The Church Fathers on this verse

John 6:43Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Jesus therefore answered and said to them: Murmur not among yourselves.

Douay-Rheims

απεκριθη ουν ο ιησους και ειπεν αυτοις μη γογγυζετε μετ αλληλων

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

12 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

What, then, does He answer to their murmuring? "No one can come to Me unless the Father Who sent Me draws him."

The Manichaeans attack this and say that nothing depends on us. Yet these very words especially prove that we have power in our own will.

But what need is there, they say, to draw someone if he comes to Him on his own? Again, this does not destroy our freedom of will. On the contrary, it shows that we need help.

Here Christ is not speaking of every person who comes, but of the one who enjoys great assistance from God. Then He also shows the manner in which the Father draws.

And lest the Jews again think anything sensory about God, He added: "Not that anyone has seen the Father, except He Who is from God; He has seen the Father" (v. 46).

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

The Jews disparage Jesus, not knowing the Father Who is in heaven. They utterly refuse to acknowledge that He could be by nature the Son of the Master of all. Instead they look only to His earthly mother and to Joseph.

Therefore He answers them somewhat more forcefully. At once He again turns profitably toward His own divine dignity.

As God, He knew their quiet whispering and the thoughts that had arisen in them. By this very fact He urged them to understand that they were swerving from the truth and had formed far too low an opinion of Him.

Indeed, should not the One Who fully knows hearts, searches the movements of the mind, and knows the intentions of the soul be crowned with divine glory instead?

Read more (48 words)

Should He not be exalted above human insignificance as greatly as God is above earthly things?

Thus He reveals the thought still hidden in their unspoken reproaches. He makes manifest the murmuring expressed in quiet whispers. For the reason already given, He says, "Do not murmur among yourselves."

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

As though saying, "I know that you will not hunger, and that you will neither grasp nor seek this bread. Do not murmur among yourselves. No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him."

A testimony to great grace! No one comes except the one who is drawn. Whom He draws and whom He does not draw, why He draws this one and not that one, do not seek to judge, lest you fall into error.

Receive this once for all and understand it. Are you not yet drawn? Pray that you may be drawn.

What, then, did Jesus answer those who were murmuring? "Do not murmur among yourselves" (Jn 6:43). It is as though He said, "I know why you do not hunger, and why you do not understand or seek this bread.

Read more (1662 words)

"Do not murmur among yourselves. No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him" (cf. Jn 6:44). This is a weighty hint of grace.

No one comes unless he is drawn. There is one whom He draws, and there is one whom He does not draw. Why does He draw one and not another?

Do not seek to judge this, if you do not wish to make a mistake. Receive it at once and understand: you are not yet drawn. I pray that He may draw you.

What are we saying here, brothers? If we are drawn to Christ, then do we believe unwillingly? Is force applied, and is will not manifested?

A man can come to church unwillingly. He can approach the altar unwillingly. He can receive Communion unwillingly. But he cannot believe unwillingly.

If faith came through the body, it would also be found in those who did not will it. But people do not believe with the body.

Hear the Apostle: "With the heart one believes unto righteousness" (Rom 10:10). And what is said next? "With the mouth confession is made unto salvation" (Rom 10:10).

This confession rises from the root of the heart. Sometimes you hear a man confess the faith aloud, but you do not know whether he believes.

Yet you should not call someone a confessor if you do not consider him a believer. To confess is to utter what you hold in the heart.

If one thing is in your heart and you say another, then you merely speak, but you do not confess. Therefore, since you believed in Christ in your heart, which certainly no one does against his will, how shall we resolve the question?

For the one who is drawn appears to act as though against his will. Yet the question is: "No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him" (Jn 6:44).

If someone is drawn, one may say, he comes against his will. If he comes against his will, he does not believe. If he does not believe, he does not come.

For we do not hasten to Christ by means of feet. We come through faith, not through bodily movement, but by the will of the heart.

For this reason, the woman who touched the hem of His garment touched Him more than the crowd that pressed upon Him. Therefore the Lord said, "Who touched Me?"

The disciples were amazed and said, "The crowd surrounds You and presses You, and You say, 'Who touched Me?'" But He repeated, "Someone touched Me" (cf. Lk 8:44-46).

The woman touched, the crowd pressed. What does "touched" mean, if not "believed"? Hence, after His resurrection, He said to the woman who wished to cast herself at His feet, "Do not touch Me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father" (Jn 20:17).

"You think that I am only what you see. Do not touch Me." What does this mean? "You suppose that I am only what I appear to be to you.

"Do not believe in that way, that is, do not touch Me. For I have not yet ascended to the Father. For you I have not ascended, because for you I never descended from there."

She did not touch Him as He stood on the earth. How, then, could she touch Him when He had ascended to the Father?

Nevertheless, He wished her to touch Him in precisely this way. Those who touch Him rightly touch Him as ascended to the Father, as abiding with the Father, and as equal to the Father.

Therefore here also He says, if you are attentive, "No one can come to Me unless the Father draws him" (Jn 6:44). Do not think that He draws you against your will.

He draws the mind, and He draws it through love. We should not fear that men who know the value of words, but are far from understanding divine things, can accuse us concerning this evangelical saying from the Scriptures.

They may say to us, "How, then, do I believe by my own will, if I am drawn?" I answer: not only are you drawn by your own will, voluntate, but even with delight, voluptate.

What does it mean that you are drawn with pleasure? "Delight yourself in the Lord, and He will give you the desires of your heart" (Ps 36:4).

There is a certain joy of the heart to which that heavenly bread is sweet. Moreover, if the poet was pleased to say, "Each one is drawn by his own delight," not by necessity, but by joy, not by obligation, but by pleasure.

How much more boldly should we say that a man is drawn to Christ when he rejoices in truth, blessedness, righteousness, and eternal life, that is, in all that Christ is?

Or perhaps the bodily senses have their delights, while the mind refuses its own delights? If the mind has no delights of its own, why is it said:

"The sons of men shall hope under the shadow of Your wings. They shall be filled from the abundance of Your house, and You shall give them drink from the torrent of Your delight. For with You is the fountain of life. In Your light we shall see light" (cf. Ps 35:8)?

Give me a man who has love, and he knows what I am saying. Imagine a man who loves. Imagine one filled with desire. Imagine one hungry.

Imagine one wandering in this wilderness and thirsting. Imagine one sighing for the fountain of the eternal homeland. Imagine such a man, and he knows what I am saying.

But if I speak to a man of cold heart, he does not know what I am saying. Such were those who murmured among themselves.

"The one whom the Father draws," He says, "comes to Me." What, then, does it mean that the Father draws him, when Christ Himself draws? Why did He choose to say, "the Father draws him"?

If we must be drawn, let us be drawn by Him to whom the one who loves Him says, "We shall run after the fragrance of your ointments" (cf. Song 1:3).

Yet, brothers, let us consider what He wished to make known, and let us grasp it as far as we can.

The Father draws to the Son those who believe in the Son because they understand that His Father is God. For God the Father begot the Son equal to Himself.

Therefore the one who acknowledges, holds in his faith, and never tires of repeating that He in whom he believes is equal to the Father, is drawn by the Father to the Son.

Arius thought that the Son was a creature. The Father did not draw him. For he does not see the Father who does not believe that the Son is equal to Him.

What are you saying, Arius? What will you say, heretic? What is Christ? "Christ," he says, "is not true God, but One whom the true God made."

The Father has not drawn you, because you have not understood the Father whose Son you do not know. You understand something else, which is not the Son.

You are not drawn by the Father, and you are not drawn to the Son. For the Son is one thing, and what you suppose is another.

Photinus said, "Christ is only a man and is not God." Photinus, bishop of Sirmium, taught that Christ was a mere man, born of Mary, upon whom the Holy Spirit descended only after His birth.

Photinus was condemned at several councils, and his teaching was finally condemned at the Second Ecumenical Council in Constantinople in 381. Whoever believes in this way has not been drawn by the Father.

The Father drew the one who says, "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God" (Mt 16:16). Not as a prophet, not as John, not as some great righteous man.

But as the Only One, as equal: "You are the Christ, the Son of the living God." See, this Peter has been drawn, and drawn by the Father.

"Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonah, for flesh and blood have not revealed this to you, but My Father who is in heaven" (Mt 16:17). This revelation itself is the drawing.

You stretch out a green branch to a sheep and draw it. Nuts are shown to a child, and he is drawn. He is drawn to what he reaches toward.

He is drawn by love. He is drawn without pressure upon the body. He is drawn by the bonds of the heart.

Therefore, if things shown among earthly joys and delights draw those who love them, for it is true that each one has his own delight, why should Christ not draw when He is shown by the Father?

And what does the soul thirst for more than truth? Toward what should it open its thirsty mouth and strive, with healthy palate, to recognize what is true?

Should it not be toward tasting and drinking wisdom, righteousness, truth, and eternity? Where will this be? There where we shall taste better, or rather, more fully.

For here it is easier for us to hunger, especially if we have good hope, than to be filled. For He says, "Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness," here, "for they shall be filled," there (cf. Mt 5:6).

Therefore, when He said, "No one can come to Me unless the Father draws him," what did He add? "And I will raise him up at the last day" (Jn 6:44).

"I give him what he loves. I give him what he hopes for. He will see what he believed before seeing. He will taste what he hungers for, and drink what he thirsts for."

Where? "In the resurrection from the dead. For I will raise him up at the last day."

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

When Jesus Christ gave them bread and filled their belly, they called Him a prophet and wanted to make Him king. But when He spoke with them about the heavenly bread, spiritual food, and eternal life, they were troubled and reproached His lineage.

They were those "whose god is their belly," as the Apostle Paul beautifully said (Phil 3:19). They pretended to be indignant because Jesus Christ had said, "I have come down from heaven."

In truth, they were angry because He had not fed them as they expected. If they had murmured against Jesus Christ because of those words, they would certainly have asked, "How is He bread? How did He come down from heaven?"

Read more (66 words)

Jesus Christ did not say, "I am not the son of Joseph." Nor did He reveal anything at all about His origin. He knew that they were not yet able to hear of His wondrous birth, much less of His pre-eternal generation.

Therefore, according to His all-wise designs, He passed over this matter. He did so lest, while removing one stumbling block, He should create another.

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryChurch Father

Hearing this, the Jews began openly to murmur because Jesus had called Himself the bread which came down from heaven.

"Do not murmur," the Lord answered. "You have not yet been brought to Me by the Father. It is written in the prophets that all shall be taught by God. You have not yet entered the number of those taught by God.

"But whoever is drawn by the Father and comes to Me, to him I shall truly give life. I shall raise him up on the last day." Therefore He has the right to call Himself the bread which came down from heaven, the bread of God.

Yet this must not be understood as though anyone could draw his instruction from the Father apart from the Son. No one has seen the Father except the Son, and only the Son can communicate true knowledge of the Father.

The word by which the Father teaches through the Son is contained in the miracles.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

In the preceding discourse Jesus Christ called Himself the true bread of God, which came down from heaven. This offended the Jews. They were offended not because Jesus Christ taught about Himself as the Messiah, but because He ascribed a heavenly origin to Himself.

They found the basis for their unbelief toward this self-testimony of Christ in the fact that they knew His earthly origin from the family of Joseph of Nazareth.

Yet this unbelief was not the fruit of misunderstanding. The miracles of Jesus Christ sufficiently testified to the extraordinary nature of His person.

Read more (193 words)

Jesus Christ saw the hardness of their hearts. He now shows why they so stubbornly refuse to believe in Him. No one, He says, can come to Me unless the Father Who sent Me draws him, as had already been foretold in the Old Testament.

Therefore, because of the hardheartedness and unworthiness of the Jews who heard Jesus Christ, the gracious action of the Father had not yet touched their hearts. This action calls to salvation.

Without it, man, blinded by sin, cannot see the light of truth. But lest anyone misunderstand Isaiah's prophecy (54:13) about direct instruction from God, Jesus Christ speaks further.

This prophecy must not be understood as though any man could ever see God, speak directly with Him, or know the divine essence through immediate sight and contemplation.

God acts upon men invisibly by His grace. The immediate vision of the divine essence belongs only to His Son.

Therefore only through the Son can men receive the full light of the knowledge of God needed for salvation, and through this receive eternal life (17:3).

Therefore: "Amen, amen, I say to you: he who believes in Me has eternal life."

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

This open murmuring and these insolent words of Christ's enemies compelled the Lord to interrupt His discourse to the people and turn toward the place where they were sitting.

Looking at them, the Lord said: "Do not murmur among yourselves. Do not stir up vain murmuring among those who hear Me.

"Take the book of the prophets and read what is meant by what is written there: 'And they shall all be taught by God' (Jn 6:45). Consider the meaning of these words and understand at last.

"No one has seen God except the One Whom He sent into the world. He alone has seen God. He alone can know His will, and knowing it, teach you.

Read more (271 words)

"Therefore only through Him can you be taught by God. Since both My words and My works prove to you that I am the One Whom He sent into the world, everyone who hears Me and believes is taught through Me by God Himself.

"For this reason only the one who believes in Me, believing that I am sent by God, can be saved and become worthy of the blessedness of eternal life.

"Therefore I tell you that I am the bread of life. I am not such bread as your ancestors ate in the wilderness. That bread nourished their bodies, but it could not deliver them from death, and they died.

"I am the bread that nourishes the soul and gives it eternal life. That is, I deliver it from spiritual death and from eternal torments.

"I am the living bread which came down from heaven. Whoever feeds on this bread will live forever.

"These words of Mine offend you. You do not wish to believe that I, Who have revealed to you the will of My Father, feed those who hunger and thirst for God's righteousness.

"For this reason I call Myself the bread which came down from heaven. What then will you say when I reveal to you the greatest mystery?

"You cannot understand it now. Only those who believe in Me will understand it, and even they will not understand it now, but afterward.

"What will you think if I tell you that I shall give My body for the salvation of the world, and that this body of Mine will be true bread, giving eternal life?"

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

But the Savior answered those who murmured, as always, with a stronger, fuller, and clearer proclamation of the very truth they rejected.

Thus He acted with Nicodemus. Thus He taught the Samaritan woman. Thus He also answered the elders of the temple, who called Him to account for breaking the Sabbath.

But the timid rabbi and the sinful woman had enough faith and sincerity to penetrate more deeply into His words. They humbly sought their meaning and thus drew near to the truth.

These hearers were different. Providence had counted them worthy of instruction from the mouth of the Son of God Himself, Who revealed to them the great mystery of redemption. Yet they rejected this great benefaction.

Read more (122 words)

Then the Savior, with irresistible directness and clarity, revealed to them that He is the source of eternal life sent from heaven.

"I am the living bread which came down from heaven. Whoever eats this bread will live forever. And the bread which I shall give is My flesh, which I shall give for the life of the world."

By these words, on the one hand, He indicated the approaching great work of redeeming sinful mankind by the offering of the flesh of the Son of Man for the life of the world.

On the other hand, He pre-established the mystery of Communion. It was to serve as the means by which later generations of believers would partake of Christ's redemptive work.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

"Do not murmur among yourselves." The Lord does not answer their perplexity directly and does not explain the subject of their murmuring. In this case, no goal could have been reached by explanation.

Neither His parents nor He Himself could speak openly to the people about Christ's supernatural conception and birth. Otherwise the speech of an unbelieving people would have profaned the highest mystery.

For them, this mystery would have been more an occasion of stumbling than a means of awakening faith, since it is received only by a believing heart (cf. Chrysostom and Theophylact).

To the murmuring of the Jews, the Lord responds by explaining the inner cause of their murmuring. This cause is their inability to understand the work of Christ in its inner essence.

Read more (65 words)

His speech may be paraphrased in this way: You do not understand how I came down from heaven while being the son of Mary and Joseph. This seems to you a contradiction.

And you will not understand it, because you have made yourselves incapable of understanding it. To explain this, the Lord says to them more decisively the same thing He said above (Jn 6:37-40).

Nikolaj Alexandrow

19th centuryChurch Father

The words of Jesus Christ, "I am the bread which came down from heaven," provoked the murmuring of the Jews: "Is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph, whose father and Mother we know? How then does He say, 'I have come down from heaven'?" (vv. 41-42).

Since the murmuring scribes and Pharisees always appealed to Holy Scripture as proof of their rightness, the Lord Jesus Christ also points to the words of the prophet Isaiah (Isa 54:13): "And they shall all be taught by God."

In these words the prophet Isaiah speaks of the descent to earth of the Lord Himself, the Son of God, to teach men the Truth.

For no one among men has seen God the Father except the incarnate Son of God, the Lord Jesus Christ (v. 46).

Paul Matwejewski

19th centuryChurch Father

To their murmuring the Lord answered not by explaining the mystery, which they could neither accept nor contain, but by a new confirmation and development of what had been said before.

"Do not murmur among yourselves. No one can come to Me unless the Father Who sent Me draws him. And I will raise him up on the last day."

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryChurch Father

The Lord turns to the whole crowd. Knowing the thoughts and doubts that the Jews are sowing among the listeners, He calms the good hearts burning with love, and directs His speech to them.

He assures them that if their heart draws them to Him, they should not struggle against this feeling or be troubled by the slanders of evil people. Rather, they should know that it is the Father, Who sent the Son, drawing them to Himself, so that the Son may raise them up on the last day.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 9 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ἀπεκρίθη
    apekrithē
    I answer
    G611 · ἀποκρίνω
  2. Ἰησοῦς
    iēsous
    Jesus
    G2424 · Ἰησοῦς
  3. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  4. εἶπεν
    eipen
    to say
    G2036 · ἔπω, ἐρῶ, εἶπον
  5. αὐτοῖς
    autois
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  6. Μὴ
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  7. γογγύζετε
    gongyzete
    I whisper
    G1111 · γογγύζω
  8. μετ᾽
    met
    with
    G3326 · μετά
  9. ἀλλήλων
    allēlōn
    one another
    G240 · ἀλλήλων