The Church Fathers on this verse

John 8:15Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

You judge according to the flesh: I judge not any man.

Douay-Rheims

υμεις κατα την σαρκα κρινετε εγω ου κρινω ουδενα

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

12 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

“You judge according to the flesh.” As living according to the flesh means living wickedly, so judging according to the flesh means judging unjustly.

“I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, My judgment is true.” These words mean: you judge unjustly.

But if we judge unjustly, they could have said, why do You not rebuke us? Why do You not punish us? Why do You not condemn us?

Because, He answers, I did not come for this. This is precisely what the words mean: “I judge no one.”

“Yet if I do judge, My judgment is true.” If I wished to judge, you would be among the condemned.

But even this, He continues, I do not say in order to judge. Still, I did not say, “I do not speak in order to judge,” because I would not be able to convict you if I began to judge.

Read more (86 words)

No. If I began to judge, I would condemn you justly. But now is not the time of judgment.

You do not know God. Therefore you judge according to the flesh. You have heard so many testimonies and proofs, and still you say, “It is not true.”

You acknowledge Moses as trustworthy, both when he speaks about others and when he speaks about himself. But you do not acknowledge Christ. This is what it means to judge according to the flesh.

But “I judge no one.”

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

I, He says, as God and as He who came from above, bear true witness concerning Myself. But you look only at what is visible.

Because I am in the flesh, you take Me for mere flesh, and not for God and for Him who came from God.

“You judge according to the flesh,” that is, wrongly. Just as it is said of one who lives according to the flesh that he lives wickedly, so one who judges according to the flesh must be called an unjust judge.

Then, as though someone might say, “If we Jews judge unjustly, why do You not punish us? Why do You not condemn us?” He says, “I did not come for the purpose of judging.

Now I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, My judgment is true” (Jn 8:16).

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

Again we find the Savior of all displaying wondrous meekness. He does not answer His revilers with deserved anger, though He knew that they would receive heavy punishments.

Here also, I think, He imitates skilled physicians and proves Himself rightly worthy of admiration.

They often pay no attention to the disrespect shown them by the sick. With patience and freedom from malice they help them by their art, without taking offense at unpleasantness and sometimes even insults.

By explaining what contributes to health, they in effect persuade the sick to strive to do what is useful for them, and thus remove the cause of the illness.

Our Lord Jesus Christ patiently endures reproaches, assists blasphemers, and heals the wounds of His offenders.

Read more (370 words)

More than this, He clearly indicates the source from which they came to suffer the vice of unbelief in Him. He says, “You judge according to the flesh.”

That is, you err, and this is quite understandable if you look only at this flesh, though you ought to do the very opposite and attend to the splendor of the works.

You are terribly deceived when, because I am clothed in your flesh, you take Me for one like yourselves.

Not perceiving the deep mystery of the divine economy with the flesh, that is, the Incarnation, you pass a senseless sentence on Me by affirming that the Truth lies.

But I postpone judgment over you until another time. “For God did not send the Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world might be saved” (Jn 3:17).

I consider the meaning of this saying sufficiently explained. Yet by other contemplations, as far as we can, we may disclose a more subtle meaning of these words.

“You,” He says, “judge according to the flesh; I judge no one.” Since you have no possibility at all of accusing Me generally, and cannot soundly attack My miracles, you belittle Me only because of the flesh.

You impiously count Me as nothing merely because I appear as a man like yourselves. But I, He says, do not condemn you for the same reason.

I by no means count you as nothing because you are men by nature. Nor will the Judge impose punishment on you for this.

I do not accuse nature. I do not condemn My creatures. I by no means assert that there is any transgression in man merely because he is man.

On the contrary, you count Me as nothing because of the flesh, and condemn Me for this. But I do not judge you in this way.

I know that man is something great and honorable, though he has come from the earth.

Being true God and in the form of the Father who begot Me, I humbled Myself, taking the form of a servant and becoming man (Phil 2:6-7).

For this alone I am now condemned by you, though I Myself condemn no one for this.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Therefore these Jews saw the Man, but they neither understood nor believed that He is God.

This question can be resolved in two ways. Either it may be understood thus: "I judge no one," that is, as He says elsewhere, "I came not to judge the world, but to save it" (Jn 3:17). He does not deny His judgment, but postpones it.

Or, since He had just said plainly, "You judge according to the flesh," He added, "I judge no one," meaning, according to the flesh. Therefore let none of us keep even a grain of doubt in his heart concerning the faith which we hold and proclaim about Christ the Judge. Christ came, first to save, and afterward to judge.

Read more (1949 words)

Among the four Gospels, or rather among the four books of the one Gospel, the holy Apostle John was not without reason spiritually likened to an eagle. He raised his preaching higher than the others and made it more exalted than the other three. Through this height he wished our hearts also to be lifted up.

The other three Evangelists, as it were, walked with the Lord upon the earth, as with a man, and said little concerning His Godhead. But John seemed almost ashamed to walk upon the earth. From the very beginning of his discourse, he soared not only above the earth and every region of air and heaven. He also rose above the whole host of angels and every order of invisible Powers, and reached Him through Whom all things were made, saying: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made" (Jn 1:1, 3).

In the spirit of so lofty a beginning, he continued to preach and spoke of the Lord's divinity as no other did. What he himself had drunk, he gave to us. For it is not without reason that this very Gospel tells how, at the supper, he reclined on the Lord's breast (cf. Jn 13:23). He drank secretly from that breast. What he drank secretly, he openly expressed, so that all nations might understand not only the Incarnation of the Son of God, His Passion, and Resurrection, but also Who He was before the Incarnation: the Only-begotten of the Father. The Word of the Father, coeternal with Him Who begot Him, equal to Him by Whom He was sent, yet in that mission made less, so that the Father might be greater.

Therefore, whatever you hear about the Lord Jesus Christ in His humility, receive it with the divine economy in mind, by which flesh was assumed. In such passages He is as He became for our sake, not as He was in order to create us.

But when you hear or read in the Gospel something said of Him as exalted above every creature, as Divine, equal and coeternal with the Father, understand that what you have read belongs to the form of God, not to the form of a servant (cf. Phil 2:6-7).

If you hold fast to this rule, at least those of you who are able to understand it, you will be walking toward the Light. Not all of you are able to understand it, but all must believe. If you hold this rule, you will contend calmly against the assaults of heretical darkness.

There have been many who, reading the Gospel, followed only those testimonies that concern Christ's humility, while remaining deaf to those that speak of His divinity. They are deaf because they are blasphemous.

There are also many who pay attention only to the passages where the Lord's exaltation is spoken of. Though they read of His mercy, by which He became man for our sake, they did not believe it. They decided it was a lie and a human invention. They asserted that our Lord Christ was only God and was not man.

Some spoke in one way, others in another, and both remained in error. The Catholic faith, however, receives what is true in both understandings and proclaims what it believes. It understands that Christ is God, and it believes that He is man. For both are written, and both are true.

If you call Christ only God, you reject the healing by which you were healed. If you call Christ only man, you reject the power by which you were created. Therefore receive both, faithful soul and Catholic heart. Receive both, believe both, and steadfastly confess both. Christ is God, and Christ is man.

What Christ is God? He is equal to the Father, one with the Father. What Christ is man? He was born of the Virgin, received mortality from man, but did not receive unrighteousness (cf. 1 Pet 2:22).

Thus those Jews saw the man, but neither understood nor believed that He is God. You have already heard what they said to Him among other things: "You bear witness of Yourself; Your witness is not true" (Jn 8:13). You also heard, when this was read yesterday and explained according to our strength, what He answered.

These words of His were also read today: "You judge according to the flesh." "And therefore," He says to them, "you say to Me, 'You bear witness of Yourself; Your witness is not true,' because you judge according to the flesh. You do not see God, but see a man. While persecuting the man, you insult God hidden in the man.

"Therefore you judge according to the flesh. For this reason I seem presumptuous to you, because I bear witness of Myself." For every man, if he wishes to give praiseworthy testimony about himself, seems presumptuous and proud. Therefore it is written: "Let not your own mouth praise you, but the mouth of your neighbor" (cf. Prov 27:2).

But this was said to man, because we are weak and speak with the weak. We can speak both truth and falsehood. Even when we ought to speak the truth, we can lie if we choose. The Light cannot lie. No darkness of falsehood can be thought to appear in the radiance of the Divine Light.

He spoke as Light, and He spoke as Truth. Yet the Light shone in the darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend Him, because it judged according to the flesh. "You," He said, "judge according to the flesh. I judge no one."

What then? Will the Lord Jesus Christ judge no one? Is He not the One Whom we confess as having risen on the third day, ascended into heaven, and sitting at the right hand of the Father, from whence He shall come to judge the living and the dead?

Is this not our faith, of which the Apostle says, "With the heart one believes unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation" (Rom 10:10)? Then when we confess this, do we speak against the Lord? We say that He will come as Judge of the living and the dead, while He Himself says, "I judge no one."

This question may be resolved in two ways. Either we may understand, "I judge no one," as He says elsewhere, "I came not to judge the world, but to save the world" (Jn 12:47). He does not deny His judgment, but postpones it.

Or, since He said, "You judge according to the flesh," He added, "I judge no one," so that you should understand: "I judge no one according to the flesh." Therefore let none of us leave in his heart the slightest doubt concerning the faith which we hold and proclaim regarding Christ as Judge.

Christ came, first to save, and then to judge. He will sentence to punishment those who refused to be saved, and bring to life those who, having believed, did not reject salvation.

Thus the first divine economy of our Lord Jesus Christ is healing, not judging. For if He had first come to judge, He would have found no one to whom He could give the reward of righteousness. Since He saw that all were sinners, and that no man was free from the death of sin, His mercy first had to be desired, and His judgment sought afterward.

For of this the Psalm sings: "Mercy and judgment I will sing to Thee, O Lord" (Ps 100:1). It does not say, "judgment and mercy." If judgment came first, there would be no mercy. But first comes mercy, and afterward judgment.

What is the mercy that comes first? The Creator of man deigned to become man. He became what He Himself had made, so that the one whom He made might not perish. What can be added to this mercy? Yet He added still more.

It was not enough for Him to become man; He arranged to be rejected by men. It was not enough to be rejected by men; He arranged to be dishonored. It was not enough to be dishonored; He arranged to be killed. Yet even this was not enough: He accepted death on the cross.

When the Apostle spoke to us of His obedience even unto death, it was not enough for him to say, "being obedient unto death." Because it was not merely any death, he added: "even the death of the cross" (Phil 2:8).

Among all kinds of death, nothing was worse than this death. When the sharpest pains are inflicted, people speak of cruciatus, a torment whose name is derived from crux, the cross. Those hanging upon a wooden cross, with hands and feet nailed to the wood, died a slow death.

To be crucified is not simply to be killed. The one condemned to death on a cross remained alive on the cross for a long time. This was not because they wished to prolong his life, but because they prolonged the dying itself, so that the pain would not quickly end.

He wished to die for us, but this, as we have said, was not enough. He chose to be crucified, becoming obedient unto death, even the death of the Cross (Phil 2:8).

He Who intended to destroy every death chose an exceptional and the worst kind of death. By the worst death He slew every death. It was worst from the viewpoint of the Jews, who did not understand its mystery.

For it was not by chance that the Lord chose it. He intended to have this very cross as His sign. He intended to place this very cross, like a trophy over the conquered devil, upon the forehead of believers. Thus the Apostle would say: "But God forbid that I should boast, except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, by whom the world is crucified to me, and I to the world" (Gal 6:14).

At that time nothing was more unbearable to the flesh than the cross. Now nothing is more glorious upon the forehead. What does He leave to the one who believes in Him, if He has given such honor to the instrument of His execution?

Among the Romans the cross is no longer used for the execution of criminals. Where the Lord's cross is venerated, it has come to be thought that if a criminal were crucified, he would be honored.

Therefore He Who came for such a purpose judged no one, and endured even evil men. He endured an unjust judgment, so that later He might carry out a righteous one. But the unjust judgment He endured belonged to His mercy.

He humbled Himself so greatly that He ascended the cross. In doing so, He laid aside His power, yet revealed His mercy. Where is it seen that He laid aside His power? In this: He refused to come down from the cross, though He was able to rise from the tomb.

Where is it seen that He revealed His mercy? In this: while hanging on the cross, He said, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" (Lk 23:34).

Therefore He said, "I judge no one," either because He came not to judge the world, but to save the world, or, as I have already mentioned, because He had said. "You judge according to the flesh." He then added, "I judge no one," so that we might understand that Christ does not judge according to the flesh, as He was judged by men.

Maximus the Confessor

7th centuryChurch Father

How, in accordance with piety, are we to understand the words of the Gospel: “The Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son” (Jn 5:22)?

And why does the Lord say elsewhere, “I judge no one” (Jn 8:15), but “the word that I have spoken will judge him” (Jn 12:48)?

As God, neither the Father nor the Son will judge anyone. A man becomes a judge for men, not for animals.

The Father gave judgment to the Son, not because the Son is God, but because He became man. He will judge all by comparing His human life with ours.

His word will also judge, that is, the teaching He revealed through deeds, according to what is written: “what Jesus began both to do and to teach” (Acts 1:1).

Read more (82 words)

Compare St. Gregory the Theologian: “Christ puts our obedience to the test and measures everything by His sufferings, guided by the art of His love for mankind.

Thus, by His own experience He may know what is possible for us, how much should be required from us, and what should be forgiven us, if our weakness is considered amid sufferings” (Greg. Naz. or. 30.6: PG 36, 109C).

This passage will become the subject of St. Maximus’ interpretation in Difficulties to Thomas 4.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryChurch Father

“You judge according to the flesh,” that is, sensually and coarsely, paying attention only to what you see and understanding nothing lofty and spiritual.

Knowing that they might say, “Why then, if You can, do You not punish us who judge in this way?” Jesus Christ said, “I judge no one.”

That is, I do not judge now. Above, Jesus Christ said, “God did not send His Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world might be saved through Him” (Jn 3:17).

Read again the interpretation given there. And so that they would not say, “You say, ‘I do not judge,’ because You do not dare condemn us,” Jesus Christ adds, “Yet if I do judge, My judgment is true” (Jn 8:16).

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryChurch Father

The Pharisees dared to object to Him that His testimony about Himself was not true, precisely because He bore witness to Himself.

That is false, the Lord answered. My testimony can be true even in this case, for who on earth, besides Me, truly knows whence I came and whither I go? You do not know this. You judge Me only according to the flesh, by outward appearance, by what you see. It would be better for you not to judge Me, or concerning Me, just as I do not judge you.

Read more (93 words)

Yet this does not mean that I fear My judgment might be as mistaken as yours. No, My judgment is true, for I do not judge alone. The Father judges with Me. If you wish to judge Me, then it would be fitting for you to hear My witnesses. Your law requires two or three witnesses. I present two to you. The first witness is Myself. Here the divine nature of Jesus is clearly distinguished, bearing witness to what is accomplished through the mediation of His human nature. The second is My Father.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryChurch Father

From the fact that Jesus Christ bears witness of Himself, the Pharisees, looking at the matter from the formal side, conclude that His testimony has no significance for others and is even untrue.

Perhaps in this case they recall the Lord Christ’s own words (Jn 5:31). But then Jesus Christ intended to reveal the truth of His testimony on the basis of others’ witness concerning Him: John, His works, and God the Father.

Now He wished to reveal the truth of His self-testimony in Himself, absolutely. Therefore He first answers that even if He bears witness of Himself, His witness is true (Jn 8:14-15).

Then He says that in His testimony about Himself He has not remained alone, but that the Father also bears witness of Him (Jn 8:17-18).

Read more (206 words)

“If I bear witness of Myself, My witness is true, because I have the most perfect knowledge of Myself, My origin, My mission, and the purpose of My coming into the world.

I alone know this, and you do not know it and cannot know it by yourselves. Therefore you must receive the testimony concerning Me from Me Myself.

What you say about testimony does not apply to My self-testimony. It has significance only for earthly relations.

You judge according to the flesh, according to fleshly motives. Therefore your judgment is false in its very foundation, whether it is judgment about yourselves or about others.

Thus you judge Me to be an untrue witness about Myself, because you judge according to the flesh and strive to condemn.

But I judge no one, that is, I do not judge according to the flesh with the aim of condemning.

Yet if I do judge, whether about Myself or about others, My judgment is just, because it is at the same time the judgment of God the Father Himself.

Thus, in every judgment and testimony of Mine, there are two witnesses: I and the Father. And your law also recognizes the testimony of two as true” (Deut 17:6; 19:15).

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryChurch Father

“Even if I bear witness of Myself, My witness,” or, in another sense, My judgment, “is true,” Jesus said, “because I know where I came from and where I am going.

You judge according to My humanity, according to My flesh, and you regard Me only as a man. For this reason you err and demand from Me another testimony.

Yet My works should bring you to understanding, for through them My Father, who sent Me into the world, bears witness of Me.

Thus two bear witness of Me, I Myself and the Father. Even according to your law, the testimony of two is considered true.

But let it be as though I Myself bear witness of Myself. Even in that case My testimony is true, because I know that I came from God and am going to Him.

Read more (43 words)

Can such testimony be false? I judge no one, since I came to save sinners and not to judge.

But if I do judge concerning Myself, My judgment is true, because I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent Me.

Michail (Lusin)

19th centuryChurch Father

“You judge according to the flesh.” In the Pharisees’ objection there already lay a judgment concerning the Lord, and even a condemnation of Him.

By refusing to acknowledge His self-testimony, they thereby considered Him a mere man. Thus they judged Him according to the flesh, according to the lower side of His God-manhood, according to His form of a servant.

They did not recognize in Him their Messiah, “looking only at what was visible in Him and imagining nothing higher or spiritual,” as Euthymius Zigabenus says, with Theophylact.

They judged in this way according to the fleshly and sensual direction of their spirit (Jn 6:63). “As living according to the flesh means living wickedly, so judging according to the flesh means judging unjustly,” says Chrysostom.

Read more (106 words)

“I judge no one; and if I do judge,” and so forth. I do not judge by My will alone, separate from the Father, as you do.

I judge in accordance with the will of My Father and God. Therefore My judgment is righteous and true, unlike your judgment according to the flesh.

This is the same teaching that Christ had previously revealed when speaking of His unity with the Father (Jn 5:30).

The unstated conclusion flowing from these words is this. If He bears witness of Himself and speaks such a judgment concerning the Pharisees, then His testimony and His judgment are sure and true.

Philaret (Gumilevski)

19th centuryChurch Father

The Pharisees hastened to object to the Lord, but so unsuccessfully that, by repeating His words from Jn 5:31 and Jn 8:5 without understanding them correctly, they revealed their dullness of mind.

If the prophecies about the Messiah as the true light were fulfilled in Jesus, then it was no longer Jesus alone who testified about Jesus, but the whole choir of the Prophets.

At the same time, His testimony about Himself was true, since He knew whence and for what purpose He had come.

Only the soul knows what takes place in the soul. Inner and spiritual phenomena, changes, and events occurring in the depth of the spirit are known to self-consciousness alone (1 Cor 2:11).

Read more (224 words)

The enemies of Jesus demanded outside witnesses for events accessible only to self-consciousness, and did not understand what they were demanding.

They could have tested the testimony of self-consciousness by the witness of the prophets and by the life of Jesus. But for this, their mind and soul needed to be healthy.

They despised Jesus because they judged according to the flesh, according to the whims of a disordered soul.

In thoughts and desires they had sunk into the interests of earthly life alone. They sought only earthly happiness and expected only earthly glory.

For them, the Messiah of the prophets was only an earthly king, and the spiritual greatness of Jesus was inaccessible to their soul.

In such a state, what could they expect from themselves except falsehood, error, and sins?

The words, “I judge no one,” were completed either with the phrase “according to the flesh,” as Cyril of Alexandria says, or with the word “now,” as Chrysostom and Augustine say.

The first addition is justified by the context, while the latter cannot be reconciled with it.

In support of the testimony of His self-consciousness about Himself, the Savior says that in all cases and about all men He judges not according to the flesh, but according to the eternal laws of the spirit.

For this reason His judgments are true judgments.

Wlastow G.K.

19th centuryChurch Father

In the absence of faith, man is utterly powerless. He imagines that he can grasp everything with his limited mind, while he moves within the narrow sphere of his material sensations.

These sensations tend rather to separate him from the surrounding world and acquaint him with it only to the slightest degree. Even in his material life, he is separated from nature as though by an impenetrable wall.

The positivist Littré pointed this out, for sensations give the mind only signals, while the essence of things remains inaccessible to man.

What, then, can man understand and comprehend in the world of spiritual life if he acknowledges his own thought and his own knowledge as the only authority to which he will submit?

Read more (350 words)

The Lord wishes to transfer His listeners into a world of higher, not earthly, thought. He points out to them that only He Himself knows who He is, where He came from, and where He is going.

But the dull and self-confident Pharisees stubbornly refuse to follow the Lord. He warns them that they are mistaken, judging only according to the flesh.

There is a higher world, inaccessible to the human mind and accessible only to faith. This world is revealed in His words, which are filled with the Spirit of God.

But they are unable to understand the Lord. Crawling upon the earth, they cannot rise from petty human proofs to the soul’s understanding of the greatness of the Son of God’s teaching on love.

“I judge no one,” the Lord adds. “I came to save the world,” He had said.

The Lord forgave every insult and blasphemy against Himself, the Son of Man, because darkened people “judged according to the flesh.”

But there is a sin which, as the Lord said, will not be forgiven either in this age or in the age to come: blasphemy against the Holy Spirit.

The Lord said this to the same Pharisees (Mt 12:24, 28, 31-32), when they dared to utter an unspeakable blasphemy by attributing the source of grace to the realm of darkness.

So long as the Pharisees saw in the Lord Jesus only a man, and a poor man at that, whose kinship they reproached, the Lord forgave everything.

So long as they disputed with Him, or even, as here, reproached Him because He bore witness of Himself, He forgave everything: “I judge no one.”

But when they not only failed to strive to receive and understand the words and deeds performed by the Spirit of God, but also blasphemed them with dreadful words, they closed to themselves forever the path to salvation.

Those were the deeds and words of God’s mercy, love, all-forgiveness, and wisdom, which saved the world. The following verse points to the coming judgment, which will take place after the Lord’s departure from the earth.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 9 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Ὑμεῖς
    hymeis
    you
    G4771 · σύ
  2. κατὰ
    kata
    down from
    G2596 · κατά
  3. τὴν
    tēn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  4. σάρκα
    sarka
    flesh
    G4561 · σάρξ
  5. κρίνετε
    krinete
    I judge
    G2919 · κρίνω
  6. ἐγὼ
    egō
    I
    G1473 · ἐγώ
  7. οὐ
    ou
    no
    G3756 · οὐ
  8. κρίνω
    krinō
    I judge
    G2919 · κρίνω
  9. οὐδένα
    oudena
    no one
    G3762 · οὐδείς