The Church Fathers on this verse

Joel 3:19Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Egypt shall be a desolation, and Edom a wilderness destroyed: because they have done unjustly against the children of Juda, and have shed innocent blood in their land.

Douay-Rheims

The Church Fathers on this verse

5 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Egypt will face utter devastation, and Edom shall lie in ruins, due to the iniquity of Judah’s children, who have spilled righteous blood upon their land. Yet Judah will endure eternally, and Jerusalem will stand for generations. I will demand their blood and will not let it go unaccounted for; the Lord shall reside in Zion. Historically, these words reflect the truth as Egypt was indeed punished, losing its sovereignty when Cambyses, a descendant of Cyrus, laid waste to it, while Idumea was left desolate, as evidenced by its circumstances. However, in these prophetic words, there seems to be a deeper reference to the covert confession made by the Only Begotten Son when He took on humanity.

Read more (247 words)

Scripture often likens the hardened idolaters and the legions of demons, who consistently oppose the saints, to these nations. Thus, it is decreed that all adversaries, like the Egyptians and Edomites, shall perish because of the assurance given by Christ that ‘the gates of hell shall not prevail against her’ (Mt. 16:18). Furthermore, the malevolent powers must face retribution for their transgressions against humanity, targeting anyone who disturbs others through erroneous teachings or leads ‘a reprobate mind’ (Rom. 1:28) into moral decay. This warning is clear, as those who rise against Zion will be annihilated, linked to their guilt in having spilled righteous blood, committing grievous offenses against Judah’s descendants, meaning the faithful, who are the children of confession; for Judah signifies confession. The inspired David does not state of the wrongfully slain: ‘for he that seeketh their blood I will remember’ (Ps. 9:13). He addresses Satan, depicted as Assyria, saying: ‘Just as a blood-stained garment cannot be clean, neither shall you be clean; for you have devastated my land and oppressed my people: you shall not endure forever’ (Isa. 14:20). Therefore, the adversaries of Zion will be destroyed; ‘but Judea shall endure eternally,’ and Jerusalem will thrive for generations, not referring to the ruined and burned remnants (for the Lord, who embodies truth, cannot utter falsehood), but to the spiritual, heavenly, exalted Jerusalem, and divine Zion, the splendid and magnificent city designed and constructed by God, through which we may enter by the grace of Christ.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Egypt will be left desolate, reflecting the destruction that has come upon you. Yet, in a deeper meaning, the prophet refers to those who oppress the holy people, proclaiming that their strongholds will be demolished and their riches dispersed. And Idumea will become a deserted wasteland; it will be uninhabited by both humans and animals, for the Idumeans declared, "reduce it to nothing" as they aimed at Jerusalem (Psalms 136:7).

Jerome of Stridon

4th centuryChurch Father

Egypt will become a desolate wasteland, and Edom a barren field, due to their wrongdoing against the people of Judah and the spilling of innocent blood within their borders. The Septuagint states that Egypt will be laid waste and Edom will be a deserted land because of the iniquity committed against the children of Judah, as they have shed righteous blood in their territory. Regarding this matter, the Jewish people are caught in a deep slumber, lulled by a false hope that in the last days, rather than receiving Christ, they will accept the Antichrist and seek vengeance upon their neighbors, the Egyptians, and the Romans, whom they associate with Edom.

Read more (209 words)

Just as Pharaoh and his entire army, who enslaved God's people for four hundred thirty years, drowned in the Red Sea, so too will the Romans, who will hold dominion over the Jews for the same duration, face the wrath of God. These are the groundless expectations they harbor.

They struggle to comprehend why, out of all the nations on earth, only two—Egypt and Edom—will face judgment, or why the term Edom should refer to the Romans when one could equally claim it denotes the Persians, Elamites, Franks, or other groups. Nonetheless, we affirm that at the time of the Lord's resurrection, or on the Day of Judgment—which we accept as parallel events—both Egypt and Edom will meet their end, particularly that which defines them. Egypt, known as Mesraim, signifies oppression and persecution of God’s saints, while Edom represents the earthly and violent. Thus, any who persecute God's people and surrender to worldly pursuits, while committing numerous offenses and consistently shedding innocent blood—that is, the blood of the deceived—will face destruction. This is mirrored in the cries of the martyrs, who pleaded from beneath the altar, "How long, O Lord, holy and true, until You judge and avenge our blood on those who dwell on the earth?" (Rev. 6:10).

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

Egypt will face destruction, signifying that the intense devotion to idols will come to an end, for Egypt represents the epitome of wickedness. Similarly, Edom will find itself in a state of ruin, indicating that it will forfeit its might and worldly wisdom, as Edom is associated with both destruction and earthly matters. However, this can also be understood in a historical context. Just as Egypt met its downfall with the collapse of its kingdom, which was ultimately brought about by Cambyses, the son of Cyrus, so too did Idumea fall into desolation, as history reveals.

Read more (40 words)

They experienced this fate as a divine consequence for the injustices they inflicted upon Judah, for the Prophet designated the blood of the righteous as innocent, implying that they unjustly took the lives of the Jews without any justifiable reason.

Vissarion (Nechaev)

19th centuryCommentator

The terms Egyptians and Idumeans symbolically represent the adversaries of God's kingdom or His Church. Historically, these groups were among the first foes of the chosen people, and as a consequence, they faced the devastation of their homeland, leaving them devoid of any trace of autonomy or strength. This serves as a foreshadowing of the unfortunate destiny that awaits the enemies of the Church when judged by the world, a fate warranted by their actions of shed righteous blood in their territories and their relentless persecution and execution of believers.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.