The Church Fathers on this verse

Isaiah 26:14Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Let not the dead live, let not the giants rise again: therefore hast visited and destroyed them, and hast destroyed all their memory.

Douay-Rheims

מֵתִים֙ בַּל־יִחְי֔וּ רְפָאִ֖ים בַּל־יָקֻ֑מוּ לָכֵ֤ן פָּקַ֙דְתָּ֙ וַתַּשְׁמִידֵ֔ם וַתְּאַבֵּ֥ד כָּל־זֵ֖כֶר לָֽמוֹ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

5 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Only those who truly acknowledge the one, naturally existing God and invoke His name without comparing anyone or anything to Him can rightly say: Lord, we cannot comprehend You otherwise; it must be added: the dead cannot experience life again unless it is through You. For the Creator of all, the Lord, inherently embodying life, grants life to everything, and in Him we find our existence (Acts 17:28). Furthermore, it is stated that they shall rise; this must be understood in relation to You, since all things proceed from God, who fashioned them from the earth in order to be restored (Sir 38:4), as indicated in the Scriptures.

Read more (569 words)

If we consider the straightforward meaning of the text, this interpretation stands firm. Yet, it is essential to delve into the deeper significance of this message to uncover the prophet's genuine intent. Some are lifeless, not in a physical sense, but rendered spiritually dead by their fixation on worldly pleasures, lacking the holy life found in Christ and the truth of the Gospel. Such individuals, he claims, would never have received life or the grace to live without You. Likewise, those designated as spiritual healers, capable of liberating those afflicted by spiritual ailments, could not rejuvenate the souls of the sick apart from You.

We regard our holy prophets, apostles, and evangelists as spiritual healers, endowed with the divine Word capable of healing through heavenly grace and intercession, mending those injured by sin and the schemes of darkness. It is likely that the prophetic word alludes to a different meaning; our Lord Jesus Christ, demonstrating His equality with the Father in power and majesty, raised the dead and healed those suffering from grievous illnesses. However, despite His wondrous acts, He faced rejection from those who witnessed His miracles and was persecuted by the Jewish leaders and teachers.

Thus, He states that without You, the dead would not experience life, for only You can impart life, and the healers would not be capable of raising those You had awakened from the tombs, as many remained steadfast in their disbelief, while others who should have recognized Him grew enraged. Your wrath has been brought upon them, leading to their destruction, and every male among them was taken away: because, while Your judgment did not annihilate all of Israel, as a remnant was preserved, it struck down every male from the ruling class, for men are generally seen as more suited to lead than women. The youngest among the Jews are addressed as men, perhaps not for their physical might, but for their understanding of the law.

God spoke to the prophet formed in His image, saying, “I will go to the men of power and speak to them” (Jeremiah 5:5). Thus, they collectively broke free from restraint and released themselves from bondage. That He rightly deems the first and foremost among the Jews as wretched and invokes severe judgment upon them is further clarified by Christ, who proclaimed: “Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, for you traverse land and sea to make one convert, and when you do, you make him a son of hell, worse than yourselves” (Matthew 23:15); and again: “Woe unto you, lawyers, for you have taken away the key of knowledge: you're entering not yourselves, and those who are entering you hinder” (Luke 11:52). Hence, the male sex, those who hold power and esteem, are justly punished; having achieved spiritual awareness of the law, they chose to betray Christ.

Not only have they fallen away from communion with God, but they have also faced devastation brought about by famine and calamities during the destruction of their land. Those referred to as men are also recognized as glorious, standing out due to their elevated status and being honored for their priestly roles. All their males, provided by God, were intended to assist them; yet, what He deems as evil encompasses the afflictions—famine, pestilence, wars, and similar trials inflicted by God. Meanwhile, those labeled as glorious are those notorious for their wicked acts and recognized for their might.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

They do not bring the dead back to life, nor do their deities resurrect the mighty. They will not emerge from the dust, unlike You who lifts the needy from the ground (Psalm 112:7) and raises the lifeless from the earth. For You have visited and brought ruin upon them, specifically the ancient giants whom You vanquished in Noah’s flood, and the rulers of Egypt whom You drowned in their chariots in the sea, hiding their horsemen within the ocean's waves.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Let those who have perished remain lifeless, and let the mighty not rise again. Hence, You have come to them and brought about their destruction, erasing all remembrance of them. Symmachus expresses this more clearly: The dead shall not come back to life; the mighty shall not rise. Therefore, You have visited and obliterated them along with all memory of their existence. We shall clarify the term 'sierwas' in line with the LXX. The challenging question arises: Why must the dead be deprived of life? This is addressed by the fact that as long as they do not witness life, they remain in death. It is akin to stating that a blind person cannot perceive light while remaining blind; yet if healing is restored, they will see the light.

Read more (521 words)

Likewise, one who dies in unrighteousness and sin cannot live again until they are revived with righteousness and virtues through Him who declared, ‘I am the way, the truth, and the life’ (John 14:6). Thus, He is recognized as the God of the living, not of the dead (Matt. 22:32). For the soul that sins shall perish (Ezekiel 18:4). The epistle to the Hebrews states, ‘let us not again lay the foundation of repentance from dead works’ (Heb. 6:1). If sins are termed as dead works, it naturally follows that virtues may be termed as living works. This underscores the futility of the poets’ legends, which narrate how Aesculapius raised Virbius.

It must also be noted that without God's mercy, the practice of healing holds no significance, even regarding all ailments. How so? Unless the Lord builds the house, those who labor do so in vain; unless the Lord guards the city, the watchman stays awake in vain (Ps. 127:1). Therefore, if the Lord does not restore the sick, the efforts of physicians aiming to heal them are in vain. If the Lord does not maintain health, the guidance provided by health manuals becomes futile; during times of health, both physical and mental, one should always find encouragement: bless the Lord, O my soul, who heals all your diseases (Psalm 102:1-3). Those, however, who remain dead in sin and persist therein cannot be revived by any healing method, and will ultimately face ruin from the Lord, their strength, which is termed manhood, wholly stripped away. This is why Pharaoh sought to destroy not only the weaker female gender but also the males (Ex. 1), as the latter, if they reach maturity, present a considerable challenge to eliminate.

According to Symmachus, the dead cannot revive because they remain snared by sin and cannot restore life to others; it is not fitting to glorify in the laughter of a depraved individual (Sir. 15:9). Moreover, the mighty, referred to as the 'nephilim' in Genesis, will not bring others back to life. The Lord visits these entities to ensure both the dead and the mighty face obliteration. For there exists only One capable of resurrecting the dead, concerning whom it is stated, ‘For as the Father raises the dead and gives them life, so also the Son gives life to whom He will’ (John 5:21). We might consider the likenesses of the deceased as lifeless, with the demons depicted in their forms as giants. We are not to be concerned with the LXX's choice of the term masculine versus other translations that prefer memorial, as both share the Hebrew letters zain, kaph, and resh. When we refer to 'memorial,' it translates as Zachar; while 'masculine' becomes Zochor. It is believed that Saul was misled by this ambiguity concerning the Amalekites when he annihilated all their males (1 Sam. 15). While God commanded the complete eradication of the Amalekites' memory from the heavens, Saul, deceived not so much by delusion as by the allure of spoils, understood it as men, disregarding the words of the apostle: Do not be deceived: God is not mocked (Galatians 6:7).

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

It is thus proclaimed by the prophet: The deceased will not be resurrected, nor shall the mighty stand again. Who are the dead if not the transgressors? And who are the mighty if not those who take pride in their sins? These individuals will remain lifeless, for their unrighteous deeds have led to the destruction of a virtuous life. They too cannot experience resurrection after death, as they have, in their arrogance following their wrongdoing, failed to seek the healing power of repentance.

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryCommentator

In previous discussions, we have explored the enigmatic contrast between the harsh Mesopotamian empires and the dominion of evil. It has been observed that in verse 11 of this chapter, the unrighteous, those opposed to the Lord, specifically refer to Asshur and Babylon, aside from their broader implications. Furthermore, verse 14 clearly reveals that the prophet refers to these nations, denoting their civilization and strength as lifeless. This statement does not negate the doctrine of resurrection, as the prophet boldly declares in verse 19, "The dead shall be made alive." Verse 14 highlights the annihilation and demise of the pagan societies of ancient Asia.

Read more (232 words)

The Rephaim, mentioned in Isaiah 14:9 and elsewhere, symbolize the various civilizations and kingdoms that thrived through violence and exploitation in the Mesopotamian region dating back to Nimrod. It is critical to note that this represents a unique type of culture and belief system typified by brutality, indulgence, and inhumanity, which wrought devastation upon the world and stood in stark contrast to Egypt, on one hand, and the chosen people of God, the Aryan tribe, specifically the Mido-Persians, on the other. The Rephaim fade into oblivion; they cannot be resurrected, for "the dead shall not revive, the Rephaim shall not rise." The prophet asserts that all remembrance of them will vanish, and we have observed the realization of this prophecy, noting that the grand cities of Mesopotamia have left no trace on the earth. Such was the decree of the Lord against them; however, the same judgment did not befall Israel. The civilizations of the Rephaim faced eternal destruction, yet Israel was destined for a future. Isaiah poses the question, “Did the Lord smite Israel as he smote those who smote him?” as noted in Isaiah 27:7. He continues with the promise that "Jacob shall give birth to sprouts, and Israel shall flourish, and the earth shall be filled with fruit" (Isaiah 27:6). The prophet consistently points to this magnificent prophecy concerning the "Branch," echoing the message of the Old Testament Evangelist.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.