The Church Fathers on this verse

Hosea 9:11Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

As for Ephraim, their glory hath flown away like bird from the birth, and from the womb, and from the conception.

Douay-Rheims

אֶפְרַ֕יִם כָּע֖וֹף יִתְעוֹפֵ֣ף כְּבוֹדָ֑ם מִלֵּדָ֥ה וּמִבֶּ֖טֶן וּמֵהֵרָיֽוֹן׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

4 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

When Israel departed from their homeland, they sought refuge from the Egyptians, appealing to the deity of that nation for safety. Was the Lord powerless to deliver them? Certainly not. The Divine Authority is all-encompassing and could have thwarted conflict with the Assyrians. However, the Ephraimites, representing Israel, had to face such turmoil because they turned away from the God who redeems. They disregarded His supreme sovereignty, treating it as outdated, and believed their own strength and stature as a great nation would render them formidable against their foes, boasting numerous offspring. Indeed, their women bore children miraculously, in fulfillment of promises, for Moses proclaimed, ‘there shall not be barrenness, below barrenness’ among the children of Israel (Ex. 23:26).

Read more (64 words)

It was, however, unwise to underestimate God's assistance due to their numbers. In truth, they ought to have recognized that with the Lord, ‘one shall chase a thousand, and two shall put ten thousand to flight’ (Deuteronomy 32:30). Thus, it is said that they do not glorify God but instead focus on their own accomplishments in childbirth, conception, and the ailments of their women.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

As a bird takes to the skies, so too does their honor vanish. The descendants of Ephraim took pride in Jacob's prophecy about their lineage, believing they would have a vast number of descendants for generations to come. Consequently, the Lord asserts, “I will strip away what is conceived and nurtured in the womb; I will remove from them those who have reached maturity and dwell among humanity.” Thus, God reveals to the people of Ephraim that their children will depart from them like a bird, illustrating that their expectations are in vain.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Ephraim has taken flight like a bird; their glory has departed from the beginning, from birth, and from conception. If they bear children, I will render them childless among humankind. And woe to them when I withdraw from their midst. As I have observed, Ephraim was like Tyre, established in a splendid region. In the Septuagint, Ephraim is depicted as having flown away like a bird; the splendor of birth, childbirth, and conception has vanished. If they bring forth children, they will face childlessness among people. And woe to them: My body will be removed from them. Ephraim, as I have seen, has surrendered his children to death. There is much debate among interpreters regarding this passage.

Read more (665 words)

Where we have said, “Woe to them when I am removed from them,” the Septuagint and Theodotion read, “Woe to them, My body shall be taken away from them.” Upon examining this variation, it seems to arise from the fact that “My body” in Hebrew is termed baѕari, while “My withdrawal” is translated as baѕori. Thus, the Septuagint and Theodotion replaced “My withdrawal” with “My body.” Moreover, where we state, “Ephraim was Tyre,” the Septuagint interprets it as θήραν, meaning “catch.” Other translators, such as Aquila, Symmachus, and Theodotion, refer to it as a very hard stone, flint, which is called sur in Hebrew. If we consult the term sog, it signifies Tyre; however, because of the similarity between the letters resh and dalet, the Septuagint interpreters rendered it as sud, signifying “catch.” Consequently, Bethsaida translates to “the house of fishers.”

Now, after addressing differing translations, we shall explain the essence. Ephraim, representing the ten tribes, has fled in captivity like a bird from his homeland. The imagery of the bird underscores the swiftness of their exile to Babylon. If we interpret “as a bird their glory has departed,” it indicates that the divine assistance has left and forsaken them. The subsequent phrase, “from birth, from the womb, and from conception,” can be understood in two ways: either as the glory having departed from Ephraim’s lineage, forsaking their children and descendants, or in context that Israel believed their glory resided in their numbers, thinking they were superior to their brother Judah due to their ten tribes compared to Judah’s two. Hence, the Lord affirms that even if they raise children and have abundant offspring, they shall face demise, coming under true woe now that God has abandoned them.

It is stated that before forsaking them, Ephraim was renowned and surrounded by divine favor, likened to Tyre encircled by the sea or a solid stone that stands firm against storms and tempests. Yet Ephraim, like Tyre established in a beautiful region, leads his children into bondage. Many connect this section to the siege of Samaria by Azael, where starvation led the beleaguered to prefer death by sword over hunger. We shall interpret it through an allegorical lens, signifying that Ephraim, or the heretics, has departed from the Church, placing their significance in birth and conception; yet the Lord warns of their impending punishment despite bearing many children. This punishment comes not from any other but through the Lord Himself, as they have borne children of iniquity, thus true woe will befall them when God withdraws His presence.

It is also recalled how Ephraim once stood; when he was with the Church, he faced the age's temptations just as Tyre faced the relentless waves of the sea, yet he was unharmed because he had Christ as his foundation, which ensures that a house built on such a foundation cannot fall. Now, however, he leads his offspring to destruction, symbolizing the devil. It is beautifully expressed that he leads them out, indicating their departure from the Church. The children of Ephraim can be seen as the evil thoughts and doctrines opposing the truth, which the Lord nullifies with the spirit of His mouth, denying them such offspring, instead consigning them to eternal perdition.

What is rendered in the Septuagint as “My body is of them; Ephraim, as I observed, gave his children to be ensnared” can be understood this way: if Christ is the head of the body, the Church, then all of us are members of Christ and His Church. Consequently, one who detaches from the Church tears apart the body of Christ; thus, Ephraim constituted a part of Christ’s body. Yet, he surrendered his children to be ensnared, namely caught by those intended to harm, echoing the words, “Our soul as a bird shall be delivered from the net of them that catch it” (Psalm 123:7). He exposed his children to injury or death, subjected to those who wield burning arrows, striking them down with fury.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Ephraim is like a bird that takes flight. They are soon to be taken away to a distant place; for they do not cherish the beauty of righteousness, yet the highest glory lies in abundance. Their achievements come from being born, from illnesses, and from the act of coming into being.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.