The Church Fathers on this verse

Isaiah 29:11Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And the vision of all shall be unto you as the words of a book that is sealed which when they shall deliver to one that is learned, they shall say: Read this: and he shall answer: I cannot, for it is sealed.

Douay-Rheims

וַתְּהִ֨י לָכֶ֜ם חָז֣וּת הַכֹּ֗ל כְּדִבְרֵי֮ הַסֵּ֣פֶר הֶֽחָתוּם֒ אֲשֶֽׁר־יִתְּנ֣וּ אֹת֗וֹ אֶל־יוֹדֵ֥עַ הספר סֵ֛פֶר לֵאמֹ֖ר קְרָ֣א נָא־זֶ֑ה וְאָמַר֙ לֹ֣א אוּכַ֔ל כִּ֥י חָת֖וּם הֽוּא׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

7 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 8 commentaries

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Our Savior Jesus Christ never instructed the Jews, "Examine the Scriptures, for you believe that in them you possess eternal life, and it is they that bear witness of me. Yet you refuse to come to me that you might have life" (John 5:39, 40). By persistently debating the commands of Moses, they demonstrated that their understanding of the law was lacking both in simplicity and sincerity. The people of Israel toiled fruitlessly, failing to seek Christ, even though the law itself attests to His will. Consequently, they were reminded, "If you believed Moses, you would believe me; for he wrote about me" (John 5:46). Despite their extensive discussions regarding the law, they ended up rejecting and killing the very One who was foretold within it, neglecting the honor due to Moses.

Read more (99 words)

The inspired Scriptures are, in a sense, sealed by God as a singular testament. They unify under the guidance of one Holy Spirit. How is this seal manifested? Those unable to read, as well as those who recognize the letters, fail to grasp the truths within, and even if they could read the letters, the deeper meanings remain elusive; thus, the law is sealed for all, rendering its profound thoughts entirely unreachable, even for the literate. This was echoed by David in his song to God: "Let their eyes be darkened, and their backs bent down continually" (Psalm 68:24).

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Be amazed and in awe: be troubled, be troubled that they have become intoxicated, yet not with wine. For the Lord has bestowed upon them a spirit of slumber, closing their eyes, including those of their prophets and leaders, who perceive the concealed truths. The vision of each will resemble the words of a book that is sealed. For some will refrain from reading it due to their ignorance, while those who are aware will hesitate to unseal it, as it remains closed.

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

The One who made known to Daniel various profound truths, while indicating that His words were also concealed, instructed that the messages be veiled and the scroll sealed, allowing many to read and seek the genuine understanding of the accounts. The deep obscurity led many to diverse interpretations. The phrase "They shall pass through," referring to many traversing the text (Dan. 12:4), illustrates how it would be read by numerous individuals.

Read more (999 words)

It's a common expression to say, "I have read through the book," or "I have gone through the narrative." This aligns with what Isaiah conveys about the overshadowing darkness in his writings: "And all prophecy is to you as the words of a sealed book, presented to one who can read, who is told, ‘Read this’; and he responds, ‘I cannot, for it is sealed.’"

In the Revelation, a scroll sealed with seven seals appears, and if given to a learned man to read, he will respond, "I cannot, for it is a sealed scroll." Many today presume they understand the Scriptures, yet they possess a sealed scroll, unable to open it unless the One with the key of David unlocks it, Who opens, and no one shuts, and shuts, and no one opens (Rev. 3:7). In the Acts of the Apostles, the holy eunuch, referred to by both titles in Scripture, was reading the prophet Isaiah. When Philip asked him, "Do you understand what you are reading?" he answered, "How can I unless someone guides me?" (Acts 8:30-31). I, too, will remark—just to relate—am not more pious or diligent than this eunuch, who, leaving the royal palace to come to the Temple from Ethiopia, cared so deeply for the Law and divine wisdom that he read the Holy Scriptures even while in his carriage. However, while holding the book and contemplating the words of the Lord, pronouncing them aloud, he still did not grasp the One whom he honored in the text, apart from his awareness. Philip came and unveiled Jesus, hidden within the Scriptures. Oh, the remarkable power of the teacher! In that instant, the eunuch believed, was baptized, became sacred and faithful, transformed from a disciple into a teacher, discovering more in the secluded fountain of the church than in the ornate temple of the synagogue. I mention this briefly, constrained by the limits of this letter, so you may realize the necessity of having a guide when engaging with the Scriptures.

Instead of the spirit of slumber, the Septuagint translates it as brokenness, while Theodotion calls it mindfulness, and Aquila renders it as sound sleep—which in Hebrew is termed thardema—an affliction which God imposed on Adam (Gen. 2) during the creation of the woman from a rib from his side. Jonah too fell into such a deep sleep upon the ship (Jon. 1:5). The entirety of the prophecy following the fall of Jerusalem and the temple, called Ariel, targets the scribes and Pharisees, who, holding the key of knowledge, neither enter themselves nor allow those wishing to enter. They are ordered to become intoxicated from astonishment and awe, or better as the Septuagint suggests, from the loosening of their entire body and spirit, staggering—not from wine or sackcloth—but from the spirit of slumber or brokenness from the Lord, so that when they recognize their wrongdoing, they may repent and echo the prophet, "I have returned to my anguish, when I observed my affliction" (Psalm 31:4). Thus, know, O scribes and Pharisees, acting as rulers of the Jews, that the Lord will recompense you. For when you listened to the Lord, you refused to comprehend, closed your eyes so you could not behold Him, and deafened your ears so you could not hear. Consequently, the Lord shall likewise shut your eyes, that is, the prophets through whom you have perceived the knowledge of God. Or He will seal your eyes, including the prophets who serve as your leaders. Before John the Baptist, the Law and the prophets were present (Luke 16:16), so that those who do not see would indeed perceive, as validated by the subsequent message: "In that day, the deaf shall hear the words of the scroll, and the eyes of the blind shall see" (v. 18). For the Lord came to judge, that those who see among the Jews should not perceive, and that the blind—meaning the Gentile nations—should come to see and behold the Lord (John 9:39). Therefore, He did not explicitly declare that the vision of all the prophets would be sealed from all readers; instead, it shall be sealed specifically to you to whom I presently speak and whom I foretell, or seal forever the eyes of your leaders, who, as the Seventy claim, presume to have seen hidden and secret matters. And it shall be, says He, that all Holy Scripture shall be enclosed and sealed for you. Thus, you who assert your understanding of the Law and the prophetic foreshadowings, who occupy yourselves day and night with the Scriptures, may remain unable to grasp the very texts you read, as it is written in the Revelation of John: "Who is worthy to open the scroll and its seals?" (Rev. 5:2). And when no one was found able to break the seals, he wept, but eventually received the divine assurance: "Weep not, for the Lion of the tribe of Judah, the Root of David, has triumphed to break the scroll and to unloose its seals" (ibid., v. 5). The Lion of the tribe of Judah represents the Lord Jesus Christ, who unsealed the scroll, not only the psalms of David as many suppose but all of Scripture, which originates from one Holy Spirit, and thus is termed one book. Ezekiel alludes to this with a mysterious declaration, stating it is inscribed both inside and outside (Ezek. 2:10), reflecting its essence and letter—not only in the book of Jeremiah or Isaiah but across all of Holy Scripture, which is referred to as one book. Therefore, while the Jewish teachers still today cannot read or unseal and unravel the mysteries of the Scriptures, if you present this book to those who are unlearned, consumed by their instructors, they will concede their lack of understanding of the texts and thus find themselves unable to read. Yet of the two evils, it is far better to admit ignorance of the Law than to pridefully claim wisdom while being unable to fathom its message.

Be filled with astonishment and wonder, intoxicated, yet not by wine; you stagger, but not under the influence of drink. The Lord has cast upon you a spirit of slumber: He will blind the eyes of your seers and silence the visions of your leaders. For every revelation will be to you like the words of a book that is sealed, which when handed to someone who knows how to read, they will be told, Read it; yet they will respond, I cannot, for it is sealed. They will give the book to one who cannot read, instructing them to read, but they will answer, I do not know how to read.

Read more (676 words)

Instead of the spirit of slumber, the Septuagint translates it as brokenness, while Theodotion refers to it as mindfulness, and Aquila as a sound sleep, which in Hebrew is termed thardema—a sleep God induced, as recorded in Scripture, upon Adam (Gen. 2) when a woman was formed from a rib taken from his side. This very sleep is what enveloped Jonah while he was on the ship (Jon. 1:5). The entirety of the prophecy concerning the destruction of Jerusalem and the temple, that is, Ariel, is aimed at the scribes and Pharisees, who, possessing the key of knowledge, neither enter the kingdom themselves nor permit those who wish to enter. They are admonished that they, out of astonishment and wonder—or more accurately, as per the LXX, due to the loosening of body and mind—will be inebriated and wobble, not from wine and sackcloth but from the spirit of slumber or brokenness from the Lord, so that upon recognizing their wrongdoing, they may repent and say with the prophet, I have returned to passion when I have seen my affliction (Psalm 31:4). Thus, you scribes and Pharisees who act as leaders of the Jews, take note that the Lord shall repay you according to your deeds. You, upon hearing the Savior, chose not to understand and closed your eyes so that you could not perceive Him, and deafened your ears so you could not hear. Therefore, He will also shut your eyes, meaning the prophets through whom you have perceived the knowledge of God, or He will render blind your leaders. For the law and the prophets were active until John the Baptist (Luke 16:16), so that when you do not see, those will see whom this discourse speaks of: and in that day will the deaf hear the words of the book, and the blind’s eyes will be opened (v. 18). Indeed, the Lord came in judgment so that the Jews who are perceiving should not perceive, and those who are blind, meaning the Gentiles, should see the Lord (John 9:39). Hence, it is not explicitly stated that the vision of all the prophets will be sealed to everyone who reads; rather, it will be sealed, He says, to you to whom I now speak, to whom I foretell it, or He shall forever blind the eyes of your leaders, who, according to the Seventy, boasted of seeing mysteries. And it will be said that all the Holy Scriptures will be enclosed and sealed for you, such that you who claim to possess knowledge of the Law and prophetic writings, and who continuously engage your lips in the Scriptures, may remain oblivious to their true meaning, as it is declared in the Revelation of John: Who is worthy to open the book and break its seals (Rev. 5:2)? And when no one was found able to break the seals, he lamented, until he was consoled with the words of God, ‘Weep not, for the Lion from the tribe of Judah, the Root of David, has triumphed to break the book and unleash its seals’ (ibid., v. 5). This Lion of the tribe of Judah is the Lord Jesus Christ, who has broken the book's seals not only of the Psalms of David, as many suppose, but of all Scriptures, which are divinely inspired writings, thus regarded as a singular book. Ezekiel affirms this through a profound statement that it is inscribed within and without (Ezekiel 2:10), denoting both meaning and literal text. (Psalms 39:8) It is not solely within the book of Jeremiah or Isaiah but in the entirety of the Holy Scriptures known as a singular book. Consequently, contemporary Jewish teachers are incapable of reading or breaking the seals to uncover the mysteries of Scriptures. When the uneducated are asked about this book, they, overwhelmed by their instructors, confess their ignorance of the writings and hence their inability to read. However, it is a lesser evil to acknowledge ignorance of the law than to boast of wisdom and yet fail to grasp what is spoken.

Gregory the Wonderworker

3rd centuryChurch Father

In the sixth month, the angel Gabriel was dispatched to a virgin pledged to a man named Joseph (Luke 1:26-27). Consider what the prophet expresses regarding both the husband and the virgin: a sealed book is meant for the man who governs the writings. What is this sealed book, if not the Immaculate Virgin herself? Who is to receive it? It is undoubtedly to be presented by the priests. But to whom exactly? To Joseph, the carpenter. When the priests united Mary with Joseph in a sacred union, entrusting him in anticipation of their marriage, he was to safeguard the Virgin’s purity. The prophet had foretold this many years prior: “This book will be handed to the man who observes the writings, and he will declare, ‘I cannot read it.’ Why, Joseph? ‘I cannot,’ he responds, ‘for the book is sealed. For whom is it reserved? It is reserved for the Prince of all in the dwelling.”

Primasius of Hadrumetum

6th centuryChurch Father

Isaiah would similarly address the people of Israel, urging them to recognize that every prophecy holds the same significance for them as the words found in a sealed book. It is stated that both the learned and the uneducated are unable to access the truth contained within, for the seal prevents the learned from unveiling its deeper meaning, while the uneducated are restricted by their lack of knowledge.

Gregorios Palamas

14th centuryChurch Father

Majestically embodying the name of the Virgin, She possessed complete purity as a Virgin in body, soul, and the faculties of the spirit, fully enriched in all sensory experiences without the slightest obstacle. All aspects of Her being were perfected and established, reflecting her eternal tranquility as is fitting for the Lady. She is the closed Door of the treasury and the sealed Book, concealing the hidden truths from view. Thus, it was said of Her: ‘This is the Sealed Book,’ and “the Door shall be shut, and no man shall pass through it” (Ezek. 44:2).

Eusebius of Caesarea

4th centuryTeacher of the Church

Our Savior and Lord did not arrive to finalize or, in a sense, seal the prophetic messages. Instead, He illuminated and clarified what had been hidden and sealed in previous ages and instructed His disciples on the significance of the sacred Scriptures. This is why He states in the Revelation of John: "Behold, the lion of the tribe of Judah, the root of David, has prevailed, and can open this book, and break the seven seals thereof" (Rev. 5:5). What could these seals represent other than the unclear passages within the prophets? Isaiah recognized this as well, affirming, "And every prophecy is to you the same as the words in the sealed book." Thus, Christ, the Son of God, did not come to finalize visions and prophecies, but to unveil them and make them known.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.