The Church Fathers on this verse

Mark 6:43Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And they took up the leavings, twelve full baskets of fragments, and of the fishes.

Douay-Rheims

και ηραν κλασματων δωδεκα κοφινους πληρεις και απο των ιχθυων

Greek (Byzantine text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

6 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Theophylact of Bulgaria

11th centuryChurch Father

The fact that such a large crowd not only received nourishment but also had leftovers demonstrates the extraordinary might of Christ. In contrast to Moses, who provided manna only sufficient for each individual's requirement, resulting in decay, and Elijah, who offered just enough sustenance when aiding a widow, Jesus, as the King, supplies an abundance that surpasses need. This represents the historical aspect. Symbolically, the five loaves represent the Pentateuch, comprising five books: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. The two fish symbolize the messages of those called, particularly the Apostle and the Gospel. The multitude of five thousand reflects our five senses.

Read more (50 words)

However, while we cannot fully partake in everything, there remains a significant surplus that only the apostles can manage. Therefore, we, who remain subject to our physical senses, find it challenging to grasp the profound truths of the Law and the Gospel, a capacity that belongs solely to the apostles.

Prudentius

5th centuryChurch Father

The meal has concluded, leaving behind an abundance of leftovers, with twelve baskets brimming full. The guest who indulged too much now finds discomfort, while his friend beside him expresses concern. Who turns the modest repast into a grand banquet? Is it not the One who formed flesh and nourishment, bringing them into being from nothing, as He did with the entire universe? Unlike an artisan who shapes lifeless materials into animated forms, the Almighty Creator crafted the cosmos from nothing, commanding existence itself into reality. The universe emerged at His word, manifesting and expanding from the smallest beginnings.

Read more (59 words)

When I witness Christ’s hands multiplying provisions, I am assured that these simple elements, created from nothing, gradually developed into the magnificent forms we observe. To ensure that nothing from this feast falls prey to the wolf, the fox, or the mouse—since there is no sentinel present—the twelve disciples generously fill the baskets with the gifts bestowed by Christ.

Dimitri of Rostov

17th centuryChurch Father

The Gospel we hear during the Divine Liturgy serves as a profound spiritual feast, recalling the miracle performed by our Lord Jesus Christ when He fed five thousand individuals using only five loaves and two fish. This miracle was executed with such abundance that all who came were satisfied, leaving twelve full baskets of leftovers (Matthew 14:20). Just as the apostles gathered the surplus pieces, I, a humble sinner, seek to share with you small morsels of divine wisdom from this Gospel, akin to the leftovers, as I present them to your ears, ‘to the Lord who works with and confirms the word’ (Mark 16:20).

Read more (1745 words)

In that moment, Jesus observed the crowd and felt compassion for them (Matthew 14:14). This occurrence took place after news reached Him of John the Baptist’s unjust murder by Herod. Upon hearing this tragic news, He withdrew to a desolate place, as His time for voluntary suffering had not yet arrived. ‘And when the multitudes had heard of it, they followed Him from the cities. And when He saw the throngs, He had compassion on them’ (Matthew 14:13, 14). Those who earnestly sought Him, leaving their towns to follow Him into the wilderness, were undoubtedly worthy of His mercy. Anyone who truly seeks Christ will find Him; those who pursue Him will receive His grace. A close walk with Christ brings the fullness of His blessings, akin to being well-fed.

Many of us, however, desire to find Christ but lack the initiative to seek Him earnestly. We long for His mercy yet wish to receive His gifts without effort. If we are idle, we wish for glory; without work, we want richness; in sloth, we desire heaven; in sin, we seek righteousness; engaging in misdeeds, we hope to be comforted alongside the righteous; indulging in fleeting pleasures of sin, we expect everlasting joy. Oh, misguided aspirations! These desires lack substance. The people mentioned in the Gospel were recipients of Christ’s mercy because they sought Him diligently: ‘Jesus observed the multitude and was filled with compassion’ (Matthew 14:14). They were granted mercy through their earnest effort rather than through laziness. They fed their bodies with the miraculous bread multiplied by Christ after first nourishing their souls with His divine words; as soon as they received the bread for their stomachs, they had already filled their hearts with His teachings.

It is beautifully stated, ‘Seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things shall be added unto you’ (Matthew 6:33). When you labor diligently for Christ, you shall not experience poverty or hunger: ‘Your heavenly Father knows what you need’ (Matthew 6:32). ‘We have here but five loaves’ (Matthew 14:17). It is remarkable to consider that among such a vast crowd, which included many thousands of men with their families, only one lad possessed bread, as noted in John’s Gospel: ‘There is a boy here who has five barley loaves’ (John 6:9). Why did no one else bring bread? Perhaps because they had eaten it before they departed from home. Yet remarkably, they did not abandon Christ; their hunger propelled them to follow Him, prioritizing the nourishment of their souls over their physical needs. The Scripture accurately states, ‘Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God’ (Matthew 4:4).

The zeal for hearing God's word among that crowd was inspiring. They neglected their daily concerns to journey far into the wilderness with their families, fasting not merely until noon but into the evening. They were so consumed with the desire to hear the words of Christ that they disregarded their physical hunger. Their fervor for spiritual enrichment stands in stark contrast to the apathy we often exhibit today, neglecting the words of God and disregarding the care for our own souls. The fervent seekers of old will judge us at the last judgment, as they dedicated their days to the teachings of Christ, while we find it challenging to remain focused even for short periods in prayer.

They pursued Christ from a distance and went into the wilderness, while we find it difficult to attend service even with our churches nearby. They approached Him without needing an invitation, while we often require the call of bells to stir us. Their faith prompted them to seek Him without fully realizing His divine nature, believing Him only to be a prophet; while we, with full knowledge of Christ’s true divinity, frequently show little zeal.

It is important to reflect on the significant multitude that followed Christ, while their leaders—the scribes and Pharisees—stayed in their homes in Jerusalem. The powerful showed no belief in Him, as the Scripture states, ‘Which of the rulers believes in Him?’ (John 7:48). They indulged in vanity while the wealthy were preoccupied with their businesses; some built larger barns, while others hoarded riches, finding little time to heed Christ’s teachings. Only the humble sought Him, listening with joy to what He had to say. Thus, it is indeed challenging for the wealthy to enter the kingdom of heaven: ‘It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of God’ (Matthew 19:24).

Let us also consider who carried the loaves. It was the young boy, as noted in John's Gospel: ‘There is a boy here who has five barley loaves.’ While many men had no bread, one boy bore it, suggesting the loaves were small enough for him to carry. Upon taking the loaves from the boy, Christ multiplied them to feed the multitude. In this, we find a significant representation. The boy symbolizes the monastic life; in Greek, ‘monasticism’ derives from ‘monos,’ meaning solitary or secluded. This pure virgin boy represents monastic purity, which is foundational to the monastic vow. The loaves symbolize the prayers of monastics, both day and night. Just as the Lord fed the people with the loaves from the young boy, so too do the prayers of monastics sustain the world.

Though the five loaves of that boy were few, they miraculously fed thousands; likewise, monastic prayers, seemingly small, fortify the entire world. The Christian community is likened to a vineyard, as noted by the prophet Isaiah about Israel, ‘The vineyard of the Lord of hosts is the house of Israel’ (Isaiah 5:7). Who does not appreciate the beauty of a vineyard, with its splendid branches, lovely leaves, and delightful clusters? Similarly, how beautiful the body of Christ is, rich in blessings, flourishing in faithfulness, and exultant in praise, as described by David: ‘The mountains are covered with its shadow, and its boughs are like noble cedars; its branches go to the sea, and the rivers embrace its roots’ (Psalm 79:11, 12).

However, let us observe what nourishes this vine. It relies solely upon the dry and barren stake. Remove the stake from the vine, and the branch falls and withers. Without the monastic order, the body of Christ would wither away, similar to a branch deprived of its support. Reflect on this: as the boy's loaves nourished thousands, so do the prayers of the monastics benefit many. Yet, to avoid extolling monasticism excessively and moving away from the core of the Gospel, let us return to the original theme of the loaves; ‘We have only five loaves’ (Matthew 14:17).

What sort of bread were they? Rye, wheat, or another variety? The Holy Evangelist John reveals that they were barley loaves: ‘There is a boy here who has five barley loaves’ (John 6:9). Notably, those who followed Christ consumed not fine wheat bread but barley bread. Let this barley bread symbolize the essence of self-denial, fasts, and a disciplined life, for barley represents a rigorous journey. Nothing fortifies a follower of Christ against the unseen adversary like the sustenance of holy fasting and abstention.

Let us remember the account of Gideon’s battle against the Midianites. The Israelites, oppressed by the Midianites, cried out to God for help. God answered their plea by providing them with Gideon, a strong leader who rallied them to fight. The Lord instructed Gideon to minimize his forces, selecting only the best soldiers. To discern who was worthy, Gideon led them to the water to drink. Those who drank like dogs were set apart from those who cupped water in their hands to drink. Ultimately, only three hundred men exhibited the latter behavior. God proclaimed He would deliver Midian through these three hundred.

As Gideon approached the Midianite camp under the cloak of night, he overheard a soldier recount a dream: ‘As if a loaf of barley bread tumbled into our camp, striking our tent so that it fell down’ (Judges 7:13). This soldier acknowledged the significance of the dream as a forewarning of defeat for the Midianites at Gideon’s hands. This dream bears a profound meaning; the barley loaf symbolizes the strength that comes from a disciplined life. The unbaked barley dough, without flavor, signifies the essence of fasting—denoting a consumption devoid of excess, which ultimately empowers one to combat adversities.

Saint Hilarion the Great once addressed his body, insisting, ‘I will not feed you, donkey, with barley, but with clay’ reflecting the austere nourishment preferred by the ascetics. Just as the dough transforms into a weapon against one’s enemies, so too does disciplined living yield strength. Look to Samson’s deeds: noted for defeating a thousand Philistines with a simple jawbone, his feats derived from the vows of abstinence upheld by his mother during her pregnancy. Saint Basil the Great articulates, ‘What made Samson invincible? Was it not fasting, which began even before his birth? Abstinence births strength for triumph over foes.’

The saints of old achieved remarkable victories through the same principle of fasting and moderation. They overcame formidable adversaries with divine empowerment drawn from their disciplined lives. In contrast, nothing weakens the soul quicker than gluttony and indulgence. The Scriptures recount how King Nebuchadnezzar, after conquering Jerusalem, dispatched a chief cook to ravage the city. This act serves as a metaphor for how excess and appetites lead to one’s ruin, paralleling the disintegration of Jerusalem’s glory under the archimagir.

In conclusion, we understand that the Lord chose not to feed those who followed Him with sweet bread but with the firm sustenance of barley bread. From this, He instructs us on the virtues of moderation rather than indulgence. ‘We are here but five loaves,’ signifies the spiritual edification available to us through various forms of divine nourishment. Some regard the word of God as bread, echoing the lament of Amos regarding famine for God’s word (Amos 8:11). Others celebrate repentance as a nourishing force, as expressed in the Psalms (Psalm 101:10). Charitable acts toward the less fortunate also serve as forms of spiritual sustenance (Ecclesiastes 11:1). Ultimately, the body of Christ, which we partake in through the Eucharist, stands as the supreme nourishment for our souls.

Let us partake in these spiritual loaves, growing rich in grace and spirit, and may our souls be filled to abundance with eternal joy in heaven alongside all the saints. Amen.

Alexander Gorsky

19th centuryCommentator

The Lord showed deep compassion, providing five loaves and two fish to nourish five thousand listeners through His abundant grace, resulting in each apostle gathering a basket of leftovers. This event echoed the manna provided in the desert and other miracles from the Old Testament. The crowd, astonished by such a wonder, recognized Him as the prophet foretold by Moses and desired to make Jesus their king. However, He retreated to the mountain to pray alone, instructing His disciples to return across the water without Him. Consequently, the people were left without the fulfillment of their desires.

Gladkow B.I.

19th centuryCommentator

When Jesus instructed them to gather the remaining pieces of bread, they collected twelve baskets. These baskets, used by Jews during their travels, were preferred over bags for carrying provisions. Regardless of their size, it would have been unfeasible to fill the twelve baskets with just five loaves of bread broken into fragments without a miraculous multiplication of the pieces. The crowd's eagerness to declare Jesus as their king showcased a wondrous act that captivated the attention of thousands. This miracle was not only witnessed but also profoundly felt, leaving no room for doubt. The impact it had on those surrounding Jesus was immense, leading them to exclaim, ‘This is truly the Prophet who is to come into the world’ (John 6:14), referring to the Messiah.

Lopuchin A.P.

19th centuryCommentator

After everyone had their fill, Christ aimed not only to reveal the true nature of the miracle that had occurred but also to teach His disciples that even miraculous abundance should not be squandered, as it was contrary to divine stewardship. He instructed them to collect the leftover pieces so that nothing would be wasted. Due to the proper arrangement of those gathered, it was evident that approximately five thousand men were nourished, excluding women and children, and remarkably, twelve baskets were filled with the uneaten fragments.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.

The original text

Greek text, 10 words with lemma, transliteration and Strong’s number. Tap to expand.

  1. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  2. ἦραν
    ēran
    I raise
    G142 · αἴρω
  3. κλάσματα
    klasmata
    a fragment
    G2801 · κλάσμα
  4. δώδεκα
    dōdeka
    twelve
    G1427 · δώδεκα
  5. κοφίνων
    kophinōn
    a large basket
    G2894 · κόφινος
  6. πληρώματα
    plērōmata
    fullness
    G4138 · πλήρωμα
  7. καὶ
    kai
    and
    G2532 · καί
  8. ἀπὸ
    apo
    from
    G575 · ἀπό
  9. τῶν
    tōn
    the
    G3588 · ὁ
  10. ἰχθύων
    ichthyōn
    a fish
    G2486 · ἰχθύς