The Church Fathers on this verse

Luke 6:43Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

For there is no good tree that bringeth forth evil fruit: nor an evil tree that bringeth forth good fruit.

Douay-Rheims

ου γαρ εστιν δενδρον καλον ποιουν καρπον σαπρον ουδε δενδρον σαπρον ποιουν καρπον καλον

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

9 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 10 commentaries

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

He reinforces His message with an illustration. He states that just as a healthy tree cannot produce bad fruit, and a bad tree cannot yield good fruit, similarly, one who seeks to impart wisdom, to transform and elevate others, must not be corrupt themselves; if they are corrupt, they cannot improve others. Therefore, He questions, how can you Pharisees, being corrupt trees, produce good fruit?

Cyrill of Alexandria

5th centuryChurch Father

In this context, Christ instructs that individuals should not be judged by their outward appearance but rather by their intrinsic truth. He emphasizes that the identity of a tree is revealed by the fruit it produces (Luke 6:44). It is as foolish to search for choice fruits like grapes or figs among thorns as it is to expect the presence of genuine virtue among hypocrites and wicked individuals. Just as a good person draws from the good stored in their heart to produce good (Luke 6:45, Matthew 12:35), a person who harbors vices and deceit will inevitably reveal what lies within. The thoughts and feelings of the heart manifest in spoken words. Thus, a person with a virtuous character expresses words that reflect their nature, while the corrupt will inevitably bring forth the impurities that reside within.

I can envision someone asking, "How can we identify someone who has a beam in their eye yet remains unaware of the speck and is merely somewhat weak?" The answer is straightforward, as He reveals that anyone willing can easily discern the truth: "for no good tree bears bad fruit, nor does a bad tree bear good fruit; for each tree is recognized by its own fruit." Therefore, the true essence of each individual shapes their morality: the splendor of a genuinely virtuous life is not defined by superficial decoration and false ideals, but by one’s actions. These actions are the results of a heart that, moved by a deep love for righteousness, opts for a pure existence. Hence, it is by our deeds, rather than mere appearances, that we must evaluate who is genuinely worthy and who is not.

Read more (42 words)

Furthermore, Christ warns us, "Beware of those who come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravenous wolves." This indicates that Christ instructs us to differentiate those who approach us, not by their outward attire, but by their true nature.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

The journey towards virtue is challenging; thus, one should not expect to harvest from barren ground or anticipate an abundant yield from land that has not been tended. The toil of cultivation yields fruit for all, yet the thorns of this world cannot produce the figs that symbolize resurrection—either due to their abundance or as indicated by the scripture where it states the fig tree bears its fruit immaturely (Song 2:13). In the synagogue, this fruit appears premature, ineffectual, and prone to fall, possibly due to our life in the flesh being incomplete, while that which has reached its fullness comes with resurrection. We must distance ourselves from the earthly distractions that torment the soul and consume the mind so that we might obtain mature fruit through diligent cultivation.

Read more (121 words)

Such a harvest cannot arise from the unplanted fields of this world, for figs do not grow on thorns, nor grapes on bushes (Luke 6:44). The first speaks to this life and the resurrection, while the latter connects to the soul and body; we cannot gather nourishment for our souls through sin, which corrupts the vine on earth and brings it to ripeness above, or only those whom Christ has redeemed—much like a vine affixed to the tree of the Cross—can break free from the bondage of the flesh. Indeed, it is decreed that thorns be borne by the condemned (see Genesis 3:18). Therefore, let us elevate our spiritual vision and extend our hands to harvest the fruit of Christ’s vine.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

A good tree does not produce bad fruit, nor does a bad tree yield good fruit, for each tree is recognized by its fruit. Likewise, it refers to those who lead others astray. Here, it addresses those who are cleansed and purify others, as well as those who are impure yet attempt to cleanse others. He metaphorically refers to them as trees, with their deeds being the fruits. He encourages us to focus on their actions, which are the fruits, rather than their words, which are akin to leaves. For one does not gather figs from thornbushes, nor do they harvest grapes from brambles. It is likewise futile to seek good from such individuals; He reinforces His point by way of example. Just as unnatural and impossible circumstances yield nothing worthwhile, so too is this situation.

Beda Venerabilis

7th centuryChurch Father

A tree that does not produce fruit will be removed and cast into the fire (Matt. 3:10). In this parable, people are likened to trees and their deeds to fruit. Are you curious about what constitutes a bad tree and its unworthy fruit? The apostle instructs us on this matter. He declares, "The works of the flesh are evident; they are: adultery, fornication, impurity, sensuality, idolatry, sorcery, enmity, strife, jealousy, anger, rivalries, dissensions, divisions, envy, drunkenness, orgies, and things like these" (Gal. 5:19-21). Would you like to ascertain if trees that produce such fruit have a place in the divine kingdom of the eternal King? The apostle warns, “I forewarn you, as I forewarned you before, that those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God” (Gal. 5:21). He then lists the characteristics of a good tree. He states, “But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control” (Gal. 5:22-23).

Tichon of Zadonsk

18th centuryChurch Father

A spiritually mature Christian can be likened to a healthy tree. Just as a fruitful tree springs from quality seed, a faithful disciple is born of God’s Word, the pure and eternal seed, as stated in Scripture: ‘They that are born again are not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, of the word of God, which liveth and abideth forever’ (1 Pet. 1:23). The quality of a tree is recognized by its fruit. Similarly, a true Christian is discerned by their righteous actions. A healthy tree produces good fruit from within, just as a devout believer performs good works that flow genuinely from the heart, free of deceit. A tree does not create good fruit; it merely displays it. Likewise, while good actions reflect a faithful Christian, they do not transform them into one.

Read more (709 words)

The essence of the tree must be pure first to yield quality fruit since a corrupt tree cannot produce good fruit (Matthew 7:17-18; Luke 6:43). In parallel, a Christian must first undergo true transformation before producing righteous deeds, for the unrighteous are incapable of goodness. A fruitful tree benefits its owner and others. In the same way, a faithful believer engages in good works for God's glory and the benefit of their neighbors. The good fruit demonstrates the tree’s condition but is not credited to the tree itself; rather, it comes from the excellent seed from which the tree emerged. Similarly, while a devout Christian performs virtuous acts, it is ultimately God's goodness that ought to be acknowledged, as He is the one who planted the good seed in our hearts, nurturing and empowering us to act virtuously. Apart from God, it is impossible to achieve goodness or perform good works, as the Lord stated: ‘Without Me you can do nothing’ (John 15:5). Just as a well-tended tree yields more fruit, a Christian who endures divine discipline and correction grows in goodness and produces even more good works (John 15:1-2). A healthy tree shares its fruit with everyone, both friends and strangers. Likewise, a faithful Christian extends kindness to all—whether they are friends or foes—emulating the Heavenly Father, who ‘commands His sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the just and the unjust’ (Matthew 5:45). Their home welcomes all travelers, and they ensure that every hungry person is nourished. They do not turn away someone in need of clothing if they have the means to help. They readily assist those who are suffering, sharing in their woes. They offer comfort to the grieving and strive to heal broken hearts. They rejoice with those who have good fortune, celebrating as if it were their own. They diligently seek God's favor for others as they do for themselves, wishing for everyone's salvation. If they had the resources, they would assist all in need. When witnessing a brother in sin, their response is not judgment but compassion. These traits exemplify the fruits produced by a healthy tree!

Christian, strive for goodness, and your actions will follow. To cultivate goodness, one must: 1) wholeheartedly turn to God in genuine repentance, as this is the crucial foundation for goodness. 2) attentively read God's Word and other Christian literature, reflecting on it diligently, for ‘All Scripture is divinely inspired and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be perfect, prepared for every good work’ (2 Tim. 3:16-17). 3) endeavor to comprehend the depravity and corruption that resides within one’s heart. This understanding fosters humility and a desire for self-correction. Recognizing one’s own weakness is the first step toward healing; acknowledging one’s own fallibility is essential for repentance. Who, seeing the deadly poison within, would not seek to rid themselves of it? Knowledge of oneself begins the journey towards salvation. Know yourself, O person, and approach God with acknowledgment of your need for repentance. Entrust yourself to Christ, much like a sick person relies on a physician, and He will heal you. 4) Exercise caution against every sin and diligently pursue every good action, even if your heart is reluctant. The Lord observes such earnest efforts and grants mercy to those striving toward goodness, progressively refining them. A weak individual desires healing and avoids actions that the healer forbids, no matter how tempting. Likewise, a believer must carefully avoid all that the Divine Healer, Christ, prohibits, else they cannot expect healing. 5) Pray fervently for Christ’s guidance and correction, as He has cleansed the lepers, restored sight to the blind, and healed the afflicted. He will also restore our immortal souls if we seek Him wholeheartedly, following His promise: ‘Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you; for everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened’ (Matthew 7:7-8). ‘Turn me, O Lord, and I will be turned..... Heal me, O Lord, and I will be healed’ (Jer. 31:18, 17:14), for without Him, conversion and healing are unattainable.

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryCommentator

In summary, the Lord instructed that in times of need we should consistently approach God through prayer, adhering to the principle that our love for our neighbors should reflect our love for ourselves. We are to continually cultivate a path of righteousness, remain vigilant against false prophets, and practice what we have learned. By establishing these life principles for His followers, the Lord highlighted the fundamental differences between their righteousness and that of the Pharisees, building a solid foundation for the spiritual formation of His chosen community.

Read more (236 words)

These teachings were not only relevant for that era or specific individuals but were intended to be a guiding law for all His disciples, grounded in the eternal truths of Divine holiness and the moral laws embedded within human nature by the Creator. The chosen ones had received little formal instruction before; some had been with John the Baptist, like Andrew and John. The Lord selected those who demonstrated their love and trust in Him, pure like children and free from the allure of misguided knowledge. He began to educate them, guiding them through His words and actions, both in private and in public, on land and at sea. He clarified what was obscure to others, making them witnesses to His life and works. He gradually dismantled the misconceptions stemming from Jewish teachings, using their misunderstandings as teaching moments. He allowed them to engage in discussions on topics within their understanding, while subtly revealing that He was aware not only of their chatter but also of the innermost thoughts of humanity. He tempered their emotional responses and aligned them with their responsibilities. In essence, He refined and illuminated their hearts and minds, preparing them for the profound outpouring of the Spirit of truth and sanctification. Initially, they related to Him as disciples; by the end of His earthly ministry, He referred to them as friends (Jn. 15:14-15), having shared all with them, and ultimately as brothers.

Bogolepow D.P.

19th centuryCommentator

The passage from verses 21 to 23 serves as a bridge from the discussion on false prophets to an urgent final appeal. In this transitional segment, the importance of not only heeding the words of Christ but also embodying them is made clear. Merely identifying oneself as a Christian does not guarantee divine favor. Many who claim to act in Christ’s name for the benefit of others may experience the workings of divine power, including prophecy and miraculous deeds, particularly the expulsion of evil spirits. Yet, at the Last Judgment, even they may hear the Lord declare, "I have never known you," indicating a lack of true relationship.

Read more (226 words)

In Luke, the concluding remarks commence in verse 39, presenting notions that appear in a different context in Matthew. Matthew offers a distinct connection and application of these teachings. When examining these passages in the light of the surrounding context in Luke, the message can be articulated as follows: you, my closest followers, are called to be lights and guides to the world, instilling the truths you are currently receiving from me into the hearts of others. However, to be effective in this mission and to illuminate others with the Gospel, you must first address your own spiritual blindness—after all, can the blind lead the blind? The former teachers from the Pharisees are examples of such blind guides. You should no longer emulate them or follow their harmful ways. Since a disciple is not above his master, you cannot bring light to the world unless you yourselves first bask in the light of truth and righteousness.

Therefore, begin by removing the flaws in your own vision and avoid the hypocrisy of focusing on the minor faults of others while ignoring your own significant shortcomings. Bear good fruit, and ensure that your confession is not merely verbal but reflected in your actions. He who truly heeds my teachings resembles a wise builder who constructs his house on a solid foundation, ensuring that it remains secure against destruction.

Paul Matwejewski

19th centuryCommentator

The path to salvation, while requiring careful navigation due to its challenging circumstances, also poses the risk of temptation and avoidance. Consequently, the Lord cautioned His disciples about false teachers by illustrating the signs that would reveal them: Beware of false prophets, who appear to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves. The sheep's clothing symbolizes a façade of humility and gentleness that deceitful individuals use to mislead and harm those who are unsuspecting. Their true nature is discerned by their fruits, meaning the deeds they produce: From their fruits you shall know them; can one gather grapes from thorns or figs from thistles? Every good tree yields good fruit, and every bad tree bears bad fruit; a good tree cannot produce bad fruit, nor can a bad tree yield good fruit...

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 15 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. Οὐ
    ou
    no
    G3756 · οὐ
  2. γάρ
    gar
    for
    G1063 · γάρ
  3. ἐστιν
    estin
    I am
    G1510 · εἰμί
  4. δένδρον
    dendron
    a tree
    G1186 · δένδρον
  5. καλὸν
    kalon
    beautiful
    G2570 · καλός
  6. ποιοῦν
    poioun
    I do
    G4160 · ποιέω
  7. καρπὸν
    karpon
    fruit
    G2590 · καρπός
  8. σαπρόν
    sapron
    rotten
    G4550 · σαπρός
  9. οὐδὲ
    oude
    neither
    G3761 · οὐδέ
  10. πάλιν
    palin
    again
    G3825 · πάλιν
  11. δένδρον
    dendron
    a tree
    G1186 · δένδρον
  12. σαπρὸν
    sapron
    rotten
    G4550 · σαπρός
  13. ποιοῦν
    poioun
    I do
    G4160 · ποιέω
  14. καρπὸν
    karpon
    fruit
    G2590 · καρπός
  15. καλόν
    kalon
    beautiful
    G2570 · καλός