The Church Fathers on this verse

Luke 3:11Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And he answering, said to them: He that hath two coats, let him give to him that hath none; and he that hath meat, let him do in like manner.

Douay-Rheims

αποκριθεις δε λεγει αυτοις ο εχων δυο χιτωνας μεταδοτω τω μη εχοντι και ο εχων βρωματα ομοιως ποιειτω

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

10 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 11 commentaries

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

John offers guidance to three distinct groups that approach him: the common people, tax collectors, and soldiers. He encourages the ordinary individuals to practice charity, instructing that those with two coats should share with those in need. He advises tax collectors to refrain from extorting more than what is required, and he urges soldiers to avoid theft, emphasizing the importance of being satisfied with their wages as determined by the king. Observe how John inspires the simple-hearted to act with goodness by sharing, while he prompts the tax collectors and soldiers to abstain from wrongdoing. At this stage, they were not yet equipped to perform good deeds, and it was sufficient for them to avoid evil.

Read more (78 words)

Some interpret the exhortation to share garments as having a moral dimension, positing that the two garments represent the Spirit of Scripture as well as its letter. They argue that John encourages those who possess an understanding of both aspects to share this knowledge with those who lack it; for instance, those able to comprehend Scripture in both letter and spirit should impart their insights to others, at least offering them the foundational teachings contained in the letter.

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

The Evangelist Luke introduced three groups of individuals to John: the crowd, the tax collectors, and the soldiers. Just as a skilled doctor offers an appropriate treatment for each ailment, the Baptist provided invaluable guidance tailored to each way of life. He encouraged the people striving for repentance to practice mutual compassion. To the tax collectors, he warned against the pitfalls of excessive taxation, while to the soldiers, he wisely advised against oppression and urged them to be satisfied with their pay.

In his Gospel, Blessed Luke depicts three distinct groups of individuals who posed questions to John: the crowd, the tax collectors, and the soldiers. Much like a skilled physician who prescribes the right treatment for each ailment, the Baptist provided relevant and essential guidance tailored to each group. He urged the people who were seeking repentance to express brotherly love toward each other, advised tax collectors to refrain from excessive greed, and prudently instructed soldiers to avoid wrongdoing and to be satisfied with their pay.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

The Holy Baptist responded to each individual based on their circumstances, yet his message remained consistent for all. He instructed tax collectors not to demand more than what was required and advised soldiers to refrain from speaking ill of others and from seeking gain through unjust means. In this way, he illustrated that soldiers receive compensation for their service and do not need to resort to theft or looting to survive. These instructions, while tailored to specific professions, underscore a broader principle: mercy is a universal obligation, essential for every aspect of life, every generation, and binding upon everyone. There are no exceptions made for the tax collector or the soldier, the rural dweller or the urban resident, the affluent or the needy.

Read more (69 words)

All are equally called to support the less fortunate, ensuring that neither clothing nor food is withheld. Charity encompasses the essence of virtue and is presented universally as the truest expression of goodness. Nevertheless, in exercising charity, it is crucial to consider one's own capacity; individuals should not feel compelled to give away all they possess, but rather to share a portion of their resources with those in need.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

He responded to them, "If you have two coats, share with those in need. Offer assistance to the one lacking entirely or to the one whose possessions hold no real value. Likewise, provide for those who are hungry. By sharing clothing and food, He teaches them to care for the needy, to be responsive, and to foster mutual love. He does not impose anything overly burdensome, as He understands that Christ will soon reveal the commandments of the gospel."

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

Following this, He responded, stating that those who possess two cloaks should share with those who are in need, and those with food should do similarly. The necessity of sharing arises from the fact that the lower garments serve a more essential purpose than the upper ones, reflecting the fruits worthy of repentance that command us to share not only our excesses but also our basic needs—such as food or essential garments. As it is written in the Law: "You shall love your neighbor as yourself" (Leviticus 19:18), it is clear that failing to help others in need, even with what is vital for ourselves, demonstrates a lack of love for one's neighbor.

Read more (1319 words)

The directive to share both garments indicates that if a person tries to divide their clothing, neither party would be adequately covered; thus, the need to give completely arises.

Meanwhile, it is crucial to understand the significance of acts of mercy, which are notably advocated as fruits worthy of repentance. This is why the Truth incites us to give alms, asserting, "and behold, all shall be clean unto you" (Luke 11:41). Likewise, it is stated, "Give, and it shall be given you" (Luke 6:38). It is also recorded, "The burning fire shall be quenched by water, and almsgiving shall cleanse sins" (Sirach 3:30). Additionally, it is advised, "Shut up alms in your cells, and it will keep you from all malice" (Sirach 29:15). Accordingly, a wise father encourages his innocent son saying, "As many as you will be, do alms from them: but if you will be few, let not the few be afraid to do alms" (Tobit 4:8).

To illustrate the virtue of providing for the poor, our Redeemer teaches: "He who receives a prophet in the name of a prophet will receive a prophet's reward; and he who receives a righteous man in the name of a righteous man will receive a righteous man's reward" (Matthew 10:41). We must pay attention to the wording here; He does not say, "A recompense for the prophet," but rather, "A recompense to the prophet," and similarly for the righteous. This implies that one who shows generosity to a prophet, though not blessed with prophecy themselves, can receive rewards from Almighty God as if they were a prophet. Those who are righteous, though they may lack worldly possessions, often have the boldness to advocate for truth. By supporting someone who possesses spiritual gifts yet might hesitate to speak the truth freely, they partake in the truth shared by the one they support, thereby gaining equal rewards for standing for that truth.

The spirit of Prophecy requires bodily sustenance; if not nourished, the voice that speaks truth becomes weak. Thus, he who nourishes a prophet through recognition of their prophetic role contributes to the preaching of prophecy. Consequently, along with the prophet, they will share in the reward intended for the prophetic work, illustrating that their support aids the presence of prophecy, even if they do not share in the prophetic spirit.

As affirmed by John in addressing Gaius on behalf of traveling brethren, "For the sake of His name they went out receiving nothing from the Gentiles" (3 John 1:7). This serves to remind us that by providing for those who bear spiritual gifts, we become partners in their ministry. When disparities exist between those who receive spiritual gifts and those who possess temporal wealth, it is through the generosity of the wealthy that they contribute to the spiritual benefits of the less fortunate. Therefore, when the Lord, through the prophet Isaiah, spoke to the gentiles left behind—symbolically, the Church—offering them the merits of the virtues associated with the poor, He assured them of blessings, stating, "I will put the wilderness into lakes of waters, and the land impassable into springs of waters; I will give in solitude cedar and thorn, myrtle and olive tree; I will put in the wilderness spruce, elm and beech tree together so that they may see and know, and ponder and understand equally" (Isaiah 41:18, 20).

The Lord transformed the desolate wilderness into abundant streams because the heathens, who previously produced no good fruits due to their hardened hearts, were nourished by the outpouring of holy preaching. In response to their previous aridity, they began to flourish with teachings. The promise given to the Gentiles includes, "I will give in seclusion a cedar and a thorn" (Isaiah 41:19). The cedar signifies resilience and strength. Regarding the thorn, as it is stated in Genesis, "Thorns and thistles shall grow for you" (Genesis 3:18), it effectively highlights how sin brings forth consequences. Conversely, those who embody the virtues bestowed upon them by God are able to declare with Paul, "For we are to God the fragrance of Christ among those who are being saved" (2 Corinthians 2:15), remaining steadfast in love that is untainted by the corruption of earthly desires.

The thorn represents those engaged in spiritual teaching who, in addressing sins and virtues, pierce the hearts of their listeners, provoking tears of heartfelt sorrow. The myrtle symbolizes those who have compassion, as it binds together the broken-hearted. In the words of Paul, "Blessed be God, who comforts us in all our tribulation" (2 Corinthians 1:4), they offer words of consolation to the distressed, linking them back to a state of peace. The olive tree represents the merciful, as even in Greek ελεος signifies mercy. In God's eyes, the oil of the olive tree reflects the fruit of mercy.

The promise also includes, "I will put in the wilderness a spruce, an elm, and a beech tree" (Isaiah 41:19). The spruce, which reaches great heights, exemplifies those who lift their thoughts to heavenly pursuits while still residing in earthly bodies. Though born of the earth, they ascend through contemplation beyond human understanding. The elm, while lacking in spiritual fruits, often supports the vine, indicating that even those without spiritual gifts can aid the righteous. The beech tree, though it does not grow tall and bears no fruit, symbolizes those who, lacking the strength to perform good deeds, still maintain the faith taught by their believing parents.

After all of this, it is noted that the purpose is that they may see, know, ponder, and understand in harmony. This highlights the importance of the diverse moral standings and varying attributes within the Church; all must learn together from the different qualities presented, as the qualities of spirit, age, and maturity are all valuable for imitation.

Returning to the elm, we take note of the importance of supporting those who bear fruit. John encourages us toward righteousness, asserting, "Bear fruits showing repentance" (Matthew 3:8; Luke 3:8), leading us to understand that the notion of taking the Kingdom of Heaven by force is necessary for sinner’s awakening.

We ponder how heaven can be seized by force and why this commotion commenced with John the Baptist. Under the Law, penalties were harsh for every transgression, offering no restoration to the sinner. In contrast, John heralded repentance, enabling the spiritually lifeless to live through transformation. Thus, through his call to repentance, the Kingdom of Heaven is sought vigorously by those who turn to God.

The Kingdom of Heaven is, after all, the realm of the Righteous, which promises rewards of eternal life to the humble, pure, meek, and merciful. When those steeped in pride or sin endeavor to repent, they find themselves outside the community of the faithful. Thus, the days since John have prompted a fervent pursuit of the Kingdom, as he urged sinners to strive for it.

Beloved friends, let us recognize our past wrongdoings, embracing unrelenting sorrow. Let us reclaim the inheritance of the righteous through repentance, for Almighty God welcomes this earnest struggle. Our faith should remain steadfast, undeterred by the weight of our past transgressions. The hope for our redemption is mirrored in the story of the penitent thief, honored not for his crimes but for his confession. How profound is God’s mercy! This thief, condemned and crucified, made his confession on the cross and earned the promise, "Today you will be with Me in Paradise" (Luke 23:43). What grace is shown when forgiveness is extended, turning punishment into the rewards of virtue and offering hope to those in need.

Let us commit ourselves to heartfelt weeping, cleansing our past offenses with truly repentant fruits, and ensure that the time for redemption is not squandered. The many who have been redeemed stand as a testament to God’s boundless mercy. To our Lord Jesus Christ, alongside the Father and the Holy Spirit, be honor and glory forever. Amen.

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryCommentator

The question naturally posed by the Jews to John was, "What fruits are truly worthy of repentance?" They were eager to understand the sentiments and attitudes that the Messiah holds in high regard. What is it that He seeks from us? The baptized inquired further. Is it lengthy prayers, rigorous vows, abundant sacrifices, or frequent purifications? What actions ought we to take? (Lk. 3:10). John's response, echoing the message of the one who embodies love, was clear: "What the Messiah requires is nothing but genuine love for your neighbor. If you possess two tunics, share one with someone who has none; if you have surplus food, offer it to the hungry. Remember to support your needy brother: give what you can. This is the essence of the Messiah's call. His kingdom is fundamentally a kingdom of love."

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryCommentator

The evangelist Luke notes that a significant portion of the crowd was deeply affected by John's message and inquired about how they could atone for their previous wrongdoings and escape the impending judgment. In his response, the Baptist emphasized acts of compassion and kindness toward the needy, highlighting charitable deeds. He imparted the same expectation to the tax collectors and soldiers who approached him with similar questions; however, he consistently urged them to renounce the sins that were typical of their respective roles.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryCommentator

The words spoken by the prophet not only instilled fear but also pointed towards a higher standard of morality in worldly matters. As the people listened to John's alarming message that "even the axe is at the root of the tree: every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire," they trembled and asked him, "What shall we do?" He replied, "Whoever has two tunics should share with the one who has none, and whoever has food should do likewise." By helping the hungry and clothing the naked, they would demonstrate the genuine nature of their repentance through acts of compassion. John’s heartfelt empathy extended to all societal levels, and, like Christ, he did not exclude anyone.

Read more (130 words)

The tax collectors, despised by many and avoided by the Pharisees as though they were cursed, were given hope and encouragement that they too could inherit the kingdom of heaven. When the tax collectors inquired, "Teacher, what shall we do?" he instructed them, "Do not take more than what is authorized." Likewise, when the soldiers asked him, "What shall we do?" he advised them, "Do not extort from anyone by threats or false accusations, and be satisfied with your wages." If the tax collectors sincerely performed their duties and the soldiers refrained from using their authority to harm others while being true to their ranks and content with their positions, this would be evidence of their true repentance and steadfastness to their conscience, which would invite God's favor upon them.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryCommentator

In response to the prophet's stern message, the crowd, puzzled and seeking guidance, inquires about the actions necessary to produce fruits that reflect true repentance and ensure participation in the kingdom of the Messiah. The Evangelist summarizes John’s replies, noting that he imparted many other teachings to the people (Luke 3:18), but highlights only the essential aspects of his responses. John emphasizes the necessity of acts of charity and compassion, as the kingdom he proclaimed is fundamentally rooted in love and mercy.

Read more (93 words)

To the general inquiry regarding what actions to take, his answer was to assist those in need: "whoever has two tunics," exemplifying the broader principle that all who possess extra should extend help to their less fortunate neighbors through acts of love and kindness. Such actions are the clearest indicators of spiritual and ethical integrity, and the level of commitment to these acts accurately reflects an individual’s moral development. Additionally, these deeds serve as a powerful testament to the repentant spirit that John called for among the people (cf. Is. 58:3-5, Dan. 4:24).

Paul Matwejewski

19th centuryCommentator

Perplexed by the forerunner's serious admonitions, the crowds inquired about how they might produce actions befitting repentance and gain entry into the kingdom of the Messiah. John, as the herald of the heavenly Teacher of compassion and grace, responded: Whoever has two coats must share with those in need, and whoever has food must do the same, emphasizing that the essence of genuine love for one's neighbor can be demonstrated in simple, practical ways. This principle was clearly at odds with the responsibilities of tax collectors, who not only failed to assist the less fortunate but also extracted taxes from them for the Roman authorities, and even more so with the soldiers, whose duties could involve taking the lives of their neighbors in dire circumstances.

Read more (166 words)

When the tax collectors asked, What should they do?—John replied, You shall observe only what is mandated for you, and to the soldiers, he instructed, You shall not extort or falsely accuse anyone, and you shall be satisfied with your wages. The Forerunner emphasized that they, along with others, ought to carry out their assigned tasks with integrity, refraining from misuse of power and violence. The evangelist Luke records that John preached many other messages to the people, instructing them and preparing them for the Messiah’s arrival. Devout individuals, recognizing John’s role as a divine messenger through his teachings and actions, considered themselves his disciples and periodically remained with him to receive his guidance. The exact number of John's disciples is not documented; the Gospel occasionally refers to them generally (Mk. 2:18; Jn. 3:25), while other references mention just two (Mt. 11:2; Lk. 7:19; Jn. 1:35). The Holy Evangelist John identifies one of these disciples as Andrew (1:40), who would later become an Apostle of Christ.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 18 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ἀποκριθεὶς
    apokritheis
    I answer
    G611 · ἀποκρίνω
  2. δὲ
    de
    but
    G1161 · δέ
  3. ἔλεγεν
    elegen
    I say
    G3004 · λέγω
  4. αὐτοῖς
    autois
    he
    G846 · αὐτός
  5. Ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  6. ἔχων
    echōn
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω
  7. δύο
    dyo
    two
    G1417 · δύο
  8. χιτῶνας
    chitōnas
    a tunic
    G5509 · χιτών
  9. μεταδότω
    metadotō
    I share
    G3330 · μεταδίδωμι
  10. τῷ
    tō
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  11. μὴ
    mē
    not
    G3361 · μή
  12. ἔχοντι
    echonti
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω
  13. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  14. ὁ
    ho
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  15. ἔχων
    echōn
    I have
    G2192 · ἔχω
  16. βρώματα
    brōmata
    food of any kind
    G1033 · βρῶμα
  17. ὁμοίως
    homoiōs
    in like manner
    G3668 · ὁμοίως
  18. ποιείτω
    poieitō
    I do
    G4160 · ποιέω