecies concerning Him according to the Scriptures, He proved that He had shone upon those in the darkness of sin and enlightened those sleeping in the night of ignorance.

He entered through locked doors, first, so that He would not frighten or disturb the disciples by knocking at the door. Second, He did so that, seeing the miracle, they might believe in His resurrection from the dead. Third, He did so to show that He comes to those people who keep the doors of the house of their soul locked, that is, the senses of the body, so that sin may not enter.

How, then, did our Lord, bearing a human body, pass through locked doors? As He passed through the womb of the Holy Virgin without violating her virginity. As He walked upon the sea without sinking into its depth. As He performed countless other miracles, by the omnipotence of His Godhead.

He stood in the midst so that all who were present there might see Him Himself, and His hands and His side, without hindrance. He stood in the midst to show that He loves all equally, provides for all equally, and wills the salvation of all equally.

He said, "Peace be unto you," because this is what He did when He came into the world. He broke down the middle wall of partition, united what had been separated, and reconciled God and man.

"For He is our peace, who has made both one, and has broken down the middle wall of partition" (Eph 2:14). Therefore, when He was born into the world, the angels sang: "Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, good will among men!" (Luke 2:14).

So also, when He was departing from the world, He says: "Peace I leave with you" (John 14:27). So also, when He had risen from the dead, He said to His disciples, "Peace be unto you."

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

On that very day, in the evening, when Thomas had gone out and the other Apostles, fearing persecutions from Jesus’ enemies, had locked the doors, Jesus Himself suddenly appeared in an instant. He stood in their midst and said His usual greeting: “Peace be to you.”

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

"On the same first day of the week," and so forth. This is the same appearance of the Lord to the disciples narrated by Mark (Mark 16:14 and following) and Luke (Luke 24:36 and following). John omits certain details of those narratives, or indicates them briefly, and reports certain others.

"When the doors were locked" is a feature noted only by John. It has great significance as an indication of the special property of the Lord's glorified body, according to which material objects did not hinder Him from passing through them. Thus the Lord's coming to the disciples while the doors were locked was entirely miraculous and inexplicable.

Read more (123 words)

They were locked "for fear of the Jews," that is, of the party hostile to the Lord, especially the members of the Jewish Sanhedrin. After the Lord's resurrection, the guards who had been at the tomb informed the members of the Sanhedrin of what had happened.

They were bribed to spread the report that the disciples had stolen the Lord's body at night, while the guard supposedly slept (Matt 28:11-15). This rumor could, of course, soon reach the Lord's disciples. They could fear that some violent measures would be taken against them.

Out of fear of such measures from the Jews, they were behind locked doors. "Jesus came," and so forth. See Luke 24:36-43 and the notes for a fuller account of this.

Philaret of Moscow (Drosdow)

19th centuryChurch Father

"It is not our business to investigate," says Saint Gregory, "how Jesus Christ could enter the house where His disciples were, when the doors were locked. Rather, it is our duty to know that if we comprehended the works of God, they would not be objects of wonder for us. Faith would have no merit in us if it were established by reason and experience" (Homily 16 on the Gospel).

"Therefore do not exert yourself," we add with Chrysostom, "to penetrate the divine mysteries. Humbly receive what God reveals to you, and by your curiosity do not try to comprehend what He hides from you" (Homily 4 on Matthew).

"This shows," as Blessed Augustine observed, "that He who, in being born, left untouched the virginity of Mary His Mother, could also after the resurrection pass through closed doors" (Tractate 10 on John).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 35 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Οὔσης
    ousēs
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  2. οὖν
    oun
    therefore
    G3767 · οὖν
  3. ὀψίας
    opsias
    late
    G3798 · ὀψία
  4. τῇ
    tē
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  5. ἡμέρᾳ
    hēmera
    a day
    G2250 · ἡμέρα
  6. ἐκείνῃ
    ekeinē
    that
    G1565 · ἐκεῖνος
  7. τῇ
    tē
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  8. μιᾷ
    mia
    one
    G1520 · εἷς
  9. σαββάτων
    sabbatōn
    the Sabbath
    G4521 · σάββατον
  10. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  11. τῶν
    tōn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  12. θυρῶν
    thyrōn
    a door
    G2374 · θύρα
  13. κεκλεισμένων
    kekleismenōn
    I shut
    G2808 · κλείω
  14. ὅπου
    hopou
    where
    G3699 · ὅπου
  15. ἦσαν
    ēsan
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  16. οἱ
    hoi
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  17. μαθηταὶ
    mathētai
    a learner
    G3101 · μαθητής
  18. διὰ
    dia
    through
    G1223 · διά
  19. τὸν
    ton
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  20. φόβον
    phobon
    fear
    G5401 · φόβος
  21. τῶν
    tōn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  22. Ἰουδαίων
    ioudaiōn
    Jewish
    G2453 · Ἰουδαῖος
  23. ἦλθεν
    ēlthen
    I come
    G2064 · ἔρχομαι
  24. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  25. Ἰησοῦς
    iēsous
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  26. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  27. ἔστη
    estē
    I cause to stand
    G2476 · ἵστημι
  28. εἰς
    eis
    into
    G1519 · εἰς
  29. τὸ
    to
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  30. μέσον
    meson
    middle
    G3319 · μέσος
  31. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  32. λέγει
    legei
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  33. αὐτοῖς
    autois
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  34. Εἰρήνη
    eirēnē
    peace
    G1515 · εἰρήνη
  35. ὑμῖν
    hymin
    you
    G4771 · σύ