The Church Fathers on this verse

John 4:33Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

The disciples therefore said one to another: Hath any man brought him to eat?

Douay-Rheims

ελεγον ουν οι μαθηται προς αλληλους μη τις ηνεγκεν αυτω φαγειν

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

14 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

What then does Christ say? “I have food to eat of which you do not know.” “Therefore the disciples said to one another, ‘Has anyone brought Him something to eat?’” (vv. 32-33). Is it surprising that the woman, hearing of water, imagined water, when the disciples experience the same thing? They think of nothing spiritual and still remain perplexed. Yet, preserving their usual reverence and respect for the Teacher, they speak only among themselves. They do not dare to put the question to Him Himself. They act this way in other cases also. They wish to ask Christ, but do not ask. What then does Christ say?

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

What of the disciples? They were still perplexed, wondering whether someone had brought Him something to eat. Yet they did not dare put the question to Him, because of their customary reverence for Him.

Notice also that the Lord accepted food when someone brought it. For the disciples say, "Has anyone brought Him something to eat?" The Lord did this not because He needed the service of others. He Himself gives food to all flesh (Ps 135:25).

He did it so that those who brought it might have a reward and become accustomed to feeding others. He also showed all men that one need not be ashamed of poverty, nor be distressed when fed by others.

Read more (45 words)

It is proper, and even necessary, for teachers to entrust care for food to others. Thus, without distraction, they may fulfill the ministry of the word. Therefore He even commanded the disciples to be fed at the expense of those whom they instructed (Lk 10:7).

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Not yet understanding this veiled saying, the disciples often judged what had happened by themselves and descended to ordinary notions. They imagined that food had been brought to Him by someone, and perhaps food better and more pleasant than what they had obtained.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

What is remarkable in this woman not understanding the water? Even the disciples did not yet understand the food.

Meanwhile the disciples asked Him, saying, "Rabbi, eat" (Jn 4:31). For they had gone to buy food and had returned. But He said to them, "I have food to eat of which you do not know."

Therefore the disciples said to one another, "Has anyone brought Him something to eat?" (Jn 4:32-33).

What is remarkable if that woman did not understand what "water" meant? See, even the disciples did not understand what "food" was. But He heard their thoughts and instructed them now as Teacher.

He did not teach them indirectly, as He had taught her, when He was still asking about her husband. He spoke directly: "My food is to do the will of Him who sent Me" (Jn 4:34).

Read more (76 words)

So also the very drink for that woman was the fulfillment of the will of Him who sent Him. Therefore He said, "I thirst; give Me to drink" (Jn 4:7).

That is, He asked that she cultivate faith within herself. Then He would drink her faith and place her in His own body, for His body is the Church.

He Himself says, "My food is to do the will of Him who sent Me" (Jn 4:34).

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

He called the salvation of men His food. The disciples, understanding this as bodily food, were perplexed among themselves, but did not dare to ask Him. Then He Himself explains this word.

Nicephoros (Theotokis)

18th centuryChurch Father

Christ answered His disciples figuratively. Therefore, not understanding the force of His word, and thinking that He was speaking to them of bodily food, they said among themselves, “Has anyone brought Him something to eat?”

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryChurch Father

At the end of His conversation the Lord told the Samaritan woman plainly that He Himself was the very Messiah whom the Samaritans and the Jews awaited. The woman hastened into the city to tell her own people the joyful news of the extraordinary event.

Crowds of inhabitants went out from the city to Jesus. Meanwhile the disciples returned with what they had bought and found their Teacher at the end of His conversation with the Samaritan woman.

His conversation with a woman, with which He had been deeply occupied, seemed strange to them and aroused their curiosity. Yet no one dared ask the reason for the conversation or its subject.

They were also astonished that the Lord had not touched the food brought to Him. Occupied with His great work, He forgot earthly needs.

Read more (353 words)

His spirit contemplated the workings of divine truth in the soul of the woman, in the inhabitants of the city, in the land, and in the whole world.

He had in view the worldwide spread of that teaching whose beginnings He was now offering to a poor woman. He already saw before Him the harvest from the seeds He was now casting into the depths of the earth.

Therefore the Lord answered the disciples' astonishment: "I have another food of which you do not know." That which nourishes My spirit makes Me forget bodily food.

"My food is to fulfill the will of Him who sent Me, and I fulfill His work." I sow the seed from which the kingdom of God must spread through all mankind.

Then, in a parabolic comparison, He showed them what He meant by the work of God begun among the Samaritans.

Perhaps He was looking, on one side, at farmers scattered through the fields, occupied with sowing, or at the grain sprouting in the fields. On the other side He saw the crowds coming out to Him from the city at the woman's summons.

The Lord said: you say that the harvest will not be earlier than four months from now. In nature this is so. But now, in spiritual matters, it is otherwise.

When the time has come, the seed is only just being sown, and the harvest has already begun. Lift up your eyes, He said, pointing to the approaching crowds of Samaritans, and see how these fields are already ready for harvest.

At the same time, seeing in spirit that He would leave the earth before the full harvest began, He knew that He would have to entrust its completion to His disciples.

The Lord prophetically foretold that this present harvest lay before them. He would enjoy it together with them, for the sower and the reaper would rejoice. They would reap what had been sown.

Thus the Lord already hinted to them at His departure from them and at His near death. This was preceded by the still nearer death of His Forerunner.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

Meanwhile the disciples invite Christ to partake of the food they had bought. As usual, He uses this as an occasion to reveal to them what His divine-human spirit is occupied with at that moment, despite His natural sense of hunger. In this way He also gives an indirect answer to their perplexity over His conversation with the woman (v. 27). The disciples, however, had not yet grown accustomed to understanding His allegorical speech. They are perplexed: what food does He speak of, which He has and which they do not know?

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

The Samaritan woman went into the city at the very time when Jesus' disciples came from the city with the supply of food they had bought. They were astonished that their Teacher was speaking with a woman.

According to Jewish custom, it was considered improper for a teacher to speak with a woman. According to the teaching of the rabbis, "Whoever teaches his daughter the law commits folly," and, "It is better to burn the words of the law than to hand them over to women."

Yet His disciples did not dare express their astonishment to Jesus. They offered Him food. But Jesus, forgetting both hunger and thirst, was now thinking of how His word had fallen into the Samaritan woman's soul.

Read more (259 words)

It had quickly kindled her with faith in Him. This word, passed on by her to her fellow citizens, had moved them to come to Him.

Seeing the crowd of townspeople coming toward Him, He rejoiced that the seed He had cast was already beginning to bear fruit. Therefore, when the disciples urged Him to satisfy His hunger, He answered that His food was to do the will of Him who sent Him.

Then, pointing to the Samaritans coming toward Him, He said, "You say that the harvest will come in four months. But I say to you: look at this field drawing near to us, how it has become white and ripe for harvest.

"I will send you to reap what has been sown by Me. You who reap will receive a reward, because you will gather fruit for eternal life.

"You will rejoice as you gather the harvest, though you yourselves did not sow. Yet the One who sows the word of God will rejoice with you, because what He sowed has borne fruit."

When grain is sown in the earth, most often the one who reaps, that is, gathers the fruit, is the same one who sowed. He sowed for himself.

But in the sowing of the word, the spiritual harvest almost always belongs to others. The one who sowed rejoices that others have gathered the fruit of his sowing, because he sowed not for himself, but for others.

Therefore, with regard to the spiritual field, it is entirely true that one sows and another reaps.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

But the disciples, in their usual simplicity, did not understand this remark. They thought that probably someone had brought Him something to eat. One may imagine how painful it was for Him at every step, even among His own chosen ones, to encounter such a strange incapacity for understanding deeper spiritual thoughts. Yet there was no impatience in Him who was meek and lowly in heart. “My food,” He said, “is to do the will of Him who sent Me, and to finish His work.”

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

The disciples were still inexperienced in the explanation of spiritual realities through sensible images. Now, as on other occasions, they did not understand Him.

Nikolaj Alexandrow

19th centuryChurch Father

The Samaritan woman could not at once enter into the deep meaning of the Savior's words about worshiping God in spirit and truth. Therefore she only said, "I know that Messiah is coming, that is, Christ; when He comes, He will tell us all things."

In answer to this remark of the Samaritan woman, Jesus says to her, "I who speak to you am He" (vv. 25-26).

The astonished and joyful Samaritan woman ran into the city and told everything there. The Samaritans came to Christ in a great crowd and asked Him to enter their city.

Jesus Christ stayed with them two days, and many Samaritans believed in Him as the Savior of the world.

The disciples of Jesus Christ also received a lesson: the Samaritans, whom they despised through Jewish prejudice, are called by the Lord to salvation equally with the Jews.

Philaret (Gumilevski)

19th centuryChurch Father

Verses 31-35. The disciples reminded the Teacher that it was time to take food for strength. "I have food," He answered, "of which you do not know." The disciples could understand that the Teacher was speaking of spiritual food.

Yet His words, "you do not know this food," brought doubts into their mind. Had the good woman perhaps given Him some food? Jesus leads them out of their uncertainty.

"My food," He says, "is to do the will of Him who sent Me and to accomplish His work." Knowing also what is done far away or in secret, He already sees that the Samaritan woman's words have called whole crowds from the city.

Read more (227 words)

These crowds are drawing near to Him. He continues, "Do you not say, 'There are still four months, and then comes the harvest'? But I say to you, lift up your eyes and look at the fields, for they are white and ready for harvest."

"Do you not say?" These words themselves show that Jesus is citing common speech. In the language of the people He expresses to the disciples His joy that whole crowds of Shechemites are coming to Him, some believing, others ready to believe.

Only recently He sowed spiritual seeds in the heart of the Samaritan woman. Now the field is already ripe: the inhabitants of Sychar, with changed hearts.

The Savior often elsewhere compared the gospel to seed, and the conversion of souls to harvest: Mt 9:37ff.; Mt 13:3ff.; Mk 4:26ff.; Lk 8:5ff. In Palestine wheat was sown in November and early December.

By February the grain is already as high as it is among us in May. In the month of Nisan, which corresponds to our April, the firstfruits of barley were offered.

Christ Jesus took the image for His thought from the green field surrounding Him. This is important for determining the times in the Savior's life. From this it is evident that from Pascha, in April, until early February Jesus remained in the land of Judea (Jn 3:22; Jn 4:3).

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryChurch Father

The disciples find the Lord, speaking in human terms, absorbed in deep thought. During His earthly life, the God-man devoted that life to one great work: the renewal and salvation of mankind.

This was according to God's thought, expressed at the very creation of man: "according to the image and likeness of God."

As God, together with the Father and the Holy Spirit, He foreordained this salvation of man. As the second Hypostasis of the Holy Trinity, who reveals God to man, He assumed human form and being.

In this form He, as man, without separation from the Godhead, performed the work of God. But in order to perform it, He, as man, entered into deep thought.

He thought and suffered. By His human spirit, He rose above temptations, weaknesses, and the bodily needs of men.

Read more (496 words)

When the disciples had gone into the city to buy food, they saw their divine Teacher wearied and weakened from the journey, thirsty and hungry. Therefore, in their zeal, they hasten to offer Him food.

But the Lord Jesus is God, and at the same time man. He is the ideal toward which every ordinary mortal must strive, though of course never attaining it.

Yet in this striving, man draws near to God and fulfills His holy will.

In the form and being of man, the Lord Jesus shows in Himself the highest image of human nature. In this nature, thought subdues the body and rules over bodily weaknesses and needs.

Drawing His disciples from earthly cares to heavenly things, He indicates to them that "man shall not live by bread alone" (Mt 4:4).

He explains and reveals to them that mystery of man's spiritual life which creates martyrs, ascetics, and all those who leave earthly things in order to follow the Lord. The Lord is the Truth (Jn 14:6).

Compare also Athanasius the Great, cited above concerning Jn 4:21-24.

In all these, who surrender their earthly desires and earthly body to the Lord, bodily weakness is joined to astonishing greatness of spirit.

This spirit is strong not by its own power, but by the power of God. It is strong when it does the will of God and gives up its earthly life and enjoyments, in order to magnify and glorify God's name.

In this case, as in many others, "His disciples did not understand this at first, but when Jesus was glorified, then they remembered" (Jn 12:16).

The beloved disciple recorded all this "that you may believe... and that believing you may have life in His name" (Jn 20:31).

Here we see how the God-man, wearied and weakened according to His humanity, causes the spirit to triumph over the flesh in man.

"My food is to do the will of Him who sent Me, and to accomplish His work."

The weakness of human strength disappears. The demand of nature to strengthen itself with food recedes into second place before the greatness of the work.

To this work "the man Christ Jesus" (1 Tim 2:5) gives Himself, in order to fulfill the work of the God-man and the will of God.

Human thought and the loving human heart fulfill the thought of God. Here in Samaria, God's thought draws crowds of foreigners to God.

For soon, very soon, they will replace before God the people once chosen. God's thought, embodied in the Lord's human thought, builds the Church of Christ.

So too does God's love, burning in the God-man's love for all mankind. It opens to all humanity, in faith in the Lord Jesus, endless prospects of perfection.

And who will dare deny that Christian society has taken possession of the world precisely because it is Christian?

The final aim of the God-man, who fulfills God's thought, is the eternal happiness of the human soul.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 11 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ἔλεγον
    elegon
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  2. οὖν
    oun
    therefore
    G3767 · οὖν
  3. οἱ
    hoi
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  4. μαθηταὶ
    mathētai
    a learner
    G3101 · μαθητής
  5. πρὸς
    pros
    to
    G4314 · πρός
  6. ἀλλήλους
    allēlous
    one another
    G240 · ἀλλήλων
  7. Μή
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  8. τις
    tis
    any one
    G5100 · τις
  9. ἤνεγκεν
    ēnenken
    I carry
    G5342 · φέρω
  10. αὐτῷ
    autō
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  11. φαγεῖν
    phagein
    I eat
    G5315 · φαγεῖν