The Church Fathers on this verse

Micah 4:12Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

But they have not known the thoughts of the Lord, and have not understood his counsel: because he hath gathered them together as the hay of the floor.

Douay-Rheims

וְהֵ֗מָּה לֹ֤א יָֽדְעוּ֙ מַחְשְׁב֣וֹת יְהוָ֔ה וְלֹ֥א הֵבִ֖ינוּ עֲצָת֑וֹ כִּ֥י קִבְּצָ֖ם כֶּעָמִ֥יר גֹּֽרְנָה׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Throughout our discussions, we have often noted that during Hezekiah's reign over Jerusalem, Sennacherib ravaged Samaria and laid waste to numerous cities in Judah. He then dispatched Rabshekah from Lachish, who greatly dishonored the divine majesty when, in a single night, an angel struck down one hundred and eighty-five thousand soldiers. This account serves as a poignant reminder. 'Many tongues gathered against you,' he states, 'mocking you, already plotting to deride you in a dance, unaware that soon you shall face defeat. Yet they do not perceive the decree of God; they are gathered as if in a threshing floor and will fall under your feet like sheaves.

Read more (198 words)

Therefore, you shall rise and vanquish them; for you shall possess 'horns of iron and hooves of brass'; meaning, you will be unbeatable and unyielding against your foes, trampling upon your adversaries. By invoking the imagery of the threshing floor and sheaves, he underscores this metaphor; for truly, their destruction was wrought not through human means but through divine retribution. He urges, do not claim this victory for yourself; rather, recognize it as the handiwork of the Lord of all creation. This encapsulates the essence of the narrative. However, some may find themselves perplexed by the apparent inconsistency in prophetic declarations. We have just heard the prophet proclaim, 'The first power shall come unto you, and the Babylonian kingdom shall approach,' detailing the manner of captivity, only to see (the daughter of Zion) later liberated yet trampled by her enemies. A careful distinction of time is essential to understand these events clearly and separately. Thus, while Sennacherib attacked Jerusalem during Hezekiah's rule, after Hezekiah's death, four kings reigned until Jechoniah came forth. Then Nebuchadnezzar seized all of Judah and Jerusalem, leading the entirety of Israel into exile. The revered prophet Jeremiah has wisely chronicled these occurrences for us.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Until the prophecy is realized, numerous voices shall arise against you from the household of Gog. Zion will be desecrated, and the eyes of the ignorant will gaze upon it—specifically, the holy place of Zion will be tarnished and held in contempt by those who fail to recognize that the truth of God will crush them like harvested grain on a threshing floor.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

O Jerusalem, O daughter of Zion! You have traversed even to Babylon, yet there found the freedom! The Lord shall deliver you from the grasp of your adversaries; meanwhile, many nations have united against you, speaking of you as they would of an unfaithful wife, proclaiming, “Let her be stoned, and our eyes shall behold her.” Or as noted in the LXX, “Let us strike and rejoice, and let our eyes regard Zion with scorn”; yet they fail to comprehend the purpose and intention of the Lord, for these nations converge against you so that you may crush them like straw or like the stalks of bread on a threshing floor.

Read more (389 words)

Therefore, arise, O daughter of Zion, and with the iron horns I pledge to give you, and with the brass hooves you possess, shatter and scatter the nations to the winds, and strike them before the Lord of all the earth. By this sacred offering and act, He shall be pleased. The Jews, still unaware that this has been fulfilled, anticipate its realization at Christ’s future return, believing that all nations will then be subservient to them, and that the very Roman Empire, which they interpret as Edom, shall fall beneath their hooves and be scattered by their horns. The absurdity of such an interpretation is evidenced throughout Scripture. However, we, adhering not to the lethal letter but to the life-giving spirit, declare that against the daughter of Zion, symbolizing the Church, numerous hordes of demons presently assail her in this age steeped in wickedness, triumphing in slaying her offspring, yet failing to grasp the mind of the Lord or to comprehend His counsel; for had they understood, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory (1 Cor. 2:8). Therefore, He shall gather them like sheaves in a threshing floor, and all that is thorny and unclean, light and worthless, He shall break with His hooves and scatter with His horns; meanwhile, He will reserve the pure grain as an offering to the Lord. But what does it signify when it declares, “And thou shalt humble many nations, and shalt consecrate to the Lord their multitude, and their strength to the Lord of all the earth”? Let us examine the books of Numbers, Joshua, and 1 Kings, where we find that after defeating the Gentiles, with many falling by the sword, gold and silver were set apart for the Lord, along with a portion of the spoils of both men and livestock. Ultimately, Achan, who took from the accursed spoils of Jericho, incited the people, and for his sin, the valley received the name Achor, meaning “the valley of trouble” (Num. 7:24-26). But understand that according to the text from the LXX, which states, “Thou shalt dedicate to the Lord their multitude, and their strength to the Lord of all the earth,” the act of dedication is to be interpreted positively; Theodotion translates ‘multitude’ as gifts, while the Fifth Edition states ‘profit,’ and Symmachus refers to ‘their profit.’

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

At present, the crowd of the Gentiles has assembled against you, and the nations proclaim, let us rejoice, and we shall behold Zion. Yet they did not grasp the intentions of the Lord, nor did they understand His wisdom, for He gathered them like bundles of grain on the threshing floor. God’s gathering is not through force or pressure but through a humble invitation that allows for the exercise of free will. This has been demonstrated through the teachings of the other prophets.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.