The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 30 (29):10Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

What profit is there in my blood, whilst I go down to corruption? Shall dust confess to thee, or declare thy truth?

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

מַה־בֶּ֥צַע בְּדָמִי֮ בְּרִדְתִּ֢י אֶ֫ל־שָׁ֥חַת הֲיוֹדְךָ֥ עָפָ֑ר הֲיַגִּ֥יד אֲמִתֶּֽךָ׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

10 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 11 commentaries

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

If I am not raised immediately and My body perishes, will the dust give You praise? In other words, will the multitude of the unrighteous, whom I will redeem through My resurrection, acknowledge Your righteousness? Or will they proclaim Your truth? Or will Your truth be declared for the salvation of others?

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

What purpose does my blood serve when I descend into decay? For what reason, He questions, have I cried out? For what have I sought You, my Lord and my God? What benefit is there in the welfare of the flesh and in the abundance of blood, when, if it remains unspoiled, it will ultimately be handed over to the inevitable decay of the body? Yet I discipline my body and bring it into submission, lest, when the blood within me is strong and fervent, my goodness become a cause for sin. Do not indulge the flesh with sleep, baths, and luxurious beds, continually reminding yourself: What good is my blood when I go down to decay? Why do you concern yourself with that which is destined to perish soon? Why do you afflict yourself and encumber yourself with the flesh?

Read more (95 words)

Do you not realize that the more you weaken your flesh, the heavier the prison you create for your soul? Food will confess to Your righteousness; or it will proclaim Your truth. How shall the carnal man give You praise, O God? How can one who has not dedicated himself to understanding, whose mind is weighed down by the flesh, declare the truth? Therefore, I withhold sustenance from my body and do not hesitate to deprive the blood that typically nourishes the flesh, so that I may be free to confess and comprehend the truth.

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

I cry out to You, O Lord. What good is my lifeblood if I descend into the grave? I implore You to lift me from the pit, for I have not confessed my transgressions to You. There is no benefit in my descent into the grave, neither for myself nor for others. You take away my life, and others shall find no salvation through me. But if You hear my plea, transform my sorrow into joy, and surround me with gladness, it will be greatly beneficial for me. Having restored my former dignity, I will call out to You in glory, untainted by guilt. This reflects the meaning of the Scripture: "I will not relent."

Gain or detriment? The Lord was crucified so that through His blood He might eradicate death. Thus, in a well-known passage, He rightly admonishes those who partook in the spilling of His blood in vain, for they failed to partake in the essence of the Word: "What profit is there in my blood, when I must decay?" The Lord’s descent was far from fruitless; rather, it brought benefit to the entire world. Therefore, after enduring such afflictions, what should sinners choose: detriment or benefit? Nevertheless, He regards our redemption as His own gain, while our condemnation reflects our loss. He desires that the grace we receive does not go to waste, but that we actively return its fruits, as the Apostle Paul teaches: "But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace" (Galatians 5:22).

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

The Judge and the Advocate

Do not be afraid that the Judge will be overly severe. Consider who your Judge truly is. The Father has entrusted all judgment to Christ (John 5:22), but can He condemn one whom He has delivered from death, for whom He has sacrificed Himself, and whose life He recognizes as the cost of His own suffering? He asks, What value is there in my blood if I condemn the one I have redeemed? You perceive Him as Judge, yet fail to recognize Him as Advocate. Can He, who continually pleads for the grace of reconciliation with the Father, issue a harsh verdict?

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

These sentiments were echoed by the revered Hezekiah, as noted in the fourth book of Kings and the prophecy of the holy Isaiah (Isaiah 38:18). Even if not all of humanity voiced them, the saints certainly called out to God with these same affirmations, for it is fitting to offer praise to You, the Creator, and to express gratitude with heartfelt words. However, such expressions belong to the living; those who have turned to dust and ashes and are unable to labor physically—how could they proclaim Your goodness?

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

What significance does my blood hold as I descend into decay? Here, he refers to blood as flesh since flesh is merely blood in a denser form. He questions the purpose of his flesh, so burdened and deteriorating, once faced with the inevitability of decay in the grave. It would have been preferable not to have been born at all. In these statements, David diminishes the human body’s nature as frail and transient, echoing his observation that 'Man is compared to vanity' (Psalm 143:5). Basil the Great advises against indulging the body with excessive rest, luxuries, and comfortable living, urging a constant repetition of the sentiment: What benefit is there in my blood when I am destined for decay? What is the worth of gratifying that which is subject to the ravages of time?

Read more (294 words)

What gain is there in self-denial or seeking comfort? Do we not realize that by indulging the flesh, we merely fortify a prison for our souls? Isidore of Pelusiot notes that while the Saviour accomplished great good by offering His soul as a ransom for many, for those still ensnared in wickedness and corruption, the Saviour's entry into mortality, representing the myriad aspects of human nature and the death to which we are all bound, appears to have no benefit. Therefore, to them, the query stands, What value is my blood? Origen echoes this sentiment, questioning whether the dead can offer praise to Thee or declare Thy truth. This resonates with another declaration: the dead cannot praise Thee, O Lord, nor those who descend into the pit, but we who live shall bless the Lord (Psalm 113:25, 26). David, confident in God’s patience and mercy, poses the question, ‘Will the dust and ashes, to which I will soon be reduced due to the trials I face, bring glory to You, O Lord? Can the dust of those who disregard Your existence and Godhead glorify You? For You are indeed the true God, unlike the false gods of the nations; You are the true God because You fulfill every promise made. Therefore, it is far better for me to live, not merely for my own sake, but to honor You, my God, to give thanks to You, and to declare Your truth to those who remain unaware. Theodoret articulates that it is just to sing to Thee, our Creator, and to express gratitude for Your gifts with heartfelt words. This privilege belongs solely to the living; for those who have turned to dust and lost their earthly forms, how can they laud Your wondrous deeds?

Isidore of Pelusium

5th centuryChurch Father

Love is fading away—fading, indeed, the most noble, magnificent, and splendid quality, for which the prophetic visage foretold, for which the Redeemer came to dwell among us, and for which the Apostles boldly proclaimed, ultimately sealing their testimony with their own lives. In our self-absorption, we neglect the common adversary, turning our weapons against one another, creating a perilous situation where, though he has been decisively defeated, he may yet reenter the fray and prevail. Despite his fall and his misguided confidence, our apathy and our conflicts serve as a stronghold for our vanquished foe, placing at risk the redemptive work of our Savior—however audacious it may seem to assert this.

Read more (162 words)

The very essence of this concern, which you seek to understand, was foreseen by the Psalmist when he declared, "What use is my blood, when I go down into decay," referring to the fallen human condition? Whether he speaks of David in a moral sense or Adam in a natural sense, as many saints suggest, his intention is clear: he condescended so greatly that many would still refuse to believe in Him. I have vanquished the tormentor, and the watchful Seraphim proclaim, "Learn ye truth, ye that dwell on the earth: for the wicked is passed away" (Isaiah 26:9, 10). Yet, it is your own negligence that betrays this extraordinary, supernatural merit, erasing this triumphant legacy that exceeds every miracle. Therefore, what will you have left? What justification will you possess? What mercy or favor remains for you when this life is demanded of you, which, as I observe, is found solely within the Scriptures and is not truly observable anywhere else?

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

In the earlier verse, the distinction between the seasons of wrath and life, sorrow and joy, is established generally, and here it is explored in a more specific manner. By reflecting on his own experience, he illustrates that his grief, resulting from misplaced trust in earthly joy, was fleeting and eventually faded. This seemingly refers to the period following David's victory over the Philistine Goliath, as recounted in the first book of Kings, chapter 18. During this time, he was favored by the king, the king's son, and the people, swiftly rising to become both the commander and son-in-law to the king.

Read more (242 words)

He declared, “But I said in my abundance, I will not be moved for ever.” This suggests that there was a moment when, following the defeat of his adversaries who had oppressed Israel, he experienced great joy, flourishing in wealth and honor; in this period, he believed his fortune would remain unshaken. This illusion stemmed from his own self-love, as he wrongly attributed his success solely to his own abilities, failing to recognize that it was the Lord's benevolence that empowered him. Yet, this joy did not last long. When the Lord withdrew His presence, I found myself suddenly stripped of His favor, facing the king's animosity, leaving me in distress. From this situation, I faced exile, flight, the threat of death, and numerous tribulations. However, in my moments of hardship and turmoil, I cried out to the Lord. I even considered that if my enemies were to take my life, it would hold no significance, for the dead cannot praise God. In response, the Lord heard my plea and showed me mercy. He turned my sorrow into joy, tore my mourning garments, and clothed me with gladness. These words highlight the power and effectiveness of prayer. Through prayer, David transitioned from a destitute exile to a renowned and mighty king; Christ emerged victorious from the grave. The prophets, apostles, martyrs, and confessor overcame their oppressors, and the rest of God's chosen people have risen from despair to a glorious heavenly homeland.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

The voice of Christ speaks to God the Father: What purpose does my blood serve? Had I not sacrificed it for the redemption of humanity, or if, as the unrighteous claim, I had not been resurrected, what faithful soul would dare to affirm this reality, proclaiming, 'I am your Son, Father'? What significance does the life-giving blood of Christ hold when a fallen individual embraces incorruption? For he who partakes unworthily brings judgment upon himself.

Sergius Ternowski

19th centuryCommentator

What gain is there in my blood if I consume the offerings I have confessed to you? In other words, my death brings no benefit; can I then offer you praise?

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.