The Church Fathers on this verse

Numbers 11:29Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

But he said: Why hast thou emulation for me? O that all the people might prophesy, and that the Lord would give them his spirit!

Douay-Rheims

וַיֹּ֤אמֶר לוֹ֙ מֹשֶׁ֔ה הַֽמְקַנֵּ֥א אַתָּ֖ה לִ֑י וּמִ֨י יִתֵּ֜ן כָּל־עַ֤ם יְהוָה֙ נְבִיאִ֔ים כִּי־יִתֵּ֧ן יְהוָ֛ה אֶת־רוּח֖וֹ עֲלֵיהֶֽם׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 5 commentaries

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Some of those near Moses felt envious and suggested that they should be restricted. However, Moses, understanding the profound truth of Christ, addressed them, saying, "Oh, if only all the Lord's people were prophets, when the Lord imparted His Spirit upon them!" This indicates that the law ensnared people and guided them to God, leading many to the mystery of Christ. Yet it could not encompass all; Christ purified those who remained. The Gentiles were not introduced to the truth through Moses or the law, but through the divine power of God the Father, who reveals His image, namely the Son, to those who are unaware; He has called and consecrated them through the anointing of the Spirit.

Read more (60 words)

Those bound by the law envy those united with Christ, who are justified through faith and sanctified by the Spirit. Only Moses found joy upon recognizing the sacrament. In contrast, those envious of the unique role of Moses irrationally resent the saints in Christ, including the nations among the Jews. Glaphers on the Exodus. Concerning the manna and the krastels.

Cyrill of Jerusalem

4th centuryChurch Father

Joshua, the successor of Moses, was struck with amazement and went to Moses saying, “Have you heard that Eldad and Medad are prophesying? They were called but did not come; my lord Moses, please stop them!” Moses replied, “I cannot stop them, for this is a divine gift. Much less can I prevent them, as I too have received grace. However, I do not believe your objection stems from envy.” Are you not envious of me because they have begun to prophesy while you have not yet done so? Be patient for the appointed time. Who would not desire that all of the Lord’s people be prophets when the Lord pours His Spirit upon them! This is the prophetic word of Moses: when the Lord chooses to give His Spirit. It has not yet been given, hence you have not received.

Read more (72 words)

Did not Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph have this same Spirit? Did not those before them also possess the Spirit? The phrase “when the Lord shall give” clearly indicates that He will bestow His Spirit upon all. Grace is currently partial, but it will be abundantly given later. He was, in essence, speaking in anticipation of what was to unfold on Pentecost, as the same Spirit was also poured out upon us.

I cannot prevent them from prophesying, as Moses declared, for it is a heavenly gift; even less can I hinder them, knowing that I too have received the gift of grace. However, I do not believe your words stem from jealousy. Do not let envy arise because they are prophesying while you have not yet received that gift. Be patient for the appointed time. "And who shall give all the people of the Lord prophets, when the Lord shall pour out His Spirit upon them?" Moses also indicated this prophetically when he spoke of "when the Lord shall give." Yet, the Spirit has not been given in fullness yet; hence, you have not experienced it yet. Did Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, and Joseph not possess this Spirit? Did those who came before them not have Him?

Read more (51 words)

The phrase "when the Lord shall give" clearly suggests that He will bestow His Spirit upon everyone. Currently, grace is bestowed in measure, but in the future, it will be given in abundance. His words hinted at what occurred on the day of Pentecost, when that same Spirit descended upon us.

Joseph of Wolokolamsk

15th centuryChurch Father

Moses replied, "I cannot prevent them, for it is a divine gift that I, too, have received. I do not believe your words stem from envy; do not criticize me for their ability to prophesy while you do not. Be patient for the appointed time." He wished aloud, "If only all the people of the Lord were prophets, when the Lord would bestow His Spirit upon them!" By stating, "when the Lord would send," Moses indicates that the Lord has not yet given His Spirit, and thus Joshua does not possess the full gift of prophecy; currently, only a limited gift is available – when the Lord bestows it, the gift will be plentiful. In this way, Moses foreshadowed the outpouring of the Holy Spirit upon the holy apostles at Pentecost.

Read more (49 words)

As Joel prophesied, "And in the last days I will pour out My Spirit upon all flesh, and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy. And on My menservants and on My maidservants I will pour out My Spirit in those days, and they shall prophesy." (See Joel 2:28-29)

Vissarion (Nechaev)

19th centuryCommentator

Are you envious of me? In other words, do you not already harbor personal jealousy toward me? And do you believe that your jealousy serves as a favor to me? It is futile for us to concern ourselves solely with our own honor and authority, rather than with the glory of God and the work He is doing, while neglecting our personal interests. Recognize that Eldad and Modad, whom you view as undermining my status, have been called to God's service. The prophetic gift they possess confirms and seals this divine assignment. To hinder them from exercising this gift would be to resist the Spirit of grace and thwart the work of God. Quiet your spirit and glorify the Lord, who has raised up two men to labor alongside us, despite your discontent.

Read more (335 words)

- And who will not desire that all the people of the Lord become prophets! Moses not only rejoices for Eldad and Modad, who have received the prophetic gift, but he also wishes for all to be transformed into prophets, wishing that all the Lord's people would be empowered. The earlier indefinite reference turns into a clear mention of the Lord, the sole Source of the prophetic gift, when the Lord pours His Spirit upon them. When the Lord chooses to pour out His Spirit on everyone! - Moses is expressing that he is not offended by the two men prophesying without his consent; rather, he would not view it as a disgrace to his status if all the people were to experience the gift of prophecy. He regards the advancement of God's glory as the fundamental goal of his life, thus, the more instruments there are for disseminating this glory, the more gratifying it is to him. He sees it as a grave sin to stifle the Spirit in others or to diminish the value of prophecy (1 Thess. 5:19-20), and he undertakes the responsibility, as does his disciple, who is protective of his honor, to foster the work of the grace of the Holy Spirit in anyone upon whom it is bestowed. - What Moses longed for was foretold by Joel as a prophecy that would come to fulfillment in the New Testament, which indeed occurred on the day of Pentecost when the Holy Spirit descended upon all those gathered in the upper room of Zion. The Apostle Peter cites this significant event, referencing Joel's prophecy concerning the outpouring of the Spirit of the Lord upon all flesh (Acts 2:16-17). Given that the Feast of Pentecost celebrates the glorification of the Holy Spirit, who triumphed over the Apostles and all who were with them, it is fitting that a passage is read on this feast that highlights the work of the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament Church, thereby glorifying the same Spirit.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.