The Church Fathers on this verse

Haggai 2:11Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

In the four and twentieth day of the ninth month, in the second year of Darius the king, the word of the Lord came to Haggai the prophet, saying:

Douay-Rheims

כֹּ֥ה אָמַ֖ר יְהוָ֣ה צְבָא֑וֹת שְׁאַל־נָ֧א אֶת־הַכֹּהֲנִ֛ים תּוֹרָ֖ה לֵאמֹֽר׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

3 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 4 commentaries

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

This additional revelation given to Israel by the prophet is believed to have occurred for a specific purpose. In the second year of King Darius, during the seventh month, God began to address those who had returned from exile, reprimanding them for their complacency—specifically regarding their responsibility to reconstruct the temple. Ultimately, they united and showed enthusiasm in their work. God acknowledged their efforts, promising to be with them and bless their endeavors, urging them to be courageous due to the presence of His Spirit among them. However, they soon fell back into a lethargic state; it appears that in less than two months, they relapsed into negligence and indecision.

Read more (177 words)

Engrossed in their mercantile pursuits and driven by an inordinate desire for wealth, they began to neglect the temple, as they found it increasingly difficult to manage their business interests at their convenience. When they offered sacrifices, they mistakenly believed those acts alone would suffice for their purification, even if the sacred temple were to be nonexistent.

Consequently, the prophet was instructed to awaken their awareness through powerful admonitions, teaching them that to engage in prayers and sacrifices while being negligent in the construction of God’s house would ultimately be to their detriment, rather than benefiting them. He further elaborated that in their commercial dealings, by associating with wicked and foreign individuals, likely including idolaters, they risked becoming profoundly tainted. The inquiry posed is indeed significant, though challenging to decipher. I will endeavor to clarify it, elaborating its implications as fully as possible. Thus, the prophet directs his questions to the priests, as it is written, “the mouth of the priests shall keep the judgement, and the law shall be called out of his mouth” (Malachi 2:7).

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Haggai served as a prophet, and the Lord communicated through him, instructing, 'Inquire of the priests regarding the Law.' Hence, it is the responsibility of a priest to provide answers to those who seek understanding about the Law.

In his epistle to Timothy, who since his youth had immersed himself in the sacred Scriptures, the Apostle urged him to engage with them earnestly, so as to remain cognizant of the grace afforded to him through his sacred calling. In his letter to Titus, after briefly highlighting the virtues required of a bishop, the Apostle emphasizes the importance of understanding Scripture, instructing that a bishop should firmly uphold the faithful word aligned with sound doctrine, enabling him to teach effectively and correct those who contradict it (Titus 1:9). The prophet Haggai conveys, or more accurately, under divine directive, "Ask the priests concerning the law" (Haggai 2:11). Thus, it is incumbent upon the priest to provide accurate responses to inquiries about God’s law.

Read more (1153 words)

Regarding certain disagreements seen in the Septuagint, it is noted that specific expressions, such as “For their morning gifts,” are absent in the Hebrew texts and from other interpretations. It bears mentioning that when referencing the twenty-fourth day of the ninth month in the second year, it is stated only: "To Haggai the prophet" without the preceding phrase used thrice earlier, indicating that the Lord's message was manifest solely in deeds at that time. He had yet to attain complete understanding or wisdom, as he was surrounded by those claiming that it was not yet time to build the temple for the Lord. However, once the foundations of the temple were established, and the community alongside its leaders entered the house of God to fulfill their sacred duties, having heard the proclamation, "I will shake all nations, and the Desired of all nations shall come," Haggai became filled with prophetic insight, and the word of God was fully present with him.

The designation of the ninth month here carries a negative connotation; for instance, during Passover and other festivals, the observances conclude by the eighth day. Those preparing the paschal lamb traditionally skipped the ninth. Similarly, the Day of Atonement and purification occurs after the ninth. In Jeremiah, it is recorded that the siege of Jerusalem by the Babylonians would commence in the ninth year (Jeremiah 52:4), signaling the impending uncleanness of the people—a contextual backdrop to this month’s association with the second year of Darius. However, as divine mercy offers an opportunity for repentance post-uncleanness, Haggai, on the twenty-fourth day, is instructed to inquire of the priests regarding the law, articulating, “Ask the priests about the law.” It is crucial to understand that priests must be versed in the Lord’s law; a priest who is unaware showcases that he does not fulfill his priestly role. The priest is tasked with knowledge of the law and addressing questions regarding it, as detailed in Deuteronomy, which instructs that when questions regarding various judgments arise within Israel, they should consult the priests and the Levites (Deuteronomy 17:8ff.). Upon receiving the priests’ deliberation, the inquirers are to act accordingly to avoid being cut off from the people.

To illustrate this not merely within the confines of the Old Testament, the Apostle advises Timothy that a bishop should be irreproachable, faithful in marriage, wise, humble, gracious, pious, and hospitable, while also being apt to teach (1 Tim. 3:2). This critical stance is mirrored in the instructions given to Titus, where he is reminded to appoint presbyters in every city, dictating that any candidate must be blameless, having faithful offspring, and notably free from accusations of debauchery or rebellion. A bishop, as God’s steward, ought to be uncontentious, not prone to anger, nor greedy for dishonest gain, but rather hospitable, temperate, just, holy, and devoted to teaching, equipped to encourage others in sound doctrine and admonish those who oppose it, as there exist many unruly individuals and deceivers, particularly among those of the circumcision, whose mouths must be silenced (Titus 1:5-11).

In this light, both the Old and New Testaments delineate the necessity for priests to be established in God’s law and ready to respond to inquiries related to it. To the preacher's role, mere simplicity and abstinence from indulgence are insufficient; a virtuous life must accompany teaching, for the preacher serves as an example for others. It is anticipated that those prepared for teaching from an early age may fulfill this calling effectively. Nevertheless, it often occurs that God, accompanied by the community’s voice, selects humble individuals for the priesthood, necessitating that they later study God's law to teach what they have learned, prioritize spiritual wealth over material gain, and dedicate themselves to the Scriptures instead of frivolity or worldly pursuits.

What question does Haggai pose to the priests on the Lord's behalf? If a man carries consecrated meat on his person, or the hem of his garment comes in contact with bread, cooked food, wine, oil, or any form of sustenance, does it then become sacred? To explore this, we must understand what it means for food to be holy and what it means to be rendered unclean. Sacrificial meat from the altar is indeed holy, yet variations exist between different portions. Some are consumed by priests at the temple, others by family members at home, some are eaten by priests under certain defilements, and some by undefiled Israelites. Levitical texts clarify that anyone who touches a corpse is deemed unclean. Notably, while life remains, the body is not unclean, but once the spirit departs, it becomes unclean, as articulated in Leviticus.

Priests are commanded not to become defiled by touching the deceased, except for close kin, with the high priest bearing a greater obligation to maintain purity. Understanding the significance of consecrated and unclean meat leads us to Haggai's inquiry. If anyone, not just designated priests, carries consecrated meat and the edge of their garment brushes against bread, boiled food, wine, oil, or any edible items, can such items become holy through contact? The priests responded, "No," affirming that the items in question remain unchanged by such contact.

Another question follows, similar yet distinct, potentially misleading the untrained. If one who is unclean through touching a dead body contacts bread or any food, shall these be rendered unclean? The priests confirmed that all items touched by the unclean individual are defiled. Haggai seized this opportunity to indicate that the people are like this unclean state before the Lord. They are spiritually impure, having "touched dead meat," and therefore everything they offer or bring to God is rendered unclean. His message was a warning to the people preparing their offerings while neglecting the restoration of the temple, reminding them that while the sacrificial meat is holy, it can’t cleanse them if they remain immersed in the ways of the world.

In a spiritual context, the faithful who offer Christ, the unblemished Lamb, and are adorned in His righteousness, when they share His essence—symbolically touching the Scriptures, which empower believers, or the teachings of the Apostles, which rightly interpret the Old Law—they do not sanctify others merely through the act of sharing; sanctification occurs when those receiving are inwardly transformed. Despite many being hearers of the law, few engage as doers of it. This reflects why these sacred offerings do not immediately sanctify those who partake, for true sanctity stems from a deep internal connection rather than superficial contact.

As Haggai’s message illustrates, defilement by unholy influences holds true today; those whose teachings are tainted, though they engage in sacred acts, must show care, for spiritual impurity will obscure their offerings. Haggai affirms that the acts and offerings of a disillusioned people are rendered unclean. The Lord sees through external appearances, understanding that offerings made by those whose spirits are impure hold no value. Rather, they become profane in His sight, regardless of their outwardly holy façade.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

The prophet declares that this house of worship will possess greater glory, not due to its dimensions or aesthetic appeal, but as a consequence of the downfall of the nations outside Israel; for the might of the Lord of all humanity has been revealed through proclamation. Thus, the Prophet refers to this occurrence as a tremor shaking the heavens, the earth, and the seas, leaving all in wonder. This miraculous event captivates not only those on land but also those who reside on islands, along with the unseen Powers, for whom the heavens and the very atmosphere are accessible.

Read more (138 words)

“And in this place I will give peace, saith the Lord Almighty, and peace of soul for a supply to every one that buildeth, that buildeth this church.” I will not only cease human conflict but will also bestow divine tranquility that brings salvation to souls. This will be the reward for those who construct the temple. In the ninth month, the Prophet received a directive from the God of all humanity to inquire of the priests, “Are the garments sanctified by the sacred sacrifice sufficient to sanctify that which is touched, such as bread, or wine, or oil, or any such thing?” When the priests replied negatively, he was instructed again to ask, “Is a garment that has touched anything unclean rendered impure?” When the priests affirmed this, the Prophet was commanded to deliver the following message:

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.