The Church Fathers on this verse

Ecclesiastes 7:17Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Be not over just: and be not more wise than is necessary, lest thou become stupid.

Douay-Rheims

אַל־תִּרְשַׁ֥ע הַרְבֵּ֖ה וְאַל־תְּהִ֣י סָכָ֑ל לָ֥מָּה תָמ֖וּת בְּלֹ֥א עִתֶּֽךָ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

God assures those who diligently follow Him: ... I will grant him a long life (Psalm 90:16). When Abraham passed away, he did so fully satisfied with his years (Gen. 25:8), while David beseeches, do not let me experience only a portion of my years (Ps. 101:25). One of Job's companions, Eliphaz, well aware of this truth, stated: You will depart this life at a ripe old age, like wheat bundles gathered at the right time (Job 5:26). Furthermore, Solomon affirms with weighty words: The spirits of the wicked are taken before their time (Proverbs 11:30; LXX), and then urges in Ecclesiastes, do not succumb to sin, and do not act foolishly: why should you meet death prematurely?

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Refrain from engaging in wickedness and avoid foolishness; what reason is there for you to perish in your own time? For the Lord declares, ‘I do not desire the death of the sinner, but rather that they turn from their ways and live’ (Ezekiel 18:32). It suffices to sin just once; after falling, we must seek to regain our standing! If, as naturalists suggest, the swallow can restore sight to its young with chelidonium, and wounded goats can find healing, why do we not recognize that the gift of repentance is available for those who have sinned?

Read more (80 words)

Regarding the phrase, ‘lest they die in their own time,’ we recall how Korah, Dathan, and Abiram faced immediate destruction by the earth opening due to their rebellion against Moses and Aaron, and that many faced condemnation in this life for the benefit of others before the final judgment (Num. 16). Thus, the implication of these words is clear: do not accumulate sins upon sins, lest God bring about His judgment upon you while you still dwell in this life.

Isidore of Pelusium

5th centuryChurch Father

The utmost form of physical beauty lies in the harmony of the body’s parts, while the highest manifestation of mental beauty exists in the balance of virtues. It has been said by sages that extremes lead to vices: the individual who strives for frugality may fall into greed, and the one who seeks to be generous might succumb to extravagance. Thus, the wise have aptly characterized virtue as the mean, where piety stands as the balance between moral failings. The counsel of the wise aptly advises against excessive righteousness. This guidance suggests we should not harshly judge our neighbors for their transgressions, but rather, let compassion outweigh strict justice, exercising mercy towards those who exceed our expectations for forbearance.

Read more (165 words)

In light of your inquiry regarding the phrase “Thou shalt not be righteous greatly,” I offer a dual interpretation. One interpretation suggests that we should not adhere to a strict interpretation of truth, but rather allow kindness to surpass mere justice. Justice entails not being wronged, yet true justice is demonstrated by patiently enduring wrongs. Alternatively, this teaching encourages us to pursue the virtuous mean, as both extremes and deficiencies diverging from the path of righteousness lead to vices. The wisdom of these teachings is emphasized by the subsequent instruction: “Do not be wise in excess, lest you be astonished.”

One of the seven esteemed wise men, perhaps inspired by this principle or sharing a similar insight, proclaimed that “all things are better than measure.” Another, conveying a related truth, asserted, “nothing is too much.” It is essential to recognize that this principle applies not only to virtues but also to piety, for piety represents the balance between impiety and superstition and prohibits both extremes.

Ireneus (Orda)

19th centuryCommentator

The wise individual's focus should be on the ultimate purpose of life. It is thus more advisable to remember the fleeting nature and triviality of worldly pleasures rather than to fabricate false joy through them (7: 2-8). From recognizing the futility of worldly pursuits, the preacher cautions everyone to guard against discontent and impatience. When initiating a matter, one should examine it carefully and refrain from haughty opposition; for often, it concludes more favorably than its beginning. Therefore, patiently await its resolution (9: 10). Complaining is the action of those who challenge God's authority (11). Wisdom surpasses material wealth; it grants life to an individual (12: 13).

Read more (149 words)

We should refrain from grumbling about adversity but rather embrace it as part of God's good plan, yielding ourselves with patience to His guidance (Ιό). Neither the righteousness of one who deems himself righteous nor the wrongdoing of the careless can lead to true joy for humanity; it is solely the fear of the Lord that can bring happiness, as human righteousness is never wholly complete (10: 21). One should ignore malicious talk (22: 23). The preacher's quest for wisdom did not render him wise; he discerned that the temptation of sin was ubiquitous, with woman symbolizing sin, as noted in Proverbs 7 (24: 27). In his pursuit of righteousness, he often found encouragement from men, but never from women (28: 29). While it may seem that God has made it hard for a man to find the right path, the true fault lies with his own deceit (30).

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.